Madoka Magica - Episode 3

hold on guys

i think the most compelling point here is the behavior about his claim

the request to be rolecopped was the big one

but i still don't like a lot of things

nice omgus lol

It’s obvious to anyone with eyes. You were hard defending Wryly with bogus arguments that you just admitted were bogus

In her recent scum game she literally blundered by saying 2 words she wasn’t supposed to say (she got blown up because of it)

That's fair. Then again it was super easy to fuck up and mikal almost fucked it up also. We have very few posts from her to compare her play to

Ive explained that it’s not a guarantee that Kyosuke is in the game

True but it seems odd that 2/3 are in the game.

nah, I may have been too hasty to concede

Exactly. If pie is scum I have to believe that he's YOLOing to get castin mislynched when he has other mislynch targets.

If castin is scum then I have to believe they played a nearly perfect game and blundered the fake claim. I will then have to believe that either they were recruited or they are OG scum and Kyosuke isn't actually in the game. If castin was originally town then I don't see them claiming anything other than their original role.

This leads me to conclude there's a strong non-zero chance they are both town

Fair points. I'll make a decision by midnight EST.

I'm not sure I like magic's sudden pivot to wryly

Yeah... strange timing and just fully conceding the point. Still, doesn't do much to shake my townread.

I'll have you know it was 1 word. Mikal had already said the other taboo word, and we only got one warning between us, which he'd used up

I really did fuck it up spectacularly though

????

Assume both of you are actually town. Who is the likely scum?

If Wryly flips town here, I am asking Thoth to replace me. I’m not moving my vote off of Wryly. Period

I really did fuck it up spectacularly though

The entire game was a cluster fuck

????

Eh?

I really did fuck it up spectacularly though

It happens. Hope you feel better, sounds like you're going through it.

oh you're talking about a couple games ago

thought that was a confession for a sec

nah, I may have been too hasty to concede

Alright then. I'll stick around, taking any lingering thoughts into account.

Vote Count

Wryly (2/4) | ILikePie5, Vader -- L2

ILikePie5 (1/4) Wryly

Kohai (1/4) | RexFavilla

Not voting: whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman

That's fair. Then again it was super easy to fuck up and mikal almost fucked it up also. We have very few posts from her to compare her play to 

Exactly, which is why I’m saying you have to compare something against a control. Basic science really. Even I’ll admit I was fooled.

True but it seems odd that 2/3 are in the game.

It could be from a hint that Thoth gave about a fake character.

D) I always take a free Mislynch here, kill Mharman2, and the fight it out tomorrow.

hmmmm

It could be from a hint that Thoth gave about a fake character.

fair

If Wryly flips town here, I am asking Thoth to replace me. I’m not moving my vote off of Wryly. Period

Sounds like this could end up being a trust tell. We lynch castin you replace out castin replaces you and then we can narrow down the game

Vote Count

Wryly (2/4) | ILikePie5, Vader

ILikePie5 (1/4) Wryly

Kohai (1/4) | RexFavilla

Not voting: whiteflame, Kohai, Mag1cman

Fuck it. I'm more and more convinced that this is town vs town and they're both actually 1x bullet proof. From a game balanced POV with killing and recruting mechanisms town needs more protection from night kills. We already have a doctor + 1 bp so there's no reason to think a second bp can't exits.

Assuming pie and castin are both town our POE narrows to: whiteflame, rex, vader, and mag2cman. For reasons I've already stated I don't think rex is the recruit. That leaves whiteflame, mag2cman and vader as the ultimate POE

I have five hours to drive tomorrow, and I just got caught up. I see Castin flubbing a fakeclaim as scum as far more likely than Pie trying to CC in a way which will give us a 1:1 trade if he's scum. I'm just gunna lay my vote on Wryly for now, if you don't lynch her please lynch SOMEBODY, even me if only to put me out of my misery.

VTL Wryly

VTL Whiteflame

Vote Count

Wryly (3/4) | ILikePie5, Vader, Whiteflame <-- L1

ILikePie5 (1/4) Wryly

Whiteflame (1/4) | Kohai

Not voting: whiteflame

Fuck it. I'm more and more convinced that this is town vs town and they're both actually 1x bullet proof. From a game balanced POV with killing and recruting mechanisms town needs more protection from night kills. We already have a doctor + 1 bp so there's no reason to think a second bp can't exits.

Im going to make it really easy for you. The lynch today is Pie or Wryly. There is no third option today. I am not changing my vote ever for the rest of the game.

I get your perspective on this, but I don't think we have much choice this DP. If there are somehow two BPs in this game, that's something we can revisit with knowledge of one of their flips in hand, which is more than we have right now. This will either come to a head this DP or next, and I'd rather know that we have another DP to work this out in case we mislynch.

I'm sticking to my guns.

VTL Pie

Vote Count

Wryly (2/4) | ILikePie5, Vader

ILikePie5 (2/4) Wryly, Magicman

Whiteflame (1/4) | Kohai

Not voting: whiteflame

Corrected

B) When I was Barbarossa in REF’s game, I delayed CCed there too.

ILikePie5

09/30/2025 05:28PM••• #474

Debates: 0

Comments: 991

LMFAO

VTL Thoth

This was your first post after Thoth claimed in Suikoden. The only reason you didn't instantly clarify your obvious CC was that you wanted to hit a few points. Herdly a delay.

Vote Count

Wryly (3/4) | ILikePie5, Vader, RexFavilla

ILikePie5 (2/4) | Wryly, Mag1cman

whiteflame (1/4) | Kohai

Not voting: whiteflame