Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Please state clearly what the relevance of the energy difference between violet and red is.


I am happy to oblige, so here you go.

Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift


“A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


Einstein’s formula E=MC2 has high relation to red-shift. Red-shift’s high energy, high frequency light deteriorates into low energy, low frequency light at the time of emission, and astronomer astrologers believe this reveals age, distance, and/or direction of celestial objects. Einstein’s formula E=MC2 is in permanent equilibrium between energy (E) and mass (M) and speed_of_light (C). Since E=MC2 needs to be maintain equilibrium with the red-shift massless (M) photon, then the commutative property of mathematics keeps the equation’s balance by moving energy (E) to the speed_of_light (C). In essence, E=MC2 forces an increase to the speed of light under the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. redshift.


I obtained the following from 4.5: The Doppler Effect at LibreTexts with respect to red-shift:

The relationship between the degree of shift in wavelength to the speed of the object is found by:
Apparent wavelength/true frequency = true wavelength/apparent frequency = 1 + recession velocity/wave speed.
Since the speed of light in a vacuum, c, is a constant, the speed of the object can be found with the following equation:
Δλ/λ = v/c
Where Δλ is the change in wavelength, λ is the normal or laboratory wavelength of the light, and v is the relative speed of the source toward or away from the observer.


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error.


You need to mess with adjusting the C (constant representing the speed of light at 186,000 miles per second) in Einstein’s E=MC2, but you are left with a MESS in so doing because light pushes beyond 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years which translates to light moving faster, much faster than your C of 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years (a.k.a. velocity well beyond 186,000 miles per second), so light speedily traverses the 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 mile distance in some unknown amount of the time, for example, maybe 2 days. I refer you to my post #199 to FLRW regarding Einstein’s Special Relativity Theory where I detailed that Rowland explained a time element is absent from E=MC2.


Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light exists not; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: They both travel at the same velocity, their frequency differs.


Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Also E=MC^2 isn’t a system.


“A group of interacting, interrelated, or interdependent elements forming a complex whole” is the definition of “system” (source: thefreedictionary.com/system), so energy (E) with mass (M) with photonic velocity (C) of E=MC2 are the interacting and interrelated elements which comprise a system.

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Where’s the forces?


Would that force be the ember (photon) speedily traveling brightly through the universe that astronomer astrologers claim has been traveling through space for 13.5 billion years from Galaxy candidate HDI until it was extinguished in a telescope at Earth? That ember which purportedly maintained it’s flame for more than a whopping 197 million lifespans of your life. Would that force be the propellant that releases a high energy blue photon as a lower energy red photon? None of this matters for the system that is represented inside of the E=MC2 formula because photons are represented by the speed of light (C) in the E=MC2 formula.

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: It states that if you convert a particle of mass M into a photon (particle-antiparticle annihilation), you get a photon whose energy is equal to the the mass of the particle (rest mass) times the speed of light squared. There is no system, what system could there possibly be in E=MC^2?


The equal sign (=) indicates balance inside E=MC2, but an integral symbol (∫) is missing. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is incomplete at best for you and false at worst for you based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Again, red shift doesn’t push anything past anything. The speed of light is constant. Photons’ oscillations appear to you to be more rapid or slower depending on the velocity and this is conmon sense since light is a wave.


Again, you converted the formula to Magoroth’s Model of E=M. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Or are you seriously suggesting photons of different frequency travel at different velocities?


I wrote that equilibrium within E=MC2 must be maintained between energy (E) and mass (M) and the speed of photons (C), but you persist in diverting to your “frequency” which isn’t specifically a variable element within E=MC2. Red-shift forces the increase of velocity as per equilibrium within E=MC2. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Why has literally the speed of light been consistently found to be 300,000km/s in a vacuum?


Light has never been tested at 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles from Earth, so the answer to your question is that “it hasn’t”, yet this doesn’t matter because this is about the the relationship between red-shift and Einstein’s E=MC2. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Do you actually believe all the photons we tested were of the same wavelength?


It doesn’t matter because your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: And more importantly; how do you explain radio waves, they travel “instantly” as far as we are concerned. If you were correct they should be much slower than other photons since they have a very low frequency, correct? This doesn’t happen. We have sent messages via radio and received messages via radio from the Moon, which is approximately 1 light second away from Earth (Apollo 11 was televised), and it had a delay of 1 second.


There’s no red-shift involved in your radio wave examples. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: And this is true for gamma rays too; a lot of nuclear physics would break down if gamma rays were faster than other photons.


It does not matter about your gamma ray example because this is about the relationship between Einstein’s E=MC2 and red-shift. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: You seem to further be doubting the validity of general relativity but I don’t think you realise how far reaching its implications are. It even affects the chemical characteristics of certain metals, like gold for instance. Why is gold yellow and not white? It’s because of relativity, the electrons are so energetix they move at considerable fractions of the speed of light.


You are missing the point which is the impact of your so-called red-shift on Einstein’s E=MC2. The gold metal seen by a person is not red-shifted. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Also… why would anyone call it the speed of light if it weren’t constant? They would just say the speed of blue light or whatever.


The speed of the car was… Your argument fails to address the core issue of the relationship between Einstein’s E=MC2 with Doppler effect for light. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: I don’t think you understood what I said. When a source moves away from a receiver, the speed of light doesn’t change, both the source and the receiver would agree the speed of the beam of the light travelling from one to the other is 300,000 km/s. If the source stops moving with respect to the receiver, the speed the measure of the light beam remains the same 300,000km/s. The kinetic energy of the source is then 0 since its not moving, BUT in the case where it IS moving (Doppler effect), it is non-zero.


I acknowledge what you are saying avoids the core concept of the relationship between the Doppler effect for light and Einstein’s E=MC2. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).

@Magoroth wrote in post #575: Yes congratulations Einstein E=MC^2 is the equivalence formula between mass (matter) and pure energy (photons), this is what I’ve been saying all along lmao


The Magoroth Model, E=M, competes against Einstein’s E=MC2.


In effect, you eliminated the speed of light (C) from Einstein’s E=MC2 which converts the formula into your Magoroth Model E=M. Your stated red-shift contextuaized belief, there, is false based on Einstein’s E=MC2 as detailed for you in “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” (see the first section of this post and also in post #361).


Red-shift disrupts Einstein’s E=MC2, and/or Einstein’s E=MC2 disrupts red-shift; therefore, red-shift is a leap of faith, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #574: Kermos, why do you like Chinese scientist?


You’re racist. You admitted that you look like one who associates with communists (post #570), and the chinese have a communist form of government.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: The validity of Eda Gjergo’s concept that early massive galaxy formation significantly contaminates or even constitutes the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is currently not accepted by the mainstream cosmological community and is considered a controversial hypothesis rather than established fact.


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. I previously explained that I use your science against you. Gjergo is your mainstream cosmological community’s scientist sorceress.


Kroupa’s credentials are primarily European. Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28). Kroupa’s credentials far exceed your credentials to address the CMBR’s status in the mainstream cosmological community!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: Gjergo and co-author Pavel Kroupa published a paper in Nuclear Physics B (2025) arguing that radiation from the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs) could account for at least 1.4% and potentially 100% of the observed CMB energy density, thereby challenging the standard Big Bang model. Their calculations suggest that these galaxies were up to 10,000 times brighter during formation than they are today, and their redshifted infrared emissions could mimic the CMB spectrum.


So, your CMBR is faith-based which is the very point that you nonsensically non-scientifically fight.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: However, prominent physicists and reviewers have raised significant criticisms:


You are a sloppy scientist who was indoctrinated at MIT. Name names.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 1. Mechanism Issues: Critics note that for galaxy emission to mimic the CMB, there must be a mechanism to distribute cosmic dust uniformly and thermalize it to the exact temperature of the CMB, which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies, not uniformly distributed.


Your CMBR is not uniform as established in post #376.


Your “which is physically unlikely given that dust is generated by specific galaxies” is your scientist sorcerers belief without proof (assumption, see post #53 for the dictionary definition).

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 2. Observational Evidence: Standard cosmology maintains that the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang), while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years). The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models.


Here, you credit “Observational Evidence”. There, you discredit “Observational Evidence” (see post #478). Your sloppy science is self-contradictory!


Your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” is a massive assumption (belief without proof, see post #53 for the dictionary definition). Nobody observed your CMB origination, so you lied by including your unobserved CMB origination under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” is your “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53 built on top of your “the CMB originates from recombination (380,000 years after the Big Bang)” massive “belief without proof” (assumption, see post #53), so you lied by including your unobserved “while the galaxies in question formed much later (~200 million years)” under your “ 2. Observational Evidence”.


Your “The spectral shape and anisotropies of the CMB are robustly explained by the Big Bang model and are not fully accounted for by galaxy formation models”, that you stated so “matter of fact” is really a “matter of faith” built on your detailed lies above.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: 3. Methodological Concerns: Some reviews point out circularity and a lack of sensitivity analysis in the authors’ claims, noting that the 1.4% figure is a conservative lower bound that the authors themselves admit could scale up to 100% with “small tweaks” to assumptions, which undermines predictive rigor.


Hmm, “Some reviews”, but not all reviews, so much for your “authoritative” “mainstream cosmological community” cohesion.


You have “assumptions”, and they have assumptions. You dogmatically believe your “belief without proof” are superior to their belief without proof by way of your fanatical evolution religion intense zeal.


Your “3. Methodological Concerns” apply to your position, as well, FLRW! You employ scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion followed by their application of mathematical statistics (magic) to arrive at your “definitive 2.725 K” (proof post #421). I posted your CMBR data points with detailed mathematical analysis in post #376 and post #421 which clearly exposed your “definitive 2.725 K” to be a magical, mystical, nonsense nonscience faith.

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


@FLRW wrote in post #574: In summary, while Gjergo and Kroupa’s work highlights a potential foreground contamination that warrants further study, the consensus view remains that the CMB is a relic of the Big Bang, and the claim that it arises primarily from early galaxy formation is regarded as unsalvageable nonsense or a provocative but unproven hypothesis by many in the astrophysics community.


Oh, look, “potential foreground contamination” is a variant of you “scientist sorcerer’s arbitrary data point deletion” which I referenced earlier in this post. That is you, Mr. MIT AI IQ scientist sorcerer FLRW committing your magical, mystical act right there!

You expressed no scientific method support for your CMBR, there.


You failed to prove your CMBR, and you failed to disprove your CMBR. I am using your science against you, so whether you prove or disprove Kroupa et al’s paper doesn’t matter to me because I’m showing you that your whole Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kroupa, with additional author Eda Gjergo, expose evidence against the existence of the CMBR. These two extracts from their abstract explain:

A previously overlooked foreground component is the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs), which can no longer be ignored, particularly in light of JWST’s detection of massive, evolved systems at extreme redshifts (z>13).
Even in our most conservative estimates, massive ETGs account for 1.4% up to the full present-day CMB energy density.
(source: “The impact of early massive galaxy formation on the cosmic microwave background” (Eda Gjergo, Pavel Kroupa; Nuclear Physics B published by Elsevier aa distributed on ScienceDirect.com; August 2025; Article: 116931; Volume 1017))


Astronomer astrologers best case scenario is that a “definitive 2.725 K” is off by 1.4% which means you the MIT trained nuclear scientist FLRW has personal faith expressed as scientific fact in his own composition in this thread of:

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.


Which is recorded in post #421 with my response.


That study’s 1.4% is the lower of the conservative echelon.


The study’s full present-day CMB energy density is the higher of the conservative echelon which excludes a so-called CMBR from being a Big Bang indicator!


This examination of the study’s conservative echelon leaves the liberal echelon unexplored. The implications of a liberal echelon destroy the Big Bang.


Your whole Big Bang is unproven and unobserved with bad evidence, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #572: Why do you sound like an artificial intelligence?


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You exhibit the Pharmakeia Principle (post #71).


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos

Here is the post, special for you, FLRW, which I mentioned in my previous post.

@FLRW wrote in post #459: See, …snip


Mr. nuclear scientist FLRW, you cravenly hide behind your undescribed content URL (not even a hyperlink), but I write to you requesting that you show your work in this thread, here on DebateCraft.com, where both of us are engaged in debate. I’ll provide you an example with this post to you. You seem unable to address the points I present to you. Your position is so weak that you repeat yourself, but I systematically dissect your arguments, and I methodologically dismantle your scientific fact statements into their proper state as your sacred faith.

Astrophysicists recalculated CMBR from data including JWST readings, and the study details astronomer astrologer’s CMBR isn’t what they scienced (knew)


Pavel Kroupa, astrophysicist and professor at the Helmholtz Institute for Radiation and Nuclear Physics at the University of Bonn and Charles University in Prague, expressed “According to our calculations, it may not exist at all” regarding the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR) as per his study published in the journal Nuclear Physics B (source: “Goodbye to the Big Bang theory: a university challenges everything we thought we knew and suggests that the creation of the universe may have been something else” (Austin Caldwell; MARCA; 2025-06-28).


Kroupa, with additional author Eda Gjergo, expose evidence against the existence of the CMBR. These two extracts from their abstract explain:

A previously overlooked foreground component is the formation of massive early-type galaxies (ETGs), which can no longer be ignored, particularly in light of JWST’s detection of massive, evolved systems at extreme redshifts (z>13).
Even in our most conservative estimates, massive ETGs account for 1.4% up to the full present-day CMB energy density.
(source: “The impact of early massive galaxy formation on the cosmic microwave background” (Eda Gjergo, Pavel Kroupa; Nuclear Physics B published by Elsevier aa distributed on ScienceDirect.com; August 2025; Article: 116931; Volume 1017))


Astronomer astrologers best case scenario is that a “definitive 2.725 K” is off by 1.4% which means the MIT trained nuclear scientist FLRW has science fiction expressed as scientific fact in his own composition in this thread of:

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.


Which is recorded in post #421 with my response.


That study’s 1.4% is the lower of the conservative echelon.


The study’s full present-day CMB energy density is the higher of the conservative echelon which excludes a so-called CMBR from being a Big Bang indicator!


This examination of the study’s conservative echelon leaves the liberal echelon unexplored. The implications of a liberal echelon destroy the Big Bang.


Scientist sorcerers cling to their Big Bang belief despite being faced with good evidence demonstrating that the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #559: I look like Robert Oppenheimer


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord Jesus willing, I will respond.


Oppenheimer was a corpse that was incinerated to ashes, and you sound proud of looking like him, and Oppenheimer’s ashes are very telling about him because he was crowned the “father of the atomic bomb” by people, the Oppenheimer whose thoughts went to the Bhavagad Gita at the time of the first nuclear weapon detonation, the instrumental developer of the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima where an estimated 45,000-83,000 died the first day - many incinerated to death, and the scientist developer of the atomic bomb dropped a few days later on Nagasaki where an estimated 30,000-40,000 died the first day - many incinerated while alive (sources include [Wikipedia}(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_and_Nagasaki) and Wikipedia and Wikipedia.

You, Mr. nuclear scientist FLRW, failed to address post #476 about the collapse of the evolutionist’s nuclear decay CMBR 13.8 billion year Big Bang argument, so my next post brings it forward for you.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. You fail to present Big Bang facts, so you have a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #565: For the record I had to break down your post with AI because it’s so utterly incomprehensible. Wtf does “red-shift related phrase” even mean?


Poor neuron-deprived Magoroth, you had to use augmented intelligence (AI) in order to understand a simple reference to your own writing!

@Magoroth wrote in post #565: It’s like 123114 extra words for literally no reason except to appear smart.


Obviously, your lack of innate neural capacity requires that I be pedantic with you. By the way, you overcounted my post #563’s word count by a factor exceeding 272, so your brain is delusionally deficient for debating your 13,800,000,000 year old Big Bang.

@Magoroth wrote in post #565: 1) “delta of the speed of light” - No, it’s the difference in velocity between the source that emits light and the receiver. The speed of light remains the same. The energy of a photon isn’t related to its velocity, which is constant, it’s related to its frequency. Not sure what you’re even trying to say here


I’m about to disect your concepts of your above paragraph very carefully for you, Magoroth.


You wrote “difference in velocity”.


Velocity is simply defined as “Rapidity or speed of motion; swiftness” (source thefreedictionary.com/velocity).


The “velocity” concept in your writing represents precisely the speed of light (C) inside of Einstein’s infamous E=MC2 equation.


I’ll state this for you another way. The speed of light (C) and the velocity of a photon (C) are exactly the same thing, and both ways of saying the same thing apply to Einstein’s infamous E=MC2 equation.


Your brain’s “it’s the difference in velocity between the source that emits light and the receiver” confusedly contradicts your brain’s immediately subsequent “The energy of a photon isn’t related to its velocity, which is constant”, and I can prove it by quoting a physics textbook here, “A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


The next segment of your broken brain’s output is “it’s related to its frequency” where you attempt to disintegrate the energy (E) relationship with the speed of light (C) inside of Einstein’s infamous E=MC2 equation.


And, finally, your brain’s blather of “Not sure what you’re even trying to say here” is a lie or you are stupid.

@Magoroth wrote in post #565: 2) “results …snip…. We are discussing Doppler redshift, not cosmological redshift.


This whole thread is about cosmology in reference to the Big Bang, just look at the thread title, Magoroth, “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Your whole “E=MC2 has nothing to do with this. The energy of the system is the kinetic energy of the source plus the energy of the photon/light beam itself. E=MC2 is an equivalence formula between mass and energy, it has nothing to do with this topic” is a poorly crafted deception.


Einstein’s E=MC2 equation is an equivalence formula between energy (E), mass (M), and photonic velocity a.k.a. the speed of light (C).

The Magoroth Model, E=M


The effect of your brain’s “E=MC^2 is an equivalence formula between mass and energy” results in a new, non-Einstein equation of E=M. Your words explicitly excluded the speed of light (C) from E=MC2, so you end up with the Magoroth Model of E=M where E is energy and M is mass.


Back to Einstein’s infamous E=MC2 equation.


The “system” in your “the energy of the system is the kinetic energy” is energy (E) inside of the “system” defined by Einstein in E=MC2 with the constituent speed of light (C) that is so very integral to this “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” topic going back to post #361.


The red-shift concept pushes the light particle speed way beyond your maximum speed limit for light of 186,000 miles per second in Einstein’s E=MC2 equation, and the red-shift concept amounts to Newton’s Third Law of Motion (Law of Action and Reaction) that I explained to you earlier in post #548, and Newton’s Law amounts to the clause, “for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”. You are desperately trying to escape physics, Magoroth.


The action of photonic energy (E) displacement inside E=MC2 requires an equal and opposite reaction inside E=MC2, and the reaction is explained in the next paragraph.


Red-shift remains science fiction because a photon contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section of post #361 contains the details.


The horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, and your pathetic research skills are glaringly visible, again.


I remind you about your bringing up “Satan” in your writing “you can’t claim the experimental results are corrupted by Satan” in your post #524. Since Lord and God Jesus Christ is not a God of confusion but of peace (1 Corinthians 14:33), then your confusion detailed in the above paragraphs of this post places you squarely in the domain of Satan the devil with you preaching your discipline of delusion (Jeremiah 10:8) about red-shift and the Big Bang.


Red-shift is a leap of belief, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #550: There’s no energy loss, it comes back in the kinetic energy difference between the source and the receiver
@Magoroth wrote in post #551: So the net energy of the system remains the same.


Your red-shift related phrase “the kinetic energy difference between the source and the receiver” represents nothing less than the dellta (change) increase of speed of light (C) inside of Einstein’s infamous E=MC2 equation for a photon because “A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts); furthermore, your antiphysics red-shift continuation phrase “So the net energy of the system remains the same” for E=MC2 results in a static energy (E) despite your first “the kinetic energy difference” statement’s dynamic energy (E), so you are very confused about mathematics and delusional about physics!


Your phrase “the kinetic energy difference” pushes the light particle speed way beyond your maximum speed limit for light of 186,000 miles per second in Einstein’s E=MC2 equation, and your “the kinetic energy difference” phrase amounts to Newton’s Third Law of Motion (Law of Action and Reaction) that I explained to you earlier in post #548, and Newton’s Law amounts to the clause, “for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”. You are desperately trying to escape physics, Magoroth.


The action of photonic energy (E) displacement inside E=MC2 requires an equal and opposite reaction inside E=MC2, and the reaction is explained in the next paragraph.


Red-shift remains science fiction because a photon contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section of post #361 contains the details.


The horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, and your pathetic research skills are glaringly visible, again.


I remind you about your bringing up “Satan” in your writing “you can’t claim the experimental results are corrupted by Satan” in your post #524. Since Lord and God Jesus Christ is not a God of confusion but of peace (1 Corinthians 14:33), then your confusion detailed in the above paragraphs of this post places you squarely in the domain of Satan the devil with you preaching your discipline of delusion (Jeremiah 10:8) about red-shift and the Big Bang.


Red-shift is a leap of belief, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #545: Also nobody brought up evolution so idk why you’re even mentioning this. Please stick to the topic


You blindly blather because you are being led by the blind such as the Roman Catholic Church priest and astronomer astrologer Lemaître (Matthew 15:14). The original post in this thread included discourse about your cosmic evolution religion, so I’m on topic writing about your Big Bang aspect of your evolution religion. The horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, your pathetic research skills, and your lost spiritual state are showing, Magoroth.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #544: I don’t even understand why you insist on 1) redshift being false 2) the connection to the Big Bang. Again, redshift can be true and the expansion of space can be false. The former is basically known beyond the shadow of a doubt, the latter is merely an interpretation of some observations.


Physics Lesson for Magoroth


As primarily foundational and pivotal to the Big Bang, red-shift imposes a make or break condition for the Big Bang; in other words, red shift, as a nonsense nonscience derived concept, makes an existential difference according to astrophysicists. The astronomer astrologer’s explanation for the expansion of the universe is very dependent on red-shift for the Big Bang adherent’s ultimate truth Hubble-Lemaître Law, v=H0D. H0 is the astronomer astrologer’s exalted Hubble Constant. That variable constant, er, constant variable, er, high priestly astronomer astrologer guesswork number (Hubble Constant) is driven by red-shift, and astronomer astrologers believe the Hubble variable Constant is between 50 kilometers per second per megaparsec and 100 km/sec/Mpc. When H=50, then the universe’s existence is about 20 billion years. When H=100, then the astronomer astrologers arrive at 10 billion years for the universe’s existence.


The age of the universe is between 10 billion years and a factor of 2 larger (essentially double the 10,000,000,000 years at 20,000,000,000 years according to astronomer astrologers; in other words, the events in the universe could have been transpiring for as much as 10,000,000,000 years more than the minimum of 10,000,000,000 years believed by your astronomer astrologer conjecturers!


Check this out, Magoroth, the error range is 10 billion years, so the error range is as big as the astronomer astrologer’s 10 billion year minimum existence time of the universe.


When H=72 (ish) in v=H0D, then astronomer astrologers put the Big Bang at 13.8 billion years ago.


Now, sufficient data sits in front of a rational, reasoning human to “understand why” I relate

“redshift” in “connection to the Big Bang”. This presents you with the opportunity to demonstrate whether you are a rational, reasonable person.


Consider your “matter of fact” structured sentence of “The former is basically known beyond the shadow of a doubt, the latter is merely an interpretation of some observations”, yet post #535 and post #541 and post #553 and post #554 and post #555 - all just a little way above here - provide facts demonstrating the whole of your structured sentence is a matter of your faith, not fact as you convey, but your redshift dogma leading to a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #542: It’s a proven fact, insofar as anything experimentally PROVEN by countless experiments over the past 100 hundred years is. Yes, red shift is a bloody fact. …snip… For instance, you have yet to address the experiments I linked.
@Magoroth wrote in post #543: It’s not even 100 years, it’s been longer than that. Closer to 140 years. Michelson Morley and the ether theory of light did not emerge in a vacuum lol.


You provided no links in either of your red-shift history posts. In my response post #535 to your demonstrated to be delusional history of red-shift post, I assigned the link that you failed to indicate. Since your second history contains substantial repeat of the first, then I’m skipping the second because you didn’t bother to address the solid historical points I presented in post #535.


If you want to advocate that Einstein, in 1920, was an idiot, then you will continue to push your “experimentally PROVEN” red-shift as a scientific fact 150 years-ish history with Vogel in 1871 (see post #535 for details).


Unless you want to obliterate Einstein’s E=MC2 formula, then you will cease to pursue your ridiculous red-shift faith (see post #548 for details).


You lied when you wrote “red shift is a bloody fact”, and the fact that you lied is supported by post #541 (immediately above your post) and post #535 and post #361 and post #548.


I’m addressing your post #542 in 3 interrelated posts because of the horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, and your pathetic research skills. If I posted them as one, then it might prove too much for you. This is the third of the three posts.


Red-shift is your faith’s discipline of delusion (Jeremiah 10:8), so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #542: snip… All you’re doing is cherry picking some random observation in a galaxy far far away and saying it disproves red shift; if only one result THAT ISN’T even conclusive btw says “oops we didn’t expect this” whereas countless others do, how the hell do you go to the conclusion that red shift is a myth? …snip


Your argument is delusional, hypocritical, and antiscience. I posted links to multiple papers related to red-shift in this thread, so you are delusional. You are hypocritical because you believe this scientist sorcerer, but you don’t believe that scientist sorcerer.


You are antiscience because you delusionally discard and besmirch the reputation of the astrophysicist who said of NGC 7319 quasar that “its redshift cannot be due to the expansion of the universe” and quasars in general “too many of them are being found closely associated with nearby, active galaxies for this to be accidental”, and these quotes were issued by astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences (source for Burbidge quotes), who with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper published in m The Astrophysical Journal (issue 1, volume 620).

“cherry picking some random observation in a galaxy far far away”


You say that I am “cherry picking some random observation in a galaxy far far away” paper, but it’s the very thing that you do except you cherry-picked an old decayed tech paper, not from this century, not from the last century, but from the prior century, going back to 1871; however, I cherry-picked a new ripe tech paper from this century!


Your whole Big Bang evolution religion is based on “some random observation in a galaxy far far away”.


I’m addressing your post #542 in 3 interrelated posts because of the horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, and your pathetic research skills. If I posted them as one, then it might be too much for you. This is the second of the three posts.


The Burbidge et al paper contributes to red-shift being a leap of faith which places your Big Bang belief as a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #542: snip… Light being a wave IMPLIES it should obey the Doppler effect and indeed experiments have shown multiple times that it does. …snip


You antiscientifically combine two entirely different types of waves to arrive at “Light being a wave IMPLIES it should obey the Doppler effect”.


In physics, atmospheric acoustical waves are fundamentally different from electromagnetic spectrum waves as shown in the following explanation.

Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers


You are using the nonsense nonscience doppler effect of light based on your assumptions, not the scientific method.


Sound waves are atmospheric tightly localized particle vibrations passed from particle to particle; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles.


As an example of the doppler effect, when a fast moving train blows it’s whistle while passing a person, then the pitch increases on approach to the person (sound wave compression) and the pitch decreases as the train races toward the horizon (sound wave decompression) as the train leaves the person; however, red-shift conjecturers have no such scientific method proof for the doppler effect of light except for their hypothesis revealing their conclusion joined with their conclusion revealing their hypothesis which puts such scientist sorcerers in an infinite loop of circular reasoning.


The Doppler effect of sound is based on the scientific method.


The Doppler effect of light is science fiction without any scientific method proof.


Your “IMPLIES” is an assumption, that is, your believing without proof.


I’m addressing your post #542 in 3 interrelated posts because of the horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, and your pathetic research skills. If I posted them as one, then you might get overwhelmed. This is the first of the three posts.


Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #532: Literally your whole phrase can be summarised as: “photons cannot lose energy because that would make me big sad"
So, I have two observations to make:
a) Congratulations on saying so little while filling an entire paragraph.
b) Photons can lose energy, there’s literally no reason why they shouldn’t be able to, you draw your conclusions out of thin air - aka you believe what you want to believe and you dress the facts up to make them say what you want.
Basically this entire thread is you complaining about people being mean to you and ppl fabricating/misinterpreting science… you’re projecting so hard you’re effectively two-dimensional


Your “b) Photons can lose energy, there’s literally no reason why they shouldn’t be able to” is precisely that which I have been conveying, yet you ignorantly continued by implying that’s not what I’ve conveyed. Here are details for you to gnarl your teeth, Magoroth.


Newton’s Third Law of Motion (Law of Action and Reaction) amounts to the clause, “for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”. This thread is about physics, Magoroth.


The action of photonic energy (E) displacement inside E=MC2 requires an equal and opposite reaction inside E=MC2, and the reaction is explained in the next paragraph.


Red-shift remains science fiction because a photon contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section of post #361 contains the details.


The horrid state of your observational competence, your abysmal analytical ability, and your pathetic research skills are glaringly visible, again.


Red-shift is a leap of belief, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #489: Redshift is critical to the Big Bang theory because it provides direct observational proof that the universe is expanding.


Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers

You are using the nonsense nonscience doppler effect of light based on your assumptions, not the scientific method. Sound waves are atmospheric tightly localized particle vibrations passed from particle to particle; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles. As an example of the doppler effect, when a fast moving train blows it’s whistle while passing a person, then the pitch increases on approach to the person (sound wave compression) and the pitch decreases as the train races toward the horizon (sound wave decompression) as the train leaves the person; however, red-shift conjecturers have no such scientific method proof for the doppler effect of light except for their hypothesis revealing their conclusion joined with their conclusion revealing their hypothesis which puts such scientist sorcerers in an infinite loop of circular reasoning. The Doppler effect of sound is based on the scientific method. The Doppler effect of light is science fiction without any scientific method proof. For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #540’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift. Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #519: Do you realise the number of scientific theories you have to deny to reach the conclusion that Doppler Red/Blue shift doesn’t exist?


Do realize that you embedded “red-shift is a matter of faith” in your question, yet you doublespeak red-shift is a fact, but your red-shift is not a proven fact, so red-shift is a leap of faith.

@Magoroth wrote in post #519: Do you not believe light behaves as a wave?


Do realize that you embedded “red-shift is a matter of faith” in your question, yet you doublespeak red-shift is a fact, but your red-shift is not a proven fact, so red-shift is a leap of faith.

@Magoroth wrote in post #519: Do you deny the validity of the Michelson-Morley experiment, for instance?


Do realize that you embedded “red-shift is a matter of faith” in your question, yet you doublespeak red-shift is a fact, but your red-shift is not a proven fact, so red-shift is a leap of faith.


Do realize that you responded without a single scientific method based paper’s link to me in your post while I presented the following paragraph’s red-shift destroying paper’s description with link to you in the very post to which you responded!


Astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers discovered a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal).


You dogmatic evolutionists get so very ignorantly confused. Look at the name of this thread, “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. The thread is not titled “show me the Big Bang is a leap of faith” nor “guess whether I believe in your evolutionism scheme or not”. The title of this thread equates to show me the facts, not just haphazardly mentioning a scientist sorcerer or two. And you failed to show me any redshift facts, so you have a redshift leap of faith which leads to a Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #489: Redshift is critical to the Big Bang theory because it provides direct observational proof that the universe is expanding.


Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method


First, I introduce you to an examination of red-shift, which scientist sorcerers base on the so-called doppler effect of light, in the light of the scientific method:

  1. Phase: activity
  2. hypothesis: red spectral light emits from a star in space indicating the star recedes away Earth and the star’s great distance from Earth.
  3. experiment: no test cases.
  4. observation: none of experiments.
  5. conclusion: a star receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion emit red spectral light.
  6. confirmation: no experiments to repeat.


Red-shift adherents abysmally failed to completely apply the scientific method. Red-shift as a distance or direction determinant is not science.


Astronomer astrologers, such as Hubble and Lemaître, engaged in circular reasoning between their hypothesis and conclusion, so their logic is flawed.


This circular reasoning is nonsense nonscience with scientist sorcerers conveying “I correctly science the Big Bang proof because I correctly science Big facts, and you are wrong because I science the Big Bang right”. All the while, those deeply confused people don’t science (know) with the scientific method.


JWST suffers from the same malady as NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck which I outlined in post #421 just a few posts above your post, but you blindly post your belief without proof (assumptions).


For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift.


Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #523: The beginning is either illogical or logical…Though I would suggest that as potential must have been available then everything becomes logical and is likely to conform to a process of behavioural conformity or physical laws…So “BIG BANG” as representative of a moment of inception is valid, relative to material existence, and therefore negates the need for faith leaping …snip… Red shift as a scientifically derived concept makes no difference …snip


As primarily foundational and pivotal to the Big Bang’s “physical laws”, so to speak, red-shift imposes a make or break condition for the Big Bang; in other words, Red shift as a nonsense nonscience derived concept makes an existential difference according to astrophysicists. The astronomer astrologer’s explanation for the expansion of the universe is very dependent on red-shift for the Big Bang adherent’s ultimate truth Hubble-Lemaître Law, v=H0D. H0 is the astronomer astrologer’s exalted Hubble Constant. That variable constant, er, constant variable, er, high priestly astronomer astrologer guesswork number (Hubble Constant) is driven by red-shift, and astronomer astrologers believe the Hubble variable Constant is between 50 kilometers per second per megaparsec and 100 km/sec/Mpc. When H=50, then the universe’s existence is about 20 billion years. When H=100, then the astronomer astrologers arrive at 10 billion years for the universe’s existence.


The age of the universe is between 10 billion years and a factor of 2 larger (essentially double the 10,000,000,000 years at 20,000,000,000 years; in other words, the events in the universe could have been transpiring for as much as 10,000,000,000 years more than the minimum of 10,000,000,000 years believed by your astronomer astrologer conjecturers!


Check this out, SergeantLynch, the error range is 10 billion years, so the error range is as big as the astronomer astrologer’s 10 billion year minimum existence time of the universe.


Consider your opening sentence of “The beginning is either illogical or logical”, and your statement’s implications combined with the v=H0D formula details, above, in evaluating the boolean state of your conclusion ‘So “BIG BANG” as representative of a moment of inception is valid’ which arrives at an illogical conclusion for your “BIG BANG”.


Now, consider your word “valid” in your conclusion of ‘So “BIG BANG” as representative of a moment of inception is valid’ which conveys your position that your “BIG BANG” theory is a fact (“valid”), yet I recall that you wrote “If it was proven it would be an unequivocal fact rather than a theory” about the Big Bang (your post #395). You produced a severe contradiction.

SergeantLynch, you are in Sector Science Battlefield


Consider the name of this thread, “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”. The thread is not titled “throw out unsupported Big Bang Theory statements”. The title of this thread equates to show me the facts, not just haphazardly mentioning your faith masquerading as fact. And you failed to show me any redshift facts, so you have a redshift leap of faith leading to a Big Bang leap of faith.


Since your “BIG BANG” is illogical and not a fact, then your “BIG BANG” is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #531: Hmmm, Photons have zero invariant (rest) mass, meaning they lack the intrinsic mass that characterizes particles like electrons or quarks. Despite being massless, photons possess energy and momentum, governed by the relativistic equation E=pc (where p is momentum and c is the speed of light). This unique state arises because photons are massless gauge bosons that always travel at the speed of light in a vacuum. Because they move at c, they cannot be brought to rest; thus, the concept of “rest mass” does not apply, and their total energy is derived entirely from their motion and frequency.


Red-shift remains science fiction because a photon contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section of post #361 contains the details.


You, the MIT trained nuclear scientist, fail again (proof post #455) and fail again (proof post #465) and fail again (your current post above) to bring your relative “Albert Einstein through the Koch family” ignominious E=MC2 formula into equilibrium resulting in the revealing of red-shift ridiculousness.


Red-shift is a leap of belief, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #515: In 1871, optical redshift was confirmed when the phenomenon was observed in Fraunhofer lines, using solar rotation, about 0.1 Å in the red.[7]


Your astronomer astrologer hero Hermann Carl Vogel of your next section’s “1887” account is attributed with your current section’s “1871” account as well.


In 1920, your great genius god Einstein wrote, “For the Sun, the theoretical redshift predicted is approximately two-millionths of the wavelength" (scraped from here).


Look at that, your great general relativity god Einstein wrote “predicted is” which indicates a red-shift reading yet to be discovered, not an already satisfied reading!


Either your genius Einstein was no genius, or your astronomer astrologer hero Hermann Carl Vogel was no observer of a Sun red-shift phenomenon. Either way, your belief is not red-shift fact because your belief is red-shift faith.


Einstein’s comment(1920) relative to mid-century Vogel(1871) is similar to @FLRW’s comment(2026) relative to mid-century Penzias(1965)/McKellar(1941).


You specifically left out your source document link which exposes your mental deficiency, so I assign Redshift (on Wikipedia) as your source document. The source citation 7 hyperlink (“The fall and rise of the Doppler effect”) for your “1871” account is your leap of faith. Your star bible lacks cohesion.


You present no scientific method in your “1871” account. Your research skills are pathetic.


I found your “wiki page” to be self-sustaining self-deceptive science with your very first of three red-shift supports.

@Magoroth wrote in post #515: In 1887, Hermann Carl Vogel and Julius Scheiner discovered the “annual Doppler effect”, the yearly change in the Doppler shift of stars located near the ecliptic, due to the orbital velocity of the Earth.[8]


Your source citation 8 hyperlink (“A History of Astronomy”) in your “literally from the wiki page” contains this:

An essential improvement was made when, in 1887, Vogel and Scheiner at the Potsdam Observatory constructed a spectrograph with proper provi¬ sions against a flexure and changes of temperature. Now the results had such greater accuracy that the orbital velocity of the earth was clearly shown by a periodic change in the measured radial velocity of the stars. Thus the validity of Doppler’s principle — previously doubted by some physicists — was demonstrated, as well as the yearly motion of the earth, for whomever might need it.


Your source failed to provide data even with two levels of indirection. You claim “I am right about red-shift because I am right about red-shift, and you are wrong about red-shift” through your data deficient source with your failed attempt at fact of “the validity of Doppler’s principle — previously doubted by some physicists — was demonstrated, as well as the yearly motion of the earth, for whomever might need it”. Just look at your high priest Stephen Hawking’s own star bible contribution of condemnation “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”. You present no scientific method in your “1887” account. Your research skills are pathetic.

@Magoroth wrote in post #515: In 1901, Aristarkh Belopolsky verified optical redshift in the laboratory using a system of rotating mirrors.[9][7]


Belopolsky constructed “a device with a narrow-linewidth light source and rapidly rotating mirrors” per your source citation 7 hyperlink (“The fall and rise of the Doppler effect”) which can be extended with “between two oppositely rotating ‘water wheels’ whose blades were strips of plane mirrors, he succeeded in obtaining a speed of the image’s motion on the order of 1 km./sec” (source “Belopolsky, Aristarkh Apollonovich” on encyclopedia.com) which scientist sorcerers erroneously believe is proof of the Doppler effect for light.


Your source citation 9 hyperlink (“On an Apparatus for the Laboratory Demonstration of the Doppler-Fizeau Principle”) links to a page with the title without data and without a paper to evaluate Belopolsky’s work.


According to your champion, MIT educated nuclear scientist @FLRW as recorded in post #421, Belopolsky’s inferior pre-mid-century technology lacked the precision instrumentation to adequately simulate the required characteristics to validate a so-called doppler effect of light.


If Belopolsky used any “Apparatus for the Laboratory Demonstration of the Doppler-Fizeau Principle” at all, then he did not measure the Doppler effect of light - not blue-shift - not red-shift because of the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” as described in detail inside post #511 just a few posts above your current post that your post neglected which indicates the horrid state of your observational ability and your pathetic research skills.

@Magoroth wrote in post #515: This is literally from the wiki page. This has been observed experimentally and empirically for over 100 years. Wtf are you even debating?


I am debating you whose first debate argument was your deceptive “1871” accouunt, whose second debate argument was your data deficient “1887” explanation of faith masquerading as fact, and whose third debate argument was your unsubstantiated, science fiction 1901 Belopolsky discipline of delusion (Jeremiah 10:8).


As shown above, your red-shift is faith, not fact, and it’s a sloppy faith at that, so I rationally call your red-shift your leap of faith. Since red-shift is the evolutionist’s foundation for the Big Bang, then the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #503: Redshift produces longer wavelengths (lower frequency)than the original light or electromagnetic radiation emitted by the source. The three main types of redshift (Doppler, gravitational and cosmological).


Red-shift remains science fiction because a photon contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section of post #361 contains the details.


Red-shift is a leap of belief, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #501: From your earlier post #500, the redshift is mentioned several times in Einstein’s Relativity theory.


E=MC2 is still an unbalanced equation when you inject red-shift as shown in the “FLRW and Debby provided ‘corrupt science’ confirmation of formula calculation error production proof of concept ala the William and Valdemar example” (details recorded in post #485).


Red-shift is a leap of belief, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #462: “Red-shift as a distance calculator and/or age determinant is falsified.” Hmmmm, This claim is incorrect according to established scientific consensus. Redshift is widely accepted as a primary method for determining cosmic distances and lookback times (the age of the universe …snip
@Debby wrote in post #442: Cosmological redshift remains the cornerstone and best supported scientific explanation for the behaviour of light from distant galaxies.


Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model fall apart under the logical consistency principle


Mr. MIT science degree holder, you continue to neglect to post scientific method based fact as your argument against the “Coup de Grâce: Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model” as enumerated in post 258. Debby, you demonstrated your inability to comprehend posts like this, but I included you because this relates to red-shift.


I quoted detailed scientific data from Rowland’s article in post #61 which culminated with Rowland writing about Eddington, Dyson, and Commelin’s sloppy work in application of Einstein’s Relativity to the 1919 solar eclipse “The readings themselves were also questionable because of (a) errors in parallax from varying angles of measurement and atmospheric conditions at the respective points of observation, and (b) equipment failure. Results were inconclusive because the error factor was as large as the deviation the experimenters were trying to prove [3]”.


Notice the closing [3] reference in that quote which is the “What Einstein did Not Consider about Gravity” in which Rowland detailed:

In 1908, attempting to better explain his former student’s theory of special relativity (E=mc2), mathematics professor Hermann Minkowski expressed it in terms of a mathematical model that fused time and the three dimensions of space into a single four-dimensional continuum (later known as Minkowski spacetime). Notice two things about this model: image Figure 1: Hypothetical Minkowski 4-D Spacetime
  1. It is not possible to assign co-ordinates to the hypothetical time axis; and
  2. Because E = mc2 does not include any time variable, there is nowhere said equation fits into this four-dimensional model.
Source of Figure 1: Wikipedia [9].


That’s just a small portion of the logic and rational reasoning in Rowland’s article exposing Einstein and Minkowski’s leap of faith about Einstein’s Relativity theories.


Essentially, Einstein’s General Relativity, Einstein’s Special Relativity, Minkowski spacetime, and related gravitational lensing are fictional fantasy faith, not fact, just faith.


Therefore, your E=MC2 is a leap of faith as support for the Big Bang.


Gravitational red-shift depends on Einstein’s Relativity theories. Since Einstein’s Relativity theories are demonstrated to be a leap of faith, then gravitational red-shift is a leap of faith!


Your “Redshift is widely” believed “as a primary method for determining cosmic distances and lookback times (the age of the universe” is a leap of belief!


Lord Jesus says “the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and there are many who enter through it” (Matthew 7:13), and the Big Bang way is wide!


For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #514’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith.


Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #492: Without the Big Bang all we are left with is a leap of faith in the creation story in the Bible.


Your Big Bang is a leap of faith, and you convey that you believe the Bible is nothing without the Big Bang.


You present zero scientific method fact about the Big Bang, so your Big Bang belief is your faith foundation. Lord Jesus Christ says “Everyone who hears these words of Mine and does not act on them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and it fell—and great was its fall.” (Matthew 7:26-27).


For us Christians, Christ is our glorious foundation. Lord Jesus Christ says “everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and yet it did not fall, for it had been founded on the rock.” (Matthew 7:24-25).


If you are a Christian, then you believe that all occurrences of six days in the fourth Commandment exclusively refer to 24 hour per day literal six days. Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God commands:

Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a sabbath of the LORD your God; in it you shall not do any work, you or your son or your daughter, your male or your female servant or your cattle or your sojourner who stays with you. For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day and made it holy.

(Exodus 20:8-11)


If you are a Christian, then you believe that Adam and Eve were there at the beginning of creation when the six days of making all the stars and planets and Earth culminated with God creating man (Genesis 1:1-31). Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God declares:

He who created them from the beginning “made them male and female”

(Matthew 19:4).


Your writing, there, is concurrent with unbelievers, that is, you reject the Word of God.


Georges Lemaître, a Belgian priest, is essentially credited as a father of the Big Bang baby. Roman Catholic Church (RCC) priests are called father by RCC church members and even some non-church members. Lord Jesus Christ says “Do not call anyone on earth your father; for One is your Father, He who is in heaven.” (Matthew 23:9), so the Roman Catholic Church rejected Christ’s Commandment; therefore, Lemaître was not a Christian by that account. Lemaître’s sins includes leading fools into believing things like “According to our best science, six days is 14 billion years”. (see post #20 and post #87 for more details).


Lemaître was an unbeliever.


The Apostle Peter warned us Christians about people like Lemaître by writing:

false prophets also arose among the people, as false teachers will also be among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, denying even the Master who bought them, bringing on themselves swift destruction. (2 Peter 2:1)

Many will follow their immoral ways, and as a result, the way of the truth will be maligned. (2 Peter 2:2)

this is hidden from them willingly, that the heavens were long ago, and the earth, out of water and through water having been composed by the Word of God, (2 Peter 3:5)

You therefore, beloved, knowing these things beforehand, beware, lest being carried away with the error of the wicked, you fall from your own steadfastness. (2 Peter 2:1)

The Word of God created the heavens and the earth.

Big Bang Philosophy holds that an evolution god created the heavens and the earth.

Every Big Bang believer is against Christ.

I remind you of your writing “Scientists are still sorting out the inconsistencies in the BigBang theory. Use the Bible to fill in the gaps.” recorded in post #159, so you represented yourself as a Big Bang believer.


You, Debby, willingly yoke yourself with Lemaître.


You, Debby, align yourself with people like SergeantLynch who wickedly compose blasphemous writings against God as recorded in his post 490 (to you before your post) and his post 495 (to you after your post).


You leave out facts, but you desperately try to sound like you speak with fact with your “The BigBang theory is not an act of faith because it is backed by science” which is truly your leap of faith!


You failed to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”, again.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #506: Light that reaches us from planets or whatever the fuck (do you believe planets exist?) IS REDSHIFTED when the planet orbits AWAY from us, and BLUE SHIFTED when it moves TOWARDS us. You can see this at play with planets in our solar system since their size, orbital velocity and current positions relative to the Sun are all fully known. It takes the brain the size of a pea to calculate redshift from that. Why the fuck are you denyint shit that is TRIVIAL to prove? whats next, the Earth is flat?

Hey foul mouth Magoroth, show me a single publicly accessible scientific method paper including data as support for your “IS REDSHIFTED when the planet orbits AWAY from us, and BLUE SHIFTED when it moves TOWARDS us. You can see this at play with planets in our solar system”.


Here is astronomical observations that red shift sinks into the abyss.


Astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers discovered a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal).


Red-shift as a distance calculator and/or age determinant is falsified, and the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #505: You’re straight up retarded if you think redshift/blueshift are a theory, THESE ARE NOT DEBATABLE FACTS.


You quoted mathematical proof that red-shift is not fact:

Your brainless MIT AI IQ cannot deal with the mathematical fact that your energy (E) decrease (“decrease in frequency”) contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving your family guy Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The details follow.

Look for energy (E) in your “c=frequency × wavelength” physics formula (see post #455). Energy (E) is absent from your equation, so the physics principle “A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts) requires your red-shift energy (E) displacement must go somewhere, and THAT SOMEWHERE IS UNAVOIDABLY THE SPEED OF LIGHT (C) IN E=MC2!

Equilibrium (=) is fundamental mathematics, so you are either a very low IQ individual or you are a confused person or you are a scientist sorcerer.

You still have the speed of light (C) bursting faster than 186,000 miles per second as a direct result of red-shift with E=MC2!

The Big Bang’s red-shift cosmicdistance ladder base rung is science fiction, so the Big Bang in a leap of faith.


Then you in your mental deficiency wrote “THESE ARE NOT DEBATABLE FACTS”.


Here, I’ll repair your sentence for you. AS PER THE ABOVE ABOUT E=MC2 AND RED-SHIFT AND DISEQUILIBRIUM, THESE ARE NOT DEBATABLE FACTS WHICH DEMONSTRATE THAT RED-SHIFT IS A BELIEF, SO THE BIG BANG IS A LEAP OF FAITH.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #462: “Red-shift as a distance calculator and/or age determinant is falsified.” Hmmmm, This claim is incorrect according to established scientific consensus. Redshift is widely accepted as a primary method for determining cosmic distances and lookback times (the age of the universe …snip
@Magoroth wrote in post #504: Wtf is there even to debate about. Red shift can be observed experimentally???
@Debby wrote in post #442: Cosmological redshift remains the cornerstone and best supported scientific explanation for the behaviour of light from distant galaxies.


Red-shift is devoid of the Scientific Method


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so you are left with a red-shift leap of faith.


Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light does not exist; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.


This post supplements my post #275.


A Big Bang cosmic distance ladder’s foundational rungs are a leap of faith.


For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #511’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift.


Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #497: Do you think that the entire concept of light losing energy/having its frequency reduced when travelling away from us is bullshit, or do you simply think it can not be used to measure distances

Did you finish the reading assignment, shown below from my (post #218)? The assignment you requested addressed your new inquiry without being reduced to your vulgar belligerence which is unbecoming to scientific debate (hint, I’m preparing you for my responses to your next posts).

@Magoroth wrote in post #200: Wtf does relativity have to do with anything?


You requested schooling about the Big Bang’s relationship with Einstein’s relativity theories, so I’m assigning for you to read the content of the following list of posts in order to comprehend the subject matter as well as the current state of this thread, provided your mind can handle it:

  1. post #61
  2. post #87
  3. post #93
  4. post #199
@Magoroth wrote in post #200: If relativity is just fictional fantasy why is it that it explains the motion of planets better than Newton’s theory of gravity?


See the above list for content which emblazons the error embedded in your question.

@Magoroth wrote in post #200: Also energy-matter equivalence is not a myth you can literally turn energy into matter or vice versa.


I don’t find the word “myth” in the post to which you quoted, but I’m not skipping this.


As you can see in post #149, the MIT scholar scientist, @FLRW, wrote “At time=0 the Universe was at zero size” based upon his presentation of the Friedmann equations; therefore, your formula E=MC2 (energy-matter equivalence) existed not according to your nonscience scientist buddies.


Regardless of which formula that you employ, you end up with an irrationally illogical universe beginning. Your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #462: “Red-shift as a distance calculator and/or age determinant is falsified.” Hmmmm, This claim is incorrect according to established scientific consensus. Redshift is widely accepted as a primary method for determining cosmic distances and lookback times (the age of the universe …snip
@Debby wrote in post #442: Cosmological redshift remains the cornerstone and best supported scientific explanation for the behaviour of light from distant galaxies.


Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift

Red-shift requires that the maximum speed of light shoots above 186,000 miles per second.


“A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


Einstein’s formula E=MC2 has high relation to red-shift. Red-shift’s high energy, high frequency light deteriorates into low energy, low frequency light at the time of emission, and astronomer astrologers believe this reveals age, distance, and/or direction of celestial objects. Einstein’s formula E=MC2 is in permanent equilibrium between energy (E) and mass (M) and speed_of_light (C). Since E=MC2 needs to be maintain equilibrium with the red-shift massless (M) photon, then the commutative property of mathematics keeps the equation’s balance by moving energy (E) to the speed_of_light (C). In essence, E=MC2 forces an increase to the speed of light under the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. redshift.


I obtained the following from 4.5: The Doppler Effect at LibreTexts with respect to red-shift:

The relationship between the degree of shift in wavelength to the speed of the object is found by:
Apparent wavelength/true frequency = true wavelength/apparent frequency = 1 + recession velocity/wave speed.
Since the speed of light in a vacuum, c, is a constant, the speed of the object can be found with the following equation:
Δλ/λ = v/c
Where Δλ is the change in wavelength, λ is the normal or laboratory wavelength of the light, and v is the relative speed of the source toward or away from the observer.


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error.


You need to mess with adjusting the C (constant representing the speed of light at 186,000 miles per second) in Einstein’s E=MC2, but you are left with a MESS in so doing because light pushes beyond 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years which translates to light moving faster, much faster than your C of 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years (a.k.a. velocity well beyond 186,000 miles per second), so light speedily traverses the 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 mile distance in some unknown amount of the time, for example, maybe 2 days. I remind you in my post #199 to you regarding Einstein’s Special Relativity Theory where I detailed that Rowland explained a time element is absent from E=MC2.


Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light exists not; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.


This post supplements my post #275.


A Big Bang cosmic distance ladder’s foundational rungs are a leap of faith.


For more “red-shift is merely red-spectral” proofs, see post #376. This current post builds upon post #498’s demonstrated scientific fact that red-shift is your leap of faith. I plan to reply to your post, again, with more scientific fact showing the ridiculousness of red-shift.


Lack of Scientific Method process leaves your Big Bang evidence in a state of science fiction, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #488: AI says,


I note that you continue to rely on your failure-prone MIT AI IQ. See post #421 for your CMBR MIT AI IQ failure earlier incident.

@FLRW wrote in post #488: Red-shift is not merely red-spectral; it describes any increase in the wavelength (or decrease in frequency) of electromagnetic radiation, regardless of whether the light is visible to the human eye.

Oh, how quickly your brain dead MIT AI IQ got confounded that I conveyed that the electromagnetic spectrum maintains uniformity in the face of red-shift infrared<–red<–orange<–yellow<–green<–blue<–indigo<–violet<–ultraviolet in post #391.


Your brainless MIT AI IQ cannot deal with the mathematical fact that your energy (E) decrease (“decrease in frequency”) contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving your family guy Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The details follow.


Look for energy (E) in your “c=frequency × wavelength” physics formula (see post #455). Energy (E) is absent from your equation, so the physics principle “A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts) requires your red-shift energy (E) displacement must go somewhere, and THAT SOMEWHERE IS UNAVOIDABLY THE SPEED OF LIGHT (C) IN E=MC2!


Equilibrium (=) is fundamental mathematics, so you are either a very low IQ individual or you are a confused person or you are a scientist sorcerer.


You still have the speed of light (C) bursting faster than 186,000 miles per second as a direct result of red-shift with E=MC2!


The Big Bang’s red-shift cosmicdistance ladder base rung is science fiction, so the Big Bang in a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #482: By calculating exactly how much kinetic energy was displaced by the Doppler shifted light, Einstein proved that the change in mass is precisely equal to the emitted energy divided by the speed of light squared. Thus the Doppler shifted of light acts as a frame dependent scale that reveals that mass is nothing more than highly concentrated energy.

A photon contains no mass (M) for E=MC2 per your physics, so you don’t displace energy (E) inside E=MC2, instead, you delusionally delete energy (E) from E=MC2 thus leaving Einstein’s Theory in a state of disequilibrium. The details follow.

Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift


“A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


Einstein’s formula E=MC2 has high relation to red-shift. Red-shift’s high energy, high frequency light deteriorates into low energy, low frequency light at the time of emission, and astronomer astrologers believe this reveals age, distance, and/or direction of celestial objects. Einstein’s formula E=MC2 is in permanent equilibrium between energy (E) and mass (M) and speed_of_light (C). Since E=MC2 needs to be maintain equilibrium with the red-shift massless (M) photon, then the commutative property of mathematics keeps the equation’s balance by moving energy (E) to the speed_of_light (C). In essence, E=MC2 forces an increase to the speed of light under the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. redshift.


I obtained the following from 4.5: The Doppler Effect at LibreTexts with respect to red-shift:

The relationship between the degree of shift in wavelength to the speed of the object is found by:
Apparent wavelength/true frequency = true wavelength/apparent frequency = 1 + recession velocity/wave speed.
Since the speed of light in a vacuum, c, is a constant, the speed of the object can be found with the following equation:
Δλ/λ = v/c
Where Δλ is the change in wavelength, λ is the normal or laboratory wavelength of the light, and v is the relative speed of the source toward or away from the observer.


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error.


You need to mess with adjusting the C (constant representing the speed of light at 186,000 miles per second) in Einstein’s E=MC2, but you are left with a MESS in so doing because light pushes beyond 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years which translates to light moving faster, much faster than your C of 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years (a.k.a. velocity well beyond 186,000 miles per second), so light speedily traverses the 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 mile distance in some unknown amount of the time, for example, maybe 2 days. I remind you in my post #199 to FLRW regarding Einstein’s Special Relativity Theory where I detailed that Rowland explained a time element is absent from E=MC2.


Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light exists not; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.


Self described scientist Debby repeats red-shift leap of faith responses lacking scientific method based evidence (aka ground for belief (post #25))


Astronomer astrologers conjured the Doppler effect for light as a successor to the Doppler effect for sound:

  1. The Doppler effect for sound adheres to the scientific method.
  2. The Doppler effect for light adheres not to the scientific method.


As shown in my post #271 the environment for sound in Earth’s atmosphere strikingly differs from the environment for light in space.


Your nonsense nonscience statement resides in your science fiction with @FLRW as shown in post #485 because the waves are fundamentally different waves. Sound waves vibrate a molecule maintaining localized proximity yet transferring energy to the next molecule which repeats the cycle through the Earth’s atmosphere; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles; therefore, the Doppler effect applies to sound, but the Doppler effect applies not to light (see also post #53).


This post supplements my post #275.


A Big Bang cosmic distance ladder’s foundational rung is a leap of faith.