Shining

My theory is that scum is disgraced MAGA people. Maybe Pence and MTG. I doubt Pie would make democrats scum, but whatever.

Its DP1. Everyone is practically fluff posting. I don't care who we pressure. Pick someone, make them character/role claim and lunch them if they are especially scummy.

I wouldn't put much money in a possible mod kill. I did think it was odd that Thoth edited his post because he been he long enough to know thats not allowed here. idk.

lmao its a bit too late to say that after everyone softed.

I'm of the opinion that theme analysis ends up being worthless 80% of the time. There can be a bumch of different things the theme could be and thene basically only exists as an extra hurdle for mafia to leap over.

I'm a little shocked that people seem supportive of potential war with Iran.

Almost forgot about this game lol. I see we are softing. I am currently in the Trump administration.

You were saying in the mafia discord that this game was cursing the Bears, so lets hope they do better next game.

Tell me about it. Town was OP as shit.

Whew. That was quite the game. Good job WF. GG all.

Honestly, I'm tired man lol. So long Thoth doesn't do anything stupid like overturn it to Kohai, town has this. So I don't care if I get mislynched. Town won in much dire straits 🤷‍♂️.

He went from dayvig to being able to kill another person to governor.

Thoth has been so cagey with his role, I thought he could kill in twilight. He even said that we should no lynch today. I have no idea what he can actually do.

How does getting a few more flips make Kohai townier or scummier? Why wait to read him? Am I not understanding something about your stance on Kohai here?

I have played too many games where we just let mafia pull a fairly risky gambit and let them coast into Endgame unchallenged. I don't remember when I posted that but Kohai is 100% town. By behavior or what have you. At the end if DP1 I considered Kohai a lean town and now hes strong town. I suppose I am noncommital when it comes to reading people.

Just do what Mharman says.

Unvote

VTNL

I am gaining a bit of weight. I don't want being retarded to be added to my pile of woes. I remember him saying we can have him shoot in place of the lynch.

The plan is to NL.

Well, maybe you should stop acting scummy with roles then.

I take it you have a grudge?

Are you guys listening to this shit?

Fuck if I know. Mago has been strange all game, but maybe WF depending on flips?

Thoth can't shoot himself, so Mago.

All of this is pointless if Thoth lied about his role. We have around 13 hours remaining, i want to lynch mafia, so hurry up and lynch Thoth/Magoroth.

How many had 3 investigation PRs and also a dayvig?

I'm not gonna believe it til I see it. I'm the Roleblocker. My justification has a lot of football shit I don't understand, but the gist I got is that someone eliminated the Bears from playoffs and kicked them from NFC North. idk

Is there a reason you haven't already shot WF?

I remember you used to be utterly baffled by how I play mafia. Like i get I am inherently scummy, but at this point you have to lnow my town play. Magoroth's claim is simply unbelievable for me. People (and I) have already went over Mago.

Can mafia ask about 4 characters or 4 roles?

Also Make Mafia Great Again /in

MAGOROTH

Pretty odd claim. I really find it hard to accept his play this past DP. I think Mharman already pointed this out but it really was odd that hes bouncing back and forth how reliable his claim is. I can't believe Vader would say his role is 100% reliable and would also give the number of scum on the Rex lynch. His role is busted. Even without Pie, I don't know he expected mafia to win this. Hes lean scum for me.

THOTH

Thoth is also playing bizarrely. When he said hes confident WF is scum, he proceeds to afk for hours after numerous attempts to explain and only then gives a fairly contrived scumtell WF supposedly created. WF might actually be scum, but I really don't like how he tried to hide it. Thoth also explains that WF made the same tell as town, so how reliable is it even?

WHITEFLAME

Whiteflame has been afk all game. I remember him being more active and while he never really drove town like Pie does, he does help town when he can. Maybe hes busy from the holidays, but its frustrating because its making me scum read him, especially when Thoth and Magoroth are sussing him.

MHARMAN

Mharman claim stands out to me because while I'll behavior read him as town, he claim as vanilla stand out because counting him, we had 3 vanilla like roles (Hated, bleeder and now vanilla). I could buy it, but its worth taking into consideration.

Scum is probably WF/Thoth or maybe Thoth/Magoroth.

In Barry mafia the informed was useless and even if the hidden Nexus was alive, no one bothered with the informed.