Kohai's avatar

Kohai

Administrator

Member since

Kohai
Ugh. Maybe Kohai can really be that clueless and town then. Thing is, I don’t see a way around him getting a reveal on his hidden ability for something that isn’t a recruitment bonus


Honestly this is the most frustrating aspect of my role

Kohai

You were the first one to verify it but it’s not like Thoth wouldn’t tell us lol


But I was the one who got Thoth independently confirming wf’s claim

Kohai

Kohai’s behavior has been all over the place tbh. It’s like he’s in pure defensive mode


Honestly I’d rather be the lynch over no lynching two days in a row. At least town can review who was on my wagon.


I’m not being defensive. I am clarifying things that got MIs interpreted

Kohai

Also post 272 I stated what I did because I looked at it from a normal perspective from my usual experience with mafia. An ascetic is immune to all night non-lethal actions which I’d assume would mean they’re immune to recruiting. Thoth clarified that recruit would supersede that. It is a weird order of priority


Also does scum me really verify whiteflame’s claim?

Kohai
Lastly, there’s the cluelessness. early in this DP, he says there’s a recruiter or cult, something that had long been speculated, ignoring clear signs from last day and night that there’s no cult. Then he says we may have multiple recruiters????? (Huh?) Then he thinks the setup is bastard for recruiting multiple people, despite the fact that said recruiter can only get one teammate at the end of it.


I will respond to a few points here:

  1. I am not used to playing games that have recruit mechanics. Alignment changing mechanics are extremely rare on the sites I more frequently play on. I had forgotten just how often these roles are used here
  2. I didn’t believe it would make sense to have a cult and a mafia team in an 8 player game. I was game manager on MU and this would get shot down in a moment.
  3. By definition alignment changing roles are bastard
  4. Everyone claimed to get an offer and that’s what lead me to thinking we may have multiple teams. Again in an 8 player game in what world does it make sense to target the entire town at once? In every single off site game I’ve ever played the cult recruiter can only recruit one per night phase


Kohai
You do realize we have to kill scum eventually, right?


This is honestly the exact problem I have with no lynching two days in a row.

Kohai

In order to solve the game we need to get information that only comes through night kills and lynches. If it turns out that there is no night kills again then we are in the same boat as we are in right now.

Kohai

Kohai - Hitomi Shizuki - Emissary

Vader - Sayaka Miki - 2x Redirector

Mikal - ??? - ???

Pie - ??? - ???

REF - ??? - ???

Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic

Mag1cman - Madonna Kaname - ???

Wryly - ??? - ???


Kohai

Disagree. If there is no traditional NK and it’s just recruitment I doubt this can be afforded plus we gain no new information.

Kohai

I accepted the offer not knowing really what it was. I later decided to read up on the character and realized it was probably an alignment changing contract. Once I realized that I attempted to back out. The mod told me I couldn’t back out but the point is moot because it failed.

Kohai

My card mentioned I had a hidden ability but it was not mentioned to me what that ability was until night 1 started. That is what I am trying to say.

Kohai
I don't get why he waited until DP2 to say his hidden ability outed Mag1c, I don't get why one of his hidden abilities was forewarned to him but the other one wasn't


Just to clear this up I did not know my hidden ability was the outing of characters until the night phase.


During day 1 I did not know that voting me could have the potential to out your character. The only thing I knew was multiple character claims on day 1 is bad for town and the character outting counted





Kohai

You aren't the only one who claimed to accept the contract offer. Rex did too.


Yes, but I was the first not knowing that others got the contract offer.


I think there is confirmed scum within the pool of folks who admitted to taking the contract.