Kohai's avatar

Kohai

Administrator

Member since

Kohai

I think someone is definitely fake claiming their characters. Either Tir McDohl or Ted is not in the game. I can't imagine a world where one of them is not in the game.

Kohai
If that’s the case why did you keep saying you thought tir was town?


I initially thought Tir was town because I was his father. however at that time I didn't realize we ended on opposite sides of the war which means Tir could very well be scum.

Kohai

Quick thought: Tir is not claiemd which is weird. What's the probability of wf being tir and tir being scum? Given myself and Tir end up on the opposing sides of the battle it would make sense for Teo to be town and Tir scum.

Kohai

Out of those airmax is not recruitable. The only person there that would make sense as a recruit is pie. Vader is a mislynch waiting to happen so I doubt scum would recruit them. Castin is also probably not a recruit.

Kohai

I'd be shocked if wf wasn't Tir. That said, I think we almost have a solve:


Max - Confirmed town

Pie - Town via flavor. There's no way Teo is town and Barbarossa is scum especially since I'm incredibly loyal to her.

Castin - Sonya makes flavor sense as town as she's my love interest.

Vader - Kasim Hazil - Only makes sense in town world as he's a close friend of Teo.


I honestly think the Toran Liberation team is scum.

Kohai

If Thoth flips scum this confirms pie as town. Thoughts on a possible Thoth / WF team?

Kohai

Never mind I read too much into it


VTL Thoth


if this flips town turbo lynch pie tomorrow.

Kohai
Well, I hate to break your town-read but they actually didn't. I knew Mikal was the NK.


What do you mean?

Kohai

Mechanics thought: Thoth may be town. If Thoth chose Mikal, shinning, and pie then scum probably attempted to janitor pie and then it directed to shinning. I need to think about this.


Unvote

Kohai
I am Lepant, Ascetic Leprechaun. Justification for being Leprechaun is that Lepant is a merchant with "pots of gold" who moves things from point A to point B and also has the same first syllable as Leprechaun. Justification for Ascetic is that he wanted to stay out of the war until it personally affected him.

Each night, I choose three people adjacent in the seating chart. That's the numbered list of players in the OP. If the NK targets one of them, I can move it to another. The chart loops around, i.e., 1 and 10 are currently adjacent. This action does not target and also moves NK-enhancing abilities like Janitor and Strongman. I chose Pie, Mikal, and Shining because I scumread both Pie and Shining and wanted to kill them in Mikal's stead in case Mikal was town, in which case he would probably be the NK target, as I correctly predicted.



I really don't buy this.

Kohai

I'm not buying the Leprechaun claim at all. More votes on Thoth.


I think we have a solve. My POE is {Thoth, Vader, Whiteflame}. I have strong reasons to town lock wylted.


I do think its possible for multipoe protective roles to exist, especially given the thirdp arty and multiple possible kills.

Kohai

I agree. Barbosa is almost confirmed town. My character is deeply loyal to her and there’s no way I’m town and she’s scum.

Kohai

Does it make sense theme wise for some of the great generals to be town aligned and others mafia aligned?

Kohai

VTL: Thoth


There's something that's been bothering me about Thoth and I am having difficulties finding the way to articulate why. Currently my POE is Pie, Vader, Thoth and maybe Mikal. I am almost certain there is at least one OG scum in that pile.

Kohai
If I were scum, my top concern would be hunting a recruit target, and I think you would all agree with this. Rex knew that whoever rolled scum would likely not be a lore-lord and would have no way of knowing whether or not a character can be recruited. My guess is that the anti-claim mechanic lets scum check your recruitability if they know certain information about your character, possibly with a full Rolecop

Anyone think this is borderline TMI?

Kohai

I already claimed my character


1. Pie - ??? - ???

2. Mikal - ??? - ???

3. Lunatic - ??? - ???

4. Vader - ??? - ???

5. Victor/Wylted - Milich Oppenheimer - 1x Poisoner/1x Healer

6. Airmax - Sanchez - Miller

7. Thoth - ??? - ???

8. Kohai - Teo McDohl, father of Tir - ???

9. Wryly - ??? - ???

10. WF(Ultra) - ??? - ???


Kohai

Couple of points


1) There’s already a TP Vig in the game

2) Shining’s flip is missing, presumably via a Janitor

Two very good points.


3) Shining claimed a Scarlet Empire character

Could have been a fake claim given everyone else was claiming a scarlet empire character. I wouldn't put too much weight into this.

Kohai

Couple of points


1) There’s already a TP Vig in the game

2) Shining’s flip is missing, presumably via a Janitor

Two very good points.


3) Shining claimed a Scarlet Empire character

Could have been a fake claim given everyone else was claiming a scarlet empire character. I wouldn't put too much weight into this.

Kohai

Fair point I understand your flavor concerns but flavor is not the thing we should focus the most on.

Kohai

Remember behavior and actions matter more than flavor.


if Wylted visited you and you ended up dying and that was confirmed that stuff would scum lock Wylted. Wylted is definitely town here