Slight town read on Pie due to I think his aggressiveness coming out the block. Almost seems too aggressive where it's town
Slight town read on Pie due to I think his aggressiveness coming out the block. Almost seems too aggressive where it's town
I was about to say, that is a fair assessment but I wouldn't say town confirmed by any means
Why is Luna town locked for this?
This is a bit weird since my role is normal and not some custom role
/in
Damn I got baited. Well played Mikal. Was suspecting WF near the end but I died too soon
/in Nostalgia
Please ping me on disc when game starts
At second thought I think I’m gonna switch to VTL Rex
I totally forgot about the fact that Kohai claimed DP1. I think that builds way more of a barrier to Pie being recruited than Rex being the original scum partner. Right now I am more confident in Rex being scum than Pie or David. Pie is not off my watch list, but I think that ref has a worse case for him considering the fact Kohai claimed DP1 and if anything, was the safest option for scum to recruit since no claims were outted at that point
So you think you’re going to be wrong about my lynch, yet you’re still going for it?
No I think I’m right but it would not shock me if I was wrong
I’m putting my vote now because more likely than not I won’t be on for when the DP ends. Today is my last crazy day of work and after this weekend I’ll be much more free
To be honest. I think that it is more likely than not that Pie got converted and scrambled for a fake claim than Ref messing up his claim Imo. When I was mafia with him he seemed to have his shit in order and wanted to plan things out. He’s also a good enough player that I could not see him fucking up a claim. I also know Casey is a big fan of Pie’s mafia play and if anything would choose Pie. Along with some behaviors I pointed out before and his more defensive attitude, I think Pie is a better lynch than REF
VTL Pie
I am probably gonna be dead wrong about this and it’s gonna be REF and I overthought this, but fuck it
/in Heartbreaking Chicago Bears Moments
Mikal and WF are strong players as well. And I’m the “obvious” choice as you said.
This is obviously true and I still consider Mikal an option but to be honest I feel like a lot of people value you as a mafia player rather than someone else. It is a bit of recency bias where you have dominated and swept games. WF is good but I have reason to believe he is town at the moment but he could be in my pool.
Mikal is the only one I'm considering, and even then, he hasn't shown any indication that he is mafia. He also was under the impression you were ready to be confirmed until the recruit happened.
Right now I am torn between Pie and Rex at the moment. I think if Rex is scum he was on the original team and if I think it's Pie he was recruited and that is not out of the realm of possibilities
Tbh I am honestly torn. At first I was really leaning toward Ref but now after seeing Ref went awol in DP1 then starting to come back DP2, I just find it hard to believe that they would be recruited. I am rulling them out of the equation for at least for being chosen
My question is were they someone who recruited. I know Casey was inactive as well so it would make sense for them to Yakuza someone that was an active town member if you think Rex was scum. Casey would have to make a bold decision on their own without any consultation from Rex. NP was relatively short.
If Casey targetted an active mafia, Pie would probably be the best pick IMO for purely behavior because I think the majority of members think he is one of the best, so if you are trying to win you are likely trying to choose the best person
Not as strong as an SOP, but I would still kinda consider it. Except you have 2 excuses on why you should stay alive and why you are alive
It's the opposite of a Beloved Princess, which in itself I think is an SOP.
Skeptical about Pie. Don’t really love the claim he gave to be honest and his behavior has irked me the whole game. Feels way more defensive than aggressive and haven’t seen him really go after someone that hard. Feels like he’s playing softer than usually, almost safer. Kinda have a feeling he could be scum tbh and I don’t love the claim either, considering he is one of the ones who believed that a Beloved Princess should be an SOP and this role functions similarly
I also think Castin is a decently town. Like I said I think the reactions to this DP’s start, their claim and character, and overall demeanor just come off as town to me at this point. Even last DP I felt like their confusion came off as a new player being confused about what just happened. So I’m essentially putting Castin there
Even night just makes it worse too IMO
I was at first kind of buying the role cop and him getting mad that he is probably not gonna use at first since it can give useful info. But that switch up really throws me off tbh. Feels like something I would do as scum when I’m in a pickle in all honesty. Character cop really does nothing imo considering we don’t know what the theme is and there’s a possibility scum use their real characters cuz people don’t know the theme.
so yeah I don’t know if I like that REF claim. I know I slight town read him but that just threw me way off
Anyway lunch is about to end in 6 and I got a meeting right at 12, so gotta bounce out. My schedule is much more clear after Wednesday so should be more active
I chose WF at first but not really sold on him at this point considering the reactions to the message and by narrowing my POV down a bit
To be honest I’m still not loving the Vengeful claim from Kohai but I have this thought in the back of my head cuz I feel like I’ve been burned so many times by roles like this where I scum read them for being anti town and easy to get away with being lynched and then get burned. I also think there behavior falls in line from what I see with them as town so idk.
I have a slight town read on castin. I think that comment at the beggining came off as genuine fmpov and a misunderstanding of mechanics. Unless it’s a mega bait but I doubt it since they are new to the game. Hard town read for that tbh I know it’s very little but honestly if I was new and didn’t know mechanics I would’ve thought that was probably a kill or a protection
With that being said, I have my suspicions about Pie as well. Tough to read besides pressuring and really haven’t seen him make deep thought compared to others besides just pressuring me to get on and pushing claims. Don’t love Pie here
I like REF’s thought process about the analysis of role and character. I think it’s a unique angle to take. Seems like he’s taking time to think about all options out there at the moment. This just seems like a gut read at the moment and fmpov seems like trying to solve a game . Mikal feels like he’s piggybacking off the logic of REF because there was no new analysis said besides “hard to read” and reiterating what Rex said. Slight FoS
I was the chief science expert but I was also a secret android, in which my goal was to serve the Weyland Corp by ensuring Xenomorph was on board at anyone’s cost. Cuz of this I am the Informant
Gonna try to catch up when I can. Worked got swamped this week out of no where so gonna try my best to catch up when I get the chance
The Bears also played football today gonna try and post but may not have time tonight but catching up now while making my lunch