McDonaldsReal

WF didn't put his own claim. Everyone else forced him. He's the towniest town in the world

Unvote

VTL Thoth

Claim please

I think it's either Thoth or Shining.

VTL Mikal

I second that. And WF if there's literally anyone who can protect you I think you'll be fine.

If there is a second mafia I think it's RexFavilla

Yeah I don't think he's scum. I know I can't like say "trust me bro" but I have a read on WF. Wish I could private DM but it would go out to everybody. But if what you say is true Mikal it's not them

Not a role thing but I have heavy town reads for WF right now

I should specify: if you have information about a role. That is, you know something about a role but not about a player. Obviously if it role reveals or reveals someone else's role maybe that's an issue

Reads:

So far either Mikal and Rex are in cahoots as scum trying to pressure WF because he's being helpful (and RT bandwagoning is strange) or WF is mafia and is playing us like a fiddle.

In any case, Mikal, if you have pertinent information that has to do with someones role why don't you reveal that info? If WF is mafia he will lie about his role anyway, and if he's town he could lie too assuming that a role gives too much away

One more thing: I don't think it's the knight. We technically don't see them appear in the first 2 chapters (though they are mentioned). And I think Casey is too nice to be that pedantic.

Eh wth actually, if there are characters that are mafia I think it's gonna be either Kris (or the "soul") and Noelle (because of the quasi genocide route), Susie and Kris (both lighteners) or Kris and Ralsei (both are hiding stuff from us). It could be that the "soul" (the player) and Kris are 2 separate characters. Or not.

However, if this is not a lightener vs darkener or villains are town heroes are mafia game, I don't know.

Ah actually this is a point given that one character is non binary (and to my knowledge, only one character), and all the enemies are like.... Not genderless per se but no obvious signs of gender (I'm thinking of like the block enemies or the Original Starwalker whose literally just a fucking star). I think most of them use gendered pronouns so they do seem to identify as one gender in particular.

Kris (the player controlled character) is complicated. We (the player) technically don't even play Kris. We control the human soul (the red heart) and make decisions for Kris. Kris rebels against us and seems to be up to no good but we don't know that and in some cases Kris fights us when we start harming Kris' friends. At some point Kris rips out the soul to regain control. There is a kinda equivalent of a genocide route in the game.

It could just be a protective role blocked the Mafia's second kill. If there were two mafia and 2 mafia only I don't know if Caroler would be used because this effectively halves the number of mafia (if we guess right out of the 3).

I have a feeling that this might be lightner vs. darkners or villains are town and heroes are mafia. If it is only two I think I know which characters they are but it's just a hunch.

I don't think he sussed me.

To be clear, Mikal I think was sus of RT

Wait a sec. You criticized in the first DP that RT claimed and now you're asking for more claims when we know that there might be an anti claim mechanic. Granted I'm a little sus of everyone cause I'm new so maybe I'm just being too jumpy. But like... Why not you claim first then? Just partially? That said this could be WF deflecting too IDK (it's hard to sus him out cause he acts trustworthy and I have my money on him doing this basically every game). Would it be too much of an issue for us to claim gender? I don't wanna rock the boat but I do wanna advance the game too

Wait a sec, why did you immediately claim in DP1? Is that normal? I guess that's all you would have to go on in the first DP but... IDK man I'm still confused why you would immediately

That's a good point sorry

Also if we're going off theme - Caroler could mean Noelle Holiday or Rudy since their personalities are Christmas inspired.

Sorry I'm infodumping just thinking out loud

Also if we're going off theme - Caroler could mean Noelle Holiday or Rudy since their personalities are Christmas inspired.

Sorry I'm infodumping just thinking out loud

Also if we're going off theme - Caroler could mean Noelle Holiday or Rudy since their personalities are Christmas inspired.

Sorry I'm infodumping just thinking out loud

Cause if memory serves the Knight only makes first appearance in Ch. 2. Could be "the soul" or (if we're being really out there) Gaster technically since we never saw him yet but it's presume he's the one speaking. If this shit is like "no the Mafia is Sans and Toriel" or something like that I'm gonna lose my mind.

Wait so Queen was the main antagonist of Ch 2 and isn't Mafia. So... Which characters are the Mafia?

So I'm new but just looked up dreamer that's so funny it's like you contracted hallucinations and you're like "that's not my role"

Ohhh that makes more sense lol. I thought this was the "consequence" for claiming that Casey was talking about now you get random hallucinations or whatever

Wait is it because you claimed that this happened?

VTNL

I guess

Ok does anyone want me to claim or not. Cause I can. But I don't need to if you don't wanna

Well I can claim or not. I can do anything.

But maybe we should vote on me role revealing.

What did you want me to do again?

Wait what the McHell is going on? I leave for like a day and now there's 5 pages of comments? Jeez this game moves

What are you asking me to do?

I am gonna be super busy tomorrow with stuff. Just wanted to let everyone know because I'm gonna be low activity. I have no reads besides wylted being kinda aggro but really that could mean anything.