ILikePie5
There is one reason that comes to mind for why you would have killed Wryly if you were a scum Neighborizer: she told you that she was a Tracker/Watcher, and you were afraid that she would see something you didn't want her to.


Exactly. She served her purpose in getting the role confirmation from her. And when he realized she’s the Tracker/Watcher it made perfect sense to have his scum partner do the dirty work while he sits on his pedestal and screams “I told you so,” while acting like he did something. When in reality, he just sat there inactive for hours upon hours.

ILikePie5
The series of lynches which this town has engaged in has been disastrous for town.


You were on the first one. You didn’t care who to lynch out of Cerulean or Kohai. You were inactive for the entire DP until the last minute where you came to put a vote.


The first was a last-minute lynch in which we targeted an unclaimed player, so it wasn't so revealing. Even scum didn't know that Kohai was the dreamer. In the second we lynched the claimed jailkeeper on incredibly shaky basis, with Pie implying that he had a protective role, then today he's waffled on that and called his claimed role 'semi-protective'.


Wow, more gaslighting. How is it “waffling.” I said an another protective role could exist and may not want to reveal themselves, but that in itself wasn’t an even a major factor in Shining’s lynch. The major factor was that he claimed a character from a different season, and he completely 180ed a read, did not JK Cerulean who he thought was scum, and instead JKed me even though he thought I was a town PR. He was scummy af objectively. And the fact that only you were against it at the end is revealing. You knew he was town and wanted to use it to your advantage while your scum partner was in favor the lynch.


Scum is clearly between Pie and I, as if it weren't one of us would be dead right now and the game would be over.


Yes, and you are scum.

ILikePie5
Why on earth would I want to talk to her if I didn't pressure her for any info or discuss her night actions beyond NP1, which she volunteered by commenting that we targeted each other? How did I manipulate her? Using a role like that as scum is just a needless risk, and not nearly strong enough to balance the protective and investigative roles in this game.


The more you try to WIFOM, the deeper in the hole you get lol.


The role is a blessing for scum. It’s a confirmable role, and we all know this community loves their confirmable roles. Only me, WF, and Luna are weary of these “confirmable roles.” I literally fake claimed Innocent Child and got away with it because it’s a confirmable role lol.


I don’t know what was said in the PM, and no one here you should believe anything you claim Wryly said in the PM. But it’s a fact that using your role on Wryly was the logical option knowing what you know.


As for balance. I don’t know what roles scum has in their arsenal. This entire argument is all WIFOM.

ILikePie5
Like what is the claim here? That I as scum have a role that lets me open a chat with a townie as scum, I used it on wryly, who was convinced I was town and suspicious of my supposed mislynch target, and then I killed her?


If Wryly was convinced you were town, she would’ve told you exactly what she did last night. And you yourself admitted that she didn’t.


It’s actually a perfect play to use his ability on Wryly as I mentioned earlier. If he’s scum and Ceru is town, then he knows that either Wryly or Luna are the investigative role. He chopped one and got into a chat with the other. Luna makes sense to kill cause he’s a strong player. Talking to Wryly makes sense as well because he can manipulate her.

ILikePie5
If you lynch me after letting him convince you to lynch to jailer last DP town deserves to lose lmao


Lol, if you had a problem, you should’ve said something. Oh wait, you were AWOL while the wagon was building. Also it’s kinda funny that you’re ONLY blaming me for it. Wryly was willing to vote for him as well and Supa was the one who started the lynch.

ILikePie5

VTL REF


There is no world where REF is town. He’s straight up gaslighting about events that happened in the game to push his own narrative. I can pull the receipts for anyone interested.

ILikePie5
Think about last DP. I was one of the ONLY people pushing back against an Earth lynch and saying that it didn't make sense. Pie literally mislynched the claimed jailkeeper last DP.


Hindsight is 20/20. But objectively he was scummy, and the fact that you’re blaming me for that lynch is rich. Literally your sole reason was “he was a claimed town protective role.” Zero behavioral analysis. And it’s actually funny that you completely ignored the behavior analysis and were AWOL for hours in the day. You didn’t do anything to stop that lynch. You’re flailing hard and you know it

ILikePie5
Think about the NKs. Whose strategy do they align with? If I wanted to mislynch Pie this DP, why kill Wryly, who townread me and was willing to lynch Pie?


Who said Wryly was willing to lynch me lol. She made one post last DP about why she sussed me and it was all based on a misunderstanding as she herself acknowledged.

ILikePie5
I told Wryly that if I were the NK she should tunnel Pie hard, thinking that the two possibilities were killing me in the night or mislynching me for scumPie this DP. The fact that I was the immediate push for a mislynch from him makes sense with the Wryly kill - it was a kill meant to take out a possible power role, a widely townread player, and one which would isolate me and allow Pie to mislynch me more easily. Wryly was also one of the first people to scumread Pie, even though I had been doing so for a bit before going public with it last DP.


This is just massive gaslighting. REF was the one immediately pushing me. His first post was literally a vote on me lol. Go read my first post. No where was I “immediately pushing” REF. I was analyzing what happened so far. It’s actually really ironic since he’s blaming me for something he literally did. And also the fact that he told Wryly to tunnel me as if she would listen to him, lol

ILikePie5

REF has been trying to get a mislynch on me since yesterday. Go read his reasoning for scumreading me DP2. It’s literally just “muh vibes.” He was trying to set it up since yesterday.

ILikePie5
Also just saying, I know this is like the second Whiteflame game ever so this sample size is so small, but he had literally a game where he had only 1 vanilla in a 9 person setup as well in this


Yes, I pointed that out, which is why I’m still undecided on who REF’s scum partner is. At this point he’s just flailing

ILikePie5
In DP1 I did not start the lynch and wasn't even on it.

I started the wagon in DP2 and was the charge of it, you hopped on quite literally at the last second despite pushing Ceru hard. Now IMO he's town lock (almost)


Bro what? Go reread the DP. I was questioning Shining literally all of last DP. Go look at the 6 points I had made. I never pushed Ceru hard DP2.


ILikePie5
Ummm, except you didn't use it? Why on earth would you be worried about a redirector targeting you for a role which you claim to never have used?


Thats hindsight bias. In the moment I was thinking about whether I should use it or not to prevent a possible NK on me. High risk, high reward. Cause believe it or not, I had been the only person active at that point. So I was worried about that, which is why I waived. Again. Conservative.

ILikePie5
Hider is just such a weak claim at this point in time consider NOW we know that a Watcher was in the game. Cerulean claimed the Gravedigger right away.


How is it a “weak” claim. Ceru could’ve just as easily asked about Gravedigger and when there was non, SOP claimed it. I’ve been wanting to do it for eons, cause everyone magically believes these SOP roles are town.


Strengthener with a town JK is feasible, maybe Thoth plays on the claim by claiming his actual mafia role at that point, but it makes a lot of sense. 


Why would there be a scum Strengthener? That makes no sense.


I feel like Rex's flip does make sense, considering my affiliation and such. It is hard to see. I just find it hard to buy Pie's claim considering his lazy last-second lynch on Kohai


”Last-second lazy lynch.”


You’ve got to be kidding right. You were the one that started the wagon.


ILikePie5

A Strengthener makes sense with a Town JK and even more sense with a Scum RB/Redirector/Bus Driver etc. It’s honestly a question of is there a grave digger in the game

ILikePie5

Actually, just looked at Microbiology Mafia and there was a lone Vanilla. So if WF used a similar design it makes sense for Supa to actually be a Vanilla here vs a full role madness game. But that means Thoth/Ceru has scum in it. Could be REF/Thoth

ILikePie5
Pie coming out with his night action claims only once he knew the Watcher/Tracker is dead is hella suss.


There was nothing to report. I waived both nights cause I am conservative. And you claim that Wryly visited you. That’s not a given either. And why would ever in a million years reveal that I am a Hider


The fact that he didn't outright counterclaim Earth is also suspect - doing so would set up a 1v1 in town's mind - if he thought Earth were scum he would have no problem with that, and it's not like his role has some crazy negative or positive utility where it would be a big problem to divulge - he can just choose not to use it, which is what he claims to have done already.


Because it’s not a counterclaim? A hider is a semi protective. I can only protect myself at the expense of there being 2 NKs. And I did push Shining…because it is a semi protective. I’m never going to out my role unless there’s sufficient votes to lynch me. You and I both know that. This is just disingenuous. I could’ve hid behind people who I thought were scum, but like I said. I’m a conservative player.


If he is scum and ceru is town he knows that ceru isn't lying about his role and so would know since DP1 that there was a watcher/tracker.


The same applies to you.


The only reason to play that card close to his chest would be to avoid having to claim his night actions while said watcher/tracker could contradict him. And to avoid setting up that 1v1, which he would see as a big risk if he knew that earth was a town power role and a disastrous mislynch for town.


Or here’s an idea. Keep my role and character hidden so scum like you don’t know what it is and take advantage of it. For example, what if your side has a redirector. You could redirect me to a townie and take 2 kills and essentially win the game.


If I said that I visited Supa or Ceru in previous nights, you would have the exact same criticism because you’re trying to find a way to implicate me that just doesn’t exist.

ILikePie5

I don’t think the Neighborizer has to be town. I know WF subscribes to the same ideology as me and Luna that confirmable roles aren’t necessarily town roles.


Vanilla is also clearly an outlier when everyone else has a role.


My theory assuming that Ceru is town (which is likely now with Wryly’s flip) is that scum knew there would be a Town Watcher/Tracker. And the people more likely to believe Ceru were more likely to be that role. Which is why Luna was the NK and REF chose to chat with Wryly. They were the only two if I recall that were hesitant on lynching Ceru that day.


Of course this assumes a Gravedigger exists in the first place, which is why I hate being in this position in the first place, but no one ever listens to me

ILikePie5
I’m also gonna claim right away. I am Cristobal Sifuentes and I am the vanilla. I slowly fade from relevance from the plot before dying at the end after being captured and going through brainwashing and was betrayed by Hank after being saved


So you’re the only claimed Vanilla. I frankly don’t buy it at all

ILikePie5
And that is... exactly what I was afraid of. Right.

Pie hardclaim, then we go from there, I suppose.


I am Monroe Fuches and the Hider. It’s a semi protective role, which is why I was hesitant to believe Shining. I waived both nights to ensure that town gets the maximum amount of lynches possible.

ILikePie5
Essentially locks Cerulean by the way


There’s an outside shot there is no Gravedigger and it all comes back to if scum asked about it. If they have like an 1x Ninja, it makes sense, especially considering Wryly was a 1x/1x. But the odds are lower that he’s scum with Wryly’s flip


Its essentially a POE of Rex, Pie, Thoth
ILikePie5
I am no-ho hank, I'm the one time neighborizer. I chose Wryly, partly because I thought she TMId DP1 and might be scum and that she would find the chat unnerving and slip, but gradually came to see her as town over the course of DP1. Unfortunately, she never gave me her results for NP1, aside from saying that she visited me. I have no idea who she visited NP2.


So your role is confirmable but your affiliation isn’t

ILikePie5
He means if there is no scum roleblocker and only a Jailkeeper in the game it would mean his Strengthener is only there to counter a townie role, ergo negative utility (I think)


But he can strengthen the townies as well so they can’t be blocked.


What do you think of the possibility of a 3P


It’s possible but probably unlikely. 6-2-1 is pretty anti-town assuming the 3P can joint win with scum as well. Town would be denied a 3rd lynch of their choosing, which doesn’t make sense to me.

ILikePie5
I will say that, if Shining flips Jailkeeper, I'm still going to believe there's a scum roleblocker or redirector. I don't think my role is just negative utility.


How is your role negative utility? Strengtheners are neutral. They can prevent scum and town actions from being blocked or manipulated


ILikePie5
You know, I am sick of having the justification conversation every game. Its utterly meaningless most times.


Thats fine, address the rest of the points. The complete 180 explanation you gave was just “muh vibes”