ILikePie5
Now comes the time when I'd like to know more about this injury-came-from-town business.


Why would u recruit Awesome if he was in ur POE?

ILikePie5
Actually, if we're operating under the assumption of a bus driver the doctor creates no obstacle. Scum could just switcheroo their NK target and some rando who would never be protected and then target the rando with the NK. This makes the Banana being jailkept scenario while NKing much more likely imo.


Thats true. Curious if there’s a character in the show that could be a bus driver

ILikePie5
I'm gonna ask everyone here a question, similar to the one I asked DP1. Let's say that Shining and Banana are both town. What does this mean for you? Who is scum in this scenario?


Casey

Kohai

Awesome


I would also take a hard look at REF

ILikePie5
assume I am town for a sec and put yourself in my shoes. how do I respond to any of this? bcuz I’m being told calm acceptance is scummy but I don’t know how to defend myself either. i know I didn’t carry out the kill cuz im town but ppl just keep repeating that they think it’s more likely i did than didn’t. What do i say against that? I know this is a debate site but im not a debater. i play this for fun and social deduction like a party game so im out of my depth with ppl like u and pie


You try to act townie. Like look at Helz for example. He was town. On the chopping block. Still giving reads. Reacting to people’s posts, etc etc. He didn’t just give up like you. And I’ve said a few times now that I’m open to Shining

ILikePie5
im not giving up, my vote is on who i think is scum. how am I supposed to defend against wha im accused of? i didnt do anything lol


In ur own words, why is shining scum?




ILikePie5

https://www.debatecraft.com/mafia/c/active-games/posts/3p/solo-leveling---day-phase-3?commentId=69db688af1ca45e41305dd39



This post caught my attention

ILikePie5
No way scum!Banana tries to divert the lynch from Helz to Shining. I suppose there's an outside chance she knew the Helz lynch was inevitable and just went for a distancing play, but it's remote. I don't see Banana/Shining here.


I think it’s possible considering they would’ve bussed their partners

ILikePie5
I guess it's not unthinkable that she was the NK target instead. I'll admit I hadn't considered that. I don't like how she just gave up like that tho


This is a good point

ILikePie5
Behaviorally she's looked pretty good all game, but I don't see them wanting to NK her over Mestari. They could've just NK'd Mestari and silenced you. That's what I would've done, knowing Vader would doctor you. 

Can Silencer be used alongside an NK?


Yes, it can

ILikePie5
If Banana is scum she bussed all her scummates. Hardcore.


She sorta had to. But DP2, she was amicable to Alyssa being town based on her claim