I’m from the scarlet moon empire which is the major antagonist of this game
As am I. Honestly Mikal is lock town
I’m from the scarlet moon empire which is the major antagonist of this game
As am I. Honestly Mikal is lock town
My pm all but tells me directly there is a recruit role in this game and not like a mason.
Based on my role PM as well I am in agreement with this. I wonder if we actually have a scum team or if it just town vs a cult.
I have never seen a kinder thing wished for someone. So touching.
I’ll try and up it: May you never need to use a public toilet.
This is obviously scum trying to get town cred!
VtL Lunatic
1. Pie
2. Mikal
3. Shinning
4. Lunatic
5. Vader
6. Magic
7. Victor
8. Airmax
9. Thoth
10. Whiteflame
11. Kohai
12.
13.
Against my better judgement
1. Pie
2. Mikal
3. Shinning
4. Lunatic
5. Vader
6. Magic
7. Victor
8. Airmax
9. Thoth
10.
11.
12.
13.
Sub/Extra
Kohai
Wryly
Maybe
Whiteflame
Moozer
Unlike MU and other places we really don't have a DVC. This is mostly because sometimes we need subs that come from other dead players.
Endgame posted with my commentary: https://www.debatecraft.com/mafia/c/endgames/posts/1c/1990s-2000s-nostalgia-mafia-endgame
Congratulations to the mafia on their win!
Mafia: ILikePie, RexFlavius
Town: Thoth, Lunatic, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Mikal, Whiteflame, Unsaid
The setup: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1X2Nh9xsbiI7Qwd9hEtj6wzCSuLQnTno3r-ERP8jd5HY/edit?usp=sharing
Night actions
Mikal - Sings a song to Awesome5000
Unsaid - Desperado whiteflame
Whiteflame - Cop awesome
Airmax - neighborize Mikal
Lunatic - Jailkeep pie
Mafia kill Thoth and Lunatic
Mafia anti claim Airmax and Mikal
Results
Unsaid, Lunatic, and Thoth are dead.
Whiteflame gets a town result on awesome
Anti-claim mechanic:
I warned everyone in advance that there were some nasty anticlaim mechanics. The mafia had the ability to permanently roleblock anyone in the day phase that claims. In addition, if the entire town claims then they could permanently roleblock the entire town. If 3 or more players claim they could permanently role block 2.
The purpose of the anticlaim mechanic is to punish town for mass claiming when it was not warranted and for focusing too much on claims and flavor rather than behavior. Over the past several games town focused too much on their character and role rather than behavior. This has caused town to lose in several of the past games. On day phase 1 not only did town lynch their tracker they ended up with 3 town folks claiming. This made the mafia job so much easier by being able to block the PRs that claimed and kill the remaining PRs.
Perhaps this was too harsh on town, but town needed to learn some harsh lessons about when to claim and how to claim. In general, town should only claim when they have a meaningful result to share or if they they are an important PR and will soon by lynched. Two folks claimed on day phase 1 that were in absolutely no danger of being lynched.
This should have been an easy town win given the setup, but hidden within it was a self destruction mechanism should town should decide to focus too much on claims. As I predicted, this setup was too town sided for their own good and the town sidedness ended up being their down fall.
A few modding mistakes
This was my first game modding in years so I do apologize for some of the issues that I made. One of the major mistakes I made was in regards to Awesome's role PM. I was doing some last minute editing and forgot to include the win condition "you win when all threats to town have been eliminated." Awesome asked me if he was town or mafia and I had simply stated he was town and apologized from there. I never thought that was going to be an issue until....
Modkillable Offenses
There were at least two offenses that would have been instant modkills if this was played on MU. On day 1 (post 11) Mikal directly copied and pasted the win condition "I win when all threats to town have been eliminated." This is directly quoting in part from a PM. This is something I take extreme offense to, especially when this specific wording was not publicized. Thoth later (day 1 post 96) wrote "Other than the obvious of confirming that my card says I win when all threats to town are bye-bye." Both of these would have been a very stern final warning or an instant modkill on other websites. This caused Awesome some trouble since he didn't have the exact wording that I used with the other roles and used that to later sus Mikal. I felt the need to publicly warn folks not to copy and paste from their PM. Scum got very angry with me as they saw it as mod confirmation that the language was correct and in return I offered compensation in the form of a second NK. This was in lieu of modkilling two players.
OGI
OGI is extremely banned and frowned upon in other mafia spaces. There were at least two instances of OGI influencing reads: (1) Mikal arguing that Lunatic is confirmed town due to me forgetting to send them their role PM; and (2) Airmax being town due to him being AWOL and not having enough time to think of a fake claim. The first reasoning is very flawed as I very well could have forgotten to give Lunatic a mafia PM. At the time Lunatic messaged me he had no idea which alignment he would be. This would have been much better if Lunatic resolved it only in private and not in public. This should never have been seen as alignment indicative.
MVP: I likepie is being awarded the MPV for very obvious reasons. He was yelling at me in the mafia chat and was ready to give up. Pie continued playing and ended up with a win.
Due to the modding errors negatively impacting them both Awesome5000 and Lunatic are being awarded no contest.
Fun fact he lied about death proof
This was literally the most town sided game in history. Yet within the design was a self destruct mechanic
White flame was killed he was innocent. It is a mafia victory.
awesome and lunatic are being awarded no contest. I’ll explain more in the endgame
Awesome was lynched. He was innocent. Submit night actions please
Vote Count
Awesome (1/4) Mikal
Not voting: (5/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Awesome (1/4) Mikal
Not voting: (5/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Awesome (1/4) Mikal
Not voting: (5/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Awesome (1/4) Mikal
Not voting: (5/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Vote Count
Not voting: (6/6): ILikePie, Awesome5000, Airmax1227, Rex, Mikal, Whiteflame
With 6 players alive it takes 4 to lynch.
Day phase 2 will end on Saturday 9/20/2025 @ 6:00 PM EST unless there is a majority.
Welcome back to 1990s-2000s Nostalgia Mafia!
Link to DP1: https://www.debatecraft.com/mafia/c/active-games/posts/19/1990s-2000s-nostalgia-mafia-dp1
Lynched day phase 1
Vader - Steve from Blues Clues
Greetings,
Welcome to Kohai’s 90’s - early 2000’s mafia game. You are Steve from Blue’s Clues that first premiered in 1996. Throughout the show you are tasked with tracking down clues that your beloved dog, Blue, left behind. You then sit at your “thinking chair” to determine what those clues mean and what Blue wants you to do. This makes you the town tracker. Each night you can select a player and you can find out who, if anyone, they visited. You win when all threats to town are eliminated.
Died night phase 1
Thoth Jimmy Neutron
Greetings,
Welcome to Kohai’s 90’s - early 2000’s mafia game. You are Jimmy Neutron from The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron, Boy Genius that first premiered in 2002. During the course of the series you invented a lie detector that you often use for your investigations. You are thus the lie detector. You may each night quote a statement that contains one self-contained piece of information made by a player and send this to the game host to learn whether the statement is completely true, partially true, or completely false. You cannot use this to confirm alignment (ie if someone simply states “I am town”). You win when all threats to town have been eliminated.
Lunatic - Steve Irwin from The Crocodile Hunters
Greetings,
Welcome to Kohai’s 90’s - early 2000’s mafia game. You are Steve Irwin from The Crocodile Hunter that aired from 1996-2004. As a host you taught children and adults of all ages the beauty of nature and showed them how to wrestle a crocodile. Each night you may “wrestle a crocodile”. You will prevent that person from being able to use any night actions in addition to rendering them untargetable by all night actions. You win when all threats to town have been eliminated.
Unsaid - Courage from Courage the Cowardly Dog
Greetings,
Welcome to Kohai’s 90’s - early 2000’s mafia game. You are Courage from Courage the Cowardly Dog that first premiered on November 12, 1999. You are, well, cowardly; however when duty calls you step up to the plate and often rescue your owners. This makes you the cowardly 1-shot desperado. You may once per game select a target to be killed during a night phase.If the target is scum, the Desperado's kill attempt will be successful, and the Desperado will live. If the target is not scum, the Desperado will die, and the target will live. You are cowardly - if you successful eliminate a mafia member you will gain courage and obtain a 1x watcher role that you can use the next night phase only. You win when all threats to town are eliminated.
Player list:
1. iLikePie
2. Thoth - Died night phase 1
3. Lunatic - Died night phase 1
4. awesome5000
5. Airmax1227
6. Rex
7. Vader - Lynched day phase 1
8. Mikal
9. Whiteflame
10. Unsaid - Died night phase 1
Vote Count
Vader (5/6) Mikal, Rex, Lunatic, whiteflame, pie
Awesome5000 (3/6) Airmax,Vader, Unsaid
Mikal (1/6) Awesome5000
With 5 votes Vader was lynched. He was innocent. Night actions are due by 5:00 PM EST tomorrow. I will try to start day 2 at 6:00 PM EST tomorrow.
5 minute warning
Vote Count
Awesome5000 (4/6) Airmax, ILikePie, Vader, Unsaid, Whiteflame,- > L2
Vader (3/6) Mikal, Rex, Lunatic
Mikal (1/6) Awesome5000
Not voting: (1/10) Pie
With 10 alive it takes 6 votes to lynch!
6 minutes
10 minutes
15 minutes