Shining

I am comfortable with buying Kohai's hated claim. I remember someone fakeclaiming Popular, but it takes a strong player to pull it off and while Kohai is good, I'd expect him to slip up eventually if scum.

Shining

I did briefly consider jailing you, but then I decided on trying to protect Pie. That might be a little funny given that I FOS him now but whatever. I also didn't FOS you as hard as I do now at the end of DP1.

Shining

You know, I am sick of having the justification conversation every game. Its utterly meaningless most times.

Shining

Why is everyone choosing to interpret the Informed flip like that? Thats not what the flips says.


"You are informed that someone’s role is a greater nuisance than they know."


What is the take away assuming this is referring to Thoth? "Lol, you can nullify a RB"? Thats something you just know from the PM. Thats how your role works.

Shining

At the very least, you should have some pause when he claims Dreamer. And he might have a dream to give town. So while its not confirmable, its at least something. And Rex only confirmed his role to Wryly.

Shining

Pie outright admitted he would have tunneled Kohai had he survived and yet when he flipped town he made no attempt to at least recognize he was wrong. If Pie is town, he can't read 'scummy' town players for shit because he was wrong about Kohai and wrong about me.

Shining

I don't see a successful wagon forming on him within 24 hours, but yeah, I'll hammer him.

Shining

Cerulean is my top lynch pick right now. Pie is out of reach, but I can easily accept a Cerulean lynch. I don't like his reaction to the Informed flip, and he hasn't looked better. Sadly he escaped Pie's policy lynch.


VTL CERULEAN

Shining

You know, I really don't understand why we put much thought into justifications. I can only report back what my DM says. And Kohai doesn't make much sense either sooooo

Shining

I feel like I am prone to have swings in my logic. I don't like Cerulean more than last DP so at least I know you couldn't have commited the NK. I don't know, you and Cerulean are rubbing me the wrong way this DP.

Shining

That would be you actually. I calculated the risk you being some PR, and prioritized saving you from a potential NK.

Shining

No need to pressure me. I am Jim Moss and I am the Jailkeeper. My justification is that I am really good at interrogations and manipulation so that makes me a JK.

Shining
#64


Something reall seems off with Cerulean. I really don't understand why Cerulean said that a watcher(/or tracker?) Seeing him visit the dead would be this grand reveal that would cause WF to create a Informed. Thats not what Informeds are for. Its just basic logic. I read that snippet and my mind immediately went towards someone has a hidden aspect of their role.

Shining

lmao, if gun to my head it would probably be you. Rex and Wryly are likely town, I'm town, and everyone else is varied levels of null.

Shining

Okay, well Rex is apparently town, so assuming it isn't something boring, my reads are something along the lines of


REX


Rex, along with everyone else, was inactive DP1, but Rex said his role was confirmable and he did something to Wryly

I don't know if its something that'll confirm his role, but for the time being I'll assume Wryly got something that confirms Rex is town. Eventually I would like him to fully out his role and character, but for now I can accept what I am given.


THOTH


Bro, I got nothing on him. I don't remember anything that stands out and he hasn't posted yet in DP2. This will change if he has anything to report, but hes null. Probably will ask him for a character claim later DP2.


PIE


Pie has been more active and something I seem to recognize is that his logic as scum is worse then his logic as town. I get that he wanted to avoid a NL DP1, but I don't understand why he didn't push harder for a Cerulean lynch. At this point he should just drop the Policy Lynch because Cerulean is still alive. I think Town!Pie realizes that losing a miller would be preferable to losing a dreamer report. Another thing I am thinking about is that while Kohai can't exactly confirm his dream, he was town, and while I remember someone faking being Dreamer, its still rather risky, so in some universe Kohai is alive, and if lucky, has a dream. I think Pie is coping, but whatever.


WRYLY


Has been active, and confirmed whatever Rex sent him. Don't know what is sent, but I am assuming its not something Wrky can lie about. I don't sus him and expect him to be near the top of my town pile for the duration of the game.


VADER


I don't have much on Vader. Same with Thoth, hes floating around not doing much.



CERULEAN


I still think we should have policy lynched him, and I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with him. I'll grill him for .ore information regarding his claim, but in hindsight maybe hes town and I obviously want town to have as many PRs over negative utility roles.

Shining

lol I should have known. Apologies Pie. In no particular order, something like Rex, Thoth, Pie.