Thread unlocked now that the game is over
Thread unlocked now that the game is over
I was literally about to post my unvote post
I knew for a fact wf was scum but didn't catch the wf / mikal team. It just didn't make sense with castin's results
Damn it. I hate my unvote post ready to go to prevent a quick hammer.
Bro are you serious?
Mikal and Whiteflame are calling EXACTLY a Pie/Kohai scum team.
You know you’re town, so Pie/Kohai can’t be a team. But that’s literally what they’re saying the team is, so they can lynch me and win the goddamn game. That’s why Mikal cares so much about the order of Pie vs WF.
TO be clear I'd rather go for whiteflame first as I think he's og scum and you're the recruit. A mikal / wf team doesn't make sense
It honestly doesn't matter which order we lynch. I'm calling it now: wf and pie are scum or mikal and castin are scum. There's no other possible combo that makese sense.
VTL Pie
anyone else smelling a massive pie / whiteflame bus?
Understood.
It's been 25 minutes. Do you have anything?
It's been over an hr. Who's scum and why?
Whiteflame hasn’t even said anything, which is also concerning
agree. Which is why I’m confident in wf scum
David if you are trying to gain town cred I respect it but no one is that dumb.
Lol. I admit it was a reaction test. I was hoping you’d get destructed by the large vote and didn’t see the unvote underneath. After all I messed up the vote count but you missed the fact that I listed everyone and also noted it was L2. If you were scum I’d hope you’d make the same mistake.
I just voted pie. I am extremely confident in my reads. If you are the scum team you guys played great and deserve the w.
Pie is the common denominator. I strongly believe wf is og and pie is the recruit. That said, if we lynch the recruit scum over og scum then I am perfectly content with that.
ᵘⁿᵛᵒᵗᵉ
Mikal / Wf doesn’t make any sense due to castin’s results.
How?
We'd have to believe that wf/mikal chose to kill vader (who was also an easy mislynch target) over castin, a tracker that could potentially implicate whoever was performing the nk. We'd also have to believe that mikal performed an action other than a nk or roleblock, which also doesn't make sense. That's why I'm confident the team is either castin / mikal or wf / pie.
The NKA makes sense: Wf wants to use the doctor role to claim town cred. They killed vader over castin because if they killed castin it would implicate wf if he tried to claim he used a doctor role. In addition, castin was the most obv town player last day phase and is a very strong town PR. This is why I'm so confident in wf being scum or Mikal and Castin being the scum team
Why do you think it’s me/pie vs me/wf?
Why do you think Pie is more likely scum than wf?
What picking a role from a graveyard. Confused about this. But don’t care.
we have a way to solve so as long as we go pie first since I think you are scum. I’m down
1. how does wf get to pick a role from the graveyard if the role hasn’t been revealed?
2. I can yield to a pie lynch.
Also wf’s power role makes absolutely zero sense. How would he know what the power role even is before it flips?
If it was wf and I. I’d have bussed him already and have you shoot pie tomorrow.
its why I know it’s pie
I understand your paranoia. If you want to kill pie today I am down for it. Here’s where I am at
I have very strong reasons to believe Castin and Mikal are town. If I’m wrong I’ll eat it. From my POV that means Pie and Wf
Why can it not be Mikal/WF with WF as OG scum? There’s a 100% chance via POE that WF is scum. There’s more of a 50/50 for me vs Mikal. That should be an objective fact for you.
Mikal / Wf doesn’t make any sense due to castin’s results.
so yeah I think it has to be you and pie.
I understand your paranoia. I’m ok with lynching pie today and me killing wf tomorrow.
Bruh we are trying to go og because I think you are scum. If you are town. Oh scum doesn’t matter cus the game is solved.
I admit I am tunneling wf due to POE. The only scum recruit (from my POV) is pie. The game is easy as pie. You 1000% lynch me tomorrow
david is not willing to kill you when by his own reads it would not matter who he picked. It’s inconsistent as shit.
It's not inconsistent. If push comes to shove I'd vote pie, but we are trying to lynch the og scum which I believe is wf
I absolutely think pie can be og. He’s literally named in Casey’s pm. Just because he claimed a passive role does not remove the option that he started as scum.
The fact he's named is why I think he is not the og.
Not to mention if david as town is being consistent with what he’s typing would have no reason not to vote you.
I thought the entire goal was to lynch the ORIGINAL scum today. Pie is definitely NOT the original scum. That said, I do strongly believe he's the recruit.
Let’s look at it logically
let’s say Castin is scum and you are town. What did he do to you last night? Obviously he didn’t NK you, didn’t redirect you, and didn’t RB you. So what did Castin do?
He could fake claim he targeted anyone.
David you either are tunneling or just trying to force a mislynch. Like you aren’t even considering other recruit option
It’s really just process of elimination. There are reasons I can town lock Castin and that would also strongly confirm you as town. I also have strong reasons to believe Pie is not OG scum. That leave whiteflame and pie.