Originally Posted by Shining on 8/11/2026 at 4:31 PM (post #167)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 8/11/2026 at 3:47 PM (post #165)
WF’s Monk claim: Monk is essentially this game’s version of a doctor. This would be a phenomenal fake claim for scum.
Isn't the play to lynch WF today? If he is town, then Rex and Pie are likely scum.
It’s the optimal play, but the issue is we won’t know for certain whether he’s scum or not. Flips aren’t revealed
So REF, Banana, Shining are either Demon or Town exactly.
Wait, the Imp wouldn’t know if a Scarlett witch exists or not, so it’s still possible
Scratch what I said, skimming really sucks. Scarlett Witch is still possible
Our goal should be to lynch the Imp. If we do, we automatically win. The Imp is the most likely to claim right off the bat since they have the have the fake claims. Purely going off Imp hunting, it puts Banana and Shining and then to a certain degree REF cause he’s basically claiming Virgin at this point.
Here is my notice that I’m going to be in a 1 on 1 groupchat with everyone
Wait when did this game start? I thought Thoth was looking for subs
/in
/in
Definitely huge props to Banana. I thought Thoth was going to sell like the other game but he held up when it mattered
1x Rolestopper + 1x Commuter is a JOAT, which is basically a CC that Thoth never did. Makes zero sense here
With respect to the interaction of roles between Thoth and Wylted, it’s oddly familiar to Rangers Apprentice Mafia where Thoth and Mharman were linked as scum. Definitely explore that
In case I die, Wylted spent DP1 heavily defending Banana/Mikal. Definitely would look there.
Submit your actions
Originally Posted by Thoth on 7/26/2026 at 11:13 PM (post #68)
I Commuted last night because I expected to be the night-kill. Justification is that Erika Kirk deflects criticism from the political scene by playing the widow card for sympathy one day, then re-enters the political stage and squees like a horny fangirl about hat sales the next day. I may or may not have more uses.
Good enough, any concerns with voting Wylted?
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/26/2026 at 10:58 PM (post #66)
Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 7/26/2026 at 11:43 PM (post #61)
Originally Posted by Wryly on 7/26/2026 at 10:25 PM (post #56)
Are you a Tracker or is wylted blowing smoke up our ass. What did you do NP1 and 2. If wylted is scum then they already know, so no point keeping it close to the vest.
I have no idea what he’s talking about. He’s 100% scum
Can't even be sure he has a Rolecop then. Well, we'll find out.
Doesnt really matter cause I’m dead tonight anyways.
See above^^^
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Pie/Wryly
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Wryly
Wylted/Banana
So these are the only possible team options based on the vote mechanics. 67% chance Wylted is scum from my POV
From Wryly’s POV:
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Banana
From Wryly’s POV, Wylted is 75% likely to be scum.
From Thoth’s POV:
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Wryly
Wylted/Wryly
Wylted/Banana
From Thoth’s POV, Wylted is 75% likely to be scum.
From Banana’s POV:
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Pie/Wryly
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Wryly
From Banana’s POV, Wylted is 60% likely to be scum (though Pie is too).
Anyone home?
Lunatic also flipped town and was lynching Wylted.
I mean, I misread - fully admit that. But you’d also have to ignore Wylted’s scummy character, scummy role, and scummy play. There’s still no dispute of the 67%
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Pie/Wryly
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Wryly
Wylted/Banana
So these are the only possible team options based on the vote mechanics. 67% chance Wylted is scum.
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Pie/Wryly
Pie/Banana - Not possible (DP2 Ana hammers)
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Wryly
Wylted/Banana
Thoth/Wryly - Not possible (DP2 Thoth hammers)
Thoth/Banana - Not possible (DP2 Thoth/Ana hammers)
Wryly/Banana - Not possible (DP2 Ana hammer)
Wait I misread. Thoth never voted. Let me redo that
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Pie/Wryly - Not possible (DP2 Wryly hammers)
Pie/Banana - Not possible (DP2 Ana hammers)
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Wryly
Wylted/Banana
Thoth/Wryly - Not possible (DP2 Wryly hammers)
Thoth/Banana - Not possible (DP2 Ana hammers)
Wryly/Banana - Not possible (DP2 Ana or Wryly hammer)
That means here are the mechanically confirmed scum teams:
Pie/Wylted
Pie/Thoth
Wylted/Thoth
Wylted/Wryly
Wylted/Banana
Which name appears most in that list? Wylted. 80% odds he’s scum.
