Periodic Table of Elements Mafia - DP1

Banana wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

Mikal wrote:

I think id rather push Casey. They seem to be sliding under the radar and I think more often than not. Scum get away with that. If the options we have are rex and bullish, id rather it be bullish. Rex still reads me as town

VTL: Bullish

do not vote bullish. the decision to soft radium long before he claimed it is incredibly towny, obvious pr behavior, he is probably the NK tonight if not lynched

@bullish only give role if you're at l-1

i dont know you should be drawing attention to this, he only has 3 votes i think.

the concern is towny

I'll probably be voting between the three of you. I want each of you to at least claim something.

RexFavilla wrote:

However, I am seriously saying it now: thinking this is how I play as scum and not exploring other reasons I could be acting erratic is retarded. I don't think Helz is retarded. I think he is looking for excuses to scum read me and is not at all steelmanning my case. I think he is also playing defensive and reacted oddly to my random FOS.

VTL: Helz

Great story.

Can you explain your own behavior? I can explain every post I have made an why but you seem to really struggle to explain your own posts throwing out "Well it was a joke" now that you are a serious option for the EOD elimination.

Helz wrote:

RexFavilla wrote:

Like, Im just really stuck on how Rex could have the position that its unreasonable to not be town read with a few bullshit RVS posts followed by a massive chain of questionable reasoning.

If it was just a joke and you were just doing reaction tests why did you not say as much 20 hours ago?

Because it was painfully obvious. We were a few pages in the DP and were just dicking around with RVS. Kohai votes me and I tell him he's retarded for not seeing how town I am.

OBVIOUSLY, I AM NOT MAKING A RATIONAL, COGENT ARGUMENT THAT IT IS OBSCENE TO NOT HAVE A HARD TOWN READ AT THIS POINT.

OBVIOUSLY.

Automated Vote Count

This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.

Bullish (3/7): Magoroth (p#403), whiteflame (p#417), Mikal (p#578)

RexFavilla (3/7): Helz (p#222), Lunatic (p#247), Banana (p#563)

Helz (2/7): Thoth (p#577), RexFavilla (p#597)

Magoroth (1/7): Bullish (p#73)

Not Voting (4): Casey_Risk, Kohai (p#499), Mag1cman, Shining

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day phase ends in 10 hours.

Do you really think rex over bullish?

I dont see it at all

Out of the three I'm almost always voting rex here

btw if the mafia team needs me pointing out that Bullish is likely town by way of obvious PR behavior, just to figure out that Bullish is a PR, when he literally softed his character, and then claimed his character without claiming his role, then they can just have the hint cause they're clearly gonna need all the hints they can get lol

Kohai wrote:

I'll probably be voting between the three of you. I want each of you to at least claim something.

I role block everyone that targets a player neutralizing everything.

Mikal wrote:

Do you really think rex over bullish?

I dont see it at all

moreso that i think bullish is more likely to be town than Rex.

wanna put some pressure on someone else?

Thoth wrote:

What did you mean when you said in #34 that oganesson was a weird part of the table to pull a fake-claim from?

Fairly unknown element, weird pull if you’re asking questions about what elements are in the game apart from wondering if a very recent element is in the game for some reason.

Mag1cman wrote:

btw if the mafia team needs me pointing out that Bullish is likely town by way of obvious PR behavior, just to figure out that Bullish is a PR, when he literally softed his character, and then claimed his character without claiming his role, then they can just have the hint cause they're clearly gonna need all the hints they can get lol

Let's mercy kill one another I'm tired of this town.

i think the biggest thing for me is rex being so stubborn about why ppl are lynching him, acting like is unfathmlble he coudl be scum and omgusing those voting him, yet admitting he was acting scummy on prupose. it makes no sense

Probably dead tonight now but eyh. Fuck it

Mag1cman wrote:

btw if the mafia team needs me pointing out that Bullish is likely town by way of obvious PR behavior, just to figure out that Bullish is a PR, when he literally softed his character, and then claimed his character without claiming his role, then they can just have the hint cause they're clearly gonna need all the hints they can get lol

That was super not helpful to point out...

Claims list:

Claims:

Thoth- Oganesson- Hidden role until dp4 (post 4, dp1)

Kohai- ??? - Innocent child (Post 178, dp1)

Bullish -?? - cesium - ??

Helz - I role block everyone that targets a player neutralizing everything.

Unclaimed:

Lunatic

RexFavilla

Shining

Mikal

Casey

Banana

Whiteflame

Mag1cMan

Magoroth

I have like 20 mins before I crash. We are prepping for graduation next week so doubt I'm around before eod

Is there any chance I sell Casey here. Otherwise I need to park my vote and I do not feel comfortable with rex personally

Mikal wrote:

Do you really think rex over bullish?

I dont see it at all

if rex seems town this whole "i saw rex as town the whole game' is gonna feel a lot like tmi. u really dont see why ppl scum read him

Casey

Helz wrote:

Kohai wrote:

I'll probably be voting between the three of you. I want each of you to at least claim something.

I role block everyone that targets a player neutralizing everything.

like passively or is it a 1x

Mikal wrote:

Casey

alr ill take alook when im done catching up

Mikal wrote:

I have like 20 mins before I crash. We are prepping for graduation next week so doubt I'm around before eod

Is there any chance I sell Casey here. Otherwise I need to park my vote and I do not feel comfortable with rex personally

I'm willing to potentially CFD on Casey. Give me a case that's not "Casey's inactive therefore scum."

casey has been inactive as town a couple times now, i think its kind of a waste of a lynch

Yes because hes polar fucking opposite of how he plays as scum. He literally afks and doesn't engage lol.

The fact hes a lynch target and still trolling is like such a town tell lol. Hes annoyed and is basically saying fuck around and find out. Its obvious as shit to me

i figured out what bothered me about whiteflame. it's this post. @whiteflame are you able to find an example of you doing this as town?

If don't see the incentive for town whiteflame to out that he's not magnesium. I'm aware it's a follow-up from the sign-ups thread for funsies, but I still think town whiteflame has more of an incentive to not give mafia even the slightest bit of hints.

Literally just saying I’m not the thing I said I wanted to be in sign ups is off? It’s exactly one element, I don’t get how this is problematic with a table full of them left.

this post: I can see the town incentive and the scum incentive. both are kinda obvious

Fair, I’d probably post something like what you referenced as either alignment.

I haven’t had a chance to catch up, just wanted to address the tags. I’ll be back.

Helz wrote:

Mag1cman wrote:

btw if the mafia team needs me pointing out that Bullish is likely town by way of obvious PR behavior, just to figure out that Bullish is a PR, when he literally softed his character, and then claimed his character without claiming his role, then they can just have the hint cause they're clearly gonna need all the hints they can get lol

That was super not helpful to point out...

it is to stop a bullish mislynch

and to restate: If the mafia team needed my help figuring that one out, then they are a weak team who will screw up later anyway. I'm not worried.

Banana wrote:

i think the biggest thing for me is rex being so stubborn about why ppl are lynching him, acting like is unfathmlble he coudl be scum and omgusing those voting him, yet admitting he was acting scummy on prupose. it makes no sense

Because scum tend to not look scummy on purpose, and people who are genuinely scumhunting and trying to analyze behavior see it and know that. Furthermore, I've demonstrated that I can play unscummy as scum several times. So, a town player trying to genuinely solve the game will look at me acting scummy and say 'what's going on here, would scum rex do this? Is this NAI?' There would be an element of WIFOM. To simply take everything I do that comes across as 'scummy' and uncritically tallying up a case to lynch me is something that scum pursuing a mislynch would do.

Banana wrote:

casey has been inactive as town a couple times now, i think its kind of a waste of a lynch

Yeah and If I recall correctly, they were fairly active once they subbed in to the scum slot

whiteflame wrote:

I haven’t had a chance to catch up, just wanted to address the tags. I’ll be back.

Hey shavua tov