Solo Leveling - Day phase 3

Im catching up but you 10,000% absolutely do not need 'all the details.' You should be the one giving the details before Rex gives any. The only thing I see you being fed details about Rex doing is giving you room to craft a better lie. If you can prove yourself then you do not need details to do so.

Better lie to do what? I’m telling you to lynch me TODAY if it’s not satisfactory

If Pie is something confirmable they should just confirm it. Demanding a full role claim in this situation is rather absurd. I do not see any world where that makes sense and I do not understand why people see it as a bad thing to require Pie to feed his info first.

Because I’m telling you to lynch me in the event that my explanation is not satisfactory to you lol. If I’m scum, why would I tell you this.

I do se harm in requiring a claim from Rex. We out PR's and we feed a possible scum outs they can manipulate by knowing specifics on the claim against them. 

He already claimed Cop. The entire town knows he’s a Cop. Anyways, idec if he characters claims and claims his justification, though he should. I’m just asking him to confirm he told his entire guild.

Im really not sure how everyone is missing this simple issue. We risk harm to the town by demanding Rex to claim first and risk nothing by demanding Pie to claim first. If Pie is confirmable then he can simply show as much and we can move on.

Again, you and everyone else have failed to articulate, what “harm” there is. He’s a claimed cop. As soon as he confirms he told his entire guild, I will prove everything. What harm is there in REF answering that tiny question, especially if it yields a confirmed townie?

(Starting to learn vb code does not work on this site..)

Better lie to do what? I’m telling you to lynch me TODAY if it’s not satisfactory

My entire thing is simply that it potentially causes harm to the town for Rex to claim. Outing guild members is a bad idea and harmful. Nailing down his PR is also a bad idea and harmful unless you want to argue that Rex is scum (which you are not.)

Im fine just parking my vote here as I get back to digging on other things and I do hope you are confirmable but I only see harm in having Rex claim a bunch of potentially harmful information. They put themselves out there as a revealed cop in a situation where it makes zero sense for a scum to do so. They have already painted a target on their back to push you. Demanding more of them is unreasonable for the moment imo.

Well honestly, it just seems like your setting up for a play that casts suspicion on his guild and will follow up with pushing to out who is in it which will tell the scum team who has active power roles in the town. I would call that 'harm' but thats just me.

For what it's worth, I think Rex telling us who the other guild member is is pro town.

I the worst case scenario is Rex not telling us and then dying without recruiting.

My entire thing is simply that it potentially causes harm to the town for Rex to claim. Outing guild members is a bad idea and harmful. Nailing down his PR is also a bad idea and harmful unless you want to argue that Rex is scum (which you are not.)

No it doesn’t because scum could’ve been recruited. When Luna was leading it, we knew for certain that he was telling the truth about everything.

He already outted his PR lol. He said he’s the Cop. I believe him. It will all make sense when I claim. Mestari gets it. Listen to him

Im fine just parking my vote here as I get back to digging on other things and I do hope you are confirmable but I only see harm in having Rex claim a bunch of potentially harmful information.

If people who you townread are telling you that you are wrong, then maybe you should listen to them.

They put themselves out there as a revealed cop in a situation where it makes zero sense for a scum to do so. They have already painted a target on their back to push you. Demanding more of them is unreasonable for the moment imo.

I also said lynch me TODAY if you don’t like my reasoning. Why would I put that target on my back.

I'm not giving any information about my guild or my role. If you want to lynch the cop, go ahead. Otherwise, we should just lynch Pie. If he wants to stop it, he can pull out this innocent-proving thing that he's holding up his ass and slap it on the table. He's scum looking to milk as much info before he gets lynched as possible and/or he and some of the other players are in Wylted's guild and are trying to pump for information on the rival guild even if it hurts town.

I'm not giving any information about my guild or my role. If you want to lynch the cop, go ahead. Otherwise, we should just lynch Pie. If he wants to stop it, he can pull out this innocent-proving thing that he's holding up his ass and slap it on the table. He's scum looking to milk as much info before he gets lynched as possible and/or he and some of the other players are in Wylted's guild and are trying to pump for information on the rival guild even if it hurts town.

Just answer if you told your guild. Yes or no? Simple

He's scum looking to milk as much info before he gets lynched as possible and/or he and some of the other players are in Wylted's guild and are trying to pump for information on the rival guild even if it hurts town.

How does answering one small question give me any sort of scum benefit

Oh wow a standoff who could have predicted that

Legit Pie isn't even asking for a name. Just whether you told them.

That’s the problem. Nobody knows what wild stuff exists And your doing nothing to justify wanting more information.

Im still confused at how you started with wanting a full role claim and now have evolved into wanting to know if Rex’s guild members knew their target. This is an inconsistent shift

You first Pie. I'm not telling you unless I know why I got a guilty and why your knowing that matters. My guild is already at an informational disadvantage, and widening that with zero reason to trust you goes against one of my wincons. Not falling for the 'trust me bro, I can prove myself town' for the tenth time. I'm not the one with the guilty result.

That’s the problem. Nobody knows what wild stuff exists And your doing nothing to justify wanting more information.

That I will be confirmed town dude. At least trust your townreads lol

Im still confused at how you started with wanting a full role claim and now have evolved into wanting to know if Rex’s guild members knew their target. This is an inconsistent shift

Cause I’m willing to compromise. What harm is caused by saying yes or no to that question

You see what I have to deal with every time lol

Because I’m telling you to lynch me in the event that my explanation is not satisfactory to you lol. If I’m scum, why would I tell you this.

WIFOM

1. You are doing this because you want to get as much info as possible and potentially get another action if you are not lynched today

WIFOM

You are doing this because you want to get as much info as possible and potentially get another action if you are not lynched today

I will literally vote myself lmaooo

good lord yall are retarded

Lemme finish eating and I’ll explain

There is literally no reason for Rex to give away information first to someone who has a guilty on them even if you are confirmable this DP. If Pie was town he would've just outted what it was that makes him confirmable atp

If you think I'm town, and you think I'm as good as you seem to believe, then my word should be enough

Why should Pie, someone who has a guilty on them, be asking information out of anyone first without justifying WHY he is confirmable. If I am town, I am explaining how I can be confirmed with a DP action this DP asap and my reasoning.

This is just killing time

You see what I have to deal with every time lol

Hey hey hey. Don't you roll your eyes and meet his gaze! He doesn't even go to our school!

Because sometimes uncertainty in him makes it easier for him to extract important information

If I confirm myself as town, yall swear to listen to everything I say?

I'll explain it like this.

Pie's defense is that he is confirmable this DP and that is it. He has not elaborated more on this issue. I'll put this way.

If Persona A where to steal a cookie and Person B saw it, and Person B told on the police, would the police ask Person B to defend themselves, or Person A to defend themselves.

If Pie has a reasonable confirmation that can happen, I am willing to pivot. But he is just stalling and staying still because you are getting more info out of a guilded un CC'd cop is inherently scummy

Obviously

If I confirm myself as town, yall swear to listen to everything I say?

Swearsie realsies

If you confirm yourself in THIS DP, this DP and it can be confirmed in this DP, your word of mouth would go quite a long way from my perspective.

But that's if you are confirmed based on your explanation

You here? I’m curious to hear your theory. See if you really got it