Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #664: Sidewalker Yes, definitely a leap of Faith.


Mr. nuclear scientist FLRW, your Big Bang CMBR is a leap of faith as visible in the following.

Astrophysicists recalculated CMBR from data including JWST readings, and the study details astronomer astrologer’s CMBR isn’t what they scienced (knew)


Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28).


Kroupa, with additional author Eda Gjergo, expose evidence against the existence of the CMBR. These two extracts from their abstract explain:

A previously overlooked foreground component is the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs), which can no longer be ignored, particularly in light of JWST’s detection of massive, evolved systems at extreme redshifts (z>13).
Even in our most conservative estimates, massive ETGs account for 1.4% up to the full present-day CMB energy density.
(source: “The impact of early massive galaxy formation on the cosmic microwave background” (Eda Gjergo, Pavel Kroupa; Nuclear Physics B published by Elsevier aa distributed on ScienceDirect.com; August 2025; Article: 116931; Volume 1017))


Astronomer astrologers best case scenario is that a “definitive 2.725 K” is off by 1.4% which means the MIT trained nuclear scientist FLRW has science fiction expressed as scientific fact in his own composition in this thread of:

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.


Which is recorded in post #421 with my response.


That study’s 1.4% is the lower of the conservative echelon.


The study’s full present-day CMB energy density is the higher of the conservative echelon which excludes a so-called CMBR from being a Big Bang indicator!


This examination of the study’s conservative echelon leaves the liberal echelon unexplored. The implications of a liberal echelon destroy the Big Bang.


Scientist sorcerers cling to their Big Bang belief despite being faced with good evidence demonstrating that the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos

The Dangerous Illusion of Scientific Consensus


Science is the process by which we learn about the workings of material reality. Though modern innovations – built on the fruits of science – would look like magic to people living only decades ago, they result from the time-tested scientific method. Contrary perhaps to media portrayals of science, the scientific method depends not on the existence of a mythical consensus but rather on structured scientific debates. If there is a consensus, science challenges it with new hypotheses, experiments, logic, and critical thinking. Ironically, science advances because it believes it has never arrived; consensus is the hallmark of dead science.


From Welcome to Dr. Jay Bhattacharya (Stanford professor) and Rav Arora’s (independent journalist) exclusive, new podcast-fuelled Substack newsletter The Illusion of Consensus.


Interestingly, Mr. scientist @FLRW vapidly repeated “scientific consensus” (proof post #655) as his Big Bang belief justification without the scientific method which is his hallmark of dead science instead of vibrant knowledge (science)!


Basically, a scientist says that if science has consensus, then that science is dead; therefore, MITman declared red-shift dead thus, by extension, the Big Bang dead. Recall that I call the Big Bang a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #655: Double_R Geoffrey Burbidge was a renowned astrophysicist


He may be dead, but he left behind his science along with the scientific consensus for the paper’s surviving scientists and his students from University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences.

YOU PRESENT NO SCIENTIFIC METHOD - a real scientific failure for you, the MIT educated nuclear scientist!


MITman AI IQ leaps in faith beyond astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, who explained with “observational data” of the NGC 7319 quasar that “its redshift cannot be due to the expansion of the universe” and quasars in general “too many of them are being found closely associated with nearby, active galaxies for this to be accidental” (source for Burbidge quotes), who with the “scientific consensus” of an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper published in m The Astrophysical Journal (issue 1, volume 620).

Your MITman AI IQ completely dropped the science about Cepheid variable, so here you go.


@FLRW wrote in post #650: a method validated by independent “distance ladder” measurements using Cepheid variables


How quickly you fall into the Lazy in your Faith-based, Lazy, Ridiculous, Wrong science! I addressed Cepheid variable earlier in this thread - another non-acute observational issue for your Ridiculous science (post #82) - your science (knowledge) is Wrong - and the following exposes your broken “distance ladder” rungs, AGAIN.

Cepheid variable; faith not fact


Astronomers believe Polaris is the nearest Cepheid variable star to Earth, at 445.5 light years (2,673,000,000,000,000 miles). Polaris is commonly referred to as the North Star.


Polaris’ minimum and maximum diameter in miles at Polaris is unobserved by astronomers, and any temperature change for Polaris is not measurable at Polaris by astronomers.


Astronomers possess no luminosity data at the source for Polaris, but astronomers do possess brightness data at Earth.


And, finally, astronomers never accurately measured the distance from Polaris to Earth - see the Episcopic Model (spatial limitations, too vast a visage) in post #53.


Astronomers do not collect sufficient, complete, and accurate data at 2,673,000,000,000,000 miles (2.6 quadrillion miles) from Polaris, the nearest Cepheid variable star, nor any other Cepheid star for comparative parallax measurements which astronomers believe are more distant from Earth.


Astronomer Henrietta Swan Leavitt published a 21-page account of her work “1777 Variables in the Magellanic Clouds” in 1908 with more astronomical work before her death in 1925. She believed that observing a Cepheid star’s pulsation period results in astronomers knowing the luminosity at a Cepheid star thus astronomers believe they possess sufficient information to determine fantastic Interstellar distances. Based on Leavitt’s work, astronomers believe they can use the luminosity of a Cepheid star in the inverse square law, which requires knowing either the distance or the luminosity at source, to determine the distance to Cepheid variable stars, and they further believe that they can hopscotch hugely gargantuan distances using these “known” (truly unknown) luminosity (of a star at the star) illogically based on observed brightness (of a star at Earth) calibrated with parallax distance to Polaris (or another Cepheid star with a “known” distance from Earth) which results in the distance to another star.


Cepheid variable nonsense nonscience is your prophetess Leavitt and her progeny preaching the abundance of light and parallax of your star bible’s millions and billions of light years away with millions and billions of years in the past.


Rewind to the foundational star bible contribution by Leavitt in which astronomers use an unobserved luminosity to calculate a star’s distance. Astronomer astrologers cannot determine the luminosity, which requires measurement at the source star, of a Cepheid by observing the change in the star’s brightness, which is a measurement at Earth - such brightness-to-luminosity extrapolation is a leap of faith.

Your cosmic distance ladder is your Faith-based science.


Therefore, your missing fact Cepheid variable “distance ladder” rung joins with your missing fact red-shift “distance ladder” rung joins with your missing fact CMBR “distance ladder” rung to arrive at your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #650: The assertion that redshift is falsified as a distance or age determinant is a fringe viewpoint, primarily found in alternative cosmology sources


MITman AI IQ leaps in faith beyond astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, who explained with “observational data” of the NGC 7319 quasar that “its redshift cannot be due to the expansion of the universe” and quasars in general “too many of them are being found closely associated with nearby, active galaxies for this to be accidental” (source for Burbidge quotes), who with the “scientific consensus” of an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper published in m The Astrophysical Journal (issue 1, volume 620).

@FLRW wrote in post #650: a method validated by independent “distance ladder” measurements using Cepheid variables


How quickly you fall into the Lazy in your Faith-based, Lazy, Ridiculous, Wrong science! I addressed Cepheid variable earlier in this thread - another non-acute observational issue for your Ridiculous science (post #82) - your science (knowledge) is Wrong - and the following exposes your broken “distance ladder” rungs, AGAIN.

Cepheid variable; faith not fact


Astronomers believe Polaris is the nearest Cepheid variable star to Earth, at 445.5 light years (2,673,000,000,000,000 miles). Polaris is commonly referred to as the North Star.


Polaris’ minimum and maximum diameter in miles at Polaris is unobserved by astronomers, and any temperature change for Polaris is not measurable at Polaris by astronomers.


Astronomers possess no luminosity data at the source for Polaris, but astronomers do possess brightness data at Earth.


And, finally, astronomers never accurately measured the distance from Polaris to Earth - see the Episcopic Model (spatial limitations, too vast a visage) in post #53.


Astronomers do not collect sufficient, complete, and accurate data at 2,673,000,000,000,000 miles (2.6 quadrillion miles) from Polaris, the nearest Cepheid variable star, nor any other Cepheid star for comparative parallax measurements which astronomers believe are more distant from Earth.


Astronomer Henrietta Swan Leavitt published a 21-page account of her work “1777 Variables in the Magellanic Clouds” in 1908 with more astronomical work before her death in 1925. She believed that observing a Cepheid star’s pulsation period results in astronomers knowing the luminosity at a Cepheid star thus astronomers believe they possess sufficient information to determine fantastic Interstellar distances. Based on Leavitt’s work, astronomers believe they can use the luminosity of a Cepheid star in the inverse square law, which requires knowing either the distance or the luminosity at source, to determine the distance to Cepheid variable stars, and they further believe that they can hopscotch hugely gargantuan distances using these “known” (truly unknown) luminosity (of a star at the star) illogically based on observed brightness (of a star at Earth) calibrated with parallax distance to Polaris (or another Cepheid star with a “known” distance from Earth) which results in the distance to another star.


Cepheid variable nonsense nonscience is your prophetess Leavitt and her progeny preaching the abundance of light and parallax of your star bible’s millions and billions of light years away with millions and billions of years in the past.


Rewind to the foundational star bible contribution by Leavitt in which astronomers use an unobserved luminosity to calculate a star’s distance. Astronomer astrologers cannot determine the luminosity, which requires measurement at the source star, of a Cepheid by observing the change in the star’s brightness, which is a measurement at Earth - such brightness-to-luminosity extrapolation is a leap of faith.

Your cosmic distance ladder is your Faith-based science.


YOU PRESENT NO SCIENTIFIC METHOD - a real failure for you, the MIT educated nuclear scientist!


Therefore, your missing fact Cepheid variable “distance ladder” rung joins with your missing fact red-shift “distance ladder” rung joins with your missing fact CMBR “distance ladder” rung to arrive at your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #489: Redshift is critical to the Big Bang theory because it provides direct observational proof that the universe is expanding.


Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss


Astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers discovered a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal). Red-shift as a distance calculator and/or age determinant is falsified.


You are the mystical, magical worker of “incorrect conclusions” as my post #485 details your and @FLRW’s E=MC2 mathematical malpractice for red-shift.


For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #546’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift.


Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos

Double_R’s debate deception doubly derailed during Double_R’s doublespeak deleting direct discourse denotation.


Double_R lied about the historical chronology within his first few entries thus his explanation was irrational thus he failed the rational chronology requirement as layed out in the accurate chronology detailed post #136, so the earliest on-topic unanswered request among the two of us was my post #136 to him.


This current post isn’t directed specifically to Double_R, but he is welcome to read it and gnash his teeth. I present post #463, below, again, for the record. I leave my composition’s second person references intact for clarity.

Double_R wrote in post #438: What an unbelievable coward. The only one hiding here is you. Since you want to play games with all the posts pretending it’s all being hidden somewhere, let’s recap our entire discussion: …snip


You unjustly slandered me, and you evaded rationally explaining how you arrived at your irrationally convoluted post #89 sequence recorded in my post #136 to you, and you lied about the correspondence sequence in your post with your very early sequential recipient error for your post #33 which was to SatanLucy without any mention of me in your post #33 yet your current post says “Me #33: I explained that you were”.


If you want to engage further, then explain yourself, first. I explained this to you on multiple occasions, and I can continue acting like your posts to me are like the Big Bang, that is, nonexistent! Unless you can muster the courage to respond to my opening inquiry inside of post #136.


My 3 ball example in post #35 demonstrated one does not know (science) as a matter of fact where the ball came from which rolled over the grandpa’s foot, but one may conject (theorize) about the ball, and that “theorize” is faith.


The Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Kermos

I didn’t hear back from you about your jury confusion, so here you go.

@linate wrote in post #613: Double_R What if he countered your argument, and claimed that jury decisions are in fact rooted in faith?


Take a good, long, hard look at the Scott Peterson case regarding the murder of his unborn child, Conner, and his wife, Laci (“Watch Scott Peterson: The New Evidence Full Episodes, Video & More - A&E”). Scott was on death row in California, U.S.A. for their murders. A full jury of 12 found him guilty “beyond a shadow of a doubt” based on their faith, but continuing case revelations bring into question whether all twelve of the jurist’s faith even achieve the jurisprudence principle “a reasonable person would believe” threshold.


linate, you Double_R_epeat like a parrot. This concept was covered in my post #82 to you way back on August 7th! I explained your Big Bang belief is outside of human witness history, so you are comparing dissimilar things. Your cognitive collection capacity is crippled.


We Christians believe in Christ. You evolutionists believe in your Big Bang god(s).


Kermos

Double_R’s debate deception doubly derailed.


Double_R lied about the historical chronology within his first few entries thus his explanation was irrational thus he failed the rational chronology requirement as layed out in the accurate chronology detailed post #136, so the earliest on-topic unanswered request among the two of us was my post #136 to him.


This current post isn’t directed specifically to Double_R, but he is welcome to read it and gnash his teeth. I present post #463, below, again, for the record. I leave my composition’s second person references intact for clarity.

Double_R wrote in post #438: What an unbelievable coward. The only one hiding here is you. Since you want to play games with all the posts pretending it’s all being hidden somewhere, let’s recap our entire discussion: …snip


You unjustly slandered me, and you evaded rationally explaining how you arrived at your irrationally convoluted post #89 sequence recorded in my post #136 to you, and you lied about the correspondence sequence in your post with your very early sequential recipient error for your post #33 which was to SatanLucy without any mention of me in your post #33 yet your current post says “Me #33: I explained that you were”.


If you want to engage further, then explain yourself, first. I explained this to you on multiple occasions, and I can continue acting like your posts to me are like the Big Bang, that is, nonexistent! Unless you can muster the courage to respond to my opening inquiry inside of post #136.


My 3 ball example in post #35 demonstrated one does not know (science) as a matter of fact where the ball came from which rolled over the grandpa’s foot, but one may conject (theorize) about the ball, and that “theorize” is faith.


The Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #640: OK, I see what is going on here. I estimate Debby’s IQ at 160 and K’s at 45-47.


FLRW has Faith-based, Lazy, Ridiculous, Wrong science (knowledge) such as exposed in my red-shift disrupting post #603 to which FLRW still fails to respond, so here’s the proof for writing Faith-based, Lazy, Ridiculous, Wrong science about FLRW.


You are antiscience because you delusionally discard and besmirch the reputation of the astrophysicist who said of NGC 7319 quasar that “its redshift cannot be due to the expansion of the universe” and quasars in general “too many of them are being found closely associated with nearby, active galaxies for this to be accidental”, and these quotes were issued by astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences (source for Burbidge quotes), who with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper published in m The Astrophysical Journal (issue 1, volume 620).

@FLRW wrote in post #586: Red-shift does not disrupt Einstein’s E=mc²


Red-shift most certainly disrupts Einstein’s E=MC2 and/or vice versa. Here is the proof that disrupts your whole post. You repeated your frequency argument, but frequency is not explicitly included in Einstein’s E=MC2, so a photon with the photon’s frequency and wavelength are represented in the speed of light (C) inside of Einstein’s E=MC2; therefore, the shift from high energy violet light to low energy red light results in a decrease of energy (E) within Einstein’s E=MC2 forcing the speed of light (C) for the photon without mass (M) to increase beyond 186,000 miles per second thus smashing your constant speed limit for light!

@FLRW wrote in post #586: Since a photon’s energy is proportional to its frequency (E=hf), a loss of energy results in a decrease in frequency and a corresponding increase in wavelength.


Your statement overflows with illogical inconsistency:

  1. You repeated the MITman Model (post #465) which holds that your faulty E=hf formula concludes with you performing the G=(+1)+(-1)+(-1) formula where G must equal 0 for logical consistency. Your loss of photonic energy is a loss of photonic frequency which is two decreases, but you have one increase up your sleeve with the wavelength. Hence your imbalanced equation garbage physics are illuminated by the MITman Model (post #465)!
  2. Your E=hf fails to provide a balanced account for your E=hf, so your E=hf certainly fails to provide a balanced account for Einstein’s E=MC2!


@FLRW wrote in post #586: energy conservation is maintained through the curvature of spacetime


Your “spacetime” is a leap of faith as per post #199 which, among other valid fact disrupting your Big Bang, shows that time is not represented in Einstein’s E=MC2 so Einstein’s E=MC2 has no plottable position in the Minkowski spacetime model resulting in Big Bang adherent’s leap of faith in spacetime.

@FLRW wrote in post #586: mass-energy equivalence


Your restriction of Einstein’s E=MC2 exclusively to equivalence of mass (M) and energy (E) results in YOU eliminating the speed of light (C) from Einstein’s E=MC2; therefore, you promote your E=M model. You science is so incredibly sloppy!


You are using your E=M leap of faith to support your spacetime leap of faith to support your red-shift leap of faith to support your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #638: The research was inconclusive and the difference in calculation very minor. Not enough for scientist to reject the Big Bang theory.


You fabricate antichrist faith. The maximum conservative deviation results in the nullification of CMBR, so astrophysicist Kroupa’s research is not your “difference in calculation very minor”; furthermore, a liberal deviation is worse for CMBR than a conservative deviation.


Your “scientist” has Faith-based, Lazy, Ridiculous, Wrong science (knowledge) as clearly illustrated in the CMBR disrupting post #631 just a short distance above your faith-based post.


Thank you for using the word “reject” which indicates your Big Bang CMBR is believable or disbelievable.


Your CMBR is your religious leap of faith, so your Big Bang is your antichrist leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #636: The Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) is considered highly accurate and robust


Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” as detailed with a link to his paper in post #631 just a short distance above your faith-based post.

FLRW, your science is so weak that you just repeat yourself without responding to post #631. WEAK SCIENCE FLRW.


Your CMB is your religious leap of faith, so your Big Bang is your leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #634:The physician signs of the Big Bang


That is one nonsensical phrase about a nonsense nonscience Big Bang!

@Debby wrote in post #634: are still visible across the entire sky today, most notably as the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB).


So says the self-described scientist therapist Debby without a scrap of scientific method in a “matter of fact” fashion with only a “matter of faith”, but Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” as detailed with a link to his paper in post #631 just a short distance above your antichrist post.


Your CMB is your religious leap of faith, so your Big Bang is your leap of faith.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #632: Who the f**k was going to observe the beginning of the universe.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord Jesus willing, I will respond.


I’ll tell you who wasn’t there - you weren’t there, so you are an unreliable witness for the Big Bang!


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #626: Hmmm, In public Hitler embraced religion and religious rhetoric is through his speeches. …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


Inept scientist FLRW used broken grammar that rendered his sentence as garbage, like his garbage science as illustrated by the MITman Model in post #465.


Having escaped your scientific observational skills or lack thereof, Hitler was a evolutionist who preached the superiority of the Arian race. That puts the mass murderer Hitler squarely in your evolution religion camp. You just massively upped the scale from when you liken yourself to Oppenheimer as recorded in post #570.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith. So, I draw your attention to a prior post to which you evade a response!

@FLRW wrote in post #586: Red-shift does not disrupt …snip


Mr. observationally challenged scientist FLRW,


Instead of addressing my CMBR disrupting recent response post #578 nor post #592 to you, you skipped it, so here is a full copy for (1) you to get back on track with your faith based CMBR and (2) you to be unable to respond to me with scientific method based procedure for your CMBR.

@FLRW wrote in post #574: Kermos, why do you like Chinese scientist?


You’re racist. You admitted that you look like one who associates with communists (post #570), and the chinese have a communist form of government.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: The validity of Eda Gjergo’s concept that early massive galaxy formation significantly contaminates or even constitutes the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is currently not accepted by the mainstream cosmological community and is considered a controversial hypothesis rather than established fact.


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. I previously explained that I use your science against you. Gjergo is your mainstream cosmological community’s scientist sorceress.


Kroupa’s credentials are primarily European. Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28). Kroupa’s credentials far exceed your credentials to address the CMBR’s status in the mainstream cosmological community!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: Gjergo and co-author Pavel Kroupa published a paper in Nuclear Physics B (2025) arguing that radiation from the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs) could account for at least 1.4% and potentially 100% of the observed CMB energy density, thereby challenging the standard Big Bang model. Their calculations suggest that these galaxies were up to 10,000 times brighter during formation than they are today, and their redshifted infrared emissions could mimic the CMB spectrum.


So, your CMBR is faith-based which is the very point that you nonsensically non-scientifically fight.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: However, prominent physicists and reviewers have raised significant criticisms:


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. Name names with links to papers.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 1. Mechanism Issues: Critics note that for galaxy emission to mimic the CMB, there must be a mechanism to distribute cosmic dust uniformly and thermalize it to the exact temperature of the CMB, which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies, not uniformly distributed.


Your CMBR is not uniform as established in post #376.


Your “which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies” is your scientist sorcerers belief without proof (assumption, see post #53 for the dictionary definition).

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 2. Observational Evidence: Standard cosmology maintains that the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang), while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years). The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models.


Here, you credit “Observational Evidence”. There, you discredit “Observational Evidence” (see post #478). Your sloppy science is self-contradictory!


Your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” is a massive assumption (belief without proof, see post #53 for the dictionary definition). Nobody observed your CMB origination, so you lied by including your unobserved CMB origination under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” is your “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53 built on top of your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” massive “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53), so you lied by including your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your “The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models”, that you stated so “matter of fact” is really a “matter of faith” built on your detailed lies above.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 3. Methodological Concerns: Some reviews point out circularity and a lack of sensitivity analysis in the authors’ claims, noting that the 1.4% figure is a conservative lower bound that the authors themselves admit could scale up to 100% with “small tweaks” to assumptions, which undermines predictive rigor.


Hmm, “Some reviews”, but not all reviews, so much for your “authoritative” “mainstream cosmological community” cohesion.


You have “assumptions”, and they have assumptions. You dogmatically believe your “belief without proof” are superior to their belief without proof by way of your fanatical evolution religion intense zeal.


Your “3. Methodological Concerns” apply to your position, as well, FLRW! You employ scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion followed by their application of mathematical statistics (magic) to arrive at your “definitive 2.725 K” (proof post #421). I posted your CMBR data points with detailed mathematical analysis in post #376 and post #421 which clearly exposed your “definitive 2.725 K” to be a magical, mystical, nonsense nonscience faith.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: In summary, while Gjergo and Kroupa’s work highlights a potential foreground contamination that warrants further study, the consensus view remains that the CMB is a relic of the Big Bang, and the claim that it arises primarily from early galaxy formation is regarded as unsalvageable nonsense or a provocative but unproven hypothesis by many in the astrophysics community.


Oh, look, “potential foreground contamination” is a variant of you “scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion” which I referenced earlier in this post. That is you, Mr. MIT AI IQ scientist sorcerer FLRW committing your magical, mystical act right there!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


You failed to prove your CMBR, and you failed to disprove your CMBR. I am using your science against you, so whether you prove or disprove Kroupa et al’s paper doesn’t matter to me because I’m showing you that your whole Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kroupa, with additional author Eda Gjergo, expose evidence against the existence of the CMBR. These two extracts from their abstract explain:

A previously overlooked foreground component is the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs), which can no longer be ignored, particularly in light of JWST’s detection of massive, evolved systems at extreme redshifts (z>13).
Even in our most conservative estimates, massive ETGs account for 1.4% up to the full present-day CMB energy density.
(source: “The impact of early massive galaxy formation on the cosmic microwave background” (Eda Gjergo, Pavel Kroupa; Nuclear Physics B published by Elsevier aa distributed on ScienceDirect.com; August 2025; Article: 116931; Volume 1017))


Astronomer astrologers best case scenario is that a “definitive 2.725 K” is off by 1.4% which means you the MIT trained nuclear scientist FLRW has personal faith expressed as scientific fact in his own composition in this thread of:

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.


Which is recorded in post #421 with my response.


That study’s 1.4% is the lower of the conservative echelon.


The study’s full present-day CMB energy density is the higher of the conservative echelon which excludes a so-called CMBR from being a Big Bang indicator!


This examination of the study’s conservative echelon leaves the liberal echelon unexplored. The implications of a liberal echelon destroy the Big Bang.


Your whole Big Bang is unproven and unobserved with bad evidence, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #606: Red-shift does not disrupt Einstein’s E=mc²


Hey Mr. scientist FLRW, substantially repeating your faith filled post #586 doesn’t make it fact, especially when your post #606 omits a scientific method based response to my post #603!


So, how about it, you faith science preacher, respond in detail to post #603 which was on this site before your post #606!


Red-shift does disrupt Einstein’s E=mc² as clearly demonstrated in post #361 as well as post #603.


You employ your E=M model leap of faith to support your spacetime leap of faith to support your red-shift leap of faith to support your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #620: It’s too bad that they didn’t have smartphones 2000 years ago.


It would have been just a bunch of people standing around yelling toward each other.because there were no cell towers.


Scientists so very often miss the obvious.


Speaking of you scientists missing the mark, let’s go back to the science you skipped again with the CMBR disrupting reminder post #607 just a little way up from this post to you - just a little way up from your post. You scientific avoidance is quite telling about your science.


Your whole Big Bang is unproven and unobserved with bad evidence, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@linate wrote in post #613: Double_R What if he countered your argument, and claimed that jury decisions are in fact rooted in faith?


Take a good, long, hard look at the Scott Peterson case regarding the murder of his unborn child, Conner, and his wife, Laci (“Watch Scott Peterson: The New Evidence Full Episodes, Video & More - A&E”). Scott was on death row in California, U.S.A. for their murders. A full jury of 12 found him guilty “beyond a shadow of a doubt” based on their faith, but continuing case revelations bring into question whether all twelve of the jurist’s faith even achieve the jurisprudence principle “a reasonable person would believe” threshold.


linate, you Double_R_epeat like a parrot. This concept was covered in my post #82 to you way back on August 7th! I explained your Big Bang belief is outside of human witness history, so you are comparing dissimilar things. Your cognitive collection capacity is crippled.


We Christians believe in Christ. You evolutionists believe in your Big Bang god(s).


Kermos

Double_R’s debate deception derailed.


Double_R lied about the historical chronology within his first few entries thus his explanation was irrational thus he failed the rational chronology requirement as layed out in the accurate chronology detailed post #136, so the earliest on-topic unanswered request among the two of us was my post #136 to him.


This current post isn’t directed specifically to Double_R, but he is welcome to read it and gnash his teeth. I present post #463, below, again, for the record. I leave my composition’s second person references intact for clarity.

Double_R wrote in post #438: What an unbelievable coward. The only one hiding here is you. Since you want to play games with all the posts pretending it’s all being hidden somewhere, let’s recap our entire discussion: …snip

You unjustly slandered me, and you evaded rationally explaining how you arrived at your irrationally convoluted post #89 sequence recorded in my post #136 to you, and you lied about the correspondence sequence in your post with your very early sequential recipient error for your post #33 which was to SatanLucy without any mention of me in your post #33 yet your current post says “Me #33: I explained that you were”.


If you want to engage further, then explain yourself, first. I explained this to you on multiple occasions, and I can continue acting like your posts to me are like the Big Bang, that is, nonexistent! Unless you can muster the courage to respond to my opening inquiry inside of post #136.


My 3 ball example in post #35 demonstrated one does not know (science) as a matter of fact where the ball came from which rolled over the grandpa’s foot, but one may conject (theorize) about the ball, and that “theorize” is faith.


The Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #616: the fact is that at this stage, any theory is just wild guesswork


As an adult, an angry adult at that, but no less an adult, you acknowledged the Big Bang leap of faith.


I would like to draw your attention back to your post #598. You expressed you believe in a god with a 13.8 billion year old universe, so the god in whom you believe is not Jesus Christ.


We Christians believe that all occurrences of six days in the fourth Commandment exclusively refer to 24 hour per day literal six days. Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God commands:

Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a sabbath of the LORD your God; in it you shall not do any work, you or your son or your daughter, your male or your female servant or your cattle or your sojourner who stays with you. For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day and made it holy.
(Exodus 20:8-11)

Moreover, we Christians believe that Adam and Eve were there at the beginning of creation when the six days of making all the stars and planets and Earth culminated with God creating man (Genesis 1:1-31). Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God declares:

He who created them from the beginning “made them male and female”
(Matthew 19:4).


Christians believe Christ. Christians believe the beginning of creation week (Genesis 1:1) is about 6,000 years ago. The calculation is based on Biblical record from the beginning until the birth of Christ added to the about 2,000 years after Christ’s birth.


Therefore, a person who claims to be a Christian yet does not believe the above Word of God (Christ) references to the creation account, then that person is not a Christian.


Christians understand six days is not six billion years, not six weeks, not about 14 billion years, but six days that the Word of God says God made Heaven and Earth.


Distinct incompatibility exists between Cosmic Evolution (13,800,000,000 years) and Christianity (6,000 years).

Lord Jesus Christ says “Everyone who hears these words of Mine and does not act on them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and it fell—and great was its fall.” (Matthew 7:26-27). For us Christians, Christ is our glorious foundation. Lord Jesus Christ says “everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and yet it did not fall, for it had been founded on the rock.” (Matthew 7:24-25).


Again, I think it took some humility on your part for you to concede the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #614: “A believer in Lord Jesus Christ, Kermos”

I believe in Jesus Christ the Lord that by Him all things were created, both in the heavens and on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or rulers or authorities—all things have been created through Him and for Him. He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together (Colossians 1:16-17). I proclaimed my belief in the opening post.


You believe in the Big Bang. Your belief is so very weak that you fail to admit that it’s faith.


Now, continuing with where you fumbled your Big Bang belief. You failed to answer my simple question, and, Mr. sloppy scientist, you failed to respond to my immediately subsequent question about your CMBR being disrupted.

@FLRW wrote in post #610: The following will refute Kermos’s claims on the Big Bang Theory. David Rowland is an independent writer and researcher who has self-published alternative claims arguing that the Big Bang theory is false and logically impossible. …snip… mainstream scientific community views the Big Bang theory as overwhelmingly supported …snip

To Mr. MIT trained nuclear scientist,


You refuted yourself, silly scientist.


You believe in the Big Bang, and your your Big Bang is not a proven fact, so yours is faith.


Rowland believes in an infinite universe without beginning according to you, and his infinite universe is not a proven fact, so his is faith.


The Rowland quotes, that I presented in post #61 and post #199 remain valid.


Would you kindly share with me how you refuted my belief that yours is a Big Bang belief because I’m not finding it?


And while you’re at it, where is your response to my CMBR disrupting post #607 response to your CMBR faith filled post? My post that you skipped for your apparent lack of scientific acumen. It’s the third post above your current post.


A believer in Lord Jesus Christ, Kermos

Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #610: The following will refute Kermos’s claims on the Big Bang Theory. David Rowland is an independent writer and researcher who has self-published alternative claims arguing that the Big Bang theory is false and logically impossible. …snip… mainstream scientific community views the Big Bang theory as overwhelmingly supported …snip

To Mr. MIT trained nuclear scientist,


You refuted yourself, silly scientist.


You believe in the Big Bang, and your your Big Bang is not a proven fact, so yours is faith.


Rowland believes in an infinite universe without beginning according to you, and his infinite universe is not a proven fact, so his is faith.


The Rowland quotes, that I presented in post #61 and post #199 remain valid.


Would you kindly share with me how you refuted my belief that yours is a Big Bang belief because I’m not finding it?


And while you’re at it, where is your response to my CMBR disrupting post #607 response to your CMBR faith filled post? My post that you skipped for your apparent lack of scientific acumen. It’s the third post above your current post.


A believer in Lord Jesus Christ, Kermos


Kermos

FLRW presented nonsense nonscience as recorded in post #376 with the outline:

Comprehensive Scientific Fact That The Big Bang Is A Leap Of Faith

  1. RED-SHIFT IS MERELY RED-SPECTRAL
  2. Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers
  3. Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss
  4. History, red-shift rapidly morphs into blue-shift
  5. Conclusion for your pillar of red-shift
  6. COSMIC MICROWAVE BACKGROUND RADIATION (CMBR)
  7. Scientist’s, er, philosopher’s public CMBR deception
  8. CMBR UnSETtling Theory
  9. CMBR Average Disformity
  10. CMBR Logical Conclusion
  11. PRIDEFUL MAN SEES LIGHT IN THE HEAVENS AND SAYS TO HIMSELF, “THERE IS NO GOD”
  12. GALAXIES CHANGE
  13. The Zenith Model
  14. THE COSMIC DISTANCE LADDER IS A POORLY FORMED FAITH
  15. The Episcopic Model


Lord Jesus says “the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and there are many who enter through it” (Matthew 7:13), and the Big Bang way is definitely broad with many like Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker and Debby and Double_R treading the Big Bang broad way!


The Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos

The MIT trained nuclear scientist @FLRW, the same FLRW who includes that he is a relative “to Albert Einstein through the Koch family”, the FLRW who prides himself as looking like Oppenheimer, who tested the first atomic bomb not knowing whether the atomic bomb explosion would consume the entire world - months after the Nazi threat of developing a competing first atomic bomb was eliminated, the same FLRW who used a DebateCraft.com screen name which is a namesake for the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric that is a cornerstone of current cosmological confused calculations along with Einstein’s relativity theories for FLRW’s relativistic morality, yes, that FLRW flowers without facts fumbling into faith for unresponsiveness to the CMBR crashing reminder post #592 (9/14/26), so I’ll provide it for you, again.

@FLRW wrote in post #586: Red-shift does not disrupt …snip


Mr. observationally challenged scientist FLRW,


Instead of addressing my CMBR disrupting recent response post #578 nor post #592 to you, you skipped it, so here is a full copy for (1) you to get back on track with your faith based CMBR and (2) you to be unable to respond to me with scientific method based procedure for your CMBR.

@FLRW wrote in post #574: Kermos, why do you like Chinese scientist?


You’re racist. You admitted that you look like one who associates with communists (post #570), and the chinese have a communist form of government.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: The validity of Eda Gjergo’s concept that early massive galaxy formation significantly contaminates or even constitutes the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is currently not accepted by the mainstream cosmological community and is considered a controversial hypothesis rather than established fact.


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. I previously explained that I use your science against you. Gjergo is your mainstream cosmological community’s scientist sorceress.


Kroupa’s credentials are primarily European. Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28). Kroupa’s credentials far exceed your credentials to address the CMBR’s status in the mainstream cosmological community!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: Gjergo and co-author Pavel Kroupa published a paper in Nuclear Physics B (2025) arguing that radiation from the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs) could account for at least 1.4% and potentially 100% of the observed CMB energy density, thereby challenging the standard Big Bang model. Their calculations suggest that these galaxies were up to 10,000 times brighter during formation than they are today, and their redshifted infrared emissions could mimic the CMB spectrum.


So, your CMBR is faith-based which is the very point that you nonsensically non-scientifically fight.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: However, prominent physicists and reviewers have raised significant criticisms:


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. Name names with links to papers.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 1. Mechanism Issues: Critics note that for galaxy emission to mimic the CMB, there must be a mechanism to distribute cosmic dust uniformly and thermalize it to the exact temperature of the CMB, which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies, not uniformly distributed.


Your CMBR is not uniform as established in post #376.


Your “which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies” is your scientist sorcerers belief without proof (assumption, see post #53 for the dictionary definition).

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 2. Observational Evidence: Standard cosmology maintains that the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang), while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years). The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models.


Here, you credit “Observational Evidence”. There, you discredit “Observational Evidence” (see post #478). Your sloppy science is self-contradictory!


Your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” is a massive assumption (belief without proof, see post #53 for the dictionary definition). Nobody observed your CMB origination, so you lied by including your unobserved CMB origination under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” is your “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53 built on top of your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” massive “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53), so you lied by including your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your “The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models”, that you stated so “matter of fact” is really a “matter of faith” built on your detailed lies above.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 3. Methodological Concerns: Some reviews point out circularity and a lack of sensitivity analysis in the authors’ claims, noting that the 1.4% figure is a conservative lower bound that the authors themselves admit could scale up to 100% with “small tweaks” to assumptions, which undermines predictive rigor.


Hmm, “Some reviews”, but not all reviews, so much for your “authoritative” “mainstream cosmological community” cohesion.


You have “assumptions”, and they have assumptions. You dogmatically believe your “belief without proof” are superior to their belief without proof by way of your fanatical evolution religion intense zeal.


Your “3. Methodological Concerns” apply to your position, as well, FLRW! You employ scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion followed by their application of mathematical statistics (magic) to arrive at your “definitive 2.725 K” (proof post #421). I posted your CMBR data points with detailed mathematical analysis in post #376 and post #421 which clearly exposed your “definitive 2.725 K” to be a magical, mystical, nonsense nonscience faith.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: In summary, while Gjergo and Kroupa’s work highlights a potential foreground contamination that warrants further study, the consensus view remains that the CMB is a relic of the Big Bang, and the claim that it arises primarily from early galaxy formation is regarded as unsalvageable nonsense or a provocative but unproven hypothesis by many in the astrophysics community.


Oh, look, “potential foreground contamination” is a variant of you “scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion” which I referenced earlier in this post. That is you, Mr. MIT AI IQ scientist sorcerer FLRW committing your magical, mystical act right there!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


You failed to prove your CMBR, and you failed to disprove your CMBR. I am using your science against you, so whether you prove or disprove Kroupa et al’s paper doesn’t matter to me because I’m showing you that your whole Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kroupa, with additional author Eda Gjergo, expose evidence against the existence of the CMBR. These two extracts from their abstract explain:

A previously overlooked foreground component is the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs), which can no longer be ignored, particularly in light of JWST’s detection of massive, evolved systems at extreme redshifts (z>13).
Even in our most conservative estimates, massive ETGs account for 1.4% up to the full present-day CMB energy density.
(source: “The impact of early massive galaxy formation on the cosmic microwave background” (Eda Gjergo, Pavel Kroupa; Nuclear Physics B published by Elsevier aa distributed on ScienceDirect.com; August 2025; Article: 116931; Volume 1017))


Astronomer astrologers best case scenario is that a “definitive 2.725 K” is off by 1.4% which means you the MIT trained nuclear scientist FLRW has personal faith expressed as scientific fact in his own composition in this thread of:

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.


Which is recorded in post #421 with my response.


That study’s 1.4% is the lower of the conservative echelon.


The study’s full present-day CMB energy density is the higher of the conservative echelon which excludes a so-called CMBR from being a Big Bang indicator!


This examination of the study’s conservative echelon leaves the liberal echelon unexplored. The implications of a liberal echelon destroy the Big Bang.


Your whole Big Bang is unproven and unobserved with bad evidence, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #586: Red-shift does not disrupt Einstein’s E=mc²


Red-shift most certainly disrupts Einstein’s E=MC2 and/or vice versa. Here is the proof that disrupts your whole post. You repeated your frequency argument, but frequency is not explicitly included in Einstein’s E=MC2, so a photon with the photon’s frequency and wavelength are represented in the speed of light (C) inside of Einstein’s E=MC2; therefore, the shift from high energy violet light to low energy red light results in a decrease of energy (E) within Einstein’s E=MC2 forcing the speed of light (C) for the photon without mass (M) to increase beyond 186,000 miles per second thus smashing your constant speed limit for light!

@FLRW wrote in post #586: Since a photon’s energy is proportional to its frequency (E=hf), a loss of energy results in a decrease in frequency and a corresponding increase in wavelength.


Your statement overflows with illogical inconsistency:

  1. You repeated the MITman Model (post #465) which holds that your faulty E=hf formula concludes with you performing the G=(+1)+(-1)+(-1) formula where G must equal 0 for logical consistency. Your loss of photonic energy is a loss of photonic frequency which is two decreases, but you have one increase up your sleeve with the wavelength. Hence your imbalanced equation garbage physics are illuminated by the MITman Model (post #465)!
  2. Your E=hf fails to provide a balanced account for your E=hf, so your E=hf certainly fails to provide a balanced account for Einstein’s E=MC2!


@FLRW wrote in post #586: energy conservation is maintained through the curvature of spacetime


Your "spacetime is a leap of faith as per post #199 which, among other valid fact disrupting your Big Bang, shows that time is not represented in Einstein’s E=MC2 so Einstein’s E=MC2 has no plottable position in the Minkowski spacetime model resulting in Big Bang adherent’s leap of faith in spacetime.

@FLRW wrote in post #586: mass-energy equivalence


Your restriction of Einstein’s E=MC2 exclusively to equivalence of mass (M) and energy (E) results in YOU eliminating the speed of light (C) from Einstein’s E=MC2; therefore, you promote the Magoroth Model of E=M. You science is so incredibly sloppy!


You are using your E=M leap of faith to support your spacetime leap of faith to support your red-shift leap of faith to support your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #589: But you refute yourself.


I didn’t conjure Einstein’s E=MC2, and I use your science against you, so your conclusion is false.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: How can E=MC^2 ever be in equilibrium for a photon when its mass is 0? Its energy is not zero as you admit, so obviously the formula does not apply to the photon.


Einstein’s E=MC2 most certainly applies to the photon because the speed of light (C) includes a photon with the photon’s frequency and wavelength; otherwise, you end up with the Magoroth Model (post #567) where you redesign Einstein’s E=MC2 as E=M.


The equilibrium of Einstein’s E=MC2 is not my problem. The disequilibrium of Einstein’s E=MC2 is your problem.


I am familiar with your E=MC2 no mass dilemma for your Big Bang. In effect, you disproved Einstein’s E=MC2 on your own. The secondary effect is that you disproved red-shift because red-shift is immensely dependent upon Einstein’s E=MC2.


You advocate for red-shift as fact, so you need Einstein’s E=MC2 formula to be a fact, yet you placed Einstein’s E=MC2 formula squarely into the faith zone with your “photon when its mass is 0”.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: Again, I literally linked studies that tested REDSHIFT on EARTH using manmade objects, in 1907, using motors on a mirror.


You didn’t supply a link to a red-shift mirror study. You mentioned it. I explained about the study’s faith based condition.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: ”Light has never been tested at 6,0000,000000,000 miles from Earth” 1. This is an unreasonable demand.


My “Light has never been tested at 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles from Earth” statement (post #584) is a reasonable observation about the state of your science.


For the record, you quoting my post #584 to you is evidence that you are responding to my post #584 to you. This makes it easier to trace your errors.


You believe that you know (science) for a fact that the maximum speed of light is 186,000 miles per second at 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles from Earth per your writing’s “matter of fact” structure in various places in this thread which you recognize as your own unreasonable thoughts as indicated by your response to me, but you call me unreasonable for calling out the fact that you don’t know.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: 2. You complain that redshift has never been tested on Earth/its immediate environs


You confuse “complain” with “expose”. As I wrote, I use your science (knowledge) against you. I expose your “matter of fact” statements as the “matter of faith” statements which they truly are.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: No, but they are photons of longer wavelength and thus lower energy, so thus they should travel more slowly according to you


Redshifted light versus nonredshifted light


Your statement is patently false. I exclusively refer to photons in reference to Einstein’s E=MC2 with red-shift in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see post #584); at the same time, I am not referring to non-doppler affected light in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift”. For example,. I am not referring to photons that start out as violet (h = 380 nm & f = 788.9 THz & 3.263 eV & 186,000 mps) and travel as violet (h = 380 nm & f = 788.9 THz & 3.263 eV & 186,000 mps) and are received as violet (h = 380 nm & f = 788.9 THz & 3.263 eV & 186,000 mps) or just keep traveling as violet (h = 380 nm & f = 788.9 THz & 3.263 eV & 186,000 mps). The photonic attributes in parentheses immediately adjacent to the photon color name are as follows per the physics field: h is wavelength; f is frequency; eV is electronvolt for energy; and mps is miles per second for speed. As a further, correlated example, I am not referring to photons like red photons which emit from source as red (h = 780 nm & f = 384.3 THz & 1.590 eV & 186,000 mps) and traverses a medium as red (h = 780 nm & f = 384.3 THz & 1.590 eV & 186,000 mps) and potentially is intercepted at a destination as red (h = 780 nm & f = 384.3 THz & 1.590 eV & 186,000 mps). This has been very clear in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: ”There is no redshift involved in radio waves” No, but they are photons of longer wavelength and thus lower energy, so thus they should travel more slowly according to you, which doesn’t happen. Again, this refutes your theory.


See the “Redshifted light versus nonredshifted light” section, above, for the relevant concept showing your dishonest representation of my writing. Just move the examples to the radio wave part of the electromagnetic spectrum.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: Same goes for gamma rays.


See the “Redshifted light versus nonredshifted light” section, above, but shift the examples to the gamma ray range of the electromagnetic spectrum.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: The point of me bringing up gold was to show that relativity and the value of the speed of light has direct influence on everyday life, it is not just a theory about spacetime and astronomy. Denial of the speed of light makes a lot of nuclear processes and just the physical behaviour of certain substances change radically, quite possibly making life as we know it impossible.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: It ignores E=MC^2 because it has nothing to do with this formula. Again, this formula cannot apply to photons or other massless particles because they have nothing mass yet they do have energy. You cannot have 0 on one side of the equation and non-zero on the other.


That is not a problem for me because I’m exposing your leap of faith, but that is a problem for you because the speed of light (C) includes the photon with it’s frequency and wavelength according to your physics.

@Magoroth wrote in post #589: I eliminate nothing, it is you who persists in claiming that e=mc^2 has a relevance in this situation, when it is pretty fucking blatant that it doesn’t if you just think for two seconds.


Your maggot rot language emerged again, Magoroth.


You better try to understand Einstein’s Relativity theories with the gravitational lensing and such before you make such nonsense nonscience claims. I’ll help you get started by providing these very useful links to posts in this thread:

  1. post #61
  2. post #87
  3. post #93
  4. post #199
  5. post #258
  6. post #361
  7. post #325
  8. post #455
  9. post #465
  10. post #485
  11. post #535
  12. post #567


Your thoughts eliminate the speed of light (C) from Einstein’s E=MC2 which converts the formula into your Magoroth Model E=M. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see post #584).


Red-shift disrupts Einstein’s E=MC2, and/or Einstein’s E=MC2 disrupts red-shift; therefore, red-shift is a leap of faith, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Skipper wrote in post #534: I believe in the Big Bang because after a Big Bang, my mother was pregnant and I was born. How could I be alive right now if there was no Big Bang?


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


I’m not going out on a limb by saying your mommy ain’t 13.8 billion years old.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #599: Unfor …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


Slander as you may, slander as you might, your science (knowledge) deficiency manifests in your failure to respond with the scientific method.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@ebuc wrote in post #587: Since a photon’s energy is proportional to its frequency (E=hf), a loss of energy results in a decrease in frequency and a corresponding increase in wavelength.


I see that you subscribe to the MITman Model (post #465) school of thought which holds that your faulty E=hf formula concludes with you performing the G=(+1)+(-1)+(-1) formula where G must equal 0 for logical consistency. Your loss of photonic energy is a loss of photonic frequency which is two decreases, but you have a single increase in your formula with the wavelength. Hence your imbalanced equation garbage physics are illuminated by the MITman Model (post #465)!

@ebuc wrote in post #587: so from my perspective


Your perspective is not based on the scientific method. Your perspective is your faith.


The Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #586: Red-shift does not disrupt …snip


Mr. observationally challenged scientist FLRW,


Instead of addressing my CMBR disrupting recent response post #578 to you, you skipped it, so here is a full copy for (1) you to get back on track with your faith based CMBR and (2) you to be unable to respond to me with scientific method based procedure for your CMBR.

@FLRW wrote in post #574: Kermos, why do you like Chinese scientist?


You’re racist. You admitted that you look like one who associates with communists (post #570), and the chinese have a communist form of government.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: The validity of Eda Gjergo’s concept that early massive galaxy formation significantly contaminates or even constitutes the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is currently not accepted by the mainstream cosmological community and is considered a controversial hypothesis rather than established fact.


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. I previously explained that I use your science against you. Gjergo is your mainstream cosmological community’s scientist sorceress.


Kroupa’s credentials are primarily European. Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28). Kroupa’s credentials far exceed your credentials to address the CMBR’s status in the mainstream cosmological community!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: Gjergo and co-author Pavel Kroupa published a paper in Nuclear Physics B (2025) arguing that radiation from the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs) could account for at least 1.4% and potentially 100% of the observed CMB energy density, thereby challenging the standard Big Bang model. Their calculations suggest that these galaxies were up to 10,000 times brighter during formation than they are today, and their redshifted infrared emissions could mimic the CMB spectrum.


So, your CMBR is faith-based which is the very point that you nonsensically non-scientifically fight.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574:](https://www.debatecraft.com/forum/c/science-and-technology/posts/10g/show-me-how-the-big-bang-theory-is-not-a-leap-of-faith?page=20&comment_number=574) However, prominent physicists and reviewers have raised significant criticisms:


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. Name names.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 1. Mechanism Issues: Critics note that for galaxy emission to mimic the CMB, there must be a mechanism to distribute cosmic dust uniformly and thermalize it to the exact temperature of the CMB, which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies, not uniformly distributed.


Your CMBR is not uniform as established in post #376.


Your “which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies” is your scientist sorcerers belief without proof (assumption, see post #53 for the dictionary definition).

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 2. Observational Evidence: Standard cosmology maintains that the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang), while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years). The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models.


Here, you credit “Observational Evidence”. There, you discredit “Observational Evidence” (see post #478). Your sloppy science is self-contradictory!


Your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” is a massive assumption (belief without proof, see post #53 for the dictionary definition). Nobody observed your CMB origination, so you lied by including your unobserved CMB origination under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” is your “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53 built on top of your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” massive “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53), so you lied by including your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your “The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models”, that you stated so “matter of fact” is really a “matter of faith” built on your detailed lies above.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 3. Methodological Concerns: Some reviews point out circularity and a lack of sensitivity analysis in the authors’ claims, noting that the 1.4% figure is a conservative lower bound that the authors themselves admit could scale up to 100% with “small tweaks” to assumptions, which undermines predictive rigor.


Hmm, “Some reviews”, but not all reviews, so much for your “authoritative” “mainstream cosmological community” cohesion.


You have “assumptions”, and they have assumptions. You dogmatically believe your “belief without proof” are superior to their belief without proof by way of your fanatical evolution religion intense zeal.


Your “3. Methodological Concerns” apply to your position, as well, FLRW! You employ scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion followed by their application of mathematical statistics (magic) to arrive at your “definitive 2.725 K” (proof post #421). I posted your CMBR data points with detailed mathematical analysis in post #376 and post #421 which clearly exposed your “definitive 2.725 K” to be a magical, mystical, nonsense nonscience faith.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: In summary, while Gjergo and Kroupa’s work highlights a potential foreground contamination that warrants further study, the consensus view remains that the CMB is a relic of the Big Bang, and the claim that it arises primarily from early galaxy formation is regarded as unsalvageable nonsense or a provocative but unproven hypothesis by many in the astrophysics community.


Oh, look, “potential foreground contamination” is a variant of you “scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion” which I referenced earlier in this post. That is you, Mr. MIT AI IQ scientist sorcerer FLRW committing your magical, mystical act right there!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


You failed to prove your CMBR, and you failed to disprove your CMBR. I am using your science against you, so whether you prove or disprove Kroupa et al’s paper doesn’t matter to me because I’m showing you that your whole Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kroupa, with additional author Eda Gjergo, expose evidence against the existence of the CMBR. These two extracts from their abstract explain:

A previously overlooked foreground component is the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs), which can no longer be ignored, particularly in light of JWST’s detection of massive, evolved systems at extreme redshifts (z>13).
Even in our most conservative estimates, massive ETGs account for 1.4% up to the full present-day CMB energy density.
(source: “The impact of early massive galaxy formation on the cosmic microwave background” (Eda Gjergo, Pavel Kroupa; Nuclear Physics B published by Elsevier aa distributed on ScienceDirect.com; August 2025; Article: 116931; Volume 1017))


Astronomer astrologers best case scenario is that a “definitive 2.725 K” is off by 1.4% which means you the MIT trained nuclear scientist FLRW has personal faith expressed as scientific fact in his own composition in this thread of:

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.


Which is recorded in post #421 with my response.


That study’s 1.4% is the lower of the conservative echelon.


The study’s full present-day CMB energy density is the higher of the conservative echelon which excludes a so-called CMBR from being a Big Bang indicator!


This examination of the study’s conservative echelon leaves the liberal echelon unexplored. The implications of a liberal echelon destroy the Big Bang.


Your whole Big Bang is unproven and unobserved with bad evidence, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #581: Though BIG BANG is a nominal generalization of an initiated and progressive universe and the very fact that we are having this conversation would seem to support this idea…Nonetheless as such, theoretical ideas do not require faith, but rather, require further consideration.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


Since a theory is not a proven fact, then a theory is a person’s faith. Your writing conveys about yourself that “I am a believer in the Hubble-Lemaître Law Big Bang because I believe in the Hubble-Lemaître Law Big Bang and my belief in the Hubble-Lemaître Law Big Bang is not a belief”.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.