Anyways I’m running 3 meetings for 2 hours so not gonna be very active
Anyways I’m running 3 meetings for 2 hours so not gonna be very active
Whiteflame got it before me. Damn it
Tbh could Awesome be 3p here?
Observer actually makes a lot of sense tbh depending on claims. Does anyone have an updated claim list?
Sorry if you claimed this, but who did you target
Ok I am going to POE here
Alive
1.Vader
2.Whiteflame
3.Kohai
4.Banana
5.iLikePie5
6.CaseyRisk
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
10.Wryly
11.MagicMan
12. Skep
Skep, Pie, Wryly, myself strong town...
2.Whiteflame
3.Kohai
4.Banana
6.CaseyRisk
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
11.MagicMan
Casey will be removed from POE...
2.Whiteflame
3.Kohai
4.Banana
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
11.MagicMan
Whiteflame town read as described #64
3.Kohai
4.Banana
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
11.MagicMan
Mestari #64 for read
3.Kohai
4.Banana
7.Shining
9.Awesome
11.MagicMan
For now, I think Magic should be slight town. He has some info and if it's good I think he gets locked town.
3.Kohai
4.Banana
7.Shining
9.Awesome
I think this is your POE here.
This is...confusing.
Behaviorally with Mharman his play is way too bold to make in the first place to start off IMO.
But Mhar is good enough to potentially try a gambit like that. Don't know what information mafia got but they could've done something to build town cred and Mharman is 100% good enough to do it. Also his engagement is relatively lower than normal versus when I see his as town in other games.
I am giving it a less than 30% chance he's scum, but 2 different NP+1 death abilities named differently is weird
Either way, Casey is not lynched. If they are alive, they are scum. Lock it in. I haven't heard another claim that can heal ailments like mine so connect the dots together. I will not be targetting Casey at all for healing
Ok, #117 is very damning to me IMO. Let's start with the most obvious. The roles have been very straight forward. The shitty roles with random names that got shifted like Alyssa were scum. Thoth had a shitty claim too. It also feels like that even the roles that are solely characters have roles recognizeable to town and not something new at all. To be hard defense about the role being different and then switching to, yeah it actually is the same is really suspicious. I do not love that reaction there from Banana.
#117 is damning as fuck
What is your reasoning behind Banana.
Honestly Mharman might go back into the POE. Casey and Mharman are claiming two different things to this point and do scum really have two delayed death mechanics in their game??
But then again, how could he have possibly known that he would be healed in the first place... it's a bit gambit. Thinking this one over
Wryly, Pie, and maybe Rex are town lock to me.
I am curious about Mharman. So Casey claims to be injured but Mharman got poisoned.
With that then if Casey is actually injured, there is no point lynching them and tbh if they don't die then they are guaranteed scum. I don't think Casey is optimal lynch today. So removing them from POE
Ok thank you Wryly for the rundown on Rex claim. I think that claim is mildly weird considering the redirect roles we have claimed but still catching up. This also makes me wanna back up off Shining
Ok thank you Wryly for the rundown on Rex claim. I think that claim is mildly weird considering the redirect roles we have claimed but still catching up. This also makes me wanna back up off Shining
Ok catch up time
Does anyone have a screenshot. Damn it I was late
Ok back. Didn't see the update but everything looks normal
Well walking back the 3p read. Re-evaluating the rest
Ok… there we go…this makes more sense then. Walking back my reads
That’s why the whole DP happened
?????? Since when. Rex got a guilty on a Pie
Rex is the cop
Got answers from Mikal about the role
My POE and reads. Sorry for grammar errors I’m typing this on a treadmill
My town locks are Pie and Whiteflame and my strongly town is Mharman / Magicman
2.Whiteflame
3.Kohai
4.Banana
6.CaseyRisk
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
10.Wryly
Banana to me is likely town. I think they have done a good job engaging players throughout the game and have pushed discussions on players and contributed with thoughtful reads. Their behavior has not irked me or felt scummy in any way to this point
2.Whiteflame
3.Kohai
6.CaseyRisk
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
10.Wryly
I think with the news of Casey, I think I would lean town on them to this point. I would like to get a full claim but they would be fucked if I survived and didn’t claim I healed them
2.Whiteflame
3.Kohai
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
10.Wryly
Anyone up to this point has a fair chance at being scum
Contradicting original thoughts, but Whiteflame is next in my town pile. I just feel like he’s well aware of the theme and the split that he would’ve came up with such better claims for scum than what they did. Those last 2 scum claims were weak. I don’t rule him out
3.Kohai
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
10.Wryly
Since I said I thought wryly could be 3p, I’ll exclude them out of scum POE
3 Kohai
7.Shining
8.Mestari
9.Awesome
I’ve had a solid town read on Mestari and that hasn’t changed at all. I think they’ve been consistent, the logic has been great, they’ve put the pressure in the right places and I don’t think they’d hard push Alyssa or Thoth
3 Kohai
7.Shining
9.Awesome
this is my POE atm
The only thing that was push me off is that if scum decided to night kill me, at least Casey would be saved so town would only lose 1. I think this will depend on how the DP ends. I’m going to confirm things with mikal
I would like Casey to full claim here. I have to choose between healing them or protecting a power role here and if Casey’s role is, for a lack of a better term, useless, I see no reason keeping them alive