Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #259: The Big Bang Theory originated in the scientific community and has remained so. The Big Bang Theory is taught around the world in schools as a scientific model for the origin of the universe. Education does not depend on a leap of faith but tried and true methods.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #256: There is no valid scientific evidence to relegate Einstein’s Relativity or the Minkowski spacetime model to the “dung heap.” …snip


There is valid scientific evidence to relegate Einstein’s Relativity with the Minkowski spacetime model to the “dung heap”, and I presented the evidence in post #199, yet you spent the duration of your entire post #256 conveying “I state fact because I state fact”, yet your fact is truly faith, so you provided no scientifically strong evidence to discredit Rowland’s propositions recorded in post #199.


You and your Big Bang high priests being wrong over the decades does not make you right. You act like William and Valdemar as exemplified in post #118.


I remind you that I declared to you, “your position is so very weak that you cannot defend against the Big Bang being a leap of faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #255: @Kermos The Big Bang theory is taught in schools around the world as the standard scientific model for the origin of the Universe. Case closed.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


The Big Bang is a leap of faith.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #246: Both nuclear power and nuclear weapons are derived from one principle; that mass can be converted into energy, and the equation that exactly predicts that conversion is E = mc2. So what has that to do with Special Relativity? The answer is that E = mc2 is derived directly from Special Relativity. If relativity is wrong, then nuclear weapons simply wouldn’t work. Any theory or point of view that opposes Special Relativity must explain where E = mc2 comes from if not relativity. Other models of relativity that contain E = mc2 exist but here we are concerned with the standard model as proposed by Einstein. OMG, is Kermos really Jelly Roll ?


If your post is your best effort to respond to my post #199 which contains strong evidence to relegate Einstein’s Relativity with the Minkowski spacetime model to the leap of faith camp, then your best effort failed miserably and your best effort is less than remedial.


E=MC2 is not the nuclear energy formula. You should have scienced (known) this very simple basic fact, MITman.


As far as nuclear weapons,.. wait for it,.. E=MC2 is not the formula for the first atom bomb which was detonated at Trinity Site. Your MIT education should have taught you that, Mr. Scientist!


As a matter of scientific fact, you do not factually know (science) that E=MC2 is a valid representation of all physical phenomenon, and I can prove it!


Now to this proof I mentioned, back in the Big Bang related Friedmann equations section of post #149, I recorded the logical conclusion of your Friedmann equations which is that E=MC2 was not in force during a portion of the Universe time of existence.


That “mass can be converted into energy” requires not E=MC2 to be a fact; in other words, some other equation could define the process by which “mass can be converted into energy”.


Your claim “If relativity is wrong, then nuclear weapons simply wouldn’t work” is composed as a statement of fact, but that is truly your statement of faith. A factual statement is “If ‘mass can be converted into energy’ is wrong, then nuclear weapons simply wouldn’t work”.


Your claim “Any theory or point of view that opposes Special Relativity must explain where E = mc2 comes from if not relativity” is your statement of faith. You believe withiut proof (assume) E=MC2 remains fact apart from Einstein’s Special Relativity.

Coup de Grâce: Einstein’s Relativity Theories with the Minkowski Spacetime Model

You spent your post defending E=MC2 primarily as a function of relatively current human witness.


In post #199, the post #199 which I challenged you to respond to prove whether you are a coward or condescender or courageous, I spent the post #199 primarily as a function of all human witness even the purportedly before human witness.


That personal “Jelly Roll” maneuver of yours was an act of cowardice as evidenced by your deviation from any explicit mention of the Minkowski spacetime, so you failed to address post #199 in context.


Your final sentence was your insecurity manifesting as your self-perceived superiority in a state of condescension toward me, so between your exposed cowardice and condescension, you projected the Pharmakeia Principle post #71.


You have shown your real “degree from MIT in Nuclear Engineering Science” colors, there Mr. Scientist.


You really emMITted error and faith in your response to my post #199, so I remind you that I declared to you, “your position is so very weak that you cannot defend against the Big Bang being a leap of faith”.

Gravitational lensing is a leap of faith

You seem easily distracted, so I remind you that since Einstein’s Relativity theories with the Minkowski spacetime model are leaps of faith, then your gravitational lensing regarding the Big Bang is a leap of faith. Do know (science) that predecessor posts on this matter are post #61, post #87, post #93, and post #199.


You preach that you know (science) massive stellar distances while determining extremely ancient stellar objects because you know (science) gravitational lensing works; however, the above discussion proves that your pillar (Einstein’s Relativity theories with the Minkowski spacetime model) is not established fact for gravitational lensing; therefore, you are left with the residual fact that you are in a leap of faith for the Big Bang.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #240: Did you know that Stephen Hawking accepted the scientific evidence for the physical Big Bang theory and also happily approved of and appeared on the TV show The Big Bang Theory. 


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


Look, Mr. Scientist, your post there is not an analytical response to my post #199 about which I asked whether you a coward or condescender or courageous to respond to my post. My post contains strong evidence to relegate Einstein’s Relativity with the Minkowski spacetime model to the dung heap.


As to your current post, Steven Hawking is not specific evidence for the Big Bang. He is demonstration of the application of his own words “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science” to himself.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #239: @Kermos The Big Bang predicted an expanding universe which has been confirmed . There are other factors predicted as an outcome has also been confirmed. Thus gaining acceptance by the scientific community.


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


Post #53 and post #82 logically demonstrates the fallacy of your opening two sentences.


Also, post #214 shows that your emotions are incorrect.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #238: I like …snip


Mr. Scientist, I departed that site when the moderator suspended my account for me not complying with his demand that I write his lies as if they were true. That was not open debate on the subject matter, but that was censorship and tyrannical behavior, in fact, the “scientist” moderator’s behavior was proof for the Pharmakeia Principle (see post #71 for an explanation of the principle).


Now, your position is so very weak that you cannot defend against the Big Bang being a leap of faith.


Are you a coward or condescender or courageous?


I remind you of post #199 regarding the steong evidence to relegate Einstein’s Relativity with the Minkowski spacetime model to the dung heap.


C’mon MITman, YOU ARE HERE AND SO AM I, so show who you are. Respond to post #199!


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #236: See: ht …snip


Mr. Scientist, that link demonstrates the fear of exposure inside of you nonscience Big Bang adherents. Your Big Bang Belief system falls apart under logic, linguistics, and spiritually. The moderator at that site closed the thread before I could issue a response to posts 2, 3, or 4.


However, over on Science Forums ( https://www.sciforums.com/threads/show-me-how-the-big-bang-theory-is-not-a-leap-of-faith.167184/ ), the conversation exceeded 1,000 posts.


Cowardly or condescending or courageous.


I remind you of post #199 regarding Einstein’s Relativity with the Minkowski spacetime model to which you have failed to respond as of yet.


C’mon MITman, YOU ARE HERE, NOW, so show who your are. Respond to post #199!


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #233: @Kermos The Big Bang already makes a scientific case for its theory based on science and observation. …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


Post #214 shows that your emotions are incorrect.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Sidewalker wrote in post #224: @Kermos INTELLIGENCE HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT You failed to use intelligence in your posts.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.

PROOF: You failed to use intelligence in your posts.


Post #87 details your unintelligent thoughts that 6=5,110,000,000,000. You called that equation your “best science” (your best knowledge).


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #198: @Kermos The Big Bang theory is a scientific theory. Science is not based on faith but evidence.
@Debby wrote in post #219: @Kermos The Big Bang is supported by a large amount of observational evidence. It is a scientific theory therefore it is not subjected to religious faith. The Big Bang and creation are fundamentally compatible as viewed by scientist and theologians.
@Debby wrote in post #221: @Kermos The Big Bang and creation are fundamentally compatible as viewed by scientist and theologians.
@Debby wrote in post #223: @Kermos If you don’t believe in science or understand it, the Big Bang will be difficult to accept.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


Your posted generalized emotion at the expense of specific evidence.


Post #214 shows that your emotions are incorrect.


If you present specific scientific method based analysis about your Big Bang Conjecture, then, the Lord willing, I will respond.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@fauxlaw wrote in post #209: @Kermos In your #181, you criticized FLRW


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You may sit on your own “stool in a corner”. You mentioned the Minkowski spacetime model diagram of post #199, yet you failed to mention the diagram’s “scientifically” recognized name, so you simple-mindedly referred to the diagram as “a double-cone illustration” by which you demonstrated your scientific ineptitude.


You can keep your “proper respect” for the Big Bang Evolution Religion because it’s abbadon (destruction). You didn’t know that because you think it’s creation. Big Bang adherents are against Christ. The Big Bang is not of the scientific method.


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #200: Wtf does relativity have to do with anything?


You requested schooling about the Big Bang’s relationship with Einstein’s relativity theories, so I’m assigning for you to read the content of the following list of posts in order to comprehend the subject matter as well as the current state of this thread, provided your mind can handle it:

  1. post #61
  2. post #87
  3. post #93
  4. post #199
@Magoroth wrote in post #200: If relativity is just fictional fantasy why is it that it explains the motion of planets better than Newton’s theory of gravity?


See the above list for content which emblazons the error embedded in your question.

@Magoroth wrote in post #200: Also energy-matter equivalence is not a myth you can literally turn energy into matter or vice versa.


I don’t find the word “myth” in the post to which you quoted, but I’m not skipping this.


As you can see in post #149, the MIT scholar scientist, @FLRW, wrote “At time=0 the Universe was at zero size” based upon his presentation of the Friedmann equations; therefore, your formula E=MC2 (energy-matter equivalence) existed not according to your nonscience scientist buddies.


Regardless of which formula that you employ, you end up with an irrationally illogical universe beginning. Your Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #196: @Kermos The Big Bang theory is not a leap of faith because there are no other theories competing with it. The Bible also says the universe was created spread over time. The Big Bang supports the Bible story of creation because there are no universe came from nothing.


There you go again with your unsupported by fact statement of “The Big Bang theory is not a leap of faith”; therefore, your statement is a leap of faith!


You are not a believer in Christ because you do not believe “All things were made through Him, and without Him was not any thing made that was made.” (John 1:3)


Your “no universe came from nothing” rejects the “All things” of the Apostle John.


This post stands with post #214.


You failed, AGAIN, to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #193: The Big Bang theory is not a leap of faith


You throw out your unsupported faith right there instead of presenting scientific fact. Your science is sloppy, and your debate tactics are abysmal.

@FLRW wrote in post #193: because it relies on mathematical models,


I showed you the Minkowski spacetime model fault in post #199, so you crying “we have models” is nothing more than your leap of faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #193: testable predictions,


That’s impossible (see post #82 for detailed explanation).

@FLRW wrote in post #193: and hard physical evidence.


You presented absolutely no good evidence up to this point. You produced summary instead of detail.

@FLRW wrote in post #193: Unlike faith, which accepts unproven beliefs, the scientific model of the universe changes and updates when new data arrives.


You pronounce yourself MIT science man, but you don’t practice the scientific method, here anyway.


The Big Bang violates the scientific method as shown in post #53, so that leaves the Big Bang as a leap of faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #193: Isn’t children dying from leukemia proof of no God.


Leukemia is proof of evil man.


You failed, AGAIN, to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #191: The BigBang theory is not an act of faith because it is backed by science. Just like God’s. creation of the world is backed by the Bible. Both theories use time to determine the elements of creation.

God’s creation is not a theory, as you put it.

You present zero scientific method fact, so your Big Bang belief is your faith foundation. Lord Jesus Christ says “Everyone who hears these words of Mine and does not act on them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and it fell—and great was its fall.” (Matthew 7:26-27).


For us Christians, Christ is our glorious foundation. Lord Jesus Christ says “everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and yet it did not fall, for it had been founded on the rock.” (Matthew 7:24-25).


If you are a Christian, then you believe that all occurrences of six days in the fourth Commandment exclusively refer to 24 hour per day literal six days. Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God commands:

Remember the sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a sabbath of the LORD your God; in it you shall not do any work, you or your son or your daughter, your male or your female servant or your cattle or your sojourner who stays with you. For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea and all that is in them, and rested on the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the sabbath day and made it holy.

(Exodus 20:8-11)


If you are a Christian, then you believe that Adam and Eve were there at the beginning of creation when the six days of making all the stars and planets and Earth culminated with God creating man (Genesis 1:1-31). Lord Jesus Christ is the Word of God (John 1:14), and the Word of God declares:

He who created them from the beginning “made them male and female”

(Matthew 19:4).


Your writing, there, is concurrent with unbelievers, that is, you reject the Word of God.


Georges Lemaître, a Belgian priest, is essentially credited as a father of the Big Bang Baby by @Sidewalker a few posts ago in post #189. Roman Catholic Church (RCC) priests are called father by RCC church members and even some non-church members. Lord Jesus Christ says “Do not call anyone on earth your father; for One is your Father, He who is in heaven.” (Matthew 23:9), so the Roman Catholic Church rejected Christ’s Commandment; therefore, Lemaître was not a Christian by that account. Lemaître’s sins includes leading fools into believing things like “According to our best science, six days is 14 billion years”. (see post #20 and post #87 for more details).


Lemaître was an unbeliever.


The Apostle Peter warned us Christians about people like Lemaître by writing:

false prophets also arose among the people, as false teachers will also be among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, denying even the Master who bought them, bringing on themselves swift destruction. (2 Peter 2:1)

Many will follow their immoral ways, and as a result, the way of the truth will be maligned. (2 Peter 2:2)

this is hidden from them willingly, that the heavens were long ago, and the earth, out of water and through water having been composed by the Word of God, (2 Peter 3:5)

You therefore, beloved, knowing these things beforehand, beware, lest being carried away with the error of the wicked, you fall from your own steadfastness. (2 Peter 2:1)

The Word of God created the heavens and the earth.

Big Bang Philosophy holds that an evolution god created the heavens and the earth.

Every Big Bang believer is against Christ.

I remind you of your writing “Scientists are still sorting out the inconsistencies in the BigBang theory. Use the Bible to fill in the gaps.” recorded in post #159, so you represented yourself as a Big Bang believer.


You, Debby, willingly yoke yourself with Lemaître.


You leave out facts, but you desperately try to sound like you speak with fact with your “The BigBang theory is not an act of faith because it is backed by science” which is truly your leap of faith!


You failed to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”, again.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #185: @Kermos See ht …snip… Abstract Einstein became world famous …snip… We reanalyze the 1919 data, and identify the error that undermines the conclusions of Earman and Glymour.


You provide no scientific data from your article link. By the way, neither Earman nor Glymour are named Rowland. I quoted detailed scientific data from Rowland’s article in post #61 which culminated with Rowland writing about Eddington, Dyson, and Commelin’s 1919 demonstrated in the provided quote to be sloppy work “The readings themselves were also questionable because of (a) errors in parallax from varying angles of measurement and atmospheric conditions at the respective points of observation, and (b) equipment failure. Results were inconclusive because the error factor was as large as the deviation the experimenters were trying to prove [3]”.


Notice the closing [3] reference in that quote which is the “What Einstein did Not Consider about Gravity” in which Rowland detailed:

In 1908, attempting to better explain his former student’s theory of special relativity (E=mc2), mathematics professor Hermann Minkowski expressed it in terms of a mathematical model that fused time and the three dimensions of space into a single four-dimensional continuum (later known as Minkowski spacetime). Notice two things about this model: Image Figure 1: Hypothetical Minkowski 4-D Spacetime
  1. It is not possible to assign co-ordinates to the hypothetical time axis; and
  2. Because E = mc2 does not include any time variable, there is nowhere said equation fits into this four-dimensional model.
Source of Figure 1: Wikipedia [9].


That’s just a small portion of the logic and rational reasoning in Rowland’s article.


Essentially, Einstein’s General Relativity, Einstein’s Special Relativity, Minkowski spacetime, and related gravitational lensing are fictional fantasy faith, not fact, just faith.


Therefore, your E=MC2 is a leap of faith as support for the Big Bang.


You see, I placed detailed scientific data supported by source link right in front of you, again, but you post nonscience abstract with a source link. Your debate skills are abysmal.


It appears to me that your data is so patheticly paltry that you hide behind your paper’s abstract.


The Big Bang Theory fails to adhere to the Scientific Method. The Big Bang is a leap of faith.


Kermos
@Sidewalker wrote in post #182: @Kermos We put faith in science …snip

You do not put your faith in scientific fact regarding the Big Bang.


Do you recall writing “The universe is expanding - this is a verifiable fact. Trace this expansion back in time and you get to a single dense beginning 13.8 billion years ago” in your post #5?


In effect, you convey that you believe your faith is fact in the combination of your two quotations above. Your mind melds what you call science with faith, but you are wrong.


I demonstrated that your Big Bang expansion of the universe is a leap of faith in post #53, post #61, post #87, and post #93.


You are a Big Bang philosopher. Your faith is not in science. Your faith is in the Big Bang Philosophy.


You confuse science and philosophy.


You have a false god in your Big Bang Conjecture, and your Big Bang priests are leading you toward everlasting torment.


You failed to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #178: @Kermos Belief in the creation of the world billions or thousands of years ago by God or the Big Bang is both an act of faith because no one actually witnessed it.


Please reread this message to you.


Every Big Bang believer is against Christ.


I remind you of your writing “Scientists are still sorting out the inconsistencies in the BigBang theory. Use the Bible to fill in the gaps.” recorded in post #159, so you represented yourself as a Big Bang believer.


You failed to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”, again.


Kermos
@Magoroth wrote in post #172: @Kermos I don’t see what either of these points mean, you could just both be wrong …snip
@Magoroth wrote in post #173: snip… I’ll take any claim that we discovered how the UNIVERSE came to be with a grain of salt …snip
@Magoroth wrote in post #174: 6,000 year old theory is just bigotry …snip
@Magoroth wrote in post #175: As an aside, even if belief in the Big Bang requires faith, it could still be correct and you would be wrong, faith notwothstanding.
@Magoroth wrote in post #176: Like much of what you said regarding evidence for the Big Bang is probably true, it doesn’t prove you right. …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@SergeantLynch wrote in post #170: @Debby, @FLRW, @Kermos Nice data FLRW.


FLRW produced faith based data, not scientific method based data as shown in post #181, so you complimented FLRW’s Big Bang Belief.


You lack scientific method derived fact about the element distribution in the Universe, and you lack fact about the Big Bang, so you are in a Big Bang leap of faith.

@SergeantLynch wrote in post #170: And …snip


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


You failed to address the thread topic of “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #169: The Sun has been shining for 4.6 billion years.


Your statement is faith, not scientific fact.

@FLRW wrote in post #169: Considerable hydrogen has been converted to helium in the core, where the burning is most rapid.


Your statement is a leap of faith. You have NO idea of the Sun’s core.

@FLRW wrote in post #169: The helium remains there, where it absorbs radiation more readily than hydrogen. This raises the central temperature and increases the brightness.


Your statement is speculative faith, not the scientific method about the Sun’s center.

@FLRW wrote in post #169: Model calculations conclude that the Sun becomes 10 percent brighter every billion years;


Your magical, mystical math calculations are your belief system, not a scientific method explanation, so astronomer astrologers deceiving vulnerable people. It’s akin to the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error example of William and Valdemar recorded in post #118.

@FLRW wrote in post #169: hence it must now be at least 40 percent brighter than at the time of planet formation.


You disguise your faith as fact in your statement, there.

@FLRW wrote in post #169: This would produce an increase in Earth’s temperature, but no such effect appears in the fossil record. There were probably compensating thermostatic effects in the atmosphere of Earth, such as the greenhouse effect and cloudiness. The young Sun may also have been more massive, and thus more luminous, and would have lost its early mass through the solar wind. The increase in solar brightness can be expected to continue as the hydrogen in the core is depleted and the region of nuclear burning moves outward. At least as important for the future of Earth is the fact that tidal friction will slow down Earth’s rotation until, in four billion years, its rotation will match that of the Moon, turning once in 30 of our present days.


You speculate, followed by more speculation, with interjections of non big bang argument, extended by more conjecture, expanded by your magical, mystical arts of astronomer astrologers.


You have no scientific proof of the Sun’s internals. The Sun is the closest star to Earth, and you science (know) nothing about the Sun’s core; therefore, your claims about the Sun are leaps of faith.


You don’t know what elements are inside of the Sun, at a mere 8 light minutes from Earth, so you have absolutely no idea of all the elements that could be in the Magellanic Clouds.


I remind you of your astrophysicist Stephen Hawking’s “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”.


The Big Bang is nothing more than a leap of faith. Try as you may, try as you might, you meander in mythical Big Bang mindset.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #168: This is why he could never get into MIT.


THREAD HIJACK ATTEMPT ALERT


So, you convey to me that your perspective of the Massachusetts Indoctrination Temple (MIT) entrance requires the disciple embrace the Big Bang god of MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology).


Or, maybe, you publicly promote MIT has no room for beliefs that oppose MIT preachers’ beliefs; in other words, MIT forbids free dialog and open debate, so MIT dogmatically preaches the Big Bang.


That which you, the disciple of MIT preachers, fail to logically argue, you turn to attack your debate opponent on a personal level (see the Pharmakeia Principle explained in post #71).


Now, back to the section of post #149 that got you to your insult. You failed in your post to touch my analysis of Friedmann equation in relation to your Big Bang belief.



@FLRW wrote in post #131: There are two equations which describe the evolution of the Universe as a whole, and they are called the Friedmann equations: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann_equations Solving the equations gives the size of the Universe as a function of time. At time=0 the Universe was at zero size! …snip


Again, Friedmann sets up 2 equations that maps to his belief system. Again, see your high priest Hawking’s star bible contribution of “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”.


MITman, FLRW, I would like to introduce you to your own intellect of “At time=0 the Universe was at zero size” which means that you believe NOTHING became EVERYTHING.


Don’t bother to theorize what I mean because I’m spelling it out for you. You admitted the universe wasn’t even a small, hot dot in the beginning. You admitted the universe exploded without any detonation accelerants, no TNT, no fission, no fusion.


You have a mystical, magical beginning of all things called the Big Bang. You have entered the faith zone.


I believe YHWH God created everything from nothing about six thousand years ago.


You believe your Big Bang god created everything from nothing about thirteen billion, eight hundred million years ago.


Kermos
@Debby wrote in post #148: @Kermos The Big Bang was an attempt to end the discussion on creation. But obviously it failed.
@Debby wrote in post #150: @Kermos Besides no one heard the sound of the Big Bang. The most obvious case against it.
@Debby wrote in post #160: @Kermos The Big Bang does not change the Christian view of the universe because both creation and the Big Bang had a beginning, both continued the expanding universe and God created the universe for humans. The scientific theory is important to explain the technical details to advance our knowledge of the universe that god created.
@Debby wrote in post #166: That explains why the Bible does not include unverified scientific theories.


Hello this third time Debby,


Every Big Bang believer is against Christ.


I remind you of your writing “Scientists are still sorting out the inconsistencies in the BigBang theory. Use the Bible to fill in the gaps.” recorded in post #159, so you represented yourself as a Big Bang believer.


You failed to “Show Me How The Big Bang Theory Is Not A Leap Of Faith”.


Regards,

Kermos


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #151: @Kermos Scientists know the elements in the sun through spectroscopy,


Your statement is false. Here is the true statement:


Scientists speculate about the elements comprising the sun’s outer layer (surface) through spectroscopy, but the sun’s core is a mystery to mankind.

@FLRW wrote in post #151: which analyzes the unique light signatures (or wavelengths) absorbed or emitted by different chemical elements. When sunlight passes through a prism, dark lines appear in the spectrum. Each element blocks specific wavelengths, acting like a chemical fingerprint.


Now you convey redshift nullification which is that red-shift spectral lines are merely light wavelengths blocked by elements, not your “tired light” recorded in post #165:.

@FLRW wrote in post #151: Why don’t you say what kind of education you have?


Your MIT trained mind neglected a huge swath of important debate points, so, instead of obsessing over my education, why don’t you dig into a non-AI generated point by point response to this post? Or, is your education insufficient to contend.



@FLRW wrote in post #131: @Kermos From: ht …snip… The Big Bang — a rapid expansion of all the universe’s matter from a single point about 13.8 billion years ago — is predicted


Your post starts with your belief that you have “predicted” a 13,800,000,000 year old past purported event called the Big Bang, but you believe you did the impossible of foretelling that 13,800,000,000 year old past event (see the dictionary definition of predict in post #82). A past prediction is a ludicrously inane oxymoron for your 13,800,000,000 year old purported event.


Your “rapid expansion of all the universe” is your unsubstantiated belief because I presented astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, with an international team who produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper which your statement directly contradicts. You have faith that the universe is expanding, yet your faith opposes astrophysicist Burbidge’s faith.

@FLRW wrote in post #131: by theoretical physics,


Where is your scientific method work, Mr. Scientist? Don’t forget astrophysicist Burbidge with his work in The Astrophysical Journal, issue 1, volume 620 mentioned above! You don’t have scientific fact, but you do have belief per your use of the concept “theoretical” fundamentally indicating faith/belief just as shown in the dictionary definition of the word theory recorded in post #20.

@FLRW wrote in post #131: a field that uses math to create consistent theories that explain the physical world we see around us.


Nobody saw the Big Bang, so your Big Bang Theory is inconsistent with the physical world. I demonstrated the broken rungs of your cosmic distance ladder in post #53, yet you come back with hollow comments unsubstantiated by scientific fact regarding the Big Bang, so you sit there with your faith based prognostications without scientific method facts!


By the way, post #118 demonstrated the scientific method (detailed) versus unscientific confirmation of error (William and Valdemar). You mentioned math, but that math remains unsubstantiated by you!

@FLRW wrote in post #131: The amounts of different elements in the universe matches what’s predicted by the theory.


You don’t know what elements are inside of the Sun, at a mere 8 light minutes from Earth, so you have absolutely no idea of all the elements that could be in the Magellanic Clouds.


I remind you of your astrophysicist Stephen Hawking’s “a case of knowing the result they wanted to get, not an uncommon occurrence in science”.

@FLRW wrote in post #131: Because the theory specifies what sorts of elements were created — and in what proportions — moments after the Big Bang, it makes predictions about what elements we’ll see in the universe around us. When we’ve measured the amount of these elements (hydrogen, helium, and lithium), they match the predictions nicely.


Your calculations are designed with the end result in mind. Again, see the William and Valdemar example in post #118. Again, your calculations are similar to the scenario encapsulated in your high priest Hawking’s proverb.

@FLRW wrote in post #131: There are two equations which describe the evolution of the Universe as a whole, and they are called the Friedmann equations: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann_equations Solving the equations gives the size of the Universe as a function of time. At time=0 the Universe was at zero size! …snip


Again, Friedmann sets up 2 equations that maps to his belief system. Again, see your high priest Hawking’s star bible contribution, above.


Mr. Scientist, FLRW, I would like to introduce you to your own intellect of “At time=0 the Universe was at zero size” which means that you believe NOTHING became EVERYTHING.


Don’t bother to theorize what I mean because I’m spelling it out for you. You admitted the universe wasn’t even a small, hot dot in the beginning. You admitted the universe exploded without any detonation accelerants, no TNT, no fission, no fusion.


You have a mystical, magical beginning of all things called the Big Bang. You have entered the faith zone.


I believe YHWH God created everything from nothing about six thousand years ago.


You believe your Big Bang god created everything from nothing about thirteen billion, eight hundred million years ago.


Kermos
@FLRW wrote in post #145: @Kermos Your statement that redshift is merely an untested assumption is incorrect;


Your statement is false. Red-shift is untested according to the scientific method, and red-shift is a belief without proof (assumption), and red-shift is merely red-spectral (see post #53 for details).


I remind you of astrophysicist Geoffrey Burbidge, noted professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California at San Diego’s Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, with an international team of astrophysicists and astronomers who produced the “The Discovery of a High-Redshift X-Ray-Emitting QSO Very Close to the Nucleus of NGC 7319” paper which your statement directly contradicts. You have faith that the universe is expanding, yet your faith opposes astrophysicist Burbidge’s faith.


Since you fight against your own, FLRW, then you are in a state of faith for the Big Bang.

@FLRW wrote in post #145: while the interpretation of redshift as evidence for cosmic expansion is a theoretical model,


Red-shift remains untested in your writing, there.

@FLRW wrote in post #145: 1. Observed Phenomenon: Redshift is the measurable increase in the wavelength of electromagnetic radiation. It is confirmed by spectroscopy, which matches observed spectral lines to known atomic structures, proving the shift is real and not an artifact of measurement.


Your red-shift spectral lines are merely markers of red-spectral light along the light spectrum. Your astronomer astrologers conjured old ages upon older ages based on light and their magical “interpretation” of differing degrees of red light.


Red-shift remains untested in your item 1 writing, there.

@FLRW wrote in post #145: 2. Testing and Validation: The relationship between redshift and distance (Hubble’s Law) is supported by extensive observational data. While there are ongoing debates about the Hubble tension and potential systematic biases, the redshift data itself has been replicated and verified by thousands of scientists over decades.


Your “observational data” fails to support “redshift and distance (Hubble’s Law)” according to astrophysicist Burbidge, mentioned to you above and in previous posts (which you unscientifically ignore, Mr. Scientist).


Your “replicated” red-shift spectral lines are not “verified” using the scientific method.


Your astronomer astrologers conjured up Hubble’s law, V=H0D, and they give each other hearty approval in like manner to William and Valdemar as exemplified in post #118.


Red-shift remains untested in your item 2 writing, there.

@FLRW wrote in post #145: 3. Interpretation vs. Observation: The primary scientific debate centers on the cause of redshift. The standard cosmological model attributes it to the expansion of space (cosmological redshift), while alternative views suggest it may be caused by light attenuation (tired light) or other mechanisms. However, even critics acknowledge the redshift measurement is accurate, disputing only its implication for universal expansion.


Your “debate” fails to be “scientific” because red-shift never achieved scientific method standards.


Your “expansion of space” belief entirely depends on your red-shift belief, so you ride on compounded beliefs without proofs (assumptions).


Look at your ludicrously inane belief without proof (assumption) of “tired light”. People get tired, but light does not get tired, nor does light grow weary!


You climax your item 3 with this ludicrously inane oxymoron “even critics acknowledge the redshift measurement is accurate”.


Red-shift remains untested in your item 3 writing, there.

@FLRW wrote in post #145: In summary, redshift is a well-established empirical observation, not an untested assumption. The controversy lies in whether it is primarily due to Doppler motion, gravitational effects, or the stretching of spacetime.


In summary, observations of red-spectral light are plainly observations of red-spectral light. Observations of red-spectral light tests not for red-shift.


As shown in post #82, the Doppler effect for light is nonsense nonscience.


Your contrived controversy about light between the nonsense nonscience “Doppler motion”, unproven General Relativity “gravitational effects” (Einstein and derivative errors disected in post #61 and post #87 and post #93), and your stretch of faith “stretching of spacetime” all amount to Big Bang as a leap of faith!


Red-shift is an untested belief without proof (assumption).