Which could easily be built into the game as punishment for Jinwoo becoming a winsteal 3P. #926 at least implies that Jinwoo chose to change his wincon after starting as Town.
Which would be bastard level modding as it would be completely unfun to play as.
The problem is if one of those 3 is a 3p this makes it incredibly unfair and nearly impossible for the 3p to win.
Right? It's like he slapped together the Dreamer and Informed role, and it doesn't even make sense thematically.
Also in world where Thoth is truthful and Jin-woo is a neutral 3p role this makes it significantly harder for the 3p to win
Also I’ll add to my defense that Mikal gave scum fake claims. Do you really think Mikal would give ascetic as a fake claim?
In my defense if I was scum and needed to get into a guild ascetic is not what I’d claim as this doesn’t help the guild activate a useful PR. If anything it is best if I stay outside a guild where I can be at least confirmed by an investigative role.
claiming ascetic tells the guild who not to recruit
Well, this one just doesn't help your case at all. Informed is unconfirmable, the list could be drawn randomly, and it doesn't make sense for your character. Why would you be unsure who Jin-woo is? You're his sister. It's not like he has any history of hiding from his sister in the show.
Also I’d say in all the times I’ve seen an informed town role I have never seen it come with a list of names. The only time I’ve ever seen it come with a name is to confirm that person is aligned with town. Not giving a 3 narrow list of people who may be a particular character
Vote count
Thoth 6/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted. Kohai <-- L3
Shining 6/9 - Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz, Thoth, Magicman <-- L4
Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5
If Jin-woo is a third party that doesn't joint win with town, they have every reason to deny being Jin-woo.
This is actually a good point if all of them deny being Jin-woo and he comes out as being informed we have a strong POE that we can look into.
I can buy informed town as this is easily fact check able if none of them claim Jinwoo then we turbo lynch Thoth. But I fail to see them going together
Explain how being a nurse and informed town go together? Like why would a nurse know this? I don’t quote buy this. At least we can verify the informed town claim.
are any of you Jinwoo? Yes or no.
31. Not much younger.
Sadly he’s not dead yet. 3 more votes which may take another thousand posts to get to
alright I"m gonna bow out for the night. In case i don't return by the end of the day I'm going back to Thoth as he's my top lynch target. I think the shining CW is a gold mine to analyze especially in a w!Thoth world
VTL THOTH
Vote count
Thoth 6/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted. Kohai <-- L3
Shining 6/9 - Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz, Thoth, Magicman <-- L4
Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5
may you find some comfort there
Ok. Who else?
what are your thoughts on the game state? Who do you think is scum?
For my part, I just thought you had a valid point that Shining's lack of opinion on Thoth seemed suspicious, and he was worth pressuring.
Agreed. I do think the shinning wagon is good.
shining Wagon makes sense. Dude hasn’t helped progress the day phase at all and has been extremely lazy: This isn’t out of character for him but it prevents a problem for trying to read his slot.
Agreed. Plus I don't buy someone not having thoughts on thoth while claiming to scum read pie.
For the full record: I would much rather lynch Thoth today over shinning. That said, I don't want to end the day without getting shinning's full claim and I want to force him to give thoughts on thoth.
Also FTR I don't buy Thoth's claim. I also want to go on record notiing that I started both the thoth and shinning wagons
I mentioned one a few times already being Alyssa, but if he is scum this will open up quite a few options based on people who have either defended him or shown hesitation in lynching him throughout the day phase. I plan on investigating these people thoroughly next day phase if that is the case.
Fair. What do you think of shinning not having any thoughts on him? Also do you have thoughts on how fast the shinning wagon grew?
Vote count
Shining 6/9 - Kohai, Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz, Thoth, Magicman <-- L3
Thoth 5/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted <-- L4
Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5
Who do you think thoth's partners are?
It'sl iterally the exact same claim except elaborating on why nothing gets past me as a moderator. I didn't want to make it sound too much like I was just copying and pasting my role pm.
I just answered. I also will say the vast majority of my posts have been mobile posting which makes things more difficult
What about "as a moderator nothing gets past me" fits with Ascetic exactly? Wouldn't that be a better justification for Cop or Lie Detector or Roleblocker or something?
I poorly rephrased my role PM. I will try rephrasing it again
During my time as a moderator I''ve endured countless criticism, complaints, reports, name calling etc. and nothing seems to affect me. That's the justification for being ascetic once recrutied
I'm literally still trying to catch up.
Building a Box
Living Players
Wylted
Alysa
WF
Helz
Luna
Banana
David
Pie
Mharm
Wyrly
Skep
Thoth
Supa
Max
Casey Risk
Mestari
Shining
Confirmed Town
Wylted
Lunatic
Solid town
Mag1c
Pie
Helz
Wyrly
Scum
Shinning
Thoth
Null
WF
Banana
Null / Unsure
Skep
Supa
Max
Casey Risk
Mestari
Any thoughts on how fast the shinning wagon grew?
Also what are your thoughts on shinning putting you as scum lean but have no thoughts on Thoth, who was the center of discussion almost the entire day phase
This Shining wagon is a gold mine. This is why we don’t end DPs super early folks
Agreed. I will say I just left synagogue and was not expecting the shinning wagon to pick up as much steam as it did. But we finally have a proper wagon and CW to analyze.
It’s sundown Friday to sundown Saturday
