Periodic Table of Elements Mafia - DP1

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

And exactly how is my iso a “treasure trove”? Wtf. People are capable of not playing the exact same way every game. That is literally all I’m being accused of, playing differently. How am I playing differently? This is miles away from my scum game lmao.

My scum game is I say weird scummy things. I don’t think I’ve said anything scummy and in any event. People are stating far too high a confidence on my slot considering all they can really say is “he’s different” without actually offering any proof in that regard. Not even proof. Like... an explanation please?

Let’s assume I am Town for a moment. How in God’s name am I supposed to defend myself when the accusations against me are “he’s playing differently” or “he’s offering fewer takes”? What do I say to that? Give me something specific I can actually reply to or I won’t even feel bad for being mislynched. Town’s fault.

Its not just about playing differently and I have explained it thoroughly.

261. 285 410

Refer to these posts for "evidence" or whatever. Respond to any of that and tell me I am wrong. It's not about being slightly different, this is mega different. You haven't taken the wheels once and picked a solid direction.

I don’t have a solid reason for why I haven’t voted. I’m not really feeling it this game. Usually I get vibes from players, I don’t do reads and some such, I rely on my gut a lot. If the gut isn’t working then there’s no votes.

Really, that’s all there is to it. I am not Mafia. If I was Mafia I would at least try to pretend to be scum hunting.

At least you’re admitting you’re not scum hunting?

Kohai wrote:

Less than 10 mins left. We can’t afford a no lynch

Its 9 central. Pie labors under the delusion that his provincial time ghetto is somehow relevant to the rest of the world. That's ten AM Real Time.

Lunatic wrote:

Gonna check rq to see if pie has ever made a strengthener in his games. Either way, not the best role. Calcium is probably a real character though, but I dont see why mafia would have it. Could have also been the fake claim. Either way I am still pretty confident in his behavior iso.

They get to ask two questions so it’s plausible this was a fake claim

RexFavilla wrote:

Kohai wrote:

Less than 10 mins left. We can’t afford a no lynch

Its 9 central. Pie labors under the delusion that his provincial time ghetto is somehow relevant to the rest of the world. That's ten AM Real Time.

Oh thank God

UNVOTE

Since people are around and we have time I wanna get more thoughts before hammering

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

And exactly how is my iso a “treasure trove”? Wtf. People are capable of not playing the exact same way every game. That is literally all I’m being accused of, playing differently. How am I playing differently? This is miles away from my scum game lmao.

My scum game is I say weird scummy things. I don’t think I’ve said anything scummy and in any event. People are stating far too high a confidence on my slot considering all they can really say is “he’s different” without actually offering any proof in that regard. Not even proof. Like... an explanation please?

Let’s assume I am Town for a moment. How in God’s name am I supposed to defend myself when the accusations against me are “he’s playing differently” or “he’s offering fewer takes”? What do I say to that? Give me something specific I can actually reply to or I won’t even feel bad for being mislynched. Town’s fault.

Its not just about playing differently and I have explained it thoroughly.

261. 285 410

Refer to these posts for "evidence" or whatever. Respond to any of that and tell me I am wrong. It's not about being slightly different, this is mega different. You haven't taken the wheels once and picked a solid direction.

I don’t have a solid reason for why I haven’t voted. I’m not really feeling it this game. Usually I get vibes from players, I don’t do reads and some such, I rely on my gut a lot. If the gut isn’t working then there’s no votes.

Really, that’s all there is to it. I am not Mafia. If I was Mafia I would at least try to pretend to be scum hunting.

If you dont think your feeling this game, then you should understand why you look so different. Having a gut read is fine, but not having any sense of direction is just not you. Town mago shoves hard. I get wanting to change behaviors but if your changing a behavior to be more in line with your scum play its not a good look. There is almost 800 posts to read through, you had one of the most posts of any player when I last checked, so I know it's not an activity thing. You have been here and participating. That is why not having a firm direction here is extra different.

Kohai wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

And exactly how is my iso a “treasure trove”? Wtf. People are capable of not playing the exact same way every game. That is literally all I’m being accused of, playing differently. How am I playing differently? This is miles away from my scum game lmao.

My scum game is I say weird scummy things. I don’t think I’ve said anything scummy and in any event. People are stating far too high a confidence on my slot considering all they can really say is “he’s different” without actually offering any proof in that regard. Not even proof. Like... an explanation please?

Let’s assume I am Town for a moment. How in God’s name am I supposed to defend myself when the accusations against me are “he’s playing differently” or “he’s offering fewer takes”? What do I say to that? Give me something specific I can actually reply to or I won’t even feel bad for being mislynched. Town’s fault.

Its not just about playing differently and I have explained it thoroughly.

261. 285 410

Refer to these posts for "evidence" or whatever. Respond to any of that and tell me I am wrong. It's not about being slightly different, this is mega different. You haven't taken the wheels once and picked a solid direction.

I don’t have a solid reason for why I haven’t voted. I’m not really feeling it this game. Usually I get vibes from players, I don’t do reads and some such, I rely on my gut a lot. If the gut isn’t working then there’s no votes.

Really, that’s all there is to it. I am not Mafia. If I was Mafia I would at least try to pretend to be scum hunting.

At least you’re admitting you’re not scum hunting?

Well, not as much as in my other games. I did hunt at the start

Did someone claim a rolestopper or am I smoking crack?

RexFavilla wrote:

Did someone claim a rolestopper or am I smoking crack?

I think Helz?

Kohai wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Gonna check rq to see if pie has ever made a strengthener in his games. Either way, not the best role. Calcium is probably a real character though, but I dont see why mafia would have it. Could have also been the fake claim. Either way I am still pretty confident in his behavior iso.

They get to ask two questions so it’s plausible this was a fake claim

It might not be, I have no idea about this nerdy ass theme but I recognize what calcium is at least, its the only reason I say it could be real. Mine is a lot more of a nuanced one, and I feel like if you are an expert in this type of thing there would be a lot more of those. But who knows

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

And exactly how is my iso a “treasure trove”? Wtf. People are capable of not playing the exact same way every game. That is literally all I’m being accused of, playing differently. How am I playing differently? This is miles away from my scum game lmao.

My scum game is I say weird scummy things. I don’t think I’ve said anything scummy and in any event. People are stating far too high a confidence on my slot considering all they can really say is “he’s different” without actually offering any proof in that regard. Not even proof. Like... an explanation please?

Let’s assume I am Town for a moment. How in God’s name am I supposed to defend myself when the accusations against me are “he’s playing differently” or “he’s offering fewer takes”? What do I say to that? Give me something specific I can actually reply to or I won’t even feel bad for being mislynched. Town’s fault.

Its not just about playing differently and I have explained it thoroughly.

261. 285 410

Refer to these posts for "evidence" or whatever. Respond to any of that and tell me I am wrong. It's not about being slightly different, this is mega different. You haven't taken the wheels once and picked a solid direction.

I don’t have a solid reason for why I haven’t voted. I’m not really feeling it this game. Usually I get vibes from players, I don’t do reads and some such, I rely on my gut a lot. If the gut isn’t working then there’s no votes.

Really, that’s all there is to it. I am not Mafia. If I was Mafia I would at least try to pretend to be scum hunting.

If you dont think your feeling this game, then you should understand why you look so different. Having a gut read is fine, but not having any sense of direction is just not you. Town mago shoves hard. I get wanting to change behaviors but if your changing a behavior to be more in line with your scum play its not a good look. There is almost 800 posts to read through, you had one of the most posts of any player when I last checked, so I know it's not an activity thing. You have been here and participating. That is why not having a firm direction here is extra different.

There’s nothing I can do about it. I can prod people but 1) the type of prodding I would be capable of now would be obnoxious and I do not think anyone wants to be subjected to that 2) I’m not sure how useful it would be.

I dunno who’s scum if I’m being honest. I did get gutpings from Mag1cman if I was to go purely by gut, but I could easily see him flipping Town. Dunno.

Idk who else.

I don't appreciate this mad dash before the end of the day. I'll hammer whoever, but everyone online rn needs to get on board with one lunch if we want to avoid a no lynch.

Claims list:

Claims:

Thoth- Oganesson- Hidden role until dp4 (post 4, dp1)

Kohai- ??? - Innocent child (Post 178, dp1)

Bullish -?? - cesium - ?? 

Magoroth - Calcium - ??

Unclaimed:

Lunatic

RexFavilla

Shining

Mikal

Casey

Banana

Whiteflame

Mag1cMan

Helz

Shining wrote:

I don't appreciate this mad dash before the end of the day. I'll hammer whoever, but everyone online rn needs to get on board with one lunch if we want to avoid a no lynch.

Are you scum Shining?

RexFavilla wrote:

Did someone claim a rolestopper or am I smoking crack?

At bare minimum I would say that it makes one of helz or mago guaranteed scum. Why put a rolestopping ability on the same team as a strengthener? It's literally the exact reason I lynched kohai when he claimed strengthener. If mago is town I will help you in taking a hard look at helz tomorrow. Alternatively if mago flips scum this looks good for helz.

Kohai wrote:

RexFavilla wrote:

Did someone claim a rolestopper or am I smoking crack?

I think Helz?

If roles like that and scum manipulative roles exist a town strengthener does make sense.

Kohai wrote:

Claims list:

Claims:

Thoth- Oganesson- Hidden role until dp4 (post 4, dp1)

Kohai- ??? - Innocent child (Post 178, dp1)

Bullish -?? - cesium - ?? 

Magoroth - Calcium - ??

Unclaimed:

Lunatic

RexFavilla

Shining

Mikal

Casey

Banana

Whiteflame

Mag1cMan

Helz

In case it’s not obvious. My claim is Strengthener.

Claims list:

Claims:

Thoth- Oganesson- Hidden role until dp4 (post 4, dp1)

Kohai- ??? - Innocent child (Post 178, dp1)

Bullish -?? - cesium - ?? 

Magoroth - Calcium - ?? 

Unclaimed:

Lunatic

RexFavilla

Shining

Mikal

Casey

Banana

Whiteflame

Mag1cMan

Claims list:

Claims:

Thoth- Oganesson- Hidden role until dp4 (post 4, dp1)

Kohai- ??? - Innocent child (Post 178, dp1)

Bullish -?? - cesium - ?? 

Magoroth - Calcium - ?? 

Helz ?! - I role block everyone that targets a player neutralizing everything.

Unclaimed:

Lunatic

RexFavilla

Shining

Mikal

Casey

Banana

Whiteflame

Mag1cMan

Shining wrote:

I don't appreciate this mad dash before the end of the day. I'll hammer whoever, but everyone online rn needs to get on board with one lunch if we want to avoid a no lynch.

Blame pie for making an early morning EOD. I am guessing most of you are just waking up.

But help me consolidate on mago and problem is solved.

Magoroth wrote:

Kohai wrote:

Claims list:

Claims:

Thoth- Oganesson- Hidden role until dp4 (post 4, dp1)

Kohai- ??? - Innocent child (Post 178, dp1)

Bullish -?? - cesium - ?? 

Magoroth - Calcium - ??

Unclaimed:

Lunatic

RexFavilla

Shining

Mikal

Casey

Banana

Whiteflame

Mag1cMan

Helz

In case it’s not obvious. My claim is Strengthener.

Can you target a player and strengthen them or is it a specific role?

Believe in the power of "just trust me bro".

Just trust me bro.

It says, and this is basically verbatim, that whoever I target, their action will become immune to any interference.

Lunatic wrote:

Believe in the power of "just trust me bro".

Just trust me bro.

Just trust me bro. I am Town.

Lunatic wrote:

RexFavilla wrote:

Did someone claim a rolestopper or am I smoking crack?

At bare minimum I would say that it makes one of helz or mago guaranteed scum. Why put a rolestopping ability on the same team as a strengthener? It's literally the exact reason I lynched kohai when he claimed strengthener. If mago is town I will help you in taking a hard look at helz tomorrow. Alternatively if mago flips scum this looks good for helz.

Yeah my main hangup on the Casey lynch is almost zero info produced on the flip.

RexFavilla wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

RexFavilla wrote:

Did someone claim a rolestopper or am I smoking crack?

At bare minimum I would say that it makes one of helz or mago guaranteed scum. Why put a rolestopping ability on the same team as a strengthener? It's literally the exact reason I lynched kohai when he claimed strengthener. If mago is town I will help you in taking a hard look at helz tomorrow. Alternatively if mago flips scum this looks good for helz.

Yeah my main hangup on the Casey lynch is almost zero info produced on the flip.

Agreed + the worry they’re a PR

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Casey_Risk (5/7): Magoroth (p#735), Mikal (p#640), RexFavilla (p#682), Mag1cman (p#693), Shining (p#719)

Magoroth (3/7): Bullish (p#73), Lunatic (p#725), Banana (p#745)

RexFavilla (1/7): Helz (p#222)

Bullish (1/7): whiteflame (p#417)

Helz (1/7): Thoth (p#577)

Not Voting (2): Casey_Risk, Kohai (p#785)

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day phase has ended.

I think yo know my meta better than Lunatic. People should listen to you because you are confirmed Town. You don’t think I’m scum. LEAD. Don’t let the town mislynch. Mislynching is against the Town’s wincon. Don’t listen to anyone saying “if X flips Town then we do Y thing”. VTNL or vote Mag1cman

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

And exactly how is my iso a “treasure trove”? Wtf. People are capable of not playing the exact same way every game. That is literally all I’m being accused of, playing differently. How am I playing differently? This is miles away from my scum game lmao.

My scum game is I say weird scummy things. I don’t think I’ve said anything scummy and in any event. People are stating far too high a confidence on my slot considering all they can really say is “he’s different” without actually offering any proof in that regard. Not even proof. Like... an explanation please?

Let’s assume I am Town for a moment. How in God’s name am I supposed to defend myself when the accusations against me are “he’s playing differently” or “he’s offering fewer takes”? What do I say to that? Give me something specific I can actually reply to or I won’t even feel bad for being mislynched. Town’s fault.

Its not just about playing differently and I have explained it thoroughly.

261. 285 410

Refer to these posts for "evidence" or whatever. Respond to any of that and tell me I am wrong. It's not about being slightly different, this is mega different. You haven't taken the wheels once and picked a solid direction.

I don’t have a solid reason for why I haven’t voted. I’m not really feeling it this game. Usually I get vibes from players, I don’t do reads and some such, I rely on my gut a lot. If the gut isn’t working then there’s no votes.

Really, that’s all there is to it. I am not Mafia. If I was Mafia I would at least try to pretend to be scum hunting.

If you dont think your feeling this game, then you should understand why you look so different. Having a gut read is fine, but not having any sense of direction is just not you. Town mago shoves hard. I get wanting to change behaviors but if your changing a behavior to be more in line with your scum play its not a good look. There is almost 800 posts to read through, you had one of the most posts of any player when I last checked, so I know it's not an activity thing. You have been here and participating. That is why not having a firm direction here is extra different.

There’s nothing I can do about it. I can prod people but 1) the type of prodding I would be capable of now would be obnoxious and I do not think anyone wants to be subjected to that 2) I’m not sure how useful it would be.

I dunno who’s scum if I’m being honest. I did get gutpings from Mag1cman if I was to go purely by gut, but I could easily see him flipping Town. Dunno.

Idk who else.

"Also, I am not claiming. Bullish can go suck a dick." Immediately followed by a bullish vote. A heavy claim like that makes me think you are a very strong role, otherwise why mention the claim. Before voting casey for "self pres" this was literally your last vote. What about your thoughts on bullish has changed and why?

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

Lunatic wrote:

Magoroth wrote:

And exactly how is my iso a “treasure trove”? Wtf. People are capable of not playing the exact same way every game. That is literally all I’m being accused of, playing differently. How am I playing differently? This is miles away from my scum game lmao.

My scum game is I say weird scummy things. I don’t think I’ve said anything scummy and in any event. People are stating far too high a confidence on my slot considering all they can really say is “he’s different” without actually offering any proof in that regard. Not even proof. Like... an explanation please?

Let’s assume I am Town for a moment. How in God’s name am I supposed to defend myself when the accusations against me are “he’s playing differently” or “he’s offering fewer takes”? What do I say to that? Give me something specific I can actually reply to or I won’t even feel bad for being mislynched. Town’s fault.

Its not just about playing differently and I have explained it thoroughly.

261. 285 410

Refer to these posts for "evidence" or whatever. Respond to any of that and tell me I am wrong. It's not about being slightly different, this is mega different. You haven't taken the wheels once and picked a solid direction.

I don’t have a solid reason for why I haven’t voted. I’m not really feeling it this game. Usually I get vibes from players, I don’t do reads and some such, I rely on my gut a lot. If the gut isn’t working then there’s no votes.

Really, that’s all there is to it. I am not Mafia. If I was Mafia I would at least try to pretend to be scum hunting.

If you dont think your feeling this game, then you should understand why you look so different. Having a gut read is fine, but not having any sense of direction is just not you. Town mago shoves hard. I get wanting to change behaviors but if your changing a behavior to be more in line with your scum play its not a good look. There is almost 800 posts to read through, you had one of the most posts of any player when I last checked, so I know it's not an activity thing. You have been here and participating. That is why not having a firm direction here is extra different.

There’s nothing I can do about it. I can prod people but 1) the type of prodding I would be capable of now would be obnoxious and I do not think anyone wants to be subjected to that 2) I’m not sure how useful it would be.

I dunno who’s scum if I’m being honest. I did get gutpings from Mag1cman if I was to go purely by gut, but I could easily see him flipping Town. Dunno.

Idk who else.

"Also, I am not claiming. Bullish can go suck a dick." Immediately followed by a bullish vote. A heavy claim like that makes me think you are a very strong role, otherwise why mention the claim. Before voting casey for "self pres" this was literally your last vote. What about your thoughts on bullish has changed and why?

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Casey_Risk (5/7): Magoroth (p#735), Mikal (p#640), RexFavilla (p#682), Mag1cman (p#693), Shining (p#719)

Magoroth (3/7): Bullish (p#73), Lunatic (p#725), Banana (p#745)

RexFavilla (1/7): Helz (p#222)

Bullish (1/7): whiteflame (p#417)

Helz (1/7): Thoth (p#577)

Not Voting (2): Casey_Risk, Kohai (p#785)

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day phase has ended.