Stereotype Mafia Day Phase 1

ILikePie5 wrote:

whiteflame wrote:

Mikal wrote:

Kohai did functionally claim vanilla

Is no one reading this dp ....

Dude, he claimed a named role. I get that the role is functionally Vanilla in terms of night actions, but your line of questioning basically just assumed he was actually Vanilla in role. I don't get that.

Well, we don’t know what he claimed. He first claimed Town Drunk.

Yeah, I thought that was what he claimed.

wylted wrote:

I'm actually a straight white man. That's my character. So technically the best character in the game so don't vote me.

Alright, please hold off on claiming anything further for now. Best to just focus on getting caught up when you can.

wylted wrote:

I am actually not going to catch up with the game. I am just starting here on page 22 anything that happened prior to page 22 I will not even know about so catch me up or cash me outside

...Seriously? It is actually worth getting at least some behavioral reads, and those aren't going to come through in some summaries of what happened over the course of the DP. I can work on something when I get a chance, but at least try skimming through.

wylted wrote:

If you guys do murder Casey you could have just done that without me swapping in btw and ruining my ability to swap in for somebody else.

Why would this ruin your ability to swap in for someone else? If we autolynched you and you're town, you'd still be able to swap in for someone else, right?

Did anyone claim jew as a character and if so who? This is a serious question I know lunatic is antisemitic so that person is scum

No one has claimed Jew as of yet, no. I'd definitely recognize them, though.

This is my weakness but I mostly base behavioral reads on what I generate in my interactions. But I will try to catch up here and there just because you asked

Cool.

whiteflame wrote:

I agree, though a bunch of roles like this is necessarily going to fall prey to (2). This role and others like it exist as roles used in actual games. I'm not saying that it's unimportant as a result (part of the reason I didn't use it in my game is that I didn't want to have to deal with determining whether any given post by Luna was "drunk enough"), just that it's going to be generally hard to accept the existence of a role like this regardless of whether it's real or not.

3 points as clear as I can make them

1- Such a role is borderline offensive to the player. They are placed into a game with a constraint by the host, not the scum and nerfed to have no role at all on top of it. I would almost certainly refuse to play if a host gave me that.

2- Such a role is literally bastard. Its the hosts decision on a super vague demand if the condition is met or not and someone will die if they do not meet it impacting the game. So the host has direct impact on the game.

3- This is a modkill function and the very last game Lunatic was super pissed about a mod kill. It would be wild for them to then turn around and cram a modkill obligation on a player that is not even any sort of rule break kinda deal.

Im pretty stuck on this.

Still a lil' confused on why everyone is pressuring me. I mean I'd be happy to claim if that's what you guys want but perhaps we should slow down on the claiming just a touch

wylted wrote:

If you guys do murder Casey you could have just done that without me swapping in btw and ruining my ability to swap in for somebody else.

Nobody even voted Casey. I just pointed out they were inactive with 1 post and wanted to hear from them. They basically signed up and never played.

Torn on Kohai, I definitely thinking they're guilty but I would feel pretty terrible if they flipped innocent

Ultracrepidarian wrote:

Still a lil' confused on why everyone is pressuring me. I mean I'd be happy to claim if that's what you guys want but perhaps we should slow down on the claiming just a touch

Some people want your claim. I really want people to chill on the claim madness.

I am just interested in hearing more reasoning and reads from you. With 23 pages of content I would like to hear about what you see in the game past "X person is town, X person is scum" and such. Stuff I can use to actually read your slot.

Hey there, wylted. Good to see you subbing for Casey. You forgot your car the last time you came over to my place to purchase some goods. Please come collect it. I have your keys.

whiteflame wrote:

I agree, though a bunch of roles like this is necessarily going to fall prey to (2). This role and others like it exist as roles used in actual games.

Can you cite any roles from past games with a purely subjective chat restriction?

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Ultracrepidarian (4/7): Banana (p#209), Helz (p#596), whiteflame (p#611), wylted (p#677)

Kohai (3/7): Mikal (p#264), RexFavilla (p#266), Thoth (p#514)

Helz (1/7): Magoroth (p#87)

RexFavilla (1/7): Ultracrepidarian (p#200)

Not Voting (3): ILikePie5 (p#634), Kohai (p#620), Wryly (p#547)

With 12 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day phase ends in 22 hours.

Why are we pressuring Ultra? Just for the sake of pressuring at least one person today?

UNVOTE

Thoth wrote:

Hey there, wylted. Good to see you subbing for Casey. You forgot your car the last time you came over to my place to purchase some goods. Please come collect it. I have your keys.

thats not wtlted’s car. Not offencive enuff.

Thoth wrote:

Why are we pressuring Ultra? Just for the sake of pressuring at least one person today?

I agree with pushing them for more content. There was some slight issues earlier but they are here now and reading so I would rather give them time.

People on this site seem to fiend for claims like they are crack. Often without even slowing down to ask "What will I get from having their claim" and more importantly "What information am I feeding mafia by outing this"

Last game I was laughing my ass off in scum chat as the town just handed us the play book on just about everything without any of us even slightly trying to get it. It was great. Can we please not do that today?

Thoth wrote:

Why are we pressuring Ultra? Just for the sake of pressuring at least one person today?

just read... we have talked about why were are pressuring in many times. do an iso, what about anything he has done makes you town read him? why should he get a pass to do next to nothing all day

I've not been the most active player, but I definitely also not been the most inactive so why is it me that you're tunneling in on??

It feels like you're trying to wrench attention away from Kohai

You are around and posting, but its void of content. There is nothing I see that shows you are hunting or lets me know why you think what you think. Looking for ways to read you.

Just hanging out and existing in the thread is not a good look.

Any1 find it odds that ultra shuwed up almost att the exakt same tyme as Wylted

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Kohai (3/7): Mikal (p#264), RexFavilla (p#266), Thoth (p#514)

Ultracrepidarian (3/7): Banana (p#209), whiteflame (p#611), wylted (p#677)

Helz (1/7): Magoroth (p#87)

RexFavilla (1/7): Ultracrepidarian (p#200)

Not Voting (4): Helz (p#680), ILikePie5 (p#634), Kohai (p#620), Wryly (p#547)

With 12 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day phase ends in 22 hours.

VTL: Ultracrepidarian

fuwidbeiwbrhdw