A-Llewella's avatar

A-Llewella

Member since

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Not sure yet. Finally had time to dig into the mech implications of the game.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

I will say for a second time Jailor should never reveal. Take that shit to your death if Regent is alive. I think its highly likely they exist because game balance may not be possible without Regent/Jailor both existing.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Their target could be town or mafia.


3p should be able to win with town or mafia as long as conditions align.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Any day cycle ever where there is not a train and counter train town is absolutely failing. No exception ever.


They do not need to suspect etch-other. They only need to exist.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

If Regent exists in game they should not reveal N1.

If Jailor exists in game players should reveal being jailed D2

Regent should only reveal knowing Jailor can protect and then open town.

Regent should also go heavy on verifying not disguised through codes.

Jailor should never claim for any reason. Unless Regent has revealed they should function as a role block/vig

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

For 3p thoughts-


Gunsmith- They won't out. A problem for town that can swing the game. Players should out if they were given a gun so we know they exist

Associate- Protective alignment with a target that could be town or scum. Evolves into jester

Ty'iga- Disguiser that pops after being killed. Everyone should post disguiser codes daily.

Sadist- Unlikely to be in the game. Roles too messy imo

Executioner- Hard anti town function (maybe rolled mafia?) Evolves into jester


3 mechanics hit on hammer functions and 1 for who is on a train for vote analysis.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Its more likely than not that "Lord of Chaos" is inherited by another mafia if they are killed

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

We should stop treating an active game thread as a test thread. Its harmful to the game.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Yeah, You also got like another 2k posts of me talking about what I was doing and why.


This one there is also a last will mechanic where I can put my thoughts into a post that will be revealed to town.


All that and I dont trust you. At every turn you are casting shade. I really want to trust you but your only turning moment was realizing who I was and not what my alignment was.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

So any reads on players you have could prove useful for further scum hunting endeavors. Unfortunately this time there is no mason PM to get a glance at the inner mechanisms of your brain, so I have nothing to read you off of, other than you seem to be admittedly putting the town team at a disadvantage for some loose concept of personal growth. What do you think you have done that should make me reconsider this read on you? Have I missed something significant about your behavior that should prove to me that you are town?

Absolutely nothing. But you saw those inner workings and you know me at 50% is still some very real shit. As to if I am town you will never fully trust me. You know better than that. But why would I shove the mech I just did in our recent interaction if I was not? Why would I outline how to trap scum in pools or even explain how they work to begin with as scum? At best put me at 3p again with just that thought.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Yup. Sub optimal play. This is the first community I have told people about my self imposed challenges. I got bored of winning a long time ago so they are a thing to push myself.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

I have no knowledge from speaking with the host but we are working with pools of potentials in line with how SC2/ToS works. The pools of potentials matter for fitting what mech can exist.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

There is multiple executioner functions.


And all posting a code will do is break disguiser.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

I would bet money were in a 3/1/town situation for what thats worth. Doubt there is a neutral evil + a neutral benign if there is 3 mafia.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Something of greater value- Look at the setup how roles have a category under them. They exist in pools. Something common in other community's but people may not know exists here. Huge mech implications as to how claims function

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Given that everyone has thrown anon out the window my challenge this game is low word. No walls and such.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Should I unvote? I will be at a birthday party tomorrow and may not have time to before.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

In a world where disguisers and blackmailers exist giving some code when its allowed protects you.

A-Llewella

Amber Mafia

A-Llewella · 5 months ago

Lets be real though. Think any person on this site could pretend to be me : )