Shining

Not a whole lot.


I can't really fault you for REF. I did notice last game he sat back and was really quite passive. It was only during the final DP he got up and questioned my wagon. I think you were fairly obvious scum, but he also made your job a bit easier. With this game, hes also a bit passive. I don't have much to talk about him. I suppose he wants a Kohai lynch and hasn't really said why. I get why you say I'm scummy lol. He hasn't said much. Null for me.


Kohai is someone I will believe. Its not like a miller who might trouble town the entire game, with proper gameplay, Kohai might never get a single town vote on him the entire game. We don't need to immediately buy his claim, but should the need arrive, we have flips to check him on. Hes more than a lean town for me.


Wryly(/Wylted) just popped in and I think it might be a mistake letting them pass by thinking about it now. Wryly just popped in, softed their character and basically has done nothing else. Its still early for Wryly, but I will keep an eye on them for now. Not their fault Wylted was inactive fwiw.

Shining

I am comfortable with buying Kohai's hated claim. I remember someone fakeclaiming Popular, but it takes a strong player to pull it off and while Kohai is good, I'd expect him to slip up eventually if scum.

Shining

I did briefly consider jailing you, but then I decided on trying to protect Pie. That might be a little funny given that I FOS him now but whatever. I also didn't FOS you as hard as I do now at the end of DP1.

Shining

You know, I am sick of having the justification conversation every game. Its utterly meaningless most times.

Shining

Why is everyone choosing to interpret the Informed flip like that? Thats not what the flips says.


"You are informed that someone’s role is a greater nuisance than they know."


What is the take away assuming this is referring to Thoth? "Lol, you can nullify a RB"? Thats something you just know from the PM. Thats how your role works.

Shining

At the very least, you should have some pause when he claims Dreamer. And he might have a dream to give town. So while its not confirmable, its at least something. And Rex only confirmed his role to Wryly.

Shining

Pie outright admitted he would have tunneled Kohai had he survived and yet when he flipped town he made no attempt to at least recognize he was wrong. If Pie is town, he can't read 'scummy' town players for shit because he was wrong about Kohai and wrong about me.

Shining

I don't see a successful wagon forming on him within 24 hours, but yeah, I'll hammer him.