Let’s just do Banana, I’m tired. Shining tomorrow
VTL Banana
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Let’s just do Banana, I’m tired. Shining tomorrow
VTL Banana
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Now you see why I’m conflicted lol
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
If one of my guild members including myself dies, we are lynching you tomorrow, jfyi
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Let’s go Shining first since his claim is similar to Redirector and we know Wryly was interfered with
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
He told me when I recruited him that he was SJW and had the power to Mutilate = Injure
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Good. Now are you willing to hedge the game in your guildmate being town?
Im fine revealing that my third guilfmafe is Whiteflame, and he was the one that claimed to use it
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
The poison took place of the factional NK. I'm arguing that the injury does the same.
0
Damn, I didn’t see that part. Hold on
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Are we confident whoever carried out the injure is scum? Did your guild know you could jail, Pie? You may have set yourself up to frame someone.
No. I told them nothing about me having a Jailkeeper
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Are you suggesting I should've used it on Rex? That wouldn't have worked, obviously.
No, used it on ANYONE else besides him instead of playing to the stupid wincon
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Alright, I only was half focused the last two days. Explain to me what's going on with Shining's claim and explain to me why the injury can't come from Mafia in lieu of the NK?
Because scum could Poison and NK starting NP2
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Why doesn't it make sense? There's literally reason to believe that the Ant King and injure
Youre essentially saying that scum get 2 NKs a night. And let’s say King is replacement for Queen. That still doesn’t explain the lack of NK. We know for a fact they could Poison and NK in NP2.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Rex did go in hard for both the Thoth and Alyssa lynches, although a bus is not impossible there. Yes, he full claimed to Lunatic in guildchat, and early.
This is why it would’ve been useful if you had just used the Cop. The question is did Mikal give Miller as a fake claim?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
That doesn't make them town
I don’t think they’re scum. Plus scum could use the poisoner, NK, and injure? That makes no sense
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
I still wanna go Shining tbh
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
In the interests of my guild and lynching a Miller, I’m fine going for REF
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Whats your role even called?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
That’s fair. What are your thoughts on REF, Casey, and Banana?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Why would an Ascetic be able to move in the first place tho is the question
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
So now can you explain your role in details and any results you may have had
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
I figured you were messing with us.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Second, why are we assuming the injury came from town? Behaviorally, I really think Banana is town. I could be dead to wrong, but I don't feel good lynching her on the assumption that town caused the injury and therefore the mafia nk was blocked.
It came my my guild, and I have no reason to believe that person is scum. I was the one that made the executive decision to choose Casey because she was not active for 2 DPs in a row.
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Look at Alyssa
but wuld he do it twice in a row? also most of the time it seems like popular is town, there is good reason to believe she is honest here
Not sure I understand your point here
If Shining is scum, what’s the point in being contrarian in DP1 and saying he has no opinion on Thoth. The lynch was inevitable
And then DP2, why point out that Alyssa was sorta claiming Lynchproof, not Popular. So much so that the mod came out to clarify.
This is the behavior part of Shining I can’t really explain. Role and justification wise he’s horrible, 100%. But Mikal also gave Helz basically false information in his PM too.
Theres also the coincidence of him claiming Lightning Rod when I gave him that role in Heroes of Olympus Mafia.
I think regardless, the order doesn’t really matter here. I can see good things about Banana too but the “buts” also give me some pause because it reads like she’s playing both sides.
Yeah, she could have been getting help. Anything is possible. It still would be a change in her scum play. And I still find it hard to scumread her merely for not joining an incorrect wagon.
I think this argument is relatively null to begin with. Claiming credit for it is relatively scummy to begin with so I don’t see her doing that anyways + as others mentioned Helz would’ve been a prime mislynch in the future anyways
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
How so?
Look at Thoth. Scumread but…I can definitely see him brain fart
ill start with the main topic of discussion which is thoth. i dont like his posts. i kind of get why people are scum reading his thing about mestari being a fear kill, but i also want to believe that he just had a brain fart or something like he said. that is understandable from a town perspective. most of my hesitation on thoth comes from his response to the pressure hes getting. like him being dodgy about his claim for a while doesn't seem like something he would do as town, ive played a few games with him but not a lot. he also was just missing for a lot of last night, and then when he got on to respond to stuff said he was about to go to bed. so if he wasn't on before what was he doing?? lurking? trying to come up with a claim or sumthin? i dont really like that he was making going to sleep an excuse when he should have been on before that if he was technically already awake. but thats kind of making assumptions about his personal life, maybe he was busy or something idk.
Look at Alyssa
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
How do you feel about a possible shining / rex team?
Who hard pushed Thoth/Alyssa out of everyone alive
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Regarding #736: I'm going to be honest, I straight up don't see the first post as being scummy at all. It's detailed, shows her entire thought process, and she leans scum on Thoth. Why should I scumread her for scumreading Thoth? Because she wasn't hard scum on him? That's weak.
It’s not that she wasn’t hard scum, it’s that she was providing an out
And the next two are just her listing minor points of favor for Alyssa being town. Big deal.
I actually think it is. Cause Shining brought up how Alyssa wasn’t really a popular, more like a lynchproof.
Wryly was doing the same thing and you trust her Cop claim.
Where?
I was prepared to start a CW on Mestari as I said earlier. Though you might not trust me here, either... Okay. But you trust Wryly, right?
I get the mechanical argument against Banana. It looks bad for her, obviously. But you always have to look at behavior and mechanics combined. It's like with the weather, you look at historical trends to temper the immediate leading indicators of the weather. Nate Silver does the same thing with political forecasting: you look at the fundamentals, and you look at the polls, and you weigh both of them together, and you consider which is giving the stronger signal. For me, I just don't see the behavioral case against Banana. I know you brought up her defending Helz, but I actually don't think she'd do that as scum.
I think it logically makes sense to that as scum. Even if Banana in a vacuum wouldn’t, she also has partners.
As scum, I'd expect her to follow the bandwagon if the town wanted to mislynch someone. Trying to defend someone for towncred would be a change in her scum play, but being contrarian is normal for her town play. I also think she makes a really good point in #750; she hasn't been trying to farm town cred off that like she could.
The farming town cred is sort of a WIFOM argument
Idk, obviously you disagree and that's your prerogative. But I don't see the behavioral case against her, and I think behavior has to be higher in importance over mechanics in this game. The lack of an NK isn't inexplicable if she's town, and I'm inclined to believe she is.
I’ve said that I’m 50/50 on Banana and Shining. Both have bad qualities and both have good qualities
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
I think both claims are bad and they both sorta provided outs. Need to check that Shining counterwagon
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Do you townread Shining?
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Vote Count:
Banana (2/7) - RexFavilla, Awesome
Shining (3/7) - Kohai, Banana, WF
ILikePie5 · 7 months ago
Good point, I like this analysis. It is definitely scummier than Banana’s, though she also had a few distancing moments
unvote