Periodic Table of Elements Mafia DP6

If my justification stands out, it's only because the other justifications are wild, and I don't think anybody was sussing the clear and obvious justification of having a hidden role because Oganesson has barely been studied.

So you're seriously going to argue that there are no uniting characteristics of the justifications we have so far? Nothing at all that would make yours stand out compared with all of them? And you're right, many of us weren't sussing you when part of your justification was that you had a hidden role due to the lack of study into your element. You've clarified that you faked that part of your justification. That doesn't help you.

Also, why did Shining bust out the Vaporizer wiki link after people were hard-sussing Helz? That's a planned bus f I've ever seen one.

So you're seriously going to argue that there are no uniting characteristics of the justifications we have so far?

They were all written by ChatGPT?

Thoth wrote:

How about this from Shining's DP1:

I also don't fully understand why Mikal is getting shit for the whole Kohai IC thing.

So once again, we're pointing to a post from DP1, this one just being a statement that it was odd Mikal was getting flak for saying Kohai should have used his IC differently. I remember that. I gave him shit over it, too. I agreed with Mikal. Should I scumread Shining for taking the same position?

Let's also not forget that Bomb is a scummy claim when you're not townlocked enough that you're likely to be the kill anyway.

Should I scumread Shining for taking the same position?

I don't fucking know. Scumread him or don't. I've given every argument I can think of and responded to your points with every piece of information I have. I don't believe there's anything more I can add to substantially sway you. So go ahead and vote.

I'm not an investigative, so I have no information from role abilities to share. Shining's ISO doesn't give me nearly as much to work from as I'd like, so I'm forced to read as much as I can into everything he said. If my behavior this game seemed scummy, I had a pro-town reason for all of it. I'm done.

Also, why did Shining bust out the Vaporizer wiki link after people were hard-sussing Helz? That's a planned bus f I've ever seen one.

He did a pretty obvious thing, which was look up the role that you'd claimed Helz had provided as the name of his role in chat with you. Claiming it's a planned bus when you've acknowledged you were in the wrong for not looking it up yourself is just... what are we doing here, man?

They were all written by ChatGPT?

And they all have similarities. I've pointed to those similarities. I've pointed out how yours doesn't match those similar characteristics despite being produced by ChatGPT with what was likely a similar prompt. Your response to that so far has been that ChatGPT generated your outlier PM for... reasons. What am I missing?

Let's also not forget that Bomb is a scummy claim when you're not townlocked enough that you're likely to be the kill anyway.

I don't know, man. Soldier's pretty scummy to me and the claimed DP4 delay, reveal that that and the justification behind it were a lie, that's pretty scummy. By contrast, Shining was one of the last to claim and almost certainly would've been a potential lynch if he hadn't claimed at that point. What did you want him to do? Refuse? Make something up like you did?

Thoth wrote:

Should I scumread Shining for taking the same position?

I don't fucking know. Scumread him or don't. I've given every argument I can think of and responded to your points with every piece of information I have. I don't believe there's anything more I can add to substantially sway you. So go ahead and vote.

Alright then, let's end this. If I'm wrong, I'll take the L.

VTL: Thoth

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Thoth (2/2): Shining (p#44), whiteflame (p#129)

Shining (1/2): Thoth (p#53)

Not Voting (0): None

With 3 players alive, it takes 2 to lynch. Day phase ends in 23 hours.

⚠️ Thoth has reached the lynch threshold. Hammer appears to be p#129.

That's game regardless. So was I right or wrong?

whiteflame wrote:

That's game regardless. So was I right or wrong?

Thoth was lynched. He was INNOCENT. Endgame will be up later tonight