Kohai's avatar

Kohai

Administrator

Member since

Kohai

what really irks me here is neither WF nor Mikal wanted a claim from mag1c before the shot.

Kohai

I just did a bit of a skim. My role PM strongly implies the generals are all town aligned.


VTL Whiteflame

Kohai
Depends on when the snapshot is and what story he’s trying to tell 


FWIW it may be best doing character mass claims today before recruitments start just so we have an idea of what we are working with.

Kohai
again, thoughts on current events? An elaboration on Wylted and I, please. and anything else that comes to your mind



I’m honestly getting ready for bed and an a bit tired to properly analyze it.


I will comment that I think wylted’s entry is fairly town. If he’s a recruiter or aligned with scum that recruits then I don’t think he’d draw attention to himself like that.

Kohai

I don't want to character claim yet 


But there is 2 options with this many people in scarlet 



The 1st is the version of the game we are playing is a snapshot at the start of the game


The 2nd is scum are going to stick out like sore thumbs depending on when the timeline of the split is happening. Cus there are not that many people in scarlet unless the snapshot is at the start



Would it make sense if everyone was scarlet or if scum have fake claims and those fake claims are scarlet?

Kohai
And if the leading theory rn is scum = Toran I'm interested to know why you're so certain Tir is town


It’s because Tir is mentioned by name in the PM and it’s in a way that heavily implies he’s town.


Also there are no flips yet and without more information we don’t know the theme split.


I strongly caution focusing not on theme split and character claims as much as results, behavior, and interaction. This is especially important as we know there’s alignment changing mechanics.

Kohai

Getting ready to sign off for Shabbos. So far I have a fairly strong town core


airmax

milal

wylted



Kohai

my assumption is that the 6 generals from the scarlet moon are in the game and can be recruited and flipped. 


which are 


teo

kasim

Georg 

milich 

sanya 

kawanda 



Agreed. At least two of these are mentioned by name in my PM. I’d be shocked if they weren’t

Kohai

Given maxs pm there possibly 5-6 players scum can’t recruit


Later on this game it might be beneficial to claim can be recruited / cannot be recrutied. Worst case scenario we lynch within the pool that can be recrutied

Kohai
I apologize guys, but some of our customers are being dicks and overloaded me with samples I don't have the reagents to process on the one fucking day when my major source of help is on vacation. I'm going to be slammed well into the afternoon, so I will try to catch up on this in the evening, but it's Shabbat and I can't promise I'll be available until tomorrow at this rate. FML.


Shabbat shalom! I'm going to take a break this shabbat so I'll try and be off all of shabbos. I'm going to a shabbat teshuva drash so I probably won't be back until late tomorrow

Kohai

max is either a lock or it’s a fake claim


I agree. This is probably a lock. I don’t see a world where w!max claims out of the gate like that.

Kohai

I'm going to drop a few more softs. The following characters are listed by name in my PM. I may or may not be one of these characters:


  1. Teo McDohl
  2. Emperor Barbarossa
  3. General Sonya Shulen
  4. Tir
  5. Ted

All of hese are probably town based on the wording of my pm

Kohai

To be clear I am not Tir. However given the wording of my PM and that Tir is mentioned by name, Tir is probably town

Kohai
the most likely scum characters are

odessa 
flik 
victor 
tir 


Based on my role PM I’m almost certain Tir is town. That said I don’t want to focus too much on characters and flavor as much as behavior and night action results.

Kohai

VTL Mag1c


So far all Mharman has done is throw shade and see if something will stick. I’m going to bed now but I’m parking my vote here for now.

Kohai
I think that’s also plausible. Toran absolutely could be cult given the recruit emphasis from the game but I’m like 99.99 percent sure there is a recruiter unless skep fucked with me

Agreed. Let’s wait for more info but I am willing to bet this game is town vs cult

Kohai

I have a very strong feeling that this isn’t a traditional mafia game of town vs mafia but rather town vs cult. I can’t say any more than that. I’ll expand on that later on.

Kohai
I’m 99 percent sure I know who you are.

I’m not going to claim any further.


Question since you know a lot about the lore: If there’s a cult what would make the most sense with a theme split?

Kohai
Skep said there is no anti claim. So outside of fake claims. I will sniff bullshit out very fast. I’m a lore god at this game so there is value in character claims at some point especially with no anti claim. We should minimize that until needed as some characters will very likely be pretty fucking obvious roles.

I know absolutely nothing about the Lore.

Kohai
im from scarlet moon 
I’m from the toran liberation 
I exist outside of those. 


I’ll go alone with this


I am part of the scarlet moon.