ILikePie5
Now I will probably be killed, but my sacrifice will not be in vain. I will go down as a super hero, as a legend as some sort of saint even. My guild will carry on and I will be the wind beneath their wings


Om Shanti 🙏

ILikePie5
Are you kidding me? Early distancing is the best way to sell a bus. It's literally what I just did with wylted last game. 


U know very well that I would quit if I was on a scum team with Kohai lol

ILikePie5
I said earlier that one of my abilities is potentially kinda-sorta-confirmable, or, if it isn't now, then it could be depending on how things play out. Let's say that I claimed information about your guild that I couldn't have known unless I knew it from an ability or shared scum chat with your recruit. If I did, do you trust your recruits enough that you would see this as confirming me, or would you suspect a mole? Just a yes/no question.


Whats the end goal of this question?

ILikePie5

I like #814 from Banana, though I’d like everyone to reread it in close detail and see if yall can see what I see. The observation imo is weak in terms of AI, but in the future could be depending on what happens

ILikePie5
Thoth is still my strongest scumread. I get that Whiteflame says it's not likely to be a fake claim for being so obscure, but then we have to ask why he has something so obscure as town. I still hate the behavior there.


It’s honestly an SOP claim, especially considering the guild leaders are mod confirmed town. Mechanically, it makes sense for scum to get that role and use it to manipulate


He would be my lynch here but 1. he has claimed a role that can be tested. 2. if he is scum, he only buys at most 1 DP. 


I don’t think he ever said it was affiliation confirmable.


May be 0 DPs bought in practice. I didn't like the math on Mestari's idea to vtnl multiple times, but with no NK, a single vtnl is pretty good. VTNLing here is basically just extending DP1, but with a halftime for night actions (and hence info from said night actions); we still have 17 heading into DP2.


VTNL is dumb

ILikePie5
everyone else is still null, except for Casey but I haven't evaluated her yet. I still need to do that.


I would like to hear these thoughts as well

ILikePie5
I get the Kohai read, but if Casey has failed to progress the game significantly, that doesn't particularly distinguish her from me, Rex, Banana, etc. Alyssa's "he could have learned it from Mikal" argument continues to be a puzzler. 


Difference with REF is that Luna recruited him and there are no indications he scumreads him. I don’t see anything notable regarding him anyways.


With Banana, her inactivity means she can’t inherently advance the game. Casey has been on and responding, but not really advancing the game.


I could possibly get behind an Alyssa lynch, but with three scummates talking in his ear, it's harder for me to believe Kohai would have a lackluster fake claim. If you were on his scum team, wouldn't nailing down his fake claim be the first thing you'd do? You'd know he would almost certainly be pressured for a claim DP1, and it would have to look good.


My theory is that for scum, the safest thing to character claim is yourself cause you know for a fact that nobody else has that character. And why would Mikal give Kohai as a fake character claim.

ILikePie5
Because there's more value to activating as many abilities as possible than hiding who has them. As we recruit more it becomes near certainly that mafia is in both guilds. Trying to hide recruits from the mafia assumes we only ever recruit town and risks both guilds recruiting the same player, activating less roles.


If scum have activating abilities, the strategy fails anyways. And for Luna/Wylted to recruit properly, everyone who is themselves needs to claim it, and that in itself reduces scum’s POE.

ILikePie5
This is such a stupid-ass thing to say. That's not how strategy works. You do what works best on average, taking all information into account. The fact that there are other possibilities isn't the point. 


It is a point when there are 16 other people playing the game. In a 9p game, sure, we would VTNL, but the odds of Vig/similar are far higher in a 17p game. Plus you don’t know if a TP even exists, which changes the calculus as well.

ILikePie5
I don't think I ever actually voted for Thoth, I just agreed he was sus.


Essentially the same thing.


Technically true, but that's always a possibility anyway. So what?


So your even/odd argument holds no weight

ILikePie5
I never once suggested that we VTNL on any future days. I'm sorry that you lack reading comprehension.


I meant what if there’s a Vig shot or another killing mechanism in future nights/days, we’d be back to odd even if we lynch someone here.

ILikePie5
I'd like elaboration on Casey, Kohai, and Alyssa


Sure.


Casey - Primarily gut read combined with the fact that I feel like she hasn’t done anything to progress the game. She joined the Thoth wagon and then the mini wagon on VTNL


Kohai - The pressure on Mestari seemed opportunistic to me. I also hate his claim. Ascetic is weak and often a scum claim as you know.


Alyssa - The defense of Thoth feels contrived. As if she knows he’s town and trying to justify it. It also doesn’t sit right with me that she ignored 11 pages and just straight voted Thoth in her second post for “reasons mentioned.” Just feels different compared to the previous game I was in with her

ILikePie5

Solid Town:

Pie

Lunatic

Wylted


Lean Town:

Melz

Mestari

REF


Tilt Town:

Mharman

Wryly


Null:

Whiteflame

Banana

Vader

Max

Shining


Tilt Scum:

Alyssa

Thoth


Lean Scum:

Kohai

Casey



A lot of these are gut reads and based on what I remember. Happy to elaborate as needed

ILikePie5
But 100% we should demand people take positions and lock them into those positions so we can post flip assign value to what their position was and nail down the fake reasoning. This is the core of mafia imo.


I agree with you, but good luck with most of these people lol. I’ve been trying for years to get someone like Shining to post enough so there’s enough to generate a read

ILikePie5
Mikal said there's no NK tonight. The reasonable assumption is that no one will die tonight. If that's wrong, Mikal is a bastard mod. Mikal is not a bastard mod. And if he is, we scream at him in the Endgame thread. QED


Just for NP1. What about the future?

ILikePie5
If we lynch today, we end up on evens tomorrow. It's better to stay on odds.


Youre assuming there isn’t a TP or Vigilante or someone else that can cause kills

ILikePie5
Im against ending the day. I want to see more from our sleepers and I want to see what Alyssa has to say when they engage.


+1


At the very least, reads from Vader, Banana, Shining, and Max

ILikePie5
I doubt my role and character make sense together. But I also have not seen the show.

I do not want to burn 12 hours of my life watching something just for context to play this game but I do question the connection between the two


That’s where we lean on the people who’ve seen the show. I personally read the wikis whe I can. 97% of the themes on this site, I don’t know lol

ILikePie5
I have thoughts on Mestari, VTNLing and guild leaders, but given that I'm busy with job hunting right now I can't be as active as I was last game. You're free to think I'm lazy, but you're also free to bite me. 

I'm still walking home from my interview. I'll address each when I get home.


What type of career are you in

ILikePie5
No NK NP1 is a good reason to not lynch yet! We'll have more information tomorrow on which to base our decision!


And we’ll have even more information if we lynch

ILikePie5
We gain information from town PRs, most likely. We also gain info from who tried to recruit whom


Thats the exact same argument in a normal game.

ILikePie5
I am very critical of this specifically. One of the things I have not directly called out about them but there is MASSIVE benefit for scum to know who was recruited and has activated abilities. Its between poor town play and absolute opportunistic scum play to pressure wylted for their recruitments. We should lock down public knowledge of these factors until we are in the mid/late game with a blatant cost/benefit evaluation of such knowledge being public.


Exactly. Why would we wanna tell scum exactly who has activated abilities. Makes zero sense



ILikePie5
While you are here if I could pick your mind on the subject of flavor. I am seeing a lot of demands for people to claim who they are as the character in the game. I generally look at flavor as NAI but on this site is that a thing? Bad alignments get the bad characters and good alignments get the good ones?


Its not necessarily is the character good/bad. It’s: would this character exist. Does the role make sense for this character. Does the mod justification the person is saying make sense



ILikePie5
I'll also do some soft claiming to help appease suspicion on me. I can do things outside of being recruited, and there's a part of my role PM that's confirmable.


Confirmable don’t really matter if it’s not affiliation indicative

ILikePie5
Regarding the actual sus being thrown at me, there's a pretty clear person that's being left off the list of people who's familiar with Mestari on a mafia level and a personal level that matches me (which I hinted at in #386, though I didn't spell it out to not provide Thoth with a get-out-of-jail-free card in case he is scum). Mikal (i.e. the person hosting this game) is just as familiar with Mestari as I am, both on a mafia level and a personal level (arguable as to who knows Mestari better per se, but it's a hair that's not worth splitting for this context). All it'd take is one question in Thoth's role pm of "Hey who's this Mestari guy who's blowing up the discord with sex jokes" for some level of understanding to be imparted. So sure, if Thoth flips scum then I could be scum by association, but there are other explanations to this.


This is hilarious