It was as if your very SOUL was glowing...
IT'S A TOWN VICTORY!
Mafia: Wylted/Shining, Ultracrepidarian
Town: ILikePie5, Mikal, Lunatic, whiteflame, RexFavilla, Thoth, McDonaldsReal, RationalTheist
Commentary:
So, that went well for the town. In large part, this was due to a really inactive mafia. Wylted scarcely had any presence at all this game. He was on briefly during DP1 and then vanished completely, both from the public thread and from mafia chat. Shining subbed in, but tbh, that did very little to improve activity. I can hardly imagine scum chat being much more of a ghost town than it already was. There was hardly any discussion of potential fakeclaims or what other players might be. In fact, during NP3, Shining had to submit for Owen just before the deadline. He chose to kill Mikal, but somehow forgot that he had already claimed, so he ended up waiving Anticlaim, allowing the NK to be blocked by Luna. Though, at that point the Mafia was already in a tough situation anyway.
I knew this game would be pretty swingy even before I started it, and it ended up swinging pretty hard toward the town, though that's partially because the scum team let it happen that way. Going into NP2, I think the scum team had a really decent chance of winning. Mikal looked sus, moreso than Shining, and there was even room to push a potential WF/RT team. DP3 is where everything fell apart for the scum team, however.
As far as balance goes, I think this game may have been a bit more townsided than I realized at first. There were several ways for the town to get information, but there was also room for counterplay. I think the Mafia JOAT was pretty strong, and Ultra would have been hard to investigate/interfere with. The Caroler was helpful, but also could have ended up targeting scum, and the list of town players it could theoretically sing to was fairly narrow. Plus, even the town Jailkeeper could have interfered with that. If the mafia had decided to kill RT instead of Pie during NP1, this would have been a very different game. I'm open to thoughts and constructive criticism regarding the balance, tho.
Town MVP goes to Whiteflame for getting not one, but TWO carols successfully sent out, which was extremely helpful to the town, even if Rex didn't even see the carol sent to him until after the game was over, lol. Also, I would like to compliment our new player, McDonaldsReal! You did fantastic for your first game on here! Certainly much better than I did in mine. Also, I just want to say that I saw your softclaim during DP1, and it was perfect. No one else seemed to catch it since no one else was nearly as familiar with the theme, but that ended up being a good thing since it led to a CC.
In the end, I hope everyone was able to have some fun with this one. GG!