From mafia - Game Over

Mafia Host — Day 3

Day 3 has begun.

thoth was killed!

There are 5 players alive. The base elimination threshold is 4. Configured role modifiers may change vote power or an individual player's threshold.

Phase deadline: Fri, 04 Sep 2026 13:05:00 GMT.

RIP Thoth

??????

He flipped scum what do you want

So we nailed Pie. Good. Should have lynched him Day phase one but I digress

Mikal was your role 1x or did you forfeit last night?

We need to full claim now. I am Kenny Liu, Vanilla Townie. My description says im friendly with most people and suffer a lot of trajedy after the deaths of both parents. I dont have a specific link for being vanilla or anything, just a brief description about my guy.

Magic needs to full claim as well.

So now is the WIFOM phase. Basically have to figure out who was recruited. It's all behavior from here, unless magic has some useful result to go off of.

Odd night

Pretty sure luna is town but would never put it pass luna to bus.

My role is verified.

Want a claim list. Assumed wykted said Miller becajse someone said he means a cop is in the game

Question is who would pie yazkua.

David did not pick that pie did

Answer is luna or magic.

Magaroth I or wylted would never have been a yakuza target. I was casey and inactive pie would have picked someone to play with

Order should be magic and luna and game is solved

Plus magic being spazzy end of last dp and trying to redirect off pie

Id bet my left nut last scum is one of those 2. Have to dismiss luna from dp1 as he could have been yazkuad and busses for credit. But high chance this is just magic

UNVOTE

But with the player list and who pie would take. Its exactly magic or lu a

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 8:22 AM (post #837)

Pretty sure luna is town but would never put it pass luna to bus.

My role is verified.

Want a claim list. Assumed wykted said Miller becajse someone said he means a cop is in the game

Question is who would pie yazkua.

David did not pick that pie did

Answer is luna or magic.

Magaroth I or wylted would never have been a yakuza target. I was casey and inactive pie would have picked someone to play with

Order should be magic and luna and game is solved

I think you are overlooking mago as a possibility. I am a bit suspicious that yesterday was theatre to distance mago and himself. Pie had to have known he was cooked at that point from his being linked with kohai dp1. I think he would want to put a ton of distance between himself and his recruit.

We should be high skeptical of everyone alive, even wylted. Wylted probably is the miller, but I could see pie advocating to recruit him if he thought he was a dreamer.

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 8/31/2026 at 5:51 PM (post #821)

Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 8/31/2026 at 4:50 PM (post #819)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 8/31/2026 at 5:49 PM (post #817)

Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 8/31/2026 at 4:48 PM (post #816)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 8/31/2026 at 5:48 PM (post #814)

It’s over dude. You took too long. Lynch Mago tomorrow

sorry bruh

just stupid shit all around. Mikal being sheep. Thoth too illiterate to see the upside and blindly following results

mikal was showing up as a frequent pick in my analysis for who was most likely to be recruited. Worth noting.

i mean common dude. Needed this yesterday. Too late now. Frustrating af. It’s probably an L now.

btw Pie I know you feel frustrated but unless I found something outright clearing of you or damning of someone else, I was gonna lynch you anyway. Was just dragging out the DP to give more thoughts that would be useful to town.

The big things were the behavior around Kohai, and that one post I called out that looked copy-pasted from scum chat.

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 10:23 AM (post #838)

Plus magic being spazzy end of last dp and trying to redirect off pie

Id bet my left nut last scum is one of those 2. Have to dismiss luna from dp1 as he could have been yazkuad and busses for credit. But high chance this is just magic

lol I did not post that all that analysis just to be called scum

Anyway, with Pie being correctly lynched as OG scum, I think we can rule out a tailor.

Tailoring Kohai NP1 would’ve been a play specifically designed to screw Pie over. Since Pie was scum, there was clearly no plan to screw Pie over. So we’re dealing with a yakuza for sure.

With that in mind, the last scum is between Mikal and Wylted, per my analysis from last DP.

Pie gas literally bitched about how much he doesnt vibe with thoth or mago

Off chance he could have got me but not casey. Casey's not active

Wylted I dont think so cus of the claim

Pie would have picked who he would have enjoyed playing with and who he considered good. Its you or magic

Also giving you benefit of the doubt. You are saying you are vanilla. No take backs? Want to confirm you aren't changing this for a gambit.

Dude we have the 2 scum flips. The fuck are you even talking about a tailor.

We can see all their roles. Lmfao.

Magic is not this retarted. Im good with him then luna. Waiting for luna to confirm hes telling the truth first though

Originally Posted by Lunatic on 9/1/2026 at 10:25 AM (post #840)

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 8:22 AM (post #837)

Pretty sure luna is town but would never put it pass luna to bus.

My role is verified.

Want a claim list. Assumed wykted said Miller becajse someone said he means a cop is in the game

Question is who would pie yazkua.

David did not pick that pie did

Answer is luna or magic.

Magaroth I or wylted would never have been a yakuza target. I was casey and inactive pie would have picked someone to play with

Order should be magic and luna and game is solved

I think you are overlooking mago as a possibility. I am a bit suspicious that yesterday was theatre to distance mago and himself. Pie had to have known he was cooked at that point from his being linked with kohai dp1. I think he would want to put a ton of distance between himself and his recruit.

We should be high skeptical of everyone alive, even wylted. Wylted probably is the miller, but I could see pie advocating to recruit him if he thought he was a dreamer.

I don’t buy that he recruits Magoroth. Magoroth has been scumread by some people since DP1. Pie was already sussed, he needed to pick up a partner who wasn’t.

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 10:52 AM (post #845)

Dude we have the 2 scum flips. The fuck are you even talking about a tailor.

We can see all their roles. Lmfao.

and I’m saying what we have disproves tailor. Say what you want but it was a possibility to think about for a while.

"I think we can rule out tailor"

What does that even mean. Its not in the game lol. Why do you think we can rule it out and why is it even being brought up

Same thing you were doing last dp. Its dumb as fuck and seems like you ste trying to invalidate the yazkua because its totally obvious who pie picks lol

Wylted mag

You guys wana commit with me.

Magic and then luna

I dont want to spend days debating this shit. If we have results say it otherwise lets just move this on and go to the next game

If you're (Pie) OG scum, you're probably recruiting either Mikal, me, or Lunatic. Thoth is an option just to find out his role. Magoroth and Wylted are for mindgames only. But given the four candidates already here, I doubt you'd go for mindgames by recruiting Magoroth or Wylted.

If you picked up Thoth was investigative, then he's a fantastic option. Problem is, he's hard bussing you rn with results and I don't think he has to do that.

So me, Lunatic, or Mikal. I can't speak on myself outside of what I've already said; I know I'm town.

Lunatic or Mikal? Lunatic not bussing you would be sus. And you know that. So you're signing up to be bussed if you recruit him. That leaves Mikal. Best option for you IMO.

Although if Mikal and I are the only good options, maybe you would try some mindgames. Although yeah, Magoroth was sussed so that's even more mindgames. And Wylted doesn't have a good role to take, unless you genuinenly thought he was dreamer. hmm. Your posts seem to indicate you did. But you could also just pay Wylted a visit then. Although you'd risk him actually being a PGO. Not a bad risk to take considering the situation tbh. Odds seem low he was actually PGO.

Also for Thoth, why pressure him so much DP1 if you can just figure him out upon recruiting? Unless you were scouting for something to recruit? You (Pie) would've pressed even more people for info at that point tho... so I don't think that was your plan.

TEAM COMBOS IF PIE OG SCUM (RANKED IMO)

1Pie-2Mikal

1Pie-2Wylted

1Pie-2Lunatic

1Pie-2Thoth

1Pie-2Magoroth

Imma make a call and drop the bottom three for now. They just seem too unlikely to me.

Copy-pasted from #685

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 10:56 AM (post #849)

"I think we can rule out tailor"

What does that even mean. Its not in the game lol. Why do you think we can rule it out and why is it even being brought up

you act like it was 100% certain last DP. It wasn’t.

Dont care for claims tbh. They are all useless anyway cus yakuza

Results are all that matter atm along with behavior and analysis on who pie would pick and why

Again this is exactly magic or luna. I know wylted will ride with me. If mago confirms. Let's just please god move this game along. But im death tunneling magic and assuming we end. If nah its luna

But the weird tailor shit from last dp

Trying to detract the pie lynch

The fact he is still trying to hedge and day he thinks there is no fuckery when both rolls have flipped

The fact pie would have instantly picked him

Ready to just move along

Originally Posted by Mikal on 9/1/2026 at 8:51 AM (post #844)

Pie gas literally bitched about how much he doesnt vibe with thoth or mago

Off chance he could have got me but not casey. Casey's not active

Wylted I dont think so cus of the claim

Recruitment doesn't effect someone's original claim my friend.

Pie would have picked who he would have enjoyed playing with and who he considered good. Its you or magic

I am the catalyst for why he was lynched, recruiting me after he thought I was hard tunneling him dp1 is kind of retarded. I also stayed consistent on lynching him all of day phase 2.

Also giving you benefit of the doubt. You are saying you are vanilla. No take backs? Want to confirm you aren't changing this for a gambit.

That's my claim. Only gambit I had up my sleeve was to hope to bait out roleblocks or night kills.

From Pie in #527

Mag1c is pure big brain. I can see the strategy with him and Kohai at EOD. Goal was to get REF so they could kill two birds with one stone and the switch to Pie was theatric. I think this is unlikely though, and my townread of him during DP1 was pretty solid.

My response in #639

Theatrical? lol how?

Also, you referring to yourself in the 3rd person gives me the impression you may have copy-pasted this from the scum chat. If this is the case, I expect a higher-level player to be with you in scum chat. I don't think a lower-level player would help you write a convincing reads list. You don't need the help, but I think you would accept it from a higher-level player.

I think this implies Mikal way more than it does Wylted.

Just confirming

And also I disagree. Pie would have grabbed someone who was not sus

Mago always gets lynched

Casey was going to be a target and they would have left that open to kill cus inactive

Wykted is possible but still more sus than you ir magic

Pe would have looked at this in a few ways

Who is easy to kill. Casey or mago. They are out

Who does he want to play with. You or magic

Who is more sus. You and mago were also on the bottom end of that

From a strategic stance. This literally has to he you or him