Banana

I'm down for Awesome's claim but I'm already thinking to lynch Kohai today. I'm 99% sure he just TMI'd thrice in three posts

VTL Awesome

can u explain?

This contradicts what you just said. If Thoth and Alyssa went off script then why would you defend your claim saying it's nothing like a fake claim Mikal gave, based on the claims Thoth and Alyssa made?

right and how do we even know those were fake claims given to them

You haven’t played with me as scum. I have claims ready almost immediately. I’m not butchering claims that bad. Period

but u never played with someone who just did there own thing and didnt listen to u? or did something that hurt ur team while u were offline?

Wylted has been killed.

Flip posted the next dp. Timer is no longer active.

what... is happening...

A scum player who is not in scum chat and doesn't know who the other scum players are.

o interestin

Also mag1c is not confirmed town. He literally could have done that to bait the doctor away from the two guild leaders. That said, I do htink mag1c is likely town based on behavior

but ur also saying that it wasnt smart for him to claim doctor so im confused why you think he would bait that if you didnt think the doctor would or should claim

A Lost Wolf could explain a lot. That means scumchat only had 3 players in it. If the third player was underactive or unformidable or both, much of scum's game makes sense.

sorry can u explain what a lost wolf is

Who gives a shit if Vader revealed he is Doc? Town is absolutely spanking mafia and Mhar is more or less conftown.

he was probly confirmed anyway, would be dumb to lie about being poisoned. but o well

That said I don't disagree that parts of pie's play is scummy. I just don't see w!Pie allowing these two retards to claim the way they did.

i dont get the argument that it happened means pie allowed it to happen lol what if it happened and he wasnt online to do anything about it or they did it without consulting him

ok. Claiming now. Last night I healed Mharman / mag1c from positioning. I am a Doctor that can heal aliments.i am min byung gyu

probaly wasnt necesary to claim there but o well

Wow how reatrded are thees wolves?

do u mean mafia? yeah idk what they are doing

ill check back in later gotta go

p#340

this post is also kinda bad lmao

im bad at this game and even i understand the purpose of his question. why do u think this post is bad?

Based on #269 and #270, I feel like there’s one scum in Kohai/Banana

why?

Okay, you guys are scumreading the self-vote hard and I'm kind of lost. Is it a thing that town never self-votes but scum do?

at this point the fact that she disapeared and never came back is kind of telling

ATTENTION:

I was poisoned last night. I will die at the end of NP2.

Any healers?

R u sure its smart for the healer to say?

If Alyssa is popular, how did the vote reset then? It had to have been activated somehow right…

idt thats the actual role she claimed just what we have been callin it. i dont think it changes much tho with the other factors regarding alyssa

So something I brought up in my mason Pm is the idea of pushing a mass claim in dp3.

We already have a decent head start after Thoth, if Alyssa is scum it s a very good start. At this point to me the risk/benefit of this leans towards benefit. As of right now we have no reason to assume mafia can kill more than once per night phase, so at best they can take out one power role that night. If there is a town vig it will help them know who not to kill going forward. And lastly it can help us narrow down third party. To be clear I don’t care about hunting third party too much if it detracts from hunting scum but my guild doesn’t feel the same way understandably.

Especially after the third party apparently chose not to win with town. So without behavioral analysis to link them to Thoth or Alyssa (they can literally just play how they would as town and we wouldn’t know) the best way to nail third party would be to use mech analysis. Getting claims can help us narrow down which claims are less likely to exist versus which claims are mostly likely to be in the game.

One of my guild mates is strongly against a mass claim and I get there reasons for it. But I figured this would be worthwhile to discuss with the rest of town. And gather some opinions on.

its 2 early for a mass claim, but im not opposed to claiming if u think it would help next dp

Vote Count 

Alyssa 7/9 - wylted, luna, shining, alyssa, kohai, Vader, banana

Awesome 1/9 - helz

That’s just WIFOM. I was the popular scum in his previous game and it definitely didn’t function the way Alyssa claims it functions

Everything is wifom im just trying to consider all options. but at this point i think its likely alyssa is scum since there has been no attempt to defend herself so it doesnt matter anyway

vtl alyssa.

Gotta say, don’t love how your only contribution was to provide and out for Alyssa. Who do you think is scum and why?

i wasnt! all i said was that it is usually a role we see as town and that its no likely the mod would do the same thing twice, but that was before i saw the part about the slip. i just want to make sure we are checking every box and not makin 2 quick a decision is all.

my scum read right now is kohai. for one i do not like that he keeps trying to beg for town cred from the vote on thoth even tho he had the weakest reasons for it. and i dont like that he claimed himself immediately because given the mod openly said people are themselves in this game it makes it a likely fake claim option. we have good reason to think thoth used a fake claim already so it makes this claim seem more sketch ya know? also his reasoning for pie seems kind of weak but he keeps goin after it

kohai can u confirm if your role is able to be used without recruitment since your the only person who claimed a non solo level character

Also with Alyssa being popular I’ll remind you in the last game Mikal hosted he made scum popular. Don’t automatically hard clear Alyssa

but wuld he do it twice in a row? also most of the time it seems like popular is town, there is good reason to believe she is honest here

I’m the one who started the Thoth wagon.

i dont like that u keep bringing this up despite having the worst argument for the wagon. like tell us you want town cred for it and then u give us a reason to suspect your intent wasn't genuine combined with being on him for the weakest reason ya know

I have two abilities:

First is called Widely Admired - I require one additional vote beyond the normal majority to be eliminated during the day phase. Once this ability triggers, the vote count resets and this ability is consumed.

Second is called Rally the Hunters - Each night, I can target one player and, if they have a night action they can take, they can use that night action an additional time that night.

both of these seem confmable to thats good news at least

hi guys had a busy easter didnt realise this was up already let me catch up. i see we got one of them tho so good job on thoth guys!

i havent read like anything but i still see people are wanting thoth, so i will go ahead and add my vote. maybe i can catch up during the night phase but tere is no earthly way im doing it 2night. u guys post soooo much

vtl thoth

Right now it's looking like Thoth is going to be the lynch today. I'm okay with that, but I'd like to ask everyone here a question. If you had to vote for someone else, who would your choice be, and why?

prolly alyssa, shining, vader, or airmax. ik that seems like im targeting all inactives but i town read a lot people

can u explain the reason for the wryly push to me? i town read her so i just dont see it ig

Could a theoretical vig actually kill during NP1 tho? I'm gonna ask Mikal

Y would u assume otherwise?