Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #424: You are debating members not the scientists who created the Big Bang Theory The Big Bang theory is a scientific theory and does not need a leap of faith to accept because it is backed by evidence.


The concept of the word “theory” is “faith” as per the quoted dictionary definition recorded in post #20 and repeated here, again, for convenience:

  1. A set of statements or principles devised to explain a group of facts or phenomena, especially one that has been repeatedly tested or is widely accepted and can be used to make predictions about natural phenomena.
  2. The branch of a science or art consisting of its explanatory statements, accepted principles, and methods of analysis, as opposed to practice: a fine musician who had never studied theory.
  3. A set of theorems that constitute a systematic view of a branch of mathematics.
  4. Abstract reasoning; speculation: a decision based on experience rather than theory.
  5. A belief or principle that guides action or assists comprehension or judgment: staked out the house on the theory that criminals usually return to the scene of the crime.
  6. An assumption based on limited information or knowledge; a conjecture.
American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Obtained from thefreedictionary.com/theory


In definition 1, “accepted” is a synonym for “believed”, so “theory” arrives at “widely believed” which is faith, not fact.


The word “science” (link to thefreedictionary.com/science) fundamentally conveys the concept of knowledge.


A person’s knowledge (science) equates to fact or faith.


The word “fact” (link to thefreedictionary.com/fact) represents absolute existence of a person, place, thing, or event.


Faith is proof of things not seen; in other words, that which one says/thinks, but not sees, is what one believes (faith=belief).


The phrase “Big Bang Theory” and the phrase “Big Bang Belief” are equivalents.


My next post to you demonstrates that you have very bad evidence resulting in you not having Big Bang scientific fact but you having Big Bang science fiction.


Kermos
Debby wrote in post #422: You are debating members not the scientists who created the Big Bang Theory.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You Big Bang believers are all united against Christ. You believe your astronomer astrologer Roman Catholic Church priest Georges Lemaître’s preaching the Big Bang as detailed in post #313, but red-shift is merely red-spectral, yet you, self-described Scientist, believe Lemaître’s nonsense nonscience instead of you believing Jesus Christ as detailed in post #214 which means you are not a Christian. You, as a person, who in your heart publicly nullifies the Word of God, you disqualify yourself from being a person with the Wisdom of God (1 Corinthians 1:24).


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Double_R wrote in post #417: Replying to everyone else while skipping over my posts, what a coward. Here’s my simple question yet again; Are all jury verdicts derived on faith? Yes or No?


So says you who continues to hide from the spot where I left off with you when you failed to rationally explain how you arrived at your irrationally convoluted post #89 explanation as I inquired of you in my post #136, so I disregarded your followup post 140. If you want to engage further, then explain yourself, first. I explained this to you last Thursday, and I can continue acting like your posts to me are like the Big Bang, that is, nonexistent! Unless you can muster the courage to respond to my opening inquiry inside of post #136.


My 3 ball example in post #35 demonstrated one does not know (science) as a matter of fact where the ball came from which rolled over the grandpa’s foot, but one may conject (theorize) about the ball, and that “theorize” is faith.


The Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Kermos

Here is the aforementioned reminder for you of my post which you failed to respond.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: Red-shift is not merely red-spectral;


Red-shift is merely red-spectral. Your words that you use, as shown below, solidify the scientific fact that red-shift is merely red-spectral!


I pointed out to you back in post #361 that no scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus astronomer astrologers red-shift unscientific confirmation of error.


Mr. Nuclear Scientist, you seem unable to address the points I present to you. Your position is so weak that you repeat yourself, but I systematically dissect your arguments, and I methodologically dismantle your scientific fact statements into their proper state as your sacred faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: it is a shift toward longer wavelengths and lower frequencies across the entire electromagnetic spectrum, not just visible red light.


You supplied absolutely, positively no scientific method based fact as support for your nonscience “shift toward longer wavelengths and lower frequencies across the entire electromagnetic spectrum” as documented in post #376 (but you couldn’t have known about post #376 yet, but you should have known about it’s predecessor post #53).


Furthermore, you ramble on while neglecting that the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” of my post #361 addressed to you, above, forces light to greatly surpass your 186,000 miles per second speed limit of light. Your red-shift breaks E=MC2 (and vice versa).

@FLRW wrote in post #368: 1. Terminology: The term “red” indicates the direction of the shift (toward the red end of the visible spectrum), but the effect applies to radio waves, infrared, ultraviolet, X-rays, and gamma rays.


The Electromagnetic Spectrum Maintains Uniformity


Under the uniformity of the Universe doctrine of your star bible such as the RW Metric (see post #325), if a distant stellar light source component particle emissions all shift toward the “red” end of the spectrum, then a replacement particle emission from the red range-ish replaces the infrared range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the orange range-ish replaces the red range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the yellow range-ish replaces the orange range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the green range-ish replaces the yellow range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the blue range-ish replaces the green range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the indigo range-ish replaces the blue range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the violet range-ish replaces the indigo range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the ultraviolet range-ish replaces the violet range-ish, etc. This describes a cascade effect that keeps the electromagnetic spectrum uniform with particle emissions occupying all the original wavelengths; therefore, astronomer astrologers red-shift Earth reference element base assumption (belief without proof (see post #53)) mismatches with the actual element at the stellar object (see the Las Cumbres Observatory Redshift document at this link), or the astronomers astrologers misinterpret the data at hand in some other manner. Astronomer astrologers interpret the light according to their star bible which is a case of astronomer astrologers high priest Stephen Hawking’s own star bible contribution of condemnation “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: 2. Physical Meaning: Red-shift signifies that the wavelength of light has been stretched (increased) due to the source moving away from the observer or the expansion of space.


Yet, you supply no scientific method based fact as support for your fantasy red-shift, so your red-shift assumption (belief without proof) is a leap of faith.


As pointed out to you, Mr. Scientist, in the “Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers” section of post #376, there is no such thing as you describe.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: 3. Observation: Astronomers detect this by measuring the displacement of known spectral lines (fingerprints of elements like hydrogen) toward longer wavelengths, regardless of whether the resulting light is visible to the human eye.


Speaking of “Observation”, astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper which explained their discovery of a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two stellar objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source is The Astrophysical Journal, issue 1, volume 620). Red-shift as a distance calculator is falsified.


Your “Astronomers detect this by measuring the displacement of known spectral lines (fingerprints of elements like hydrogen) toward longer wavelengths, regardless of whether the resulting light is visible to the human eye” statement directly contradicts that astrophysicist’s determination. You have faith that the universe is expanding based on red-shift, yet your faith opposes astrophysicist Burbidge’s faith.


Since you fight against your own, FLRW, then you are in a state of faith for the Big Bang.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #416: OMG, you graduated from Trump University, didn’t you?


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


What’s the matter, pudding, did Trump University decline your application and now you’re angry and bitter?


Not only are your Big Bang “predictions” a leap of faith, your MIT scientific “prediction” about my education is false. You are a false prophet!


I’m reminding you of my post which you failed to respond in my next post in this thread.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #412: The premise that the temperature of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation increased between 1941 and 1965 is based on a historical misunderstanding of early experimental measurements, rather than an actual physical increase in the temperature of the universe.


Upon my thorough inspection, your post appears to be more than 95% composed by AI (artificial intelligence). If the evidence I collected from your post accurately demonstrates your AI utilization, then your MIT augmented intelligence (AI) failed you miserably. Do not forget, you opened your post with “This is why SomRek’s IQ is approximately 45-47”, and I’m about to show your inferior intelligence quotient (IQ) even with the addition of your augmented intelligence (AI).

@FLRW wrote in post #412: The universe did not warm up; rather, scientists were using two entirely different methods that yielded slightly different numbers for the exact same static background.


You admit:

  1. they measured the same thing.
  2. they measured at two different times.
  3. their measurements differed.

These points aggregate into a Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation increasing temperature from 1941 to 1965 resulting in a logical inconsistency for the Big Bang Theory requirement for decreasing temperature (see post #376 for mathematical analysis demonstrating this fact).

@FLRW wrote in post #412: Because of this, there is no logical inconsistency with the Big Bang Theory’s requirement for a cooling universe. The difference in values is explained by how these two historic data points were collected:


Your MIT AI failed you, and in just your first few paragraphs, but your MIT AI folly runs even deeper, so I illuminate your logical inconsistency even further!

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 1. The 1941 Measurement (2.3 Kelvin) In 1941, Canadian astronomer Andrew McKellar analyzed the light absorbed by cyanogen (CN) molecules in interstellar clouds. He noted that these molecules were being excited by a background source, calculating a “rotational temperature” of space to be roughly 2.3 K. Crucially, because the Big Bang model was still in its infancy, McKellar did not know he was looking at a relic of the early universe; he simply documented the local temperature of interstellar space. Why this is not a contradiction


You omit, obfuscate, and try to deceive by using a statistical aggregation of McKellar’s median 2.3 K reading instead of his full measurements of 2.5 +0.9/-0.7 K or stated another way, McKellar (1941): M = {x ∈ R | 1.8 ≤ x ≤ 3.4} (see post #376 for details).


You wrote “he simply documented the local temperature of interstellar space”, so he measured and documented your CMBR, yet you proceed to claim it’s not a contradiction, yet McKellar’s measurements differ from Penzias and Wilson (1965): P = {x ∈ R | 2.5 ≤ x ≤ 4.5} or stated another way 3.5 +/- 1.0 K (see post #376 for details); therefore, the two researchers, McKellar and Penzias, measured the same thing, CMBR, and they arrived at substantively different ranges leading to a logical inconsistency with the Big Bang Theory’s requirement for a cooling universe.

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 1. Observational Margins of Error: Early mid-century astrophysics lacked the precise satellite instrumentation we have today. A fluctuation between 2.3 K and 3.5 K represents the technical margins of error inherent to ground-based radio telescopes and chemical spectrum analysis at the time.


I will summarize your argument as “Two scientists measured a right angle. Scientist Alpha used a protractor while Scientist Beta used the Pythagorean Theorem with a ruler. Both scientists determine a 90° angle on the same angle, years apart, decades ago. Logically, because we have better measurement tools now, Scientist Alpha’s measurement is inferior, even Scientist Beta’s measurements are inferior, so they must be excluded because I say they must be excluded”.


Your own mid-century imprecise satellite instrumentation argument in your current post busts your own prior Big Bang belief support arguments about VLBI (recorded in my response post #93) and about Einstein’s General Relativity with the 1919 solar eclipse (recorded in my response post #199 (see also post #61)).


You illogically fantasize that “2.3 K and 3.5 K”, 1941 and 1965 respectively, are the same thing, but those represent two separate statistical aggregation totals in two different decades with a result of an increasing temperature leading to a logical inconsistency with the Big Bang Theory’s requirement for a cooling universe.


Typical of you sorcerer scientists, you Illegitimately eliminate valuable data points, the 1941 data set and/or the 1965 data set, in order to conquer in a debate, but your deception is exposed. You, Mr. MIT AI IQ Scientist, are doing what your astrophysicist high priest Stephen Hawking wrote about in your star bible contribution of condemnation “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”.

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 2. Modern Verification: Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck Observatory have measured the CMB’s true current temperature down to a definitive 2.725 K.

Your MIT AI IQ lacks the knowledge that Modern precision satellites like NASA’s COBE and ESA’s Planck are built on data from prior years and decades of data collection which means that your Modern precision satellites were calibrated with flawed data by way of your imprecise satellite instrumentation, as per your own admission in your “1. Observational Margins of Error” section above, resulting in your faith based, nay flawed fantasy, conclusion about a “definitive 2.725 K”.


Your “definitive 2.725 K” is a fraudulent statistical aggregation, not an actual universally uniform data acquisition of “definitive 2.725 K” temperature readings from all directions, and you scientist astronomer astrologers are known for throwing out data that disproves your preconceived notions with said elimination indicators recorded inside of your star bible’s studies. Your astronomer astrologers work their magical, mystical mathematical manipulations (statistical sorcery (making numbers disappear)) in order to arrive at their preconceived notions about CMBR, and their statistical sorcery is excruciatingly easy to locate because of phraseology, such as “outliers” and “compensating for”.

@FLRW wrote in post #412: 3. Proof of Cooling: Astronomers can test the Big Bang’s cooling requirement by looking at the CMB spectrum in the ultra-distant universe (looking back in time). When measuring the CMB temperature in galaxies billions of light-years away, the temperature increases linearly with redshift ((z)) exactly as predicted—meaning the universe was much hotter in the past and has been steadily cooling ever since.


Your red-shift cosmic distance ladder is broken because the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section in post #361 demonstrated that red-shift requires E to decrease while increasing C in E=MC2 resulting in light’s speed limit soaring beyond 186,000 miles per second, so your “galaxies billions of light-years away” are much, much closer than than “galaxies billions of light-years away”!


Considering your final sentence “When measuring the CMB temperature in galaxies billions of light-years away, the temperature increases linearly with redshift ((z)) exactly as predicted—meaning the universe was much hotter in the past and has been steadily cooling ever since” which it doesn’t because astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper which explained their discovery of a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two stellar objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source is The Astrophysical Journal, issue 1, volume 620). Under this circumstance, your “galaxies billions of light-years away” is a leap of faith.


Your “Proof of Cooling” just went “poof”.


As I detailed in post #411, your Big Bang Theory is logically inconsistent, falsified, untestable, unparsimonious, and a leap of faith!


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #415: What college degrees do you have?


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #412: This is why SomRek’s IQ is approximately 45-47.


Mr. Scientist, your statement, there, is you performing the Pharmakeia Principle (see post #71).


I plan to respond to your post in detail, but I remind you of more which you failed to refute again.


I pointed out to you back in post #361 that no scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus astronomer astrologers red-shift unscientific confirmation of error.


Red-shift is merely red-spectral, and your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
Debby wrote in post #408: @Kermos But the universe is very visible and the Big Bang theory has established its finding as a scientific fact with overwhelming evidence. It will take a leap of faith to ignore it.
Debby wrote in post #410: @Kermos Like John 1:1-5 in the beginning was the Big Bang, there was nothing before the Big Bang. All things came into existence after the Big Bang.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #407: A scientific theory requires logical consistency, empirical testing, and falsifiability to reliably explain natural phenomena.


The Big Bang Theory violates your first statement in your set of parameters because your Big Bang natural phenomena was never empirically recorded by a logically thinking human.

@FLRW wrote in post #407: As the saying goes, “science without logic is blind”. Logic provides the structural framework that connects observations, hypotheses, and evidence into a unified explanation.


Post #376 illuminated your Big Bang broken hypothesis, bad evidence, and absence of observation. Your Big Bang Theory “science without logic is blind”.

@FLRW wrote in post #407: Core Logical Rules for Scientific Theories


Your position is so weak that you neglected to respond with scientific method evidentiary based fact for your Big Bang belief, but I systematically dissect your arguments, and I methodologically dismantle your scientific fact statements into their proper state as your sacred faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #407: 1. Logical Consistency: A valid theory cannot contain internal contradictions. Every part of the explanation must fit neatly with the rest without canceling itself out.


Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation increasing temperature from 1941 to 1965 indicates a logical inconsistency for the Big Bang Theory requirement for decreasing temperature (see post #376 for mathematical analysis demonstrating this fact).

@FLRW wrote in post #407: 2. Falsifiability: Introduced heavily in the philosophy of science by Karl Popper, a good theory must state what evidence could prove it wrong. If no test can ever disprove an idea, it is not scientific.


As I wrote in the original post, your Big Bang is a philosophy, and it’s a field populated by philosophers, not scientists who adhere to the parameters of your post!

@FLRW wrote in post #407: 3. Testable Predictions: Theories must do more than just describe past events. They must use logical deduction to forecast new outcomes that experiments can verify.


I’m quoting your colleague, here, about you employing the words “Predictions” and “forecast” in respect to purportedly “past events”:

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #384: Yes “scientists” have a habit of trying to hijack the dictionary.


Mr. MIT Graduate, your parameter is absurdly illogical and linguistical lunacy, that you predict a past event! The definition of predict is to foretell a future event as shown in the dictionary definition of predict contained in post #82. You Big Bang philosophers come across as very desperate to sound like sorcerers predicting things.

@FLRW wrote in post #407: 4. Simplicity (Parsimony): Guided by principles like Occam’s razor, the best theories use the simplest unifying ideas without adding unnecessary assumptions.


Assumptions run rampant in the Big Bang Theory. An assumption is believing without proof as shown in the dictionary definition of assumption contained in post #53; therefore, the Big Bang Theory violates your closing statement in your set of parameters because your Big Bang isn’t simple.


The Big Bang Theory is illogical, falsified, untestable, unparsimonious, and a leap of faith.


Kermos
@JenKiggans2026 wrote in post #398: Simple answer to the thread title. It’s not possible.


Amen! Truly!

@JenKiggans2026 wrote in post #398: The substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. Obviously nobody alive witnessed the so-called big bang. There’s no infallible authority behind it,


Know this first of all, that in the last days mockers will come with their mocking, following after their own lusts, and saying, “Where is the promise of His coming? For ever since the fathers fell asleep, all continues just as it was from the beginning of creation.” For when they maintain this, it escapes their notice that by the word of God the heavens existed long ago and the earth was formed out of water and by water, through which the world at that time was destroyed, being flooded with water. But by His word the present heavens and earth are being reserved for fire, kept for the day of judgment and destruction of ungodly men.

(2 Peter 3:3 -7)


@JenKiggans2026 wrote in post #398: however we have God’s own Word so, although that is also faith, it is a supported faith. That’s the evidence that we have as believers


In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came into being through Him, and apart from Him nothing came into being that has come into being. In Him was life, and the life was the Light of men. The Light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it.

(John 1:1-5)


We Christians have the Light. Disbelievers have the darkness.


The Redeemer redeems the disbeliever into the redeemed in the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ. By His Blood, we redeemed are saved from the wrath of God.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #384: Yes “scientists” have a habit of trying to hijack the dictionary.


You call it like it is, right there. Many people vehemently use the word “theory” confusedly in-situ for the concept of “fact”, and your opponent practices this linguistic lunacy.

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #395: Therefore BIG BANG theory is still unproven, because it remains theoretical…If it was proven it would be an unequivocal fact rather than a theory.


The concept of the word “theory” is “faith” as per the quoted dictionary definition recorded in post #20 and repeated here, again, for convenience:

  1. A set of statements or principles devised to explain a group of facts or phenomena, especially one that has been repeatedly tested or is widely accepted and can be used to make predictions about natural phenomena.
  2. The branch of a science or art consisting of its explanatory statements, accepted principles, and methods of analysis, as opposed to practice: a fine musician who had never studied theory.
  3. A set of theorems that constitute a systematic view of a branch of mathematics.
  4. Abstract reasoning; speculation: a decision based on experience rather than theory.
  5. A belief or principle that guides action or assists comprehension or judgment: staked out the house on the theory that criminals usually return to the scene of the crime.
  6. An assumption based on limited information or knowledge; a conjecture.
American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Obtained from thefreedictionary.com/theory


In definition 1, “accepted” is a synonym for “believed”, so “theory” arrives at “widely believed” which is faith, not fact.


@SergeantLynch wrote in post #395: But there is still no way of actually knowing.


That’s right! Your word “knowing” is intimately related to the concept of “science”.


The word “science” (link to thefreedictionary.com/science) fundamentally conveys the concept of knowledge.


A person’s knowledge equates to fact or faith.


The word “fact” (link to thefreedictionary.com/fact) represents absolute existence of a person, place, thing, or event.


Faith is proof of things not seen; in other words, that which one says/thinks, but not sees, is what one believes (faith=belief).


The phrase “Big Bang Theory” and the phrase “Big Bang Belief” are equivalents.


Kermos
Debby wrote in post #377: @Kermos The Big Bang theory challenge has reduced the requirements to a Tik Tok episode. It claims there was a big Bang before the Big Bang and the evidence is overlapping.
Debby wrote in post #379: @Kermos You have proven it will take a leap of faith to accept the Big Bang theory for people like you who believe the universe was created without any noise.
Debby wrote in post #387: @Kermos If you trust science you will trust the Big Bang.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


The blindly blather of your non-scientific method bad evidence, that is, your science (knowledge) deficiency manifests in your failure to respond with scientific method good evidence.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


The Big Bang Theory is an unproven leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #368: Red-shift is not merely red-spectral;


Red-shift is merely red-spectral. Your words that you use, as shown below, solidify the scientific fact that red-shift is merely red-spectral!


I pointed out to you back in post #361 that no scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus astronomer astrologers red-shift unscientific confirmation of error.


Mr. Nuclear Scientist, you seem unable to address the points I present to you. Your position is so weak that you repeat yourself, but I systematically dissect your arguments, and I methodologically dismantle your scientific fact statements into their proper state as your sacred faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: it is a shift toward longer wavelengths and lower frequencies across the entire electromagnetic spectrum, not just visible red light.


You supplied absolutely, positively no scientific method based fact as support for your nonscience “shift toward longer wavelengths and lower frequencies across the entire electromagnetic spectrum” as documented in post #376 (but you couldn’t have known about post #376 yet, but you should have known about it’s predecessor post #53).


Furthermore, you ramble on while neglecting that the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” of my post #361 addressed to you, above, forces light to greatly surpass your 186,000 miles per second speed limit of light. Your red-shift breaks E=MC2 (and vice versa).

@FLRW wrote in post #368: 1. Terminology: The term “red” indicates the direction of the shift (toward the red end of the visible spectrum), but the effect applies to radio waves, infrared, ultraviolet, X-rays, and gamma rays.


The Electromagnetic Spectrum Maintains Uniformity


Under the uniformity of the Universe doctrine of your star bible such as the RW Metric (see post #325), if a distant stellar light source component particle emissions all shift toward the “red” end of the spectrum, then a replacement particle emission from the red range-ish replaces the infrared range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the orange range-ish replaces the red range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the yellow range-ish replaces the orange range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the green range-ish replaces the yellow range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the blue range-ish replaces the green range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the indigo range-ish replaces the blue range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the violet range-ish replaces the indigo range-ish, a replacement particle emission from the ultraviolet range-ish replaces the violet range-ish, etc. This describes a cascade effect that keeps the electromagnetic spectrum uniform with particle emissions occupying all the original wavelengths; therefore, astronomer astrologers red-shift Earth reference element base assumption (belief without proof (see post #53)) mismatches with the actual element at the stellar object (see the Las Cumbres Observatory Redshift document at this link), or the astronomers astrologers misinterpret the data at hand in some other manner. Astronomer astrologers interpret the light according to their star bible which is a case of astronomer astrologers high priest Stephen Hawking’s own star bible contribution of condemnation “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: 2. Physical Meaning: Red-shift signifies that the wavelength of light has been stretched (increased) due to the source moving away from the observer or the expansion of space.


Yet, you supply no scientific method based fact as support for your fantasy red-shift, so your red-shift assumption (belief without proof) is a leap of faith.


As pointed out to you, Mr. Scientist, in the “Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers” section of post #376, there is no such thing as you describe.

@FLRW wrote in post #368: 3. Observation: Astronomers detect this by measuring the displacement of known spectral lines (fingerprints of elements like hydrogen) toward longer wavelengths, regardless of whether the resulting light is visible to the human eye.


Speaking of “Observation”, astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper which explained their discovery of a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two stellar objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source is The Astrophysical Journal, issue 1, volume 620). Red-shift as a distance calculator is falsified.


Your “Astronomers detect this by measuring the displacement of known spectral lines (fingerprints of elements like hydrogen) toward longer wavelengths, regardless of whether the resulting light is visible to the human eye” statement directly contradicts that astrophysicist’s determination. You have faith that the universe is expanding based on red-shift, yet your faith opposes astrophysicist Burbidge’s faith.


Since you fight against your own, FLRW, then you are in a state of faith for the Big Bang.



Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #369: still nonetheless theories rather than known facts. So not the BIG BANG FACT,


Sir, yes sir! We agree on this fact.

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #369: despite massive amounts of verifiable science evidence.


Sir, no sir! Red-shift is a movement toward the U.S.A.’s adversarial type of government called communism, not a Doppler effect of light as strongly evidenced in post #361.


The Big Bang Theory has unverifiable evidence. No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error; therefore, the Big Bang’s red-shift is not of the scientific method.


The Big Bang is a leap of faith


Kermos
@Double_R wrote in post #353: @Kermos Still going I see. I never did get a response to my post 140. Pasted it below for your convenience:


You didn’t rationally explain how you arrived at your irrationally convoluted post #89 explanation as I inquired of you in my post #136, so I disregarded your followup post 140. If you want to engage further, then explain yourself, first.


My 3 ball example in post #35 demonstrated one does not know (science) as a matter of fact where the ball came from which rolled over the grandpa’s foot, but one may conject (theorize) about the ball, and that “theorize” is faith.


The Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Kermos
Debby wrote in post #351: @Kermos Even Einstein changed his original position and accepted the expanding universe. The Big Bang is universally accepted by the scientific community. You doubting it is a leap of faith. But you are not going to far. You have not provided an alternate theory and just continue to deny facts.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


Your irrelevant science (knowledge) about whether Einstein believed (“accepted”) the Big Bang *is not the point of post #301; moreover, you appear incapable of sciencing (knowing) the point which is specifically stated in the post.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
FLRW wrote in post #349: Hmmmm, poor thinking or cognitive changes can sometimes be a sign of a brain tumor or a side effect of cancer and its treatments (often called “chemo brain” or brain fog),


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


Ohhhhhh, are you suffering from poor thinking or cognitive changes? It doesn’t necessarily mean you have a brain tumor or cancer, FLRW. You might be really, really tired. Is that why you failed to come back with scientific method evidentiary based fact about the Big Bang?


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #348: The Big Bang theory is supported by massive empirical evidence gathered through the scientific method,


I intend to interrogate you via your arguments as to whether the scientific method applies. I draw on post #53’s content, but the scientist, that you are, failed to science (know) that post #53 addressed your post before you posted your post even with me pointing you to post #53 beforehand.

@FLRW wrote in post #348: proving that the universe originated from an extremely hot, dense state and has been expanding ever since.


Your verbiage of “proving” elevated your bar to equivalency with scientific fact for the Big Bang; in other words, you are absolutely, positively, certain that the Big Bang occurred 13,800,000,000 years, but nobody was there to witness your Big Bang, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #348: Main Evidentiary Pillars


My post #361 used E=MC2 in the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section to prove the error of your “Main Evidentiary Pillars”!

@FLRW wrote in post #348: 1. Hubble-Lemaître Law (Expansion of the Universe): In 1929, astronomer Edwin Hubble discovered that distant galaxies move away from us, with speed proportional to distance, showing space itself expands.


You provided absolutely, positively no scientific method basis for your faith based “Hubble-Lemaître Law (Expansion of the Universe)”!


The Hubble Law is centered on red-shift, and the Hubble Bubble pops without red-shift.

1. Red-shift Is Merely Red-spectral


Red-shift is one of your star bible’s pillar foundations.

Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method


First, I introduce you to an examination of red-shift, which you base on the so-called doppler effect of light, in the light of the scientific method:

  1. Phase: activity
  2. hypothesis: red spectral light emits from a star in space indicating the star recedes away Earth and the star’s great distance from Earth.
  3. experiment: no test cases.
  4. observation: none of experiments.
  5. conclusion: a star receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion emit red spectral light.
  6. confirmation: no experiments to repeat.


Red-shift conjecturers abysmally failed to completely apply the scientific method. Red-shift as a distance determinant is not science.


Astronomer astrologers, such as Hubble and Lemaître, engaged in circular reasoning between their hypothesis and conclusion, so their logic is flawed, and so is your logic by extension.


This circular reasoning is nonsense scientists saying “I correctly science the proof because I correctly science facts, and you are wrong because I science right”. All the while, those nonsense nonscience scientists don’t science (know) with the scientific method.

Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers


You are using the nonsense nonscience doppler effect of light based on your assumptions, not science.


Sound waves are atmospheric tightly localized particle vibrations passed from particle to particle; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles.


As an example of the doppler effect, when a fast moving train blows it’s whistle while passing a person, then the pitch increases on approach to the person (sound wave compression) and the pitch decreases as the train races toward the horizon (sound wave decompression) as the train leaves the person; however, red-shift conjecturers have no such proof for the doppler effect of light except for their hypothesis pointing at their conclusion joined with their conclusion pointing at their hypothesis.

Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss


Astronomers discovered a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal). Red-shift as a distance calculator is falsified.

History, red-shift rapidly morphs into blue-shift


Sirius was known as the Star of Isis in ancient Egypt and was described as red, but Sirius is blue, now. This change describes a stellar u-turn, and astrophysics declare that it’s impossible, yet human witness indicates that the change from red to blue occurred, so your red-shift falls apart based on recorded history.

Conclusion for your pillar of red-shift


Stellar red-shift is really stellar red-spectral frequency production.


Red-shift is a magical, mystical interpretation of red-spectral light without a scientific method based explanation of “why” or “how”.


I need to dig into your ridiculously miniscule observational window in terms of space and time in this post.


The good evidence contradicts your section “1. Hubble-Lemaître Law (Expansion of the Universe)”. You have very bad evidence for your faith in the Big Bang.


Your star bible’s red-shift massive star direction teaching and distance doctrine is a leap of faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #348: 2. Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) Radiation: Detected in 1964 by Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson, this faint microwave glow fills all space and matches the exact predicted cooling afterglow of a hot early universe.


You provided absolutely, positively no scientific method basis for your faith based “Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) Radiation”!


Nobody measured your purported “microwave glow fills all space” from the vantage point of “all space” in order to make your ridiculously faith based statement. Your CMB is not of the scientific method, and I am about to show you that your CMB claim disintegrates even further!

2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)


I present to you the history recorded by others which reveals CMB was a known quantity decades before 1964. This directly derails your “predicted” “fact” leaving a mere residual called “faith”.


Andrew McKellar used W. S. Adams’ spectroscopic instrumentation during 1941 to measure background temperature of 2.3 K of a B type star.


In 1948, cosmologist George Gamow led a group that calculated cosmic microwave radiation.


The vaunted Bell Telephone Laboratories had a facility atop Crawford Hill in Holmdel, New Jersey where Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson experimented in 1964. They detected a homogeneous, constant radiation. They were awarded the Nobel Prize in 1978 for their CMB work.


Robert H. Dicke, Jim Peebles, and David Wilkinson, astrophysicists at Princeton University believed the Big Bang emitted a tremendous radiation blast resulting in cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR), and they prepared to investigate microwave radiation levels in the year 1964.


But, Bernard F. Burke, professor of physics at MIT (your alma mater), introduced the two groups working a mere 40 miles from each other.


The two groups agreeably jointly published in Astrophysical Journal Letters. Two notes were published, (1) Dicke et al substantiated the Big Bang based on CMBR, and (2) Penzias et al noted the existence of 3.5 K CMBR universally.


McKellar recorded the CMBR in 1941, so the CMBR was a known quantity by the time of Penzias et. al. as well as Dicke et. al.; therefore, neither Penzias et. al. nor Dicke et. al. “predicted” anything. You wrote deception.


In essence, your history of using something like the RW Metric (see post #361 for RW Metric details) deceives people, including you.

Scientist’s, er, philosopher’s public CMBR deception


It is time to compare and contrast these data collections:

  1. McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K


Your manipulation of statistics (mathematical nonsense) to arrive at “this faint microwave glow fills all space and matches the exact predicted cooling afterglow of a hot early universe” is a deeper lie and malevolent representation.


Your astrophysicist high priest Stephen Hawking issued the condemnation of astronomer astrologers with “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”, so you keep his words in mind while reading the following.

CMBR UnSETtling Theory


Set theory is fascinating, and set theory is destructive to your argument.

  1. McKellar (1941): M = {x ∈ R | 1.8 ≤ x ≤ 3.4}
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): P = {x ∈ R | 2.5 ≤ x ≤ 4.5}


M and P represent two mutually exclusive, independent and discreet studies.


M=P is false.


M∩P is a range of real number temperature elements that potentially one set can be greater than or lesser than the temperature in the opposing set (except for the boundaries which would be equality on one side), so M∩P elements are excluded from this evaluation because these cancel each other out. This leaves the elements represented in MΔP.


MΔP is the range of real number temperature elements that uniquely qualify as exclusively greater than or less than the temperature in the opposing set, so MΔP is included in this evaluation.


Proof samples:

  1. M∩P and M>P, M=3.2 and P=3.1
  2. M∩P and M<P, M=3.1 and P=3.2
  3. MΔP and M>P, nonexistent
  4. MΔP and M<P, M=1.8 and P=4.5
  5. MΔP and M<P, M=2.4 and P=3.5


The exemplary intersection (M∩P) elements of 3.1 and 3.2 sufficiently illustrate the cancelation effect of the corresponding intersection elements.


The result is M<P.


The CMBR temperature increases going forward in time according to this logic demonstrated using set theory which potentially indicates a lower temperature in the past.


Set theory applied to your star bible data upends your “this faint microwave glow fills all space and matches the exact predicted cooling afterglow of a hot early universe” writing.

CMBR Average Disformity


Scientists like averages (mean), or medians, or blind faith guesses, such as the astronomer astrologer’s current magical, mystical 2.7255 K CMBR nonsense nonscience temperature, so I present the mean temperature values to test their conclusion that there has been a decrease in the temperature over the years.


The data averaged:

  1. McKellar (1941): 2.5
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): 3.5


2.5=3.5 is false.


2.5<3.5 is true.


1941<1965 is true.


3.5-2 5=1.0 is true.


1965-1941=24 is true.


The five factual statements directly above show a 1.0 K increase of heat on average over a period of 2 dozen years starting in 1941 AD until 1965 AD.


A decrease in heat temperature from 1941 to 1965 is the Big Bang adherent’s requirement, but it’s just not there, so your CMBR is very bad evidence for your Big Bang.

CMBR Logical Conclusion


The above dissection of historical data shows that these are each distinctly different surveys:

  1. McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K


McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K is not isotropic agreement with Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K.


Statistical consolidation of the points is unreasonable because reasonable doubt has been cast by the potential for decreased temperature in earlier time thus anyone claiming increased temperature is a person defying the logical conclusion from the data; in other words, you cannot logically claim that there was a high heat temperature deep in the past around your Big Bang timeframe which would make the differences in points statistically insignificant. The differences in points are statistically significant as a function of the recorded increase in temperature over the decades, yet astronomer astrologers exhibit Stephen Hawking’s quote, recorded above.


In other words, these measurements are in agreement with one another that the Big Bang is a leap of faith/belief.


Deception of the CMBR is a very poor method to present your case.


Various sources of material for this whole CMBR section include “cosmic microwave background” of Encyclopedia Britannica, “Cosmic microwave background” of Wikipedia, and “A Review of the 1941 to 1961 CMBR Temperature Measurements” on ResearchGate.


Your section “2. Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) Radiation” is very bad evidence for the Big Bang.

@FLRW wrote in post #348: 3. Abundance of Light Elements: Observations of primordial nucleosynthesis confirm that the amounts of hydrogen, helium, and lithium in space match calculations of reactions in the early universe.


You supplied absolutely, positively no scientific method basis for your faith based “Abundance of Light Elements”!


Nobody made your purported “Observations of primordial nucleosynthesis” because nobody was there during your and Lemaître’s “primordial” leap of faith based “before mankind existed” timeframe in order to observe your fantasy “primordial nucleosynthesis” as a natural phenomena for the scientific method’s hypothesis phase.


An example is needed, here.


When astronomer astrologer William sess light in the sky then formulates an equation to match what he sees then solves his flawed formula about cosmic evolution in London and astrophysicist Valdemar solves the same flawed formula in Copenhagen arriving at the same flawed result, then confirmation occurred which is truly confirmation of an error, yet William and Valdemar believe the formula with their ensuing result are good evidence.


William and Valdemar’s work was not based fully on the scientific method of hypothesis (concept based on observation of natural phenomenon), experiment (test with natural ingredients in controlled environment), observation (natural ingredients reproduce the hypothesis), conclusion (reasonable thoughts of prior steps), and repeatability (confirmation under similar circumstances).


William and Valdemar excluded hypothesis (not an observed in natural phenomenon), experiment (replaced by formula/model), observation (the hypothesis is calculated/speculated not reproduced).


See Hawking’s “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”, so your vaunted astronomer astrologer Hawking laid out your leap of faith long ago.

3. Prideful man sees light in the heavens and says to himself, “there is no god” (Psalm 14:1)


A prediction exposes a future person, place, or thing. The Big Bang purportedly existed as a thing of the past.


In your “3. Abundance of Light Elements” section, your broken linguistics wrongly utilize predict (foretell, see post #82) for your past thing (Big Bang).


I present a real example of a prediction. Unless you think differently after an encounter with the Word of God, you will surely die in your crimes against the Living God who created you (Luke 13:5). See, I’m referring to the future.


Your section 3 fails to adhere to the Scientific Method in all aspects. Your hypothesis and conclusion are the same which leads you to circular reasoning. Nobody observed a natural phenomenon that you call the Big Bang, so your hypothesis is null and void. You have no experimentation, so you have no observations of said experimentation. Repeatability exists not. You do not have science because you actually have sorcery about your light recipes which you presented.


You leap to faith for your abundance of light as support for your Big Bang.

@FLRW wrote in post #348: 4. Age of Oldest Objects: Stellar ages and white dwarf cooling rates measure out to roughly 13.5 to 13.8 billion years, aligning tightly with calculated cosmological timelines.


You provided absolutely, positively no scientific method basis for your faith based “Age of Oldest Objects”!


Your total leap of faith based “white dwarf cooling rates measure out to roughly 13.5 to 13.8 billion years” entirely lacks scientific method based fact support in your post!

4. Galaxies change


Galaxies changing over time does not indicate that a Big Bang occurred. The Earth revolves around the Sun, so this results in change for the Milky Way Galaxy, yet the Earth’s orbit is by no means proof of your fantasy Big Bang Theory.


If you looked at a small galaxy, then all you science (know) is that you saw a small galaxy in relation to your location. You know (1) not whether the galaxy is truly large and very distant, (2) not whether the galaxy is truly small and very near, (3) not the luminosity at the galaxy, and (4) not the galaxy size as an age determinant. Your “Stellar ages” “aligning tightly with calculated cosmological timelines” is an astoundingly unscientific theory (conjecture) which makes your conjecture a leap of belief/faith.


During your Big Bang, the speed of light was greatly exceeded. You do not know whether current conditions conducive to exceeding the speed of light exist out in the vastness of space; therefore, nonsense nonscience scientist’s “When we look billions of light-years away, we’re looking billions of years into the past”, presented as fact by types such as yourself, is truly a leap of faith based statement.


Your “Monumental Star Distance Conversion Calculator To Massive Star Age Calculations” are based on light speed of 186,000 MPS, but the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section in post #361 details that Einstein’s relativity theories result in the speed of light far outpacing the astronomer astrologer’s top speed of 186,000 miles per second, so your calculator for star age is broken. This illuminates a higher degree of error for your “Age of Oldest Objects” section.

The Zenith Model


I examine just how untenable it is for you to believe you can accumulate sufficient data to draw conclusions about an event 13.8 billion years ago.


Carl Sagan wrote Cosmos, and in Cosmos, Sagan presented his Cosmic Calendar representing 13.8 billion years as a conventional single calendar year with January 1st as the Big Bang and December 31st as the current time. Are you familiar with Sagan’s work?


Sagan’s calculations put the birth of Christ on December 31st at 23:59:55. That’s mere seconds before the end of the calendar year.


Each second on the Cosmic Calendar corresponds to 438 Earth years, According to historians, Hans Lippershey applied for a “telescope” patent in 1608, and astronomical observations were initiated by Galileo Galilei using an improved design. For your sake in this model, I’ll give you the more ancient date of 1608 which is 417 years of documentary evidence for telescopes which is one second at the very end of that Cosmic Calendar year.


You believe you collected sufficient data about the Big Bang through such a negligibly small window, one second out of 31,536,000 seconds as represented by Sagan’s Cosmic Calendar.


As an aside, Edwin Hubble is largely credited by the scientific community with discovering in 1924 that almost all galaxies are moving away from Earth, about 100 years ago, which is the last one-quarter second of 23:55:59 on December 31st. Further distilling the times into equal time segments, each unit being equal to 0.25 of 1 second, the ratio is 1:126,144,000 for your data collection since Hubble’s work.


Back to giving you the full second.


The model also needs to compensate for space, and I’m extending a beneficial handicap to you. I’ll only calculate for an X-axis, and I’ll skip the Y-axis and Z-axis. Light reportedly travels at 186,000 miles per second, so one light year is about 6 trillion miles (6,000,000,000,000 miles).


Earth is 8 light minutes from the Sun, so the field of measurement is about 16 light minutes (2,976,000 miles diameter of orbit).


Scientists speculate the solar system is about 4 light years across (24,000,000,000,000 miles).


Our own Milky Way galaxy is about 100,000 light-years (600,000,000,000,000,000 miles) across according to NASA personnel, and they estimate that the observable universe is about 92 billion light-years (552,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles) across.


As of Feb. 1, 2020, Voyager 1 is about 13.8 billion miles (13,800,000,000 miles) from the Sun.


Let’s pretend CMBR data, telemetry data, and such continues to flow back to Earth’s scientists from Voyager 1 collected with instruments congruent with 2025 technology instead of 1977 technology; in other words, I’m giving you another big fat handicap.


Your data collection ratio is 13.8:552,000,000,000,000 miles. That ratio is a linear X-axis - excluding the compounding effect of the Y-axis and the Z-axis.


Scientists collected data across 13.8:552,000,000,000,000 distance units spanning 1:31,536,000 time units (a.k.a. 438:13,800,000,000 time units). This is conservatively favorable to your advantage.


I observe that you collected data over an insufficient time frame in an insignificantly sized sampling region.


In conclusion, the Big Bang Theory is not science, and the Big Bang Theory is a leap of faith.


Scientists had a leap of faith with a data reading in time - a sliver of time - in a sliver of space. No detailed temperature with speed including specific path history embedded in the particles exists. Bi Bang scientists are not doing science because they are doing sorcery.


The above is titled the Zenith Model.


Your “4. Age of Oldest Objects” section is laden with assumptions, that is, your believing without proof (see thefreedictionary.com/assumption).

@FLRW wrote in post #348:Opinions are mixed regarding the absolute origin of singularities versus alternative models like eternal inflation, though observations heavily favor the standard hot Big Bang framework.


The “Opinions” to which you refer are beliefs, not proof, not scientific fact, but are leaps of faith.

5. The Cosmic Distance Ladder is a poorly formed faith


As you coalesced your prior four points into your “observations heavily favor the standard hot Big Bang framework”, your astronomer astrologer cosmic distance ladder, which you as a scientist failed to specifically name, emerges with broken and missing rungs as distinctively enumerated above; in other words, your Big Bang is a leap of faith as evidenced above. In fact, the following obliterates your foundational rungs.

The Episcopic Model


Now, I arrived at your cosmic distance ladder or your “star bible” as I put it. You have a book of your forefathers, and that book was developed with less mature technology as compared to your current instruments.


A galaxy candidate named HDI is pegged at 13.5 billion light years from Earth by astronomers who put HDI in the early universe of only about 300 million years after the Big Bang.


The astronomer astrologers cannot use parallax in combination with the inverse square law because of the hyper super-small angles (even in arcseconds), the requirement to know the luminosity at the source, or the requirement to know the distance to the object.


Astronomers already claim to know the distance without visiting the source to determine the brightness.


This leaves telescopes for determining the distance.


Astronomers claim that telescopes provides evidence for you, even that telescopes enable you to determine the distance from Earth to celestial bodies many light years away.


If you take a first measurement to a particular object in space from a telescope on Earth on June 21 and a second reading on December 21 of the same year, then you can use the angle-side-angle geometric formula to determine the distance to the object.


For the purposes of this example, I’m switching to a much more manageable distance from 13,500,000,000 light years (HDI) to an object 1 (one) light year away from Earth.


I want to give you an idea of just how narrow that triangle is by way of a scale model.


A first person uses a red marking pen to put a dot on the TransAmerica building in San Francisco.


A second person sets up two street survey instruments on tripods 800 miles away on the Space Needle in Seattle, and the survey instruments are set 16 inches apart. These two points sixteen inches apart represent Earth’s orbit around the Sun for a triangulation base.


Now, the second person finds the red dot and collects the angle-side-angle data for calculating the distance to the red dot.


That is one NARROW triangle, and that is merely a single light year scale model.


The triangle with respect to the nearest solar system, Andromeda, at 4 light years away, is much narrower. Think of it, the first person leaves San Francisco California, 800 miles from Seattle, to travel south, past Los Angeles, past Mexico City all the way through Mexico, further south into Central America, into the northern outskirts of Managua in Nicaragua, 3,200 miles from Seattle, and tethers a red helium filled balloon to the top of the tallest tree; meanwhile, the second person keeps the two survey instruments in the same 16" separated locations on the Space Needle in Seattle of the USA, and the second person finds the red balloon and collects the angle-side-angle data for triangulating the distance to the red balloon. Those angles are ever so slight, in fact, the triangle baseline angles are virtually indistinguishable from 90° angles!


FLRW, if you don’t perceive your evidence disappearing, then that’s a shame.


Astronomers claim VY Canis Majoris, is approximately 3,900 light-years away from Earth. Could the second person place a red tarp over the descent stage of the Lunar Module Eagle sitting on the moon for this example? Not without being about 60,000 to 80,000 miles too close to those two survey instruments sitting 16" apart on the Space Needle in Seattle, WA, USA, Earth (312,000 miles required for the 16" surveyor scale model)! I’m giving you the benefit of the red tarp over the decent stage, yet the triangulation has the appearance of being parallel lines for a celestial object far less than 100,000 light years from Earth, and this example hasn’t even touched upon the 100,000 light years diameter of the Milky Way galaxy, so Astronomers are faith based regarding celestial bodies being 1,000,000 (one million) light years from Earth instead of science based. 1,000,000,000 (one billion) light years from Earth is a triangulation distance measurement nightmare leap of faith calculation.


Back to galaxy candidate HDI, the resulting triangle using telescopes on Earth to arrive at 13.5 billion light years from Earth is nonscience, definitely not the scientific method.


Your star bible fails to help you avoid the leap of faith because your star bible itself is a foundation based on faith.


I title this the Episcopic Model that proves you only have the characteristics of received particle emissions at the time of reception. Light particles contain (1) no date of production data, (2) no static location of production data, and (3) no internally recorded path of travel data. You do not have accurate origin object distance nor luminosity nor size nor age for celestial objects purportedly exceeding 6,000 light years from Earth.

The Big Bang is a belief system


You failed to establish fact for the Big Bang, so you are left with a leap of faith for the Big Bang.


You possess bad evidence for the Big Bang. Your grounds for belief (evidence) is just shifting sand, and Lord Jesus says this about shifting sand: Therefore everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and yet it did not fall, for it had been founded on the rock. Everyone who hears these words of Mine and does not act on them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and it fell—and great was its fall.

(Matthew 7:24-27)


Kermos

@FLRW, I point out your lack of logic in the below about the Big Bang, so you are left with a Big Bang leap of faith. This post continues my response to your post #341.

@FLRW wrote in post #293: The statement is incorrect; the Doppler effect does apply to light. Similar to sound …snip


Mr. relative “to Albert Einstein through the Koch family” - FLRW with your prestigious MIT issued nuclear scientist collegiate certificate, who repeats his red-shift leap of faith responses lacking scientific method based evidence (aka ground for belief (post #25),


Astronomer astrologers conjured the Doppler effect for light as a successor to the Doppler effect for sound:

  1. The Doppler effect for sound adheres to the scientific method.
  2. The Doppler effect for light adheres not to the scientific method.


As shown in my post #271, the environment for sound in Earth’s atmosphere strikingly differs from the environment for light in space.


Your nonsense nonscience statement resides in your fantasy because the waves are fundamentally different waves. Sound waves vibrate a molecule maintaining localized proximity yet transferring energy to the next molecule which repeats the cycle through the Earth’s atmosphere; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles; therefore, the Doppler effect applies to sound, but the Doppler effect applies not to light (see also post #53).

Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift


“A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


Einstein’s formula E=MC2 has high relation to red-shift. Red-shift’s high energy, high frequency light deteriorates into low energy, low frequency light at the time of emission, and astronomer astrologers believe this reveals age, distance, and/or direction of celestial objects. Einstein’s formula E=MC2 is in permanent equilibrium between energy (E) and mass (M) and speed_of_light (C). Since E=MC2 needs to be maintain equilibrium with the red-shift massless (M) photon, then the commutative property of mathematics keeps the equation’s balance by moving energy (E) to the speed_of_light (C). In essence, E=MC2 forces an increase to the speed of light under the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. redshift.


I obtained the following from 4.5: The Doppler Effect at LibreTexts with respect to red-shift:

The relationship between the degree of shift in wavelength to the speed of the object is found by:
Apparent wavelength/true frequency = true wavelength/apparent frequency = 1 + recession velocity/wave speed.
Since the speed of light in a vacuum, c, is a constant, the speed of the object can be found with the following equation:
Δλ/λ = v/c
Where Δλ is the change in wavelength, λ is the normal or laboratory wavelength of the light, and v is the relative speed of the source toward or away from the observer.


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error.


You need to mess with adjusting the C (constant representing the speed of light at 186,000 miles per second) in Einstein’s E=MC2, but you are left with a MESS in so doing because light pushes beyond 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years which translates to light moving faster, much faster than your C of 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years (a.k.a. velocity well beyond 186,000 miles per second), so light speedily traverses the 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 mile distance in some unknown amount of the time, for example, maybe 2 days. I remind you in my post #199 to you regarding Einstein’s Special Relativity Theory where I detailed that Rowland explained a time element is absent from E=MC2.


Einstein’s Special Relativity E=MC2 causes the speed of light to do precisely that which physicists declare cannot be done - LIGHT BURSTING SPEEDILY BEYOND THE 186,000 MILES PER SECOND SPEED LIMIT AS A CONSEQUENCE OF RED-SHIFT. This is a violation of the Robertson-Walker Metric (RW Metric) which is astronomer astrologers formulaic assumption of a uniform universe with characteristics of (1) isotropy (same in all directions) and (2) homogeneity (constant density). That RW is in FLRW, Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker. You, FLRW, refused to respond to the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section regarding astronomer astrologers utter confusion about the impossible relationship between E=MC2 and red-shift.


Einstein’s E=MC2 calculates the impossibility of red-shift as per astronomer astrologers’ own rules.


Hubble’s Law depends upon red-shift, but red-shift is merely red-spectral, so Hubble’s Law is an evolutionist’s leap of faith, not even a law, just faith. The Big Bang bang is a leap of faith.

Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light exists not; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.


This post supplements my post #275.


A Big Bang cosmic distance ladder’s foundational rung is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #341: Hmmmm, the direct opposite of taking a “leap of faith” is exercising extreme caution, empirical proof, or complete distrust . A “leap of faith” means making a choice or taking a big risk without hard proof, relying only on trust. Its exact opposites depend on whether you look at it through action, attitude, or logic:


The point of this thread is that the Big Bang is a leap of faith. Your Big Bang is absent of hard proof that you place on your astronomer astrologers.


Your “empirical proof” is not the complete scientific method. The Scientific Method comprises much more as outlined in the original post, post #53, post #118 (to you), and post #296 (also to you), yet you ignore this logical fact over and over and over again, even in your subsequent post #347 in which you state grounds for belief (assumptions, see post #53 for the dictionary definition) instead of scientific method based evidence.


Oh, and I noticed you concluded your post #341 with a colon, so you indicated your continuation, so I interpret that as you linking your post #341 to post #347. My post #53 addresses your post #347, but your science (knowledge) abysmally ignored my post #53 which shows your lack of scientific “action, attitude, or logic”. Your science (knowledge) deficiency manifests in your failure to respond with the scientific method.


I started composing my response to your post #347, but, in the meantime, my next post restores to you that the logical application of E=MC2 in the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” section demonstrates several of the Big Bang “Main Evidentiary Pillars” are a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Sidewalker wrote in post #347: Kermos learned to debate at the Argument Clinic. Argument Clinic | Monty Python (Official Sketch)


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You describe your own debate inability as demonstrated in post #20. Do try to remain on topic.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #342: @Kermos The main evidence for the Big Bang. The expanding universe.Galaxies move away from us in all directions. This means everything was closer to us in the past. Cosmic Microwave background. Scientists found a faint glow of microwave radiation everywhere in space . This leftover heat is the sign of a very hot early universe. Light elements. The amount of hydrogen and helium found in space match what the Big Bang match predicts. The Hubble space telescope has helped scientists test and support the Big Bang Theory by measuring the expansion rate and age of the universe with high precision. …snip

If you read the linked content for the first eighteen points of my post #331 (not too far above your post 342), then you would science (know) that your points have been covered. As it is, you demonstrated your lack of science (knowledge).


The Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #339: @Kermos The Big Bang theory is similar to the creation theory in the Bible.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You believe your astronomer astrologer Roman Catholic Church priest Georges Lemaître’s preaching the Big Bang with Edwin Hubble’s redshift universe expansion as detailed in post #313, but red-shift is merely red-spectral, yet you, self-described Scientist, believe Lemaître’s nonsense nonscience instead of you believing Jesus Christ as detailed in post #214 which means you are not a Christian. You, as a person, who in your heart publicly nullifies the Word of God, you disqualify yourself from being a person with the Wisdom of God (1 Corinthians 1:24).


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #337: See above…I rest my case.


Excellent, you concede the Big Bang theory is a leap of faith as I demonstrated in post #331 above. I explained to you that you don’t have the science (knowledge) to refute my post #301 nor it’s associated post #325.


See above in my post #335 to you in which your confusion about the concept for the word “theory” is on full display.

By definition, the Big Bang theory is the Big Bang belief/faith.


Even your champion, scientist @FLRW, fails to respond with scientific method evidentiary based fact for the Big Bang. The Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #336: @Kermos General theories explain why and how things happen. But ins Jen r a scientific theory is the highest level of understanding.It is a well tested deeply verified explanation for a broad range of observation back by mountains of hard data.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang belief, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


What is “ins Jen r a scientific theory”? Your “It is a well tested deeply verified explanation for a broad range of observation back by mountains of hard data” is not you presenting scientific method developed evidence in this thread.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #333: You just repeat your position without responding to the evidence provided.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You are demonstrably a liar based on my response in post #53 and post #93 as just a couple of examples of me responding to Big Bang adherents poor evidence in this thread.


You are a hypocrite because you repeat yourself with your “The Big Bang is taught in schools throughout the world as established science” while you provide no scientific method evidence for the Big Bang. Lord Jesus says “woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you shut off the kingdom of heaven from people; for you do not enter in yourselves” (Matthew 23:13), and you repeat your preaching of your Big Bang belief instead of the Word of God. I pointed this out the distinction to you in post #214 (which includes another example of me responding to poor (or lack of) evidence for the Big Bang).


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #329: @Kermos @Kermos I argue that the premise is a fundamentally flawed contradiction…Extensive science knowledge is irrelevant.


I wrote that you don’t have the science (knowledge) to refute my post #301 nor it’s associated post #325, do you?

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #329: Scientific theory does not require belief…The clue is in the word “theory”.


The dictionary definition for the word “theory” helps right about now:

  1. A set of statements or principles devised to explain a group of facts or phenomena, especially one that has been repeatedly tested or is widely accepted and can be used to make predictions about natural phenomena.
  2. The branch of a science or art consisting of its explanatory statements, accepted principles, and methods of analysis, as opposed to practice: a fine musician who had never studied theory.
  3. A set of theorems that constitute a systematic view of a branch of mathematics.
  4. Abstract reasoning; speculation: a decision based on experience rather than theory.
  5. A belief or principle that guides action or assists comprehension or judgment: staked out the house on the theory that criminals usually return to the scene of the crime.
  6. An assumption based on limited information or knowledge; a conjecture.
American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Obtained from thefreedictionary.com/theory


In definition 1, “accepted” is a synonym for “believed”, so you arrived at “widely believed” which is faith, not fact.


By definition, a scientific theory is belief/faith.

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #329: Therefore “Leap of Faith” is an irrelevant secondary epithet that contradicts to the primary epithet “Big Bang Theory”. …snip


Your linguistical ineptitude is on full display in your writing.


You are in fantasy land with your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #326: @Kermos No other theory has replaced the Big Bang theory. Which proves how well it stands in the scientific community.
@Debby wrote in post #328: @Kermos Major space agencies like NASA and European Space Agency support the Big Bang Theory.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted communally generalized emotion at the expense of specific scientific method evidence. If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


Lord Jesus says “the gate is wide and the way is broad that leads to destruction, and there are many who enter through it” (Matthew 7:13), and the Big Bang way is definitely broad!


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos

The Big Bang’s Cosmic Distance Ladder never achieved the scientific method, as shown in the following:

  1. Comprehensive Scientific Fact That The Big Bang Is A Leap Of Faith
  2. RED-SHIFT … RED-SPECTRAL
  3. Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method
  4. Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers
  5. Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss
  6. History, red-shift rapidly morphs into blue-shift
  7. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)
  8. Scientist’s, er, philosopher’s public
  9. CMBR deception
  10. CMBR UnSETtling Theory
  11. CMBR Average Disformity
  12. CMBR Logical Conclusion
  13. Prideful man sees light in the heavens and says to himself, “there is no god”
  14. Galaxies change
  15. The Zenith Model
  16. The Cosmic Distance Ladder is a poorly formed faith
  17. The Episcopic Model
  18. (See post #53 for the details of the above items)
  19. Einstein’s Theories Destroy And Are Destroyed By The Big Bang
  20. The 1919 Solar Eclipse “Proof” For Einstein’s General Relativity Had A Data Error Range Equivalent To The Effect They Were Measuring
  21. (See post #61 for the details of the above item)
  22. Orthodox Jew Gerald Scroeder Didn’t Prove The Big Bang Using Einstein’s Theory of General Relativity
  23. (See post #87 for the details of the above item)
  24. Einstein And His Successors VLBI (Very Long Baseline Interferometry) Is Very Short Baseline Inferometry (VSBI)
  25. (See post #93 for the details of the above item)
  26. Einstein’s Teacher’s Minkowski Spacetime Added A Fantasy Fourth Dimension Into The Three Dimensions Of Height, Width, And Depth
  27. (See post #199 for the details of the above item)
  28. Einstein’s “Mass Can Be Converted Into Energy” Concept Requires Not E=MC2
  29. (See post #258 for the details of the above item)
  30. Energy Displacement Inside Einstein’s E=MC2 Regarding The Doppler Effect For Light A.K.A. Red-shift Which Requires Energy (E) To Decrease While Increasing The Speed Of Light (C) Thus Light Exceeds Astronomers Universal Speed Limit Of Light
  31. (See post #301 for the details of the above item)
  32. FLRW Spacetime Is Self-contradictory
  33. (See post #325 for the details of the above item)
  34. Cepheid Variable Star Seer Henrietta Swan Leavitt Had Visions Of Star Luminosity At The Star Without Visiting The Star
  35. (See post #82 for the details of the above item)
  36. Big Bang Adherents Avoid The Scientific Method
  37. Red-shift Fails The Hypothesis Phase Because Of The Absence Of A Natural Phenomenon
  38. The Big Bang Fails The Hypothesis Phase Because Of The Absence Of A Natural Phenomenon
  39. (See post #296 for the details of the above items)


Every Big Bang Philosopher engages in a leap of faith. They cry foul, but it is faith.