ILikePie5
Rex/Shining/Vader feels like the "easy" POE here.

But I also don't think Mafia games are ever allowed to be easy, unless I'm wolfing.


Sometimes the mafia gods are in our favor. I think Wryly’s behavior is town. Vader is still null to me. Thoth feels better now. I think behaviorally you have improved significantly as well. REF is getting weaker. It’s very plausible that there’s 2 scum in Shining/Vader/REF imo. But I am paranoid that Gravedigger was one of the questions asked and not even in the game


ILikePie5
I don't believe WF would discard Barry from the game, and frankly it would surprise me if the main character was on the Mafia side of the theme split. This means that, unfortunately, game is hard.


I wouldn’t discount Barry being scum. I’ve made games here the main character is scum or outright omitted. Barry is probably in the game, but the character itself is NAI

ILikePie5
Question, Shining- why didn't you try to roleblock me? It's clear that you did and still do suspect me, and with my claim, I likely would have carried the nightkill, if scum, since being seen wouldn't be incriminating. If you thought Pie was a PR, blocking him would have cost his action as well.


+1

ILikePie5
I'm unsure of the implications on Shining's claim. Strengthener implies scum have an RB and Shining could be a scum RB claiming Jailbreaker as a cover. Everyone who's claimed or flipped has a major character from season 1 except Shining. Jim Moss seems like a bit of a pull.


I like this theme analysis. I’ll also say that my character is in season 1 as well, so it fits the analysis.

ILikePie5
Again, I thoroughly apologize to everyone for my low activity level. I think I have to claim, even if it's only to get out of the grave I dug (no offense to Cerulean) for myself by being inactive.


Yes you do. And I’m glad you did.


I am Barry Berkman, Strengthener. Each night, I can choose a player and make their action immune to blocks or redirects. Justification is that Barry got other people tangled into his misadventures with the criminal underworld, which led them into committing acts that they would not have done otherwise. Last night, I used it on Wryly because she was my strongest townread.


Hmm. Barry is definitely in the game as the main character. Could he be scum? Maybe. This claim further implicates Shining though. The role is a direct counter to the Roleblock aspect


The reason I thought Lunatic's Informed Townie message about someone's role being a greater nuisance than they know might refer to me is because I could override Shining's Jailkeeper. When I got my role PM, I figured that my role was in this setup to counter a scum roleblocker or redirector of some kind. There probably is one in the setup because I don't think my role is purely negative utility, especially not with Cerulean likely being a Gravedigger, but I didn't know that, if I targeted a mafiosi, I could potentially nullify a town roleblocker and/or a town protective.


This doesn’t make any sense to me, but it’s a red herring regardless. We won’t know what the nuisance is until endgame.


I would still like your reads

ILikePie5
If you didn't execute an action that doesn't mean much; if you did it means quite a bit


I asked WF I should’ve and he said no. He said his policy is that if the role being JKed gives any sort of feedback, the person would receive a notification that their action failed. My role doesn’t receive feedback

ILikePie5
If Shining is telling the truth, you either have a passive, waived your action, or got an action failed message last NP. Did you get an action failed message? 


I received no such message

ILikePie5
No one has claimed one; if someone came forward with one that would put some pressure on Shining.


I wouldn’t want them to come out, because the other 5 points should be enough. He comes in last second to hammer Kohai. Fine. He Jailkeeps me cause he thinks I’m town. Fine. But now he wants to lynch me? He knows logistically I’m less likely to be town cause if he JKed me, then I wouldn’t be able to execute the NK.

ILikePie5

If you’re sussing me for this alone then REF and Shining go way above. I at least had a scum read on Kohai. They just came out of nowhere

ILikePie5

Maybe I should just go AWOL like Thoth. Town deserves to lose this. Some of you are hard throwing

ILikePie5

Pie: Thoth, Cerulean, Shining

Shining: Pie, Cerulean, XXX

REF: Pie, Supa, Thoth

Vader: Shining, REF, Pie


3 - Pie

2 - Ceru

2 - Thoth

2 - Shining

1 - Supa

1 - REF


ILikePie5
Pie outright admitted he would have tunneled Kohai had he survived and yet when he flipped town he made no attempt to at least recognize he was wrong. If Pie is town, he can't read 'scummy' town players for shit because he was wrong about Kohai and wrong about me. 


It’s not rocket science that I was wrong but that doesn’t mean I was wrong objectively. Objectively, he was scum. Period. And it’s not my fault that he’s scummy as a townie.


Even if he survived, he was going to be scummy. So ironically it’s better that we lynched him yesterday cause if we had lynched Ceru and he’s town we could have been at LYLO tomorrow.


ILikePie5

Pie: Thoth, Cerulean, Shining

Shining: Pie, Cerulean, XXX

REF: Pie, Supa, Thoth

Vader: Shining, REF, Ceru


3 - Cerulean

2 - Pie

2 - Thoth

2 - Shining

1 - Supa

1 - REF

ILikePie5
His reasoning just seems stretched and more scant than in games where he was town.


Like what?


I don't share or understand many of his scum reads, and I've noticed subtle shifts to drive the lynch onto people who have scumread him this DP, which I interpret as an attempt to mold the late game by establishing himself as an uncontested town leader, not as an honest attempt to scum hunt.


This makes zero sense. I’ve already shared my reasoning for why Shining and Ceru could be scum. Thoth is inactive so he’s dead weight anyways.


Trying to lynch our only claimed protective role with no counterclaim this DP also just seems insane to me from a town perspective, especially since we already lost an investigative role.


And how do you know I’m not a protective role or someone else isn’t?


A) Role isn’t everything.

B) JK could be a RB and likely is

C) Justification doesn’t make sense

D) Complete flip flop on his part on me

E) Hammered Kohai last minute for sole purpose of getting lynch

ILikePie5
I don't see a successful wagon forming on him within 24 hours, but yeah, I'll hammer him.


On what grounds lol. Yes let’s lynch the guy who’s been hard carrying town. Genius idea lol

ILikePie5

Pie: Thoth, Cerulean, Shining

Shining: Pie, Cerulean, XXX

REF: Pie, Supa, Thoth



2 - Cerulean

2 - Pie

2 - Thoth

1 - Shining

1 - Supa


ILikePie5

Name your top three people you would be willing to lynch right now. I’ll start:


Thoth, Shining, Cerulean

ILikePie5
The problem is you are giving credit to Rex for the same logic that Kohai gave and still voted Kohai. I think this is just a disagreement of philosophy, but no lynch > mislynch.


A no lynch when it’s 7-2 benefits scum lol. I also had behavioral reasons to vote Kohai as well regardless of what he said.


Obviously we know Kohai wasn’t confirmable but if you wanted to lynch him today after that over Ceru, I would’ve been way more understanding and town read you. It’s kind of contradictory


It was no lynch or lynch Kohai who I had behavioral reasons to lynch as well. No lynch purely benefits scum because we lose a lynch on our terms

ILikePie5
My issue with that is that it's pretty ballsy to be the first dude to claim a protective role as scum. The counterclaim risk would be pretty high.


2 protective roles are possible and pretty common in games. I think the bigger issue is behavior. The hammer is whatever. But the 180 flip from town to scumreading me, especially after he knows I didn’t execute the NK. Combine that with the justification being wacky

ILikePie5
Didn't think of Jailbreaker being an easy cover for an RB. Whether the justification works, eh idk. He did claim with minimal pressure.


It’s a very common scum fake claim, and the justification seems a little manufactured, which is why the alarm bells are going off. Plus the complete 180 on behavioral reads

ILikePie5
Lean Town
Wryly

I think that they have actively tried to move this game in a positive direction with their thoughts and activities, as much as they can for a player with limited experience. I think their contributions have been enough. As a new player, I remember when I was first scum I didn’t want to talk too much and was careful with posting. Don’t think wryly is doing that


I think Wryly is experienced at this point. She just made a silly mistake last game, otherwise it was easily the best TP performance I’ve seen


Null
Thoth - not enough behaviorally to go off of


Agreed. Would like a claim from him before the DP ends


FoS
iLikePie- I think no matter you have to put Pie in the FOS. I understand his logic for voting Kohai in that situation but I also know that quick lynching after proclaiming “Kohai” always seems scummy and pivot off your pivot target is a red flag. On the other hand, as scum I don’t think he actively tries to push the game as much as does with reads. I also just think him jumping so easily on that wagon isn’t how he would go about that as scum. He’d be way more calculated


Go read back. I preferred Ceru until the last minute basically, but we simply just didn’t have the votes


Ceru - I honestly could just be overthinking this, but it’s known he has experience and even after rereading DP1, I get his points in this DP but it still doesn’t come off right. Why, even in that position, do you not just claim what your role is??? I just don’t understand the logic there. The logic is that the question he asked to WF was if a cop was in and the answer was yes, so he didn’t want to out a miller. But even then, the miller would have CC’d that by the time he switched to Gravedigger. It’s just not adding up but if I read into it I think I overthought it


I agree that it’s odd not to just SOP full claim. If Ceru lives till LYLO and I’m also alive, it’s gonna suck balls. I also don’t think Ceru has done any scum hunting, which is odd to me. Thematically he started saying a few things but crickets since then. Maybe the SOP I can get over the behavior seems just like he’s skating.


Lean Scum
Shining - don’t love the claim to be honest. Thought I could rule it off to him being lazy but he’d do the same lazy thing as scum too. I also think it’s an easy cover for a RB. his justification also reads WAYYYY too much like a Role Cop or some Lawyer role


Ya I don’t like the justification either, which is why I want Ceru’s thoughts on it. And yes, JK is a common fake claim for Scum Roleblockers. The flip flop also doesn’t make sense for me.


Rex - this is tough but sometimes Rex as scum does obviously scummy things to make yourself overthink things. Lack of activity and a quick vote with limited input in the game (ironic from me), but to jump in a lynch without any justification is so weird


Thats fair, but he has a confirmable role. Whether it’s scummy, only Wryly would know. It’s hard to judge


so I’m fine with either 4 at this point