I support trans people, because I oppose slavery

Started by SatanLucy

Replies
73
Posts
74
Page
1 / 3

Conversation

#1 •••

It is a true dichotomy that you can either believe people own their bodies, or not believe that.


But if you believe someone else owns my body, you believe in slavery (state of being owned by someone else).


But then the issue rises, if you believe people can own bodies of other people, who gets to own who?


How do we decide who gets to own who?


Do I get to own you then? I am fine with that if slavery is true.


But because I oppose slavery and dont believe its true, then no one can own other people.


So trans people can do anything they want to their bodies. Its their body, not mine.



Edit comment

#2 •••

Who gets to own whom?

Edit post

#3 •••

Do you support conversion therapy for gay people just because someone brainwashed them into thinking they should identify as straight despite their reality?

Edit post

#4 •••
@SatanLucy

In other words: Do you support conversion therapy for gay people just because someone brainwashed them into thinking they should identify as straight, despite their biological reality? If not, then why would you support doing the exact same thing to someone with dysphoria, encouraging them to reject reality instead of helping them reconcile with it?

Edit post

#5 •••
@SatanLucy

The therapist owns both.

Edit post

#6 •••
@Shoresy
In other words: Do you support conversion therapy for gay people just because someone brainwashed them into thinking they should identify as straight, despite their biological reality? If not, then why would you support doing the exact same thing to someone with dysphoria, encouraging them to reject reality instead of helping them reconcile with it?


If some gay wants to try being straight, thats okay.

Edit post

#7 •••
@SatanLucy

I expect that most trans people rely on others to do things for them.


Such is self determination.

Edit post

#8 •••
@Shoresy

Everything that occurs within a universe at any given moment is real.


It is impossible to reject reality

Edit post

#9 •••
@SergeantLynch
I expect that most trans people rely on others to do things for them.


Yes, voluntary.

Edit post

#10 •••

Everybody is someones servant. Saying people define themselves by feelings rather than chromosomes just tells you whose servant they are.

Edit post

#11 •••
@melcharaz

Servant, sure. Being owned by another person tho, cannot be defended because we cannot decide who owns whom. Do I own all of you guys?

Edit post

#12 •••
@SatanLucy
we cannot decide who owns whom

Yes we can.


"I give myself the right to decide...I decided that other people are, in most cases, dogs who should serve me until they die."


- Best.Korea


https://web.archive.org/web/20250715173103/https://www.debateart.com/debates/3821-anyone-who-disagrees-with-me-is-wrong-i-am-always-right

Edit post

#13 •••
@SatanLucy

They rely upon the determination of others, which is slavery to a system.


And the others are slaves to the system of wealth and power.



A Lynchku for Lucy.


Slaves to drugs.


Slaves to technology.


Slaves to inherent programming.


Slaves to Planet Earth, the Sun and the Universe.


Slaves to evolution and the GOD Principle.


So Batman, anoint yourself with sheer lingerie and call yourself Daisy for a relative nanosecond of sexuality and existence.


Such is volunteering.



Edit post

#14 •••
@SergeantLynch
They rely upon the determination of others, which is slavery to a system.


Body ownership means the opposite. It means they determine for themselves and others dont try to prevent them from making own choices.

Edit post

#15 •••
@Savant
"I give myself the right to decide...I decided that other people are, in most cases, dogs who should serve me until they die."


I am mean when drunk.

Edit post

#16 •••
@SatanLucy

A body is and ownership is a concept.

Edit post

#17 •••
@SergeantLynch

Ownership simply means my body belongs to me.

Edit post

#18 •••

Born--Blip--Dead

Edit post

#19 •••

"Owning" another's body or soul is generally considered impossible and unethical within religious, philosophical, and ethical frameworks, as both the body and soul are viewed as belonging to the individual, God, or a greater divine being. Concepts like bodily stewardship (Islam) and the soul's inherent individuality (various beliefs) suggest that a person's existence, including their physical form and spiritual essence, is not a commodity to be possessed by another. Instead, ideas of human relationships and care focus on respect for the individual's whole being, including their body, mind, and spirit. 





Edit post

#20 •••

I question what trans has to do with other body ownership, let alone other-body ownership with straights and gays/lesbians. W/here trains believe they can be either/or, or "other" simultaneously, what has that to do with anyone else? It's still a trans' own body, so no other body ownership is in play, unless they do accept slavery, which, clearly, some straights and gays/lesbians do, as well.

Edit post

We tell God what to do and then blame Him for our errors.

- Dr. Pet Dragon of Sorbonne University

#21 •••
@SatanLucy
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

#22 •••
@RemyBrown

You can say that, but many even oppose trans gender care. So I would say there are people trying to decide how much body ownership can other people have. Now, I also support self-determination when it comes to names. I dont give people names. People tell me their names and that is how I call them. Tho I understand one can use freedom to give people names.

Edit post

#23 •••
@SatanLucy
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

#24 •••
@RemyBrown
You are a bitchy and petty asshole if you think calling Caitlyn Jenner a man is the same as taking away their human rights because you disagree with a classificationist issue


I dont think misgendering is any serious crime. I just consider it not polite for me to use it.

Edit post

#25 •••
@SatanLucy
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

#26 •••
@fauxlaw

The principle that "trans people should own their own bodies" is an articulation of bodily autonomy and self-determination, meaning that transgender individuals have the fundamental right to make decisions about their own bodies, including choices regarding their gender identity and medical care. This right encompasses access to gender-affirming care, such as hormone therapy or counseling, and the freedom to make personal choices about appearance, identity, and healthcare, free from external pressure or discrimination. 





Edit post

#27 •••
@RemyBrown

Sure, if person wants to be called that.

Edit post

#28 •••
@SatanLucy

Trans people don’t want to be labeled but to be accepted for what they are.

Edit post

#29 •••
@SatanLucy
⚠️ This comment has been marked as offensive.

Edit post

#30 •••
@RemyBrown

If they dont like the name, I wouldnt call them that name. There is no point in me making someone uncomfortable like that.

Edit post