Shining

I remember playing as a Tailor and I could not alter alignments.

If Alyssa is scum, then her role isn't much help because even if it resets, town will just vote you again.

I'll buy that from Mharman.

First is called Widely Admired - I require one additional vote beyond the normal majority to be eliminated during the day phase. Once this ability triggers, the vote count resets and this ability is consumed.

This is what Alyssa said about her role. Mikal reset the votes when she reached 9 votes. Popular would have been lunched at 10. What exactly is the trigger? Popular is nonsensical in context. Imagine if I voted immediately after Casey did. Would the hammer happen? No. Mikal would reset the vote when Casey 'hammered' and I would be the sole vote on the new VC.

Can you explain to a retard like me why Alyssa would be some Popular then? Her role triggered when she was at 9/9 votes. That isn't Popular. All we saw was that she can reset votes against her once.

I did see him talk about how sus Alyssa is or whatever so its not like hes sleeping.

Actually I just noticed Pie isn't voting Alyssa.

Town

Lunatic

Wylted

Shining

Lean Town

Helz

Mestari

magic

Vader

Alyssa

I feel like everyone feels like something is off about Alyssa. The thing I am thinking about is how her first role works and how they described it, but maybe I am just stupid. Alyssa is however is REALLY experienced mafia player. I think more than a few times they had to have been up against the wall defending themselves and even for stupid reasons. Them giving up is odd. Also, as I believe it was Lunatic who said it, Alyssa seemingly decided to volunteer her character and role. Hard scum, but her giving up is giving me a bit of pause.

Anyone else not mentioned is more or less null, but I am interested in Pie regardless of how this lynch flips.

Going to sleep. I imagine Alyssa's scum buddies will work hard to make a defense. Funny that Alyssa afks when she gets shit.

Literally everyone that plays mafia with Pie agrees he sometimes leads town off a cliff. Pie just acts like that.

VTL Alyssa

Honestly the more I think about it, the more I scratch my head and wonder. Alyssa's first role doesn't seem to be Popular. Its more like a governor. I don't understand why Alyssa saud that she needs an extra vote to be lunched if votes reset when she hits L-0.

If that’s the case then she just died and it blew up in their face

True. But I wouldn't put it past the more gifted players to pull a gambit like them being 1x lynch proof or a governor. Probably not though this time. Still think Alyssa is a little sus from her explaing her role.

I'll note Alyssa could be faking her popular in some fashion.

All of it really.

Like if I am a mafia redirector and I target you, it doesn't really matter who you originally targeted?

I guess, but you shouldn't fear a redirector anyway? I don't understand your logic.

In theory, not visiting plays around other ways to fuck with my targeting (like a redirector or something).

In practice, I just didn't think about it

Maybe I am just exhausted, but wdym?

Lunatic and Wylted are town

Mestari is town

Magic and Vader/WF lean town, but moreso Magic.

Honestly? Pie. Don't really get a good feel for the guy and hes a pain in the ass no matter what his alignment is.

I simpky have no opinion on Thoth. If you don't like it, give me a TL;DR why I should vote him.

I suppose and while it does, it pisses me off that Pie gets on my ass to post reads.

Can you expand on what makes you think lynching Thoth is lynching blind?

I just feel like half the time we lynch people for basically retarded reasons, and like 1/4 of the other time we lynch for reasons that boil down to "uh, DP is ending soon and I guess x is kinda scummy so YOLO???" if you want Thoth dead, fine. Whatever, but I can't really get a good read on anyone that isn't mech cleared or Mestari right now.

Whats the math on VTNLing over mislynching? I get the meta here is to lynch DP1 even if it results in a mislynch

Right now I feel like we are basically lynching blind. Wryly hasn't popped out in my mind as particularly scummy.

Shining

Lunatic

Wylted

Lean town

Mestari

I already touched on Mestari

I have terrible reads DP1 and having to parse through thousand posts isn't helping. I will disregard guilds as that just serves as a distraction for town.

Good luck with the job interview. I have one coming up soon.

Anyway, I don't really get the Mestari wagon. We had like 2 wagons recently that blew up in town's faces just because a townie was obstinate. I slightly town Mestari. I don't remember how he plays, but I have a good gut read on him and we can always revisit him later. Lunatic and Wylted are hard town. Still not done reading

I read the past few pages and I don't think anyone is at L-1.

Well, this is fun. Its nice to wake up to 500 messages that I'll have to read.

/in

Sounds like you are trying to pin me as redirector, but obviously Lunatic and Thoth don't know that.

I am always this quiet. Pie bitches constantly about how I lurk or whatever.

You really want a redirector to be accepted because its the only way I am not confirmed town. Maybe there isn't a redirector and ninja. Maybe banana overtuned town and last mafia is just goon. Who knows.