Mikal's avatar

Mikal

Administrator

Member since

Mikal

I disagree with this wholy lol.

you are to stuck on the five generals. One of them is a good fake claim


I get why you think that as teo but skep confirmed he gave them fake claims

Mikal

Yes


soul eater insta kills people in the game by removing them from the field. So it’s a very good way to write in the deletion effect.




Mikal

Do you mind character claiming



I may possibly be able to confirm you. Not 100 percent sure but depending on your character I can town lock you.

Mikal

I think I know who barbosa is so I think I have a pretty good town pile atm


town pile


max

luna

David

myself

Castin



Luna could change and Castin is a behavior read



but myself max and and David are pretty hard town imo

Mikal

im prob moving forward with David as a town confirmation for a variety of reasons that I am not going to mention. But he’s basically town confirmed.

Mikal

So tir used his soul eater rune to kill someone and delete them out of the game as town



i Don’t buy scum can’t kill unless tir can kill as town


if tir is town and killed someone and deleted them out of the game flip and all.


they should claim or we should assume he is scum

Mikal

I’m not dismissing it. The posion does wear off



I’m just saying it’s very inconsistent

Mikal

You need to claim your character today. You said you would if you were alive and we need some Claims or results.


chances are we get today and tomorrow so we all can’t just shit up. Need to start piecing stuff together.



and I was town reading you off your dp1 thoughts and now you are backtracking

Mikal

You don’t need to do a defense. It just whether I think skep made something inconsistent with the theme because of balance.


given how in depth all his pms are I’m struggling with this

Mikal

Look at your pm And how in depth it is and tell me skep Fucked up. He’s also back tracking sayinf someone else could heal it in game.


Liukan isn’t in this game lol. I don’t even have to ask someone to claim cus it’s just not.



I mean debating if I want to kill him off that but it’s hella sus

Mikal

I also don’t buy that. The only person who can heal this is Liukan and he’d be scum because he was a hermit.


Mikal

I mean I could be wrong but this is so inconsistent with lore, I can’t buy it. It’s possible he did that but skep is way to into lore to just throw that in imo. Want to sit on it some more but lord it’s not consistent.

Mikal

Skep writes 2 + paragraphs of justifications and you don’t have a reason why you heal?

Mikal

This confirms it even more



if you got just a character. They got milich and wylted made that role up

Mikal

It’s not. It’s a good fake claim. There are 5. Giving one to them makes perfect sense

Mikal

No I think they got milich


and they had to make something work with it



skep did not write he is a healer in his pm. I can’t see any world where that is a justification

Mikal

Yea it’s making me second guess David


janitor could be a lot of people. The vanishing like he never existed is very consistent with soul eater



so mathiu could be in the game. Really a lot of people could be scum if tir started scum



Mikal

Oh and barbosa is a town lock and prob has a true rune. I believe it’s his sword and it’s the sovereign true rune.



im not going to say how I know but I’m pretty sure I know who this is

Mikal

anyway I’m going to air this out.


wylted is claiming milich


milich does not cure poison. He is a hard town character in this theme. He poisons people as they visit his castle. One arch of the game requires healing that posion and it’s by doctor Liukan. I don’t think skep fucks this up and writes this into an actual character


they we’re prob either given milich and they came up with the claim or for whatever reason he’s saying he heals I’ll die on the hill skep did not make him a healer.

Mikal

If mathias is in the game he’s scum lock


there are two scenarios



if tir is scum, Mathias can be in the game and on the scum team


if tir is town. Mathias is prob not in the game at all



i think it’s the former. I think Wyited is tir

Mikal

I don’t think so at all. That’s just factually not accurate in the game at all


its inconsistent as shit

Mikal

I think Thoth or wylted are scum and I’m heavily thinking Wylted


The healing part of his character makes no sense at all.

Mikal

Can you ask those questions differently and so I can process it differently and I will answer