Mikal

Actually I’m even more sus of Wylted and pie now. No idea why that didn’t cross my mind earlier.

Wait I just figured out why scum hit earth and it’s obvious lol.

No I was bitching about David’s dumb game and he said he didn’t love anti claim and would make roles counter other roles etc

he also would have warned us about a character anti claim

some of the info I’ve said is wrong. Some is embellished and some is correct. I’m trying to misdirect scum so based on what I’ve said. I see how you got to that post

Also reading back thoths post. I don’t think it’s tmi. From his pov and some of the things I’ve said. I see how he can get to those conclusions other than the anti claim which is not in the game.

I’m just saying they will side with who wins.

if it’s 4-3-1 and they can side with scum to auto win. The will. That’s playing to their win con

I agree he was tp. I said he prob was even before he claimed it. But the second they can turn numbers and win with scum they will play to their wincon and out

I think there is only one role Thoth could be but I have no idea how that role makes him town place me

I do understand how it would solve for the wylted situation

Surprised we do not have more results tbh

That’s fair. I forgot about the janitor

Wylteds ability to heal poison is largely inconsistent with theme

Luna wanting to leave wf alive bugs me

and Thoth is just behaving weird

thats about all I have to go on.

but since the Luna claim

town pile to me is

me

max

david

castin

I don’t think we need to fully out but I’m okay with getting Vader and thoths full claims and picking from there

David’s claim seems largely reasonable and he’s been hinting at it since dp1

There is a reason I’m asking.

and I was assuming you were were barbosa

and there is a part of me that just wants to have more claims

largely because I think I can solve with inconsistencies. Combine that with behavior and we have a narrow list.

by end of claim there will be at least one claim that’s true and converted very likely. It’s why I want to do as much as I can now catching theme before they potentially convert (assuming they Havnt or could have missed ). Cus end of game it’s all behavior

Not at all.

okay that’s not what I was expecting you to say.

Are you willing to character claims. I potentially have something on you but making assumptions atm

sometimes people just shoot blindly to throw people off.

I think people are over thinking the why shining to much. They prob yolo picked and inactivity as both town and scum be a wild card

I disagree with pie about Castin as well

i think right now I’m looking between wylted pie and Luna but I’d be interested to hear wfs character

I dislike Luna right now and it’s why I want a character claim. It helps me remove him from my scum list

but his level of effort compared to other games seems very low. It’s hard to tell if that is recent or just with this.

When we feel it’s necessary I can give my actual theory but not sure if it’s game breaking for town and fucks us over if I do that

I don’t think they know who they can recruit. Plus I’ve been just saying a bunch of dumb shit about who can and can’t be just to confuse them

i do know who can be recruited though. Not sure it’s entirely intuitive

Why do you think scum can recruit the generals ?

I had something happen and depending on his character. I potentially can townlock him.

Will you character claim?

I forget. Was dart

Why do we not want them to know who the great generals are

He didn’t create an antidote. Liuken did.

I’m waiting to hear other results are thoughts. It is possible he just wrote it for flavor. It’s just consistent with the game.

so we will see how it plays out

It’s how I caught wf

It’s possible bust still don’t buy the flavor of his role