Banana

can we try something wierd guys? just indulge me. its about the pms.


what does your pm say. does it say you win with the town or something like that? if everyone could tell me what theirs says exactly i would appreciate it. i might not be onto something here but i just wanna check


mine says 'you win with the town'

Banana


whiteflame wrote:

Kohai wrote:

whiteflame wrote:
Can someone point me to the reason for sussing Ultra? Is it just the VTL out of nowhere?
1. VTL out of nowhere with poor reasoninggg behind it. Et waz literaly just an OMGUS bote.
2. He den completely disappeared
3. Haz little interactions and kontent.
4. Ergo dis is a good slot to presssire.

2-4 I get. The first is harder to read given his interaction with Rex.

interestin defense. lets flip this around, do you town read him, n if so why?

Banana


whiteflame wrote:
Can someone point me to the reason for sussing Ultra? Is it just the VTL out of nowhere?

just read his iso, see if it feels as odd to u as it did to me. buncha of posts that dont really establsh anything or push the game fwd and then random vote on rex. then he gets pressure, but doesnt think 4/7 is eough for a claim so he stalls it out for some reason. idk just seems sus to me.

Banana


Ultracrepidarian wrote:
You just want everything to be handed to you. Y'know when I was your age I won mafia games while walking to school uphill, BOTH WAYS!

is this a soft claim for old ppl?

Banana


Ultracrepidarian wrote:
If I had to guess I would say the lie is five, purely because that's what I would choose as mafia for fake claiming.

interesting

Banana


Thoth wrote:
The wording “Mafia Tailor” strikes me as odd. Why would any other alignment have a Tailor? Something about that wording stands out to me as being in Lunatic’s pen.

like u think the tailor is false?

Banana


Wryly wrote:

whiteflame wrote:

Thoth wrote:
whiteflame wrote:
Option #4 limits the possible claims to one of those 3 areas. If it just laying out the actual theme split, then why would scum post #3 at all?
I was just saying that this is a plausible example of a theme split, not the actual theme split.

And my point is that there are an absurd number of possible splits and ways to split characters with this theme. That’s my point: the presence of a theme split doesn’t put a lot of pressure on scum because it would almost certainly be difficult to parse out anyway.

Well never mind lol I misunderstood you.

It seems to me that if you were told you'd be getting no fake claims but could make up any game mechanic you wanted, you'd probably want a game mechanic that offsets the loss of being given no fake claims.

Saying there's no theme split allows you to straight claim your characters with virtually no risk, which is preferable to the some-to-moderate risk of straight claiming when everyone knows there is a theme split.


yeah my thoughts exactly

Banana


whiteflame wrote:

Thoth wrote:
whiteflame wrote:
Option #4 limits the possible claims to one of those 3 areas. If it just laying out the actual theme split, then why would scum post #3 at all?
I was just saying that this is a plausible example of a theme split, not the actual theme split.

And my point is that there are an absurd number of possible splits and ways to split characters with this theme. That’s my point: the presence of a theme split doesn’t put a lot of pressure on scum because it would almost certainly be difficult to parse out anyway.

i was thinking that one would be a good option for scum to choose. if we think there’s no theme split we don’t have a lot of basis to sus ppl on their claims. if we lynch people we can tie scum with other scum. it leaves us with just role analysis

Banana

Mikal wrote:
Also we are already getting lost in the sauce about the op. Need to focus someone to get any info out of the day. Which one is accurate or not will become more apparent in later dps id imagine. There is going to be nothing we can read from opinions on this dp1 and just lets scum fluff post or slide by. We need to actually get a claim. My pick is wf

im okay with moving on from it but i understand why pie wants us to get peoples opinions on this. basically we can form analysis later on in the game as we have more information based on who thought what thing about the manipulation. if it gets revealed that there is a tailor we can look at people who cast doubt about it being a tailor in dp1. if it’s the vanillas one then if we find out there isn’t more than one vanilla than look at people who doubted that one. it’s a good idea to get people to form ideas about this

Banana


whiteflame wrote:
Banana wrote:
ching Chong bing bong very good points u make. U might be one of my ppl

We are all united, my child.

will i be born again?

Banana


Magoroth wrote:

Banana wrote:

ILikePie5 wrote:
can we plz be girls girls this game. men are stupid
i tried tell u about the patriarchy and u didn’t believe me. u should have known cuz im the smarter race
Jew? Asian?

what u think fuk boiii i will kung fu u if you guess my race wrong!

Banana


ILikePie5 wrote:
can we plz be girls girls this game. men are stupid

i tried tell u about the patriarchy and u didn’t believe me. u should have known cuz im the smarter race

Banana


RexFavilla wrote:

Kohai wrote:
Hickuo hickup

VTL: RexFavilla

lookeng furward 2 dis.
джжншсикб

Please kill me. The people I received a rolecard for do not deserve to exist.

and the first racism has oficily happened guys

Banana


ILikePie5 wrote:

Banana wrote:
i think it’s 1 or 2. 1 becuz mafia want us to be paranoid about 3p and waste time hunting them and 2 bcuz again is causes paranoia n confusion which mafia want more of. i dont think the other ones help them much.

omg slayyy

uh r u a girl or a gay man lol

Banana

i think it’s 1 or 2. 1 becuz mafia want us to be paranoid about 3p and waste time hunting them and 2 bcuz again is causes paranoia n confusion which mafia want more of. i dont think the other ones help them much.