wylted

If we apply Occam's razor than the only person dumb enough to kill Shining here would be Vader so

VTL Vader

He was probably drunk when he did it

Wouldn't it t be odd if there was like some role where the scum could choose to target a player and whoever that player visits gets killed?

Like they choose somebody and it would be funny because they could come in and have a watcher fake claim ready or a tracker fake claim ready and then they could claim they tracked the person to the kill. I never seen a role like that but it would be interesting . Is there a character in this game that could make that happen?

He’s also back tracking sayinf someone else could heal it in game.

I am not backtracking. The wording is ambiguous and I think it could mean a second healer. It's 2 sentences

The poisoned player may be healed in the DP. You can choose to heal the player.

So like 2 sentences when it would more naturally be said

The player will die unless healed by you. You are also 1x healer.

So it deals ambiguous to me and I am going back and forth on if it means a second healer

I mean Milich is a botanist but he didn't create the antidote for the main poison he uses in the game.

I have done zero research on this theme. I will take your word for that. I also think you guys might want me to make a vigorous defense of myself and I won't do it. All I can do is present facts and hope they are interpreted correctly.

Skep writes 2 + paragraphs of justifications and you don’t have a reason why you heal?

Lol yes this is correct. I am not mad it is what it is but yes it mentions poison a lot but only mentions healing as kinda an after thought. I think he added it for balance late in the design stage

My character explanation also seems to imply there could be another protective role or something that could heal after the fact because it says a person could heal or I could do it over the course of the DP. It can be interpreted both ways tbh

What was your PM's justification for the healing part of your power

I think healer was an afterthought to be honest because it says I am a master of botanical.arts which can be deadly and because of this mastery I am 1x poisoner and a 1x healer.

I didn't make the justification though.

If you redirected me to poison somebody else or something crazy you should say so I can heal them

Thoth can apparently verify I am innocent somehow. He isn't a cop so not sure how he would but he says it

You know what annoys me is I can't black mail any players for information now that are in my scum pool

I can say it would be odd if thoth was scum and having that sort of mild panic about the situation

I saw people were going after Wylted

I literally did not notice if they were lol.

Yes it is a movie name

Keeping your role in reserve when you can't verify that it was used, and potentially getting a chance to use it later, seems valuable.

It's 1x and I shot my load

What’s your character and justification?

I am waiting for a few other people to ask that since op in DP1 said character claiming could harm town and allow scum to know who is safe to recruit

This really isn't much to base a decision on, but I feel like shooting from the hip would be characteristic of you, so whatever.

I am the type of person when I have the vigilante I just use it every single night and am often mistaken for the SK

So you’re admitting to visiting the person who you think got NKed?

Yes I visited the NK victim and attacked him with a lethal substance that had a delayed effect but apparently the scum team wanted the same person dead

Yeah... this is why it would have paid to ask about it before announcing that you poisoned him.

What harm is there in me role claiming early this DP?

I havent played with him before but he was saying obvious stuff and it felt like fluff. Like his comments about white flame felt contrived. I guess it's too late now but he had so few posts maybe he was hinting at a role and the scum team want to use the role he was hinting at as a fake claim or something

Pardon he said alive and fully functional. So he was the NK target which surprises me

I just got word back. Red says a poison victim would still be alive the following DP so probably just a coincidence with the NK

I didn't choose to heal him yet but I can this DP and assume others will want me to

It does say in the PM he heals over the course of the DP which seems to imply he isn't fully healed until the DP is over

So if you choose to heal him, does he magically show up right now?

I believe so but not sure.

I asked ref and am awaiting a response

Do I put in the request to heal him or not I am probably the only person here who suspects he is scum so?

I just asked ref if he says my role doesn't act like that it's an NK if he says it does or refuses to answer I will use my healing ability

It could be coincidence that they NKed who I targeted. Let me heal him and if it works we know he wasnt the NK

So... you poisoned him, but didn't check to see what the effect of said poison would be?

Correct. I guess I can ask now to see if that is the effect of the poison but I assumed he would be informed he was poisoned and mention it during the DP where I would offer to save him if he full claimed and I liked what he said.

Also, wouldn't that suggest that the NK failed?

I think so

I guess you are catching up. I poisoned him but I was told he wouldn't die until the following NP so unless scum coincidentally killed him I think his death is temporary unless we decide I don't use my healing ability