Vader

Because they claimed a role where they actively disable chats, and that would imply what the OP is saying about claiming and such to a certain extent about being weary. At that point I’m going to be forced to claim at this point because we feel it’s going to be better to claim when there’s a literal statement that says to not claim versus holding off claims or even, not lynching. So if I die it’s not my fault and I don’t want to have the burden of getting lynched for not wanting the claim

Vader

Alright well I’m the tracker and I’m Steve from blues clues


tough shit if I die atp. Town deserve it for forcing claims in an anti mass claim mechanic

Vader

Im not claiming my actual role because of the anti claim utility but I have confirmation utility in the next DP that will confirm my role


Normal mafia I would claim this but with the anti claim mechanic that is strongly advised against doing, I will not be claiming this DP. If I’m lynched well, I don’t really care

Vader

I mean this is just incorrect. I literally corrected myself and have even said that it’s like 80/20 , 65/35. Blind following is actually detrimental to town play and having skeptism for thing not mod confirmed itself is town play. However since there isn’t a lot of reads this DP and because of how setup is, my POE is that way. This is just misconstruing information

Vader

I think I only played forum mafia with Max like once and I don’t remember his meta at all. I think he’s somewhat easier to identify in live mafia than in forum mafia tbh but I don’t feel like there’s any sus about him

Vader

Right now my reads are as follows


Town

mikal

luna


slight town

unsaid

thoth


null

pie

max

wf

awesome

rex


i think scum is probably in that 5 pool but I don’t see enough behaviorally. The only thing that stands out is Pie getting revenge and I feel he could do that as scum IMO and just clean wipe. Idk it just felt kinda odd for him to say that as town but also why would scum Pie even say that?


awesome is someone with experience and it seems like they aren’t analyzing the game as much as they could be despite having MU experience. Unsaid has forum mafia experience and is trying to evaluate a new player base and I actually really like, even if he is wrong. Seems like he is making an attempt


cant really read Rex and I always find WF hard to read when he’s trying and making a lot of deeper thought


Vader

I think Awesome is a good person to target at this point. My gut is telling me unsaid is town just cuz of his reactions and posts and interactions with other players


whiteflame really hasn’t deviated from his normal play at all from what I’ve seen

Vader

I try to post in bits and spurts but I work 6-3 most days and it’s an hour and 10 drive home with a site that’s not as mobile friendly. I’m home usually around 4:20-4:40 on a good day and then I eat dinner and gym so I usually am back at 7 and if there’s football on forget about posting so sorry for the lack of activity

Vader

I don’t mind switching to Awesome at this point but looking at Mikals behavior and other things I think he’s deffo playing to solve the game and not some hyper fixation on winning. I also think his combo is lethal enough that I just can’t see it being scum unless he’s paired with someone. Mikal is a slight town along with Luna.


At this point I can’t read the new players and it seems like unsaid is talking about a debate site and Epstein rather than mafia but I just feel like he’s town because of this and I have no idea why. I honestly think awesome has been laying a bit low (ironic I say this) and not really putting anything out there despite the experience playing mafia. I also am re-evaluating my Pie read

Vader

Right now my POE is between Whiteflame , awesome, Rex, and Pie. I do like Pie coming off strong but I think he could be enacting revenge in other ways than just trying to carry town

Vader

Also I’m taking Luna out of my town lock pile. I checked where he said he didn’t get a message and couldn’t find any post about it anywhere, so this indicates a private post. Someone please link me if it is there and I could not find it

Vader

I also know this is like Kohai’s 3rd time modding from what I’ve known between DART and DC. Correct me if I’m wrong on this. It seems like this may be a very swingy game where balance may be questionable due to a lack of game creation. This isn’t an insult at all but just something to point out mechanically so I think we really have to hone in on behavior.


But I am also very skeptical on Mikals role for the same reason above. I’ve played in 1 Kohai game and it was an overall basic game with not much different and unique variables

Vader

I don’t really know how to read the new people in this game and I also feel like there’s a mechanic that is making us overthink this “town confirmed” mechanic

Vader

Pretty hard to figure out, I think mechanically Luna is probably town but I’m like 80%. I guess Thoth is like 65% town imo but this game is a bit of a nightmare

Vader

I don’t know how to read awesome or unsaid. Not having a win con seems really weird but I also would think that you would know if you were scum because of discord invites, etc. could be a 3p scenario but don’t think so.

Vader

I feel like this definetly confirmed Thoth at the very least. Spektical of Mikal but he has town confirmation on his side so can’t really push him