SatanLucy

During 2000-2013, 19 previously healthy neonates were admitted for acute complications after circumcision. Four were admitted for bleeding, with hemophilia identified in two cases and von Willebrand disease in one. Eight boys required emergency surgery, three for severe bleeding. Four boys with amputation of the glans underwent immediate surgical reconstruction. One infant was taken to the operating room to remove an obstructing Plastibell ring. Seven boys were admitted to the intensive care unit with severe bleeding or sepsis, three of whom ultimately progressed to hemorrhagic or septic shock. Two of these children died of their complications.


https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34973956/

SatanLucy

In August of 2013, the mother of a three month old Memphis boy brought him to a local clinic to be circumcised. As she waited for the surgery to be completed, she felt that something was not right because her son was screaming in pain. When she inquired about how the surgery was going, doctors reassured her that everything was fine. The surgery, which normally takes between five minutes and half an hour, lasted for three hours. After the surgery was finished, the mother saw that her son’s penis had been severely damaged. She reports that in addition to being disfigured, her son experiences excruciating pain when he urinates.


https://greerinjurylawyers.com/memphis-boy-disfigured-by-botched-circumcision/

SatanLucy

A 12 day old male, term baby with mild glanular hypospadias underwent ritual circumcision after the family had consulted and obtained approval from a pediatric urologist. He presented to emergency department with amputation of the entire glans performed by an experienced religious practitioner using the Mogen clamp technique. The practitioner, who had performed thousands of circumcisions, admitted a momentary lapse of attention and accidently cutting proximal, rather than distal to the Mogen clamp. The excised glans was put on ice during transport. Two hours passed between the amputation and surgical intervention.


https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7970056/

SatanLucy

The authors present here a case of a 7-day-old boy who had ritual circumcision with a cauter complicated by an entire penile amputation, which was treated with the insertion of a catheter to prevent the closure of the urethra. The patient reported his penis was circumcised with cautery one day later the glans and the entire penis became discolored and necrosis, unfortunately, the entire penis was lost with the overlying skin.


https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10405999/

SatanLucy

Each year in the United States more than 100 newborn baby boys die as a result of circumcision and circumcision complications. This is the alarming conclusion of a study, published in the Journal of Boyhood Studies which examined hospital discharge and mortality statistics in order to answer two questions: (1) How many baby boys dies as a result of circumcision in the neonatal period (within 28 days of birth)? (2) Why are so few of these deaths officially recorded as due to circumcision?


https://www.darboninstitute.org/circumcision_deaths_complications_usa

SatanLucy
Nope, what we have established is you think of circumcision of infants as a sexual thing, and like "normal" people, I don't.


You were lucky so that circumcision didn't disrupt your sexual function. If it did, you would be telling a different story now.


And circumcision complications range from small complications, to severe penis damage, to even death. But I guess 100 babies dying from circumcision in USA every year just isn't bad enough.

SatanLucy
So we think that the ritual abuse of an infants penis is bad.
And you think that it is fine.
End of story.


Circumcision is a perfect crime. The victim is tied down, can't fight back, has no legal protection, and perpetrator is immune from prosecution.


Tho my parents didn't benefit from circumcising me, because they don't get it. They circumcised me to please some religious people around them. But those religious people weren't the future. I was. So now I hope they enjoy giving me free money while I remain unemployed forever. And they are not going to have grandchildren either cuz I won't reproduce. So yeah, I don't see how they win.

SatanLucy

I will tell chatgpt to disprove your claim one more time, and I dont want to bother chatgpt anymore, so this is last time.


That claim defeats itself.

“Empiricism is the most reliable path” is not itself an empirical observation. You cannot measure, weigh, or experimentally observe the principle “only empirical evidence counts.” It is a philosophical claim about knowledge — meaning it relies on non-empirical reasoning to justify empiricism.

So the position already depends on something beyond empiricism.

There are several deeper problems too:

  1. Logic is not empirical
  2. The laws of logic are not discovered through the senses in the same way physical facts are.

For example:

  1. If all humans are mortal
  2. And Socrates is human
  3. Then Socrates is mortal

The conclusion follows necessarily even before observation. The validity comes from rational structure, not laboratory testing.

Empirical science itself depends on:

  1. logic,
  2. mathematics,
  3. inference,
  4. causality,
  5. identity,
  6. induction.

None of those are empirically proven without circularity.

  1. Empiricism cannot justify induction
  2. Science assumes:
  3. the future will resemble the past,
  4. repeated observations reveal general laws.

But that assumption itself cannot be empirically proven without begging the question.

You would need to assume induction works in order to use past observations as evidence that induction works.

This is David Hume’s famous problem of induction.

So empiricism rests on a non-empirical foundation.

  1. Mathematics gives genuine knowledge without observation
  2. You do not need experiments to know:

2+2=4

or

genui{"math_block_widget_always_prefetch_v2":{"content":"a^2+b^2=c^2"}}

These are not “speculation.” They are necessary truths derived rationally.

Empirical observation may help apply mathematics, but mathematical truth itself is not established through sensory testing.

  1. Empirical evidence already contains non-empirical interpretation
  2. Raw sensory data does not interpret itself.

To move from:

  1. “I observe regularity”

to:

  1. “therefore there is a law”

requires reasoning beyond mere sensation.

Even scientific theories involve:

  1. explanatory inference,
  2. unobservable entities,
  3. metaphysical assumptions,
  4. probabilistic reasoning.

Atoms, fields, spacetime curvature, wavefunctions — these are not directly sensed. They are inferred.

If inference beyond direct observation were “mere speculation,” much of science would collapse.

  1. Some truths are known conceptually, not experimentally
  2. Examples:
  3. “No bachelor is married.”
  4. “A square has four sides.”
  5. “Contradictions cannot both be true in the same sense.”

These are not scientific discoveries. Yet denying them destroys coherent reasoning itself.

  1. “Non-empirical = speculation” is too broad
  2. There is a difference between:
  3. arbitrary imagination,
  4. and
  5. rational inference.

For example:

“If contingent things exist, there may be a necessary explanation” is not random fantasy. It is a philosophical inference from metaphysical premises.

You may reject the argument, but calling it “not evidence at all” ignores that rational deduction is a legitimate form of justification.

Science itself constantly uses inference to unobservables:

  1. black holes before direct imaging,
  2. quarks,
  3. dark matter,
  4. other minds,
  5. historical events.

None are directly sensed in full. They are inferred from explanatory necessity.

So the real issue is not “empirical vs non-empirical,” but whether the reasoning is:

  1. valid,
  2. coherent,
  3. explanatory,
  4. non-contradictory.

Empiricism is extremely powerful for studying the physical world. But the claim that only empirical evidence counts is philosophically self-undermining, because that claim itself is not empirically established.

SatanLucy

Chatgpt is happy to disprove that too.


That claim defeats itself unless it can be justified empirically.

The statement “empiricism is the only reliable way of knowing” is not itself established through observation, experiment, or sensory measurement. You cannot run a laboratory test proving that only empirical methods yield reliable knowledge. So the claim is either:

  1. A non-empirical philosophical principle — which means non-empirical reasoning can produce reliable knowledge, contradicting the claim.

or

  1. An empirical claim — but no finite set of observations can prove that all reliable knowledge must come from observation. That is a universal epistemological rule, not an empirical datum.

There are also several categories of knowledge that empiricism depends on but cannot itself justify:

  1. Logic
  2. Empirical science presupposes laws like non-contradiction and inference validity. Experiments do not prove logic; experiments already assume logic to interpret results.
  3. Mathematics
  4. Mathematical truths are not discovered by measuring the world repeatedly.
  5. 2+2=4
  6. No amount of sensory experience is needed to know this necessarily.
  7. Induction itself
  8. Empiricism relies on induction: the assumption that past regularities predict future outcomes. But this principle cannot be empirically proven without circularity. Any empirical defense of induction already assumes induction works.
  9. Uniformity of nature
  10. Science assumes reality behaves consistently across time and space. That assumption is not something empiricism can establish without presupposing it.
  11. Conscious experience and other minds
  12. You directly know your own consciousness prior to scientific measurement. Likewise, belief that other people have minds is an inference not strictly derivable from sensory data alone.

Even science itself is partly built on non-empirical reasoning:

  1. hypothesis formation,
  2. mathematical abstraction,
  3. causal inference,
  4. probabilistic reasoning,
  5. interpretation of evidence.

Empirical data alone is just raw sensation. Reason is what turns observations into knowledge.

A stronger position would be:

“Empiricism is extremely effective for studying the physical world.”

That is defensible. But saying it is the only reliable path to knowledge overreaches, because empiricism rests on foundational principles that are themselves not empirically established.

SatanLucy

The claim defeats itself if taken literally.

“Empiricism is the only way we can know the world.”

That statement is not itself an empirical observation. You cannot measure it in a lab, weigh it, see it through a telescope, or derive it from sensory data alone. It is a philosophical principle about knowledge. So if the statement is true, then the statement itself cannot be known to be true.

That is a classic self-referential problem with strict empiricism.

A stronger version of empiricism usually retreats to something softer, like:

“Empirical methods are the most reliable for discovering physical facts.”

That is much harder to attack. But it is very different from saying empiricism is the only source of knowledge.

There are several categories of knowledge that are not derived purely from empirical observation:

1. Logic is not empirical

Basic logical truths are not learned through experimentation.

For example:

A \lor \neg A

The law of excluded middle (“A or not A”) is not something discovered by observing many objects in nature. It is a structural principle of reasoning itself.

Likewise:

A \land \neg A

cannot both be true simultaneously in classical logic.

No empirical experiment proves logic without already presupposing logic. Every experiment already assumes inference rules, identity, non-contradiction, validity of reasoning, etc.

Empiricism therefore depends on non-empirical foundations.

2. Mathematics is not fundamentally empirical

You do not need to perform physical experiments to know:

2+2=4

or:

genui{"math_block_widget_always_prefetch_v2":{"content":"a^2+b^2=c^2"}}

for right triangles.

You can verify examples empirically, but the truth itself is not contingent on measurement. If every physical triangle vanished from existence, the theorem would still hold.

Empirical observation may inspire mathematics, but mathematical necessity is not established by sensory observation alone.

3. Empiricism cannot justify induction by itself

Science relies heavily on induction:

  1. the future will resemble the past
  2. repeated patterns imply laws
  3. observed regularities continue

But this principle itself cannot be empirically proven without circularity.

David Hume pointed this out centuries ago:

  1. If you justify induction by saying “it worked before,” you are already assuming induction.

So empiricism relies on a non-empirical assumption: that inference from past to future is rational.

4. Causality itself is not directly observed

The statement:

“something caused the universe”

already goes beyond raw sensory data.

What we observe are sequences and correlations. “Cause” is an inferred metaphysical relation.

Hume again argued that causation is not literally seen; we observe events followed by events.

So even basic scientific reasoning already contains conceptual structures beyond direct empiricism.

5. Moral truths are not empirically measurable

Claims like:

  1. torture is wrong
  2. truth is preferable to deception
  3. rational consistency matters

are not measurable in the same way mass or temperature are.

You can measure human reactions to morality, but not morality itself through empirical instruments alone.

Yet most people still treat at least some moral truths as meaningful knowledge.

6. Conscious experience is not reducible to third-person empiricism

Your awareness of your own consciousness is immediate, not inferred from observation.

You do not run an experiment to know:

  1. “I am experiencing pain”
  2. “I am thinking”

Descartes’ point survives here:

awareness of thinking is more certain than sensory knowledge, because senses can deceive.

7. The scientific method itself is partly philosophical

Science presupposes:

  1. logic
  2. uniformity of nature
  3. reliability of reasoning
  4. existence of an external world
  5. meaningfulness of truth

None of these are established purely empirically without circularity.

Science works extraordinarily well, but its foundations are not themselves derived entirely from empirical testing.

The original statement also overstates what “empirical” means.

Inference is not the same thing as observation.

Once someone says:

“we infer larger conclusions from empirical evidence”

they have already admitted that reason contributes something beyond raw sensory input.

Evidence alone never mechanically interprets itself. Interpretation requires:

  1. logic
  2. abstraction
  3. metaphysical assumptions
  4. probability judgments
  5. conceptual frameworks

So empiricism alone is insufficient even for science itself.

A more defensible position would be:

“Empirical evidence is the best tool for investigating physical reality, but reason, logic, mathematics, and philosophical assumptions are also necessary for knowledge.”

That avoids the self-refutation problem while preserving the strength of science.

SatanLucy
Nobody thinks you actually circumcise infants, what is creepy is that you want to fuck infants.


Who told you that? Same God who told you to circumcise infants to alter their sexual function because he accidentally created foreskin when he didnt mean to?


Apparently, we were made in God's image, except the foreskin.

SatanLucy

The claim is not obviously true, because it quietly assumes that all knowledge about reality must ultimately come from sensory observation. But that assumption itself is not established empirically. It is a philosophical principle.

A strong counterargument is that some truths about reality appear knowable prior to observation:

  1. Logic
  2. Mathematics
  3. Identity
  4. Causality
  5. Possibility/impossibility
  6. Inference itself

If someone says “only empirical evidence counts about reality,” that statement is not itself an empirical discovery. No experiment measures that principle. It is a philosophical rule imposed a priori. So the position risks self-reference problems.

You can structure the disproof several ways.

1. Empiricism depends on a priori assumptions

Empirical science already presupposes non-empirical principles:

  1. The law of non-contradiction
  2. Reliability of inference
  3. Uniformity of nature
  4. Mathematical validity
  5. Existence of causal relations

None of these are directly observed as raw sensory data.

For example, no microscope detects the law of non-contradiction. Yet without it, interpreting evidence becomes impossible.

So purely philosophical reasoning cannot be dismissed as “non-evidence,” because empirical reasoning itself stands on philosophical foundations.

2. Observation alone cannot generate universal truths

Experience only gives finite observations.

Suppose you observe 10,000 falling objects. Empirically, you only know:

“These observed objects fell.”

You do not directly observe the universal rule:

“All unsupported objects fall.”

The jump from finite cases to universal law requires induction — a philosophical principle.

\forall x,(Observed(x) \rightarrow Falls(x)) \not\Rightarrow \forall x,(Falls(x))

So empirical evidence alone cannot justify many scientific conclusions without additional a priori reasoning.

3. Some truths are necessarily true independent of experience

Consider:

“A square circle cannot exist.”

This is not learned by surveying the universe for square circles.

It is known through conceptual analysis alone. The contradiction is intrinsic.

Likewise:

  1. 2 + 2 = 4
  2. If A = B and B = C, then A = C
  3. Nothing can both exist and not exist in the same respect simultaneously

These are not weaker because they are non-empirical. In fact, they are often treated as more certain than sensory observations, since observations can be mistaken.

A mirage can deceive perception.

A contradiction cannot become true through better instrumentation.

4. Empirical evidence itself requires interpretation

Raw sensations are not self-explanatory.

Two people can observe identical data and reach different conclusions because interpretation depends on prior conceptual frameworks.

Example:

  1. Data does not interpret itself.
  2. Philosophical assumptions determine what counts as explanation, causation, identity, probability, evidence, etc.

Therefore philosophy is not merely “optional decoration” around empiricism; it partly determines what empiricism even means.

5. Some realities may be inaccessible to direct observation

If something is:

  1. abstract,
  2. metaphysical,
  3. logical,
  4. mathematical,
  5. modal (possible/impossible),
  6. or foundational,

then demanding empirical observation may be category error.

For example:

  1. numbers are not observed like rocks,
  2. logical validity is not detected by telescopes,
  3. possibility/impossibility are not physical measurements.

Yet these clearly affect reasoning about reality.

6. The dismissal principle defeats itself

The statement:

“Purely a priori arguments should not count as evidence about reality unless tied to observation.”

is itself:

  1. not an empirical observation,
  2. not experimentally verified,
  3. not derived from sensory measurement.

It is a philosophical epistemic rule.

So if the rule were true, it undermines its own justification.

7. History shows successful a priori discovery

There are cases where reasoning preceded observation:

  1. Mathematical physics predicted phenomena later observed.
  2. Albert Einstein derived consequences from theoretical principles before experimental confirmation.
  3. Non-Euclidean geometry existed before physical application.
  4. Dirac predicted antimatter mathematically before observation.

This shows a priori reasoning can genuinely track reality rather than merely reorganize observations afterward.

A weaker version of empiricism is much harder to disprove:

“Empirical evidence is usually more reliable for claims about contingent physical facts.”

That is more defensible.

But the stronger claim —

that purely philosophical arguments are not evidence about reality at all unless empirically tied —

fails because:

  1. empiricism relies on philosophy,
  2. universal inference exceeds observation,
  3. logic/math are non-empirical yet indispensable,
  4. the claim itself is philosophical rather than empirical.


SatanLucy
Do you support the ritual circumcision of infants?


That is a too difficult question for Sidewalker to answer. If he answers "no", he is agreeing with me, which is impermissible. If he says "yes", he is agreeing with sexual abuse of infants, which is also impermissible.