Shining

You are assuming we are dealing with a conventional poisoner. I assume we are not given its chuuni name

Also, I should have a double vote, so VTL Thoth to prove it.

Shining

Vader can appoint a new Empress if I die, so its not some massive loss. Additionally, its not like I dropped dead providing zero value to town. You have the role cop on Mago and the existence of a Shadow Poisoner to work with

Its a gambit on mafia's part.

Shining

Pie never fucking uses his policy. Next time I'm mafia, I'm claiming Miller because Pie won't lynch me.

Shining

The thing is, why would a scum!wryly cc me like that? If they managedl to secure a mislynch on me, that just placed wryly in a nad spot and mafia will always lose a 1 for 1 trade. Its mind-boggling and I feel like we are missing something important that no one seems to care about.

Shining

Well, lynching awesome for being inactive isn't ideal, but its better than lynching the cop.


VTL awesome

Shining


Why do you think I’m being a dumbass for voting you?

My reason for thinking you’re scum(my) is that Mafia do like to reveal their investigative results, for towncred and because, who’s gonna kill a Mafia? It’s risk-free.


You have done nothing but OMGUS all game. And I still haven't seen a good reason why I should get lynched. Yeah, nafia sometimes like to reveal their own results, but I am still town.

Shining

Fuca Langhua. My justification is something like I have a network of spies that allow me to tracks rivals or some shit.

Shining

Why have all your takes been so shit? Like I would be dumbfounded if you are actually mafia. But go ahead and lynch the claimed cop.

Shining

Know what? Sure. My consort role is Odd night Rolecop, my noble consort is odd night cop, and my passive is careful.

Shining

I really didn't and still don't know what to make of Magoroth. He played a bad DP1 and if he had been lynched, I would probably be okay with it. But by NP1 I felt like he was a mislynch target and wanted to avoid that, or confirm him as scum.

Shining
Favor and town cred? They poison Mago, Shining town confirms him, and then Mago dies from poison, flips town, confirms Shining's rolecop results, and Shining ends up looking pretty good.

But I have lingering questions: why does scum Shining say the Shadow Poisoner visited him, and why does scum Shining fake claim a passive like that when Rex handed scum fake role cards that were perfectly safe to claim? Also, why did scum poison Mago at all? He's an easy mislynch target, why waste poison on him.


Why would I want favor when its obvious I am already Empress? Also, why would I bother announcing the shadow poisoner at all? If its an issue of town cred, I argubly did that with the rolecop.


Shining

Isn't it just as likely shadow poisoner works by visiting someone, and whoever the target visits gets poisoned instead? Would make sense, especially since I wouldn't have known if it wasn't for my passive.

Shining

I'm debating if my role is supposed to tell me an investigative/healing/etc role visited me and Wryly tells him the name of the role, but mine seemingly told me a role name. I dunno. I town read Wryly nonetheless. Confusing.

Shining

I targeted Magoroth because he was constantly lying and pushing a mass claim. I investigated him so that I either catch him in a lie or I at least confirm his roles so we don't end up barking up the wrong tree like we usually do.