Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #323: @Kermos Flogging a dead horse now


How dare you call @Debby a horse!

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #323: …snip… The “BIG BANG” is a general theory …snip


As a theory (see post #20 for the dictionary definition of theory), the Big Bang is a belief, that is your leap of faith!


Your linguistical ineptitude is on full display in your writing.


You don’t have the science (knowledge) to refute my post #301 nor it’s associated post #325, do you?


You are in fantasy land with your Big Bang leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #321: @Kermos Even Einstein did not disprove redshift.

FLRW Spacetime Cancelled By E=MC2

As per “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” in post #301, Einstein’s Special Relativity E=MC2 causes the speed of light to do precisely that which physicists declare cannot be done - LIGHT BURSTING SPEEDILY BEYOND THE 186,000 MILES PER SECOND SPEED LIMIT AS A CONSEQUENCE OF RED-SHIFT. This is a violation of the Robertson-Walker Metric (RW Metric) which is astronomer astrologers formulaic assumption of a uniform universe with characteristics of (1) isotropy (same in all directions) and (2) homogeneity (constant density). That RW is in FLRW, Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker. You might recall the user named @FLRW who refuses to respond to post #301, regarding E=MC2.


Einstein’s E=MC2 calculates the impossibility of red-shift as per astronomer astrologers’ own rules.


Red-shift is merely red-spectral, so red-shift is an evolutionist’s leap of faith. The Big Bang bang is a leap of faith.

@Debby wrote in post #321: It is a fundamental prediction of his General theory of relativity.

Calculate Versus Predict

Einstein calculated his formulas, and Einstein conjured up his theories, but Einstein did not predict anything (see post #82 for the dictionary definition of predict which is foretell).

@Debby wrote in post #321: It is a fundamental prediction of his General theory of relativity.

Your Dilemma

If you believe that Einstein correctly calculated his formulas, then you believe in the demise of redshift and the Hubble Bubble pops and the Big Bang goes bust.

@Debby wrote in post #321: It is a fundamental prediction of his General theory of relativity.

You failed to explain the “how” in relation to your statement and the title of this thread You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #319: @Kermos Einstein did not disprove redshift. In fact gravitational redshift is a fundamental prediction of his General theory of relativity.


You failed to understand the science of “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” in post #301 with it’s implications. Red-shift is merely red-spectral. Astronomer astrologer Hubble interpreted red-spectral light using his magical, mystical formulation, and he leads you and has led many others away to hell with his red-shift sorcery.


Einstein’s Relativity theories are demonstrated to be Big Bang believer’s leap of faith in these interrelated posts:

  1. post #61
  2. post #87
  3. post #93
  4. post #199
  5. post #258
  6. post #301.


The Big Bang is your leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #317: @Kermos The physical phenomenon of redshift has not been disproven, It is a thoroughly documented and measured observation in physics and astronomy. Cosmological redshift, Doppler redshift and Gravitational redshift.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


I scientifically detailed how no scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift) in my post #301 only a little way above your post, but you fail to provide scientific method evidence as support for your "thoroughly documented and measured observation for red-shift!


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #315: @Kermos Your profile does of mention any of your science qualifications. To you the Big Bang is a leap of faith. I practice science asa therapist


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


You believe your astronomer astrologer Roman Catholic Church priest Georges Lemaître’s preaching the Big Bang with Edwin Hubble’s redshift universe expansion as detailed in post #313, but red-shift is merely red-spectral, yet you, self-described Scientist, believe Lemaître’s nonsense nonscience instead of you believing Jesus Christ as detailed in post #214 which means you are not a Christian.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos

I scientifically detailed how red-shift breaks under Einstein’s Special Relativity formula E=MC2 causing the 186,000 miles per second speed limit of light to be shattered in my post #301 to you, the namesake FLRW spacetime scientist expert, but you remain silent about this Big Bang breakdown!


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #312: @Kermos In the 1920$ EdwinHubble discovered that almost all distant galaxies show a redshift.


What was it that you wrote in post #310? Ah, yes, it was “Those who are not familiar with science, accepting the Big Bang theory would be a leap of faith”.


I scientifically detailed how red-shift breaks under Einstein’s Special Relativity formula E=MC2 causing the 186,000 miles per second speed limit of light to be shattered in my post #301 a very short distance above your post. Red-shift is merely red-spectral, but you believe your magical, mystical astronomer astrologer Roman Catholic Church priest Lemaître’s preaching the Big Bang with Hubble’s redshift universe expansion as detailed in post #313.


Astronomer astrologer Edwin Hubble interpreted red-spectral light which is bad evidence for the existence of red-shift. Hubble was a liar about red-shift. Hubble had no proof that he was looking at anything more than red-spectral light.


You sell-described yourself as one of “Those who are not familiar with science, accepting the Big Bang theory would be a leap of faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #310: @Kermos Those who are not familiar with science, accepting the Big Bang theory would be a leap of faith.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #306: @Kermos Redshift is proof of an expanding universe.

Your statement is for people, like you, who disbelieve facts (look at you neglect evidence (grounds for belief, see post #25) based response to post #301.


Your statement is for people, like you, who believe that fantasy is proof (look at you omit proof while you fail to understand the physics models as demonstrated in post #307).


Your statement is for people, like you, who believe the magical, mystical red-shift Roman Catholic Church priest Lemaître preached. In post #214, I detailed that astronomer astrologer Lemaître disobeyed Lord Jesus Christ who is the Son of God, and John the Baptist declared “He who believes in the Son has eternal life; but he who does not obey the Son will not see life, but the wrath of God abides on him” (John 3:36). But it gets worse for antichrist Lemaître and his followers because as a liar, Liar Lemaître did the works of his father (John 8:41) described by Jesus with “You are of your father the devil, and you want to do the desires of your father. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth because there is no truth in him. Whenever he speaks a lie, he speaks from his own nature, for he is a liar and the father of lies” (John 8:44).


Not only is your “Redshift is proof of an expanding universe” statement a leap of faith, but you and your statement lacks solid evidence, omits sound logic, neglects realistic reasoning, and most critically opposes the Truth (John 14:6).


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #305: Sirius appears blue-white today, but ancient descriptions of it as red are likely due to atmospheric scintillation or metaphorical usage rather than actual rapid stellar evolution. Why Ancient Writers Saw Red 1. Atmospheric effects: …snip… 2. Cultural metaphors: …snip… 3. Stellar physics: Modern astrophysics shows that a star like Sirius cannot change from a red giant to a blue-white main-sequence star in just a couple of thousand years, as that evolutionary timeline takes millions of years


Ptolemy of Alexandria Egypt was an astronomer, not merely one of your “Ancient Writers”, but also a mathematician.


The temporal and physical proximity of Ptolemy in Alexandria with the historically renowned Library of Alexandria in Egypt placed Ptolemy in a position to readily acquire information about a red Sirius for his works from said library. Recall that you wrote “Ancient Writers”.


You are so religiously zealous for your Big Bang that you personally disqualified the mathematician and astronomer Ptolemy of Alexandria Egypt.


Your points apply to astronomer Lemaître, astronomer Hubble, astronomer Hawking, astronomer Sagan, astronomer deGrasse Tyson, nuclear scientist you FLRW, and other astronomer astrologers etc. What Modern Writers conjure

  1. Atmospheric effects: Lemaître, Hubble, Hawking, Sagan, deGrasse Tyson, you, etc built a faulty cosmic distance ladder with data collected from the Earth’s surface which suffered from distortion by traveling through the Earth’s atmosphere (see your point 1).
  2. Cultural metaphors: Lemaître, Hubble, Hawking, Sagan, deGrasse Tyson, you, etc ‘used “red”’ “to denote” star’s direction of travel and/or distance from Earth and/or velocity of which you all contribute to your Big Bang Theory culture.
  3. Stellar physics: “Modern astrophysics” models lack any tolerance for “a star like Sirius” to “change from a red” “to a blue” “star in just a couple of thousand years, as that evolutionary timeline takes millions of years.” Therefore, “Modern astrophysics” models are broken thus “Modern astrophysics” is a Big Bang leap of faith.


This post continues post #303.


You believe astronomer Hubble’s bubble red-shift, but you disbelieve astronomer Ptolemy’s perceived red-spectral.


Your science is biased, so you fail to exercise the objective scientific method.


You exalt yourself as a godlike authority to disqualify the human witness of a red Sirius by Ptolemy of Alexandria, but you merely preach your nonsense nonscience Big Bang belief.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #272: @Kermos Ancient descriptions describe the bright Sirius as fiery red or ruddy around 2000 years ago. Modern appearance. Sirius is clearly a brilliant blue-white star today. While the red-blue shift in Cosmology relates to light spectra in an expanding universe, but neither involves Sirius changing colour because of the Big Bang.


Since current astrophysicists, astronomers, and university professors preach, teach, and believe the red-shift and blue-shift doctrine, then Sirius changing color has serious problematic consequences for the Big Bang.


You should understand physics before you post, Debby, because FLRW’s 3rd point in his post which follows your post (and to which you replied in your post #306) shows the astronomer astrologers urgent requirement to crush their theological opposition about Sirius changing from red to blue because such a serious Sirius change in color proves their Big Bang god is false.


You finally correspond about evidence after so many emotional posts, but you essentially admit the light arriving at Earth is merely “light spectra” which is the point I conveyed before you posted.


Your purported “expanding universe” viewport is far, far too small to determine whether the universe is expanding, see the Episcopic Model, spatial limitations, too vast a visage, in post #53 and the Zenith Model, temporal limitations, too titanic a timespan, in post #53.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #272: snip… redshift is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon …snip


In a well illuminated display of historical ignorance by a MIT graduate nuclear scientist, you omitted the ancient historian and astronomer Ptolemy’s record that the star named Sirius, known as the Star of Isis in ancient Egypt, was described as red, but Sirius is currently blue. This change describes (1) a stellar u-turn from an Earth bound vantage point which astronomer astrologers claim cannot occur as rapidly as the Sirius change time-line, or (2) Sirius merely producing higher concentration of blue-spectral light instead of red-spectral light.


I demonstrated the Big Bang is a leap of faith in my post #271, including the good evidence about human witness record of Sirius’ red to blue change of color.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #293: The statement is incorrect; the Doppler effect does apply to light. Similar to sound …snip


Mr. relative “to Albert Einstein through the Koch family” - FLRW with your prestigious MIT issued nuclear scientist collegiate certificate, who repeats his red-shift leap of faith responses lacking scientific method based evidence (aka ground for belief (post #25),


Astronomer astrologers conjured the Doppler effect for light as a successor to the Doppler effect for sound:

  1. The Doppler effect for sound adheres to the scientific method.
  2. The Doppler effect for light adheres not to the scientific method.


As shown in my post #271, the environment for sound in Earth’s atmosphere strikingly differs from the environment for light in space.


Your nonsense nonscience statement resides in your fantasy because the waves are fundamentally different waves. Sound waves vibrate a molecule maintaining localized proximity yet transferring energy to the next molecule which repeats the cycle through the Earth’s atmosphere; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles; therefore, the Doppler effect applies to sound, but the Doppler effect applies not to light (see also post #53).

Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift


“A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


Einstein’s formula E=MC2 has high relation to red-shift. Red-shift’s high energy, high frequency light deteriorates into low energy, low frequency light at the time of emission, and astronomer astrologers believe this reveals age, distance, and/or direction of celestial objects. Einstein’s formula E=MC2 is in permanent equilibrium between energy (E) and mass (M) and speed_of_light (C). Since E=MC2 needs to be maintain equilibrium with the red-shift massless (M) photon, then the commutative property of mathematics keeps the equation’s balance by moving energy (E) to the speed_of_light (C). In essence, E=MC2 forces an increase to the speed of light under the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. redshift.


I obtained the following from 4.5: The Doppler Effect at LibreTexts with respect to red-shift:

The relationship between the degree of shift in wavelength to the speed of the object is found by:
Apparent wavelength/true frequency = true wavelength/apparent frequency = 1 + recession velocity/wave speed.
Since the speed of light in a vacuum, c, is a constant, the speed of the object can be found with the following equation:
Δλ/λ = v/c
Where Δλ is the change in wavelength, λ is the normal or laboratory wavelength of the light, and v is the relative speed of the source toward or away from the observer.


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error.


You need to mess with adjusting the C (constant representing the speed of light at 186,000 miles per second) in Einstein’s E=MC2, but you are left with a MESS in so doing because light pushes beyond 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years which translates to light moving faster, much faster than your C of 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years (a.k.a. velocity well beyond 186,000 miles per second), so light speedily traverses the 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 mile distance in some unknown amount of the time, for example, maybe 2 days. I remind you in my post #199 to you regarding Einstein’s Special Relativity Theory where I detailed that Rowland explained a time element is absent from E=MC2.


Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light exists not; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.


This post supplements my post #275.


A Big Bang cosmic distance ladder’s foundational rung is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #292: The statement is incorrect; the Doppler effect does apply to light.  Similar to sound …snip


MITman flops again,


Circular reasoning dominates your and astronomer astrologer’s star bible red-shift.


Scientific method experiment, observation, and confirmation are all missing for red-shift (the Doppler effect for light).


The nonscience red-shift hypothesis points at the conclusion while the nonscience red-shift conclusion points back at the hypothesis.


This red-shift hypothesis:

red spectral light received from a star in space indicates the star’s direction of travel away and great distance from Earth.

points at this red-shift conclusion:

stars receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion trail longer red spectral light.

yet, this red-shift conclusion points at this red-shift hypothesis:

red spectral light received from a star in space indicates the star’s direction of travel away and great distance from Earth.

and the loop continues because this red-shift hypothesis points at this red-shift conclusion:

stars receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion trail longer red spectral light.

and your circular reasoning loop goes on and on - that’s called an infinite loop, MITman. Red-shift is nonsense nonscience.


Astronomer astrologers declare their Big Bang star bible is right because they say their Big Bang star bible declares itself right.


The scientific method supports the Doppler effect for sound.


This post extends post #283.


The Big Bang is a leap of faith built on red-shift that is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #290: @Kermos I am going to act presidential here. You are dumb as fuck.
@FLRW wrote in post #291: …snip…
@FLRW wrote in post #294: …snip…


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted extremely emotional content at the expense of intelligent MIT certified nuclear scientist quality specific evidence. Your vulgar demeanor epitomizes the Pharmakeia Principle (see post #71 for details).


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
Debby wrote in post #287: @Kermos The Big Bang is …snip
Debby wrote in post #289: @Kermos You make a …snip
Debby wrote in post #297: @Kermos The Big …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #272: snip… redshift is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon …snip


FLRW, the scientific method’s hypothesis phase requires a natural phenomenon just as LiveScience indicates with “A scientific hypothesis is a tentative, testable explanation for a phenomenon in the natural world. It’s the initial building block in the scientific method” (again, see the LiveScience link in the original post or select this LiveScience link).


Red-shift’s hypothesis violates the scientific method because man observes not a natural phenomenon (stars detectably receding) in order to “discover” the explanation for said natural phenomenon, so red-shift is part of the astronomer astrologer’s magical, mystical star bible.


In Truth (John 14:6), red-spectral light “is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon”.


FLRW, you lampoon science with your “redshift is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon” deception.


This post extends post #286.


In fact, the Big Bang fails the scientific method’s hypothesis phase because no human observed your purported Big Bang natural phenomenon; therefore, the Big Bang is disqualified as scientific fact, so the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #284: Yes, the Doppler effect applies to light as well as sound and other waves.


Only in your fantasy because you clumsily neglected to address the “Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift” of my post #283 to you. Your composition is riddled with belief without proof (assumptions).


You are incapable of debating scientific method fact just as the evidence of your postings show that you fail to logically argue against my posts to you (another case in point, besides the current, is post 258 which you STILL fail to logically argue against the "Coup de Grâce: Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model).


The Doppler effect applies not to light, so your red-shift for your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #272: snip… redshift is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon …snip


MITman,


Circular reasoning dominates your and astronomer astrologer’s star bible red-shift.


Scientific method experiment, observation, and confirmation are all missing for red-shift.


The nonscience red-shift hypothesis points at the conclusion while the nonscience red-shift conclusion points back at the hypothesis.


This red-shift hypothesis:

red spectral light received from a star in space indicates the star’s direction of travel away and great distance from Earth.

points at this red-shift conclusion:

stars receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion trail longer red spectral light.

yet, this red-shift conclusion points at this red-shift hypothesis:

red spectral light received from a star in space indicates the star’s direction of travel away and great distance from Earth.

and the loop continues because this red-shift hypothesis points at this red-shift conclusion:

stars receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion trail longer red spectral light.

and your circular reasoning loop goes on and on. Red-shift is nonsense nonscience.


Astronomer astrologers declare their Big Bang star bible is right because they say their Big Bang star bible declares itself right.


This post extends post #283.


The Big Bang is a leap of faith built on red-shift that is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #272: snip… redshift is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon …snip


Mr. relative “to Albert Einstein through the Koch family”,


Astronomer astrologers conjured the Doppler effect for light as a successor to the Doppler effect for sound:

  1. The Doppler effect for sound adheres to the scientific method.
  2. The Doppler effect for light adheres not to the scientific method.


As shown in my post #271, the environment for sound in Earth’s atmosphere strikingly differs from the environment for light in space.

Energy Displacement inside E=MC2 regarding the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. red-shift


“A photon of violet light, therefore, has more energy than a photon of red light” (from 4.1: Wave Properties at LibreTexts).


Einstein’s formula E=MC2 has high relation to red-shift. Red-shift’s high energy, high frequency light deteriorates into low energy, low frequency light at the time of emission, and astronomer astrologers believe this reveals age, distance, and/or direction of celestial objects. Einstein’s formula E=MC2 is in permanent equilibrium between energy (E) and mass (M) and speed_of_light (C). Since E=MC2 needs to be maintain equilibrium with the red-shift massless (M) photon, then the commutative property of mathematics keeps the equation’s balance by moving energy (E) to the speed_of_light (C). In essence, E=MC2 forces an increase to the speed of light under the Doppler effect for light a.k.a. redshift.


I obtained the following from 4.5: The Doppler Effect at LibreTexts with respect to red-shift:

The relationship between the degree of shift in wavelength to the speed of the object is found by:
Apparent wavelength/true frequency = true wavelength/apparent frequency = 1 + recession velocity/wave speed.
Since the speed of light in a vacuum, c, is a constant, the speed of the object can be found with the following equation:
Δλ/λ = v/c
Where Δλ is the change in wavelength, λ is the normal or laboratory wavelength of the light, and v is the relative speed of the source toward or away from the observer.


No scientific method procedure used a man controlled, receding, light emmitting object to measure a purported frequency shift of light (more specifically, red-shift), so your Δλ/λ = v/c formula is akin to the William and Valdemar example of post #118 showing the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error.


You need to mess with adjusting the C (constant representing the speed of light at 186,000 miles per second) in Einstein’s E=MC2, but you are left with a MESS in so doing because light pushes beyond 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years which translates to light moving faster, much faster than your C of 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 miles per billion years (a.k.a. velocity well beyond 186,000 miles per second), so light speedily traverses the 6,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 mile distance in some unknown amount of the time, for example, maybe 2 days. I remind you in my post #199 to you regarding Einstein’s Special Relativity Theory where I detailed that Rowland explained a time element is absent from E=MC2.


Scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for light exists not; in contrast, scientific method validation of the Doppler effect for sound exists. The result is that red-shift is merely red-spectral.


This post supplements my post #275.


A Big Bang cosmic distance ladder’s foundational rung is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #281: @Kermos Specific scientific method based analysis can be found in the big Bang theory and how they arrived at the conclusion. It was then adopted by the scientific community when it passed their scientific requirements.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted recently repeated generalized emotion by you at the expense of specific evidence for the Big Bang.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #279: snip… F …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence for the Big Bang.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #276: @Kermos He provided other scientific theories to support his position on the Big Bang. He has not yet resorted to a leap of faith.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


Big Bang philosophers are in a leap of faith.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #273: The claim that the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is “very bad evidence” for the Big Bang is contested; …snip


Mr. MIT Trained Nuclear Scientist,


By virtue of you contesting the quality of CMBR evidence, you admit that that your CMBR position is focused on grounds for belief; in other words, you have a leap of faith for your CMBR as a historical Universe age indicator. I previously presented the dictionary definition of “evidence” in post #25, and the “evidence” concept indicates “grounds for belief” or “grounds for disbelief”.


Not a single one of your points addressed my points presented in my post #271. I outlined the error of your history of the CMBR. I mathematically detailed the opposite of astronomer astrologer’s conclusion of decreasing temperature over time which places your/their increasing temperature going backward in time squarely as a leap of faith.


Your arguing against other people’s arguments illuminates your “scientific” inability to address my arguments recorded in my post #271.


Your good evidence for CMBR is red-shift (see your point 3), yet I demonstrated that redshift is poor evidence in my post #271.


You failed to show fact for your Big Bang, so your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #272: snip… redshift is a robust, empirically verified phenomenon …snip


In typical nonscience scientist fashion, you stated as fact without any scientific method results as support for your unsupported statement, so you stated your leap of faith.


On the contrary, I provided the astrophysicist produced paper in which sstronomers discovered a quasar with an enormously ancient redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal). Red-shift as a distance and age calculator is falsified.


Kermos

Scientific Proof That The Big Bang Is A Leap Of Faith

1. Red-shift Is Merely Red-spectral


Red-shift is one of astronomer astrologer’s star bible pillar foundations.

Redshift collapses under the Scientific Method


First, let’s look at a examination of red-shift, which astronomer astrologers base on the so-called doppler effect of light, in the light of the scientific method:

  1. Phase: activity
  2. hypothesis: red spectral light received from a star in space indicates the star’s direction of travel away and great distance from Earth.
  3. experiment: no test cases.
  4. observation: none of experiments.
  5. conclusion: stars receding away from Earth with distances of monumental proportion trail longer red spectral light.
  6. confirmation: no experiments to repeat.


Red-shift conjecturers abysmally failed to completely apply the scientific method. Red-shift as a distance determinant is not science.

Waveforms, it gets worse for red-shift conjecturers


Astronomer astrologers are using the nonsense nonscience doppler effect of light based on their assumptions, not science.


Sound waves are atmospheric tightly localized particle vibrations passed from particle to particle; on the other hand, light waves are projectile particles.


As an example of the doppler effect, when a fast moving train blows it’s whistle while passing a person, then the pitch increases on approach to the person (sound wave compression) and the pitch decreases as the train races toward the horizon (sound wave decompression) as the train leaves the person; however, red-shift conjecturers have no such proof for the doppler effect of light except for their hypothesis pointing at their conclusion joined with their conclusion pointing at their hypothesis.

Astronomical Observations, red shift sinks further into the abyss


Astronomers discovered a quasar with an enormous redshift embedded inside a nearby to Earth spiral galaxy with far lower red-shift, so these two celestial objects that need to be the same distance away from Earth due to the collocation are simultaneously greatly separated because of red-shift (both conditions cannot be true). The galaxy is reportedly 300 million light years away while the quasar within the heart of the galaxy is reportedly several billion light years away (source “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper readily publicly available from Table of contents for issue 1, volume 620, The Astrophysical Journal). Red-shift as a distance calculator is falsified.

History, red-shift rapidly morphs into blue-shift


Sirius was known as the Star of Isis in ancient Egypt and was described as red, but Sirius is blue, now. This change describes a stellar u-turn.

Conclusion for astronomer astrologer pillar of red-shift


Stellar red-shift is really stellar red-spectral frequency production.


Red-shift is an observed phenomena without a scientific explanation of “why”.


Astronomer astrologers used a ridiculously miniscule observational window in terms of space and time in order to believe in their Big Bang (see the Zenith Model and the Episcopic Model in post #53).


Big Bang believer’s star bible red-shift massive star distances doctrine and tremendously ancient billions of years old universe is a leap of faith.

2. Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR)


CMBR is another of astronomer astrologer’s star bible pillar foundations.


Big Bang adherents lie along the lines of “In 1965, astronomers accidentally discovered faint microwave radiation coming from every direction in space”, and here is the proof of concept.


I present to you the history which reveals CMB was a known quantity decades before 1965. This directly derails nonscience scientists “fact” leaving a mere residual called “faith”.


Andrew McKellar used W. S. Adams’ spectroscopic instrumentation during 1941 to measure background temperature of 2.3 K of a B type star.


In 1948, cosmologist George Gamow led a group that calculated cosmic microwave radiation.


The vaunted Bell Telephone Laboratories had a facility atop Crawford Hill in Holmdel, New Jersey where Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson experimented in 1964. They detected a homogeneous, constant radiation. They were awarded the Nobel Prize in 1978 for their CMB work.


Robert H. Dicke, Jim Peebles, and David Wilkinson, astrophysicists at Princeton University believed the Big Bang emitted a tremendous radiation blast resulting in cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR), and they prepared to investigate microwave radiation levels in the year 1964.


But, Bernard F. Burke, professor of physics at MIT, introduced the two groups working a mere 40 miles from each other.


The two groups agreeably jointly published in Astrophysical Journal Letters. Two notes were published, (1) Dicke et al substantiated the Big Bang based on CMBR, and (2) Penzias et al noted the existence of 3.5 K CMBR universally.


In essence, Big Bang philosopher history of

In 1965, astronomers accidentally discovered faint microwave radiation coming from every direction in space. The Big Bang predicted decades earlier that if the universe began in an extremely hot state, it should leave behind cooled radiation filling the cosmos. That’s exactly what was found

deceives people.

Scientist’s, er, philosopher’s public CMBR deception


It is time to compare and contrast these data collections:

  1. McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K


Big Bang philosophers manipulation of statistics (mathematical nonsense) to arrive at “It has almost exactly the predicted temperature (2.725 K)” is a deeper lie and malevolent representation.


The astrophysicist Stephen Hawking said of astronomer astrologers, “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”, so keep his words in mind while reading the following.

CMBR UnSETtling Theory


Set theory is fascinating, and set theory is destructive to Big Bang philosophers argument.

  1. McKellar (1941): M = {x ∈ R | 1.8 ≤ x ≤ 3.4}
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): P = {x ∈ R | 2.5 ≤ x ≤ 4.5}


M and P represent two mutually exclusive, independent and discreet studies.


M=P is false.


M∩P is a range of real number temperature elements that potentially one set can be greater than or lesser than the temperature in the opposing set (except for the boundaries which would be equality on one side), so M∩P elements are excluded from this evaluation because these cancel each other out. This leaves the elements represented in MΔP.


MΔP is the range of real number temperature elements that uniquely qualify as exclusively greater than or less than the temperature in the opposing set, so MΔP is included in this evaluation.


Proof samples:

  1. M∩P and M>P, M=3.2 and P=3.1
  2. M∩P and M<P, M=3.1 and P=3.2
  3. MΔP and M>P, nonexistent
  4. MΔP and M<P, M=1.8 and P=4.5
  5. MΔP and M<P, M=2.4 and P=3.5


The exemplary intersection (M∩P) elements of 3.1 and 3.2 sufficiently illustrate the cancelation effect of the corresponding intersection elements.


The result is M<P.


The CMBR temperature increases going forward in time according to this logic demonstrated using set theory which indicates a lower temperature in the past.


Set theory applied to Big Bang adherents star bible data upends their “the universe began in an extremely hot state” faith based statement.

CMBR Average Disformity


Scientists like averages (mean), or medians, or blind faith guesses, such as your “2.725 K” CMBR temperature, so I present the mean temperature values to test their conclusion that there has been a decrease in the temperature over the years.


The data averaged:

  1. McKellar (1941): 2.5
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): 3.5


2.5=3.5 is false.


2.5<3.5 is true.


1941<1965 is true.


3.5-2 5=1.0 is true.


1965-1941=24 is true.


The five factual statements directly above show a 1.0 K increase of heat on average over a period of 2 dozen years starting in 1941 AD until 1965 AD.


A decrease in heat temperature from 1941 to 1965 is the Big Bang adherent’s requirement, but it’s just not there, so their CMBR is very bad evidence for their Big Bang.

CMBR Logical Conclusion


The above dissection of astronomer astrologer data shows that these are each distinctly different surveys:

  1. McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K
  2. Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K


McKellar (1941): (2.5 +0.9/-0.7) K is not isotropic agreement with Penzias and Wilson (1965): (3.5 +/- 1.0) K.


Statistical consolidation of the points is unreasonable because reasonable doubt has been cast by the potential for decreased temperature in earlier time thus anyone claiming increased temperature is a person defying the logical conclusion from the data; in other words, one cannot logically claim that there was a high heat temperature deep in the past around their Big Bang timeframe which would make the differences in points statistically insignificant. The differences in points are statistically significant as a function of the recorded increase in temperature over the decades, yet astronomer astrologers exhibit Stephen Hawking’s quote, recorded above.


In other words, these measurements are in agreement with one another that the Big Bang is a leap of faith/belief.


Deception of the CMBR is a very poor method to present the astronomer astrologers case.


Various sources of material for this whole CMBR section include “cosmic microwave background” of Encyclopedia Britannica, “Cosmic microwave background” of Wikipedia, and “A Review of the 1941 to 1961 CMBR Temperature Measurements” on ResearchGate.


The Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation is very bad evidence for the Big Bang. Logically, astronomer astrologers strong evidence of the CMBR represents strong grounds for disbelief in the Big Bang.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #268: @Kermos For those who are not good at science, the scientific theory the Big Bang is a leap of faith.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


Your Big Bang is your leap of faith.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #264: Hmmmm, No. The big bang theory is a scientific theory, you see. Christianity is faith-based. It is a religion.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


The Big Bang Conjecture is not of the scientific method, so the Big Bang is not scientific. The Big Bang is evolution religion. The Big Bang is faith based.


You remain in a Big Bang Einstein’s Relativity theories with the Minkowski spacetime model leap of faith as demonstrated in post #199 and post #258.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #261: Does anyone else think that Kermos has a cross on his right cheek?


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


You exhibited the Pharmakeia Principle post #71. I told you that “your position is so very weak that you cannot defend against the Big Bang being a leap of faith”.

You remain in a Big Bang Einstein’s Relativity theories with the Minkowski spacetime model leap of faith as demonstrated in post #199 and post #258.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #260: Hmmmm, Mass turns into energy whenever a system loses bound energy or particles vanish into radiation. 1. Nuclear Fission: When heavy atoms like uranium split apart in power plants or atomic bombs, the remaining pieces weigh slightly less than the original atom. That missing mass becomes heat and radiation. 2. Nuclear Fusion: When light atoms like hydrogen fuse together to form helium inside the Sun, the resulting helium nucleus has less mass than the separate hydrogen parts. The difference turns into sunlight and heat.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalization about nuclear physics at the expense of specification regarding the Big Bang.


You remain in a Big Bang Einstein’s Relativity theories with the Minkowski spacetime model leap of faith as demonstrated in post #199 and post #258.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.