ILikePie5
yeah. that makes sense, what doesn’t make sense is why they wouldn’t just straight up claim 3P? it’s weird.


Cause it sets a target regardless of their affiliation.

ILikePie5

Okay so here’s what I think happened:


1) A TP Caroler exists

2) They used their fake claim

3) They used their fake claim so scum don’t NK them because their win con is Survivor


Its a fair argument

ILikePie5
1x Neighorizer. So no, Pie, no one would have been able to protect Kohai NP1. He could not have been doctored or watched.


There was no reason for Banana to give the Doctor cause Kohai was already dead lol. But if he wasn’t, the Doctor could’ve been given

ILikePie5
There’s another possibility. Caroler is scum and didn’t claim because their fake claim doesn’t match Caroler at all


If you’re a scum Caroler, just claim everything you have. It’s easy to believe that. No one would suspect you

ILikePie5
Role blocking obviously would block her role not some random caroler gift but did somebody claim caroler or is it just a made up thing?

Or is a member of town a complete retard and just not admitting to the carol thing?


No one has claimed Caroler, which means there’s 2 possibilities:


A) There is a scum Caroler and they didn’t claim it for the sole reason of getting Wryly lynched.


B) There is no Caroler and Wryly is lying



Issue with A is that in the long run, it just makes it easier to win as a claimed Caroler. So B imo is more likely, and Wryly just messed up or something

ILikePie5
Am I missing something with wryly? She's like 90% scum here isn't she?


Unless a townie is lying. I only see the two scenarios I described earlier. A fake scum Caroler is theoretically possible I guess, but it doesn’t make sense for scum to not just claim that. There could be some weird TP mechanic here as well, but face value, it does seem likely the Wryly is not town

ILikePie5
You know what? I think Rex may be confirmed-ish. 

Remember what thoth said dp1 OP? 

"I mainly picked regulars, but I also included at least one player who would not be considered a regular or to have had much impact on this site's Mafia community."

Ultra is like the only one who matches that desription, and I don't see why he gives the non regular player to scum, but its possible IG.


Thats a good point. It makes it more likely that Wryly is lying about the Carol. Maybe their scum partner bailed on her



ILikePie5
Anyway, I am ILikePie. My justification is that many are in awe of me because I dominate town as either alignment, but people also think I am a bit of a knob and that there are big overlap of people who think both about me. 


So what’s your role actually called?

ILikePie5
I feel like town Pie would be trying to lynch me right now because in his mind it should be between me and Shining. Instead he seems to be looking for a way out of the carol.


No one has claimed Caroler lol. So we need Wryly to explain herself. Cause she could just be lying about all 3 people.

ILikePie5
Pie is also known for being a mafia ego maniac, thinks he is a god so this is also common knowledge lol. No offense pie, love ya buddy. Tbf he does have a pretty good win percentage and elo, not that that he isn't ever wrong.


I think I’m better than average. Have been my whole life

ILikePie5
One last thing, I do find it odd that Pie isn't calling out my claim as scummy. Its like he doesn't want to call attention to the fact that his claim is also scummy.


I don’t get the justification you have. Someone who just doesn’t talk = Ascetic? I would expect Vanilla. But regardless, we need to hear from Wryly. Cause there’s game hinges on what she says.

ILikePie5
The thing is, Pie plays aggressively as scum and gets away with it, last game when he was scum in Rex’s game he pushed me consistently and scumread me when nobody else was, and it just so happens this matches a scum motivation, and it doesn’t make sense as a town strategy to try to get a claim out of a player right out the gate. That and it happens to be a dick move, and I dont think Pie is a dick so I think he’s just scum


You haven’t played long enough with me. You’re literally just plain wrong

ILikePie5
Yes, it wasn't Kohai's fault beause you don't fucking put someone at L-2 THREE HOURS INTO DAY START. I don't care that I sound like a broken record, we don't have an automated vote counter + early on it's VERY easy to get people to accidentally vote someone, and even if you don't, wtf is the point of getting someone to hardclaim 3 HOURS into the day, when there's ZERO information and you may be outing an important Town role? Which, gee, guess what, turns out to be the case!
 0


I already explained this multiple times. If you’re just going to refuse to listen to me and everyone else around, that’s fine. You’re wrong. Everyone thinks you’re wrong. You’re wasting everyone’s time by going up this tree.

ILikePie5
Yes.
Pie could be non-Caroler scum. I don’t trust Pie’s reaction test D1, it feels more like opportunism designed to get Kohai mislynched. Like I said it makes sense as a town strategy IF you have reason to suspect someone is scum, not as a “blind lets get someone to claim” thing, cause it can easily backfire and get a town lynched (as it did).


Literally everyone agrees, that it was Kohai’s own fault that he got lynched…except you.

ILikePie5
They wouldn't thats the thing. Unless it's just a bastard role that gives town wrong info but I doubt that.


Even if there is a scum Caroler, which itself is bastard, the only utility it has is


A) Scum claims the role and confirms themselves, which didn’t happen herw


B) Scum says nothing and just gets the person lynched, but that strategy makes zero sense compared to A

ILikePie5

Pie - Mikal - Odd Night Roleblocker

Lunatic - Vader - Oracle

REF - Ultra - Ascetic

Shining - ??? - Hated/Popular

Wylted - Mharman - Innocent Child

Wryly - ??? - ???

Magoroth - Kohai - Reroller (NP1??)



Banana - Lunatic - Inventor (Doctor, Tracker, Neighborizer)

Kohai - Whiteflame - Lie Detector


ILikePie5

Pie - Mikal - Odd Night Roleblocker

Lunatic - Vader - Oracle

REF - Ultra - Ascetic

Shining - ??? - Hated/Popular

Wylted - Mharman - Innocent Child

Wryly - ??? - ???

Magoroth - Kohai - Reroller (NP1??)

ILikePie5
He failed the test and got lynched. What did that achieve?


He didn’t fail the test. He got hammered cause he refused to claim. If he would’ve said Lie Detector, we would’ve moved on