Edit: After discussion on MyLo / LyLo criteria the Mafia team wins. Congratulations Whiteflame and Lunatic.
Mafia Wins
Few mod notes:
1) I'm disappointed with the amount of replacement and lack of activity in this game. I was hoping since you picked your own character you would be more excited to play the game. I was also kinda hoping to see some more roleplay.
2) I realize how culturally illiterate I am. I literally heard of almost none of your selected characters before.
3) In order to make the game I first randed your alignments and then reversed engineered a role that would fit with both your character and the alignemnt. This was much more difficult than I had anticipated. The result was a messy game with far too much kill power.
4) Town MVP: Mikal for nailing both wolves on day 1. Mikal's vig shot was available starting night 2. If he had a shot on night 1 he would have popped whiteflame which could have altered the trajectory of the game.
5) Mafia MVP: Whiteflame. The fake claim was just hilarious.
Role PMs: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J7qdy6nqaL9Ev6-vY6DH-A942HBfKdY78SlsMsa5WSs/edit?usp=sharing
Night actions
Wylted: N1 cops Mikal; N2 cops Whiteflame
Mag1cman: No action N1; protects banana n2
Whiteflame: N1 strongarm Mikal; N2 kills pie
Lunatic: N2: Vigs Rex
A word about MyLo/LyLo
Wryly was town popular and their popular status disables in MyLo / LyLo. This raises a major debate: When does MyLo actually begin and erase that status? MyLo is technically defined as the game state where mafia will reach parity with town via their night kill if town mislynches during the day phase. The big red question mark is this: Is MyLo a numbers game or a roles game? Since town had a doctor and could potentially stop the night kill, then mafia could be prevented from meeting their win condition during the night phase. On the flip side, if town has a single doctor or way to prevent the NK then MyLo technically can never be reached and the game could continue until LyLo.
In this case, the doctor was outted so mafia had a clear objective. However, in a world where he did not claim there's a chance that mafia would miss the doctor. Regardless, the night phase would have to be played out. If the doctor did somehow stop the night kill then the game will continue to LyLo and the mafia team would be completely outted for that quick hammer.
I did reach out to a few trusted people on MafiaUniverse and got two different answers on this debate. I think this question is worth debating. Is MyLo if when mislynch may cause wolves to win overnight or when it is a guaranteed loss? This is a hard question to fully reconcile. I can see both sides to the case and believe this is a worthy debate to have.
I do think we need to have a clear community standard on when MyLo actually begins. If MyLo is a purely numbers game, then day 3 was MyLo. However, if the definition of MyLo depended on roles then day 3 was objectively not MyLo.
Discussion is now open. In before everyone calls me a retard.
