ILikePie5
This was false as an ascetic would not be told of their role. I was playing along and asked him about this. He said this was the opposite of what he told you initially.


I have no idea what ur saying lol

ILikePie5

Oh I almost forgot, I was perma roleblocked NP1. The ability was acquired by REF NP1. WF and REF were both in my POE at the end of NP1 so logically makes sense for them to perma roleblock me

ILikePie5

Alright, so I’ve reread all the DPs. Not much going on in DP1. DP2 is where it gets interesting. Supa’s reaction to the recruitment seems genuinely like wtf is going on. I’m also respecting Mharman2’s read on Supa about that. I also think the approach to Mikal’s action was townie. The action choice and behavior sound like classic Supa.


DP3 is also interesting especially with the CC. Supa immediately votes me with his supposed plan for the night. REF comes in after followed by WF. Like I said this is a red herring for the most part cause scum REF clearly did not care about keeping Wryly alive (so this argument that WF made DP4 falls flat imo). That means the only thing he has is the yolo


Admittedly the recruitment mechanic is my biggest hold up right now, but if this was a yolo, then I can’t really do much about it. I think behaviorally Supa has been better than WF. Anyways I hate being in this position but hopefully I didn’t sell lol.


VTL Whiteflame

ILikePie5
The END OF THE DP SAYS IT WAS GIVEN TO A TOWNIE BRUH. Even if you think I yolo’d, if I was scum in anyway I wouldn’t have gotten it and I would’ve been CC’d. It says townie at the end of dp3. There is 0% chance 


You wouldn’t be CCed if Magic was the one that got it.

ILikePie5

I can buy the idea that REF/WF preferred to keep me alive because I was more likely to lynch Kohai the following DP. This plan was foiled though by Wryly basically outting that REF was scum.


By lynching Pie though, they could’ve secured a lynch on Wryly to win the game today though, which is where I am confused

ILikePie5
READ THE FUCKING END THREAD I CANT BE SCUM


I can read bruh. The argument WF is making is that you yoloed it in the hope that Mharman2 got the shot. Do I believe it? Idk yet. I need to still reread the DPs

ILikePie5
It honestly doesn’t say anything about how his recruitment works. It describes his character as granting them wishes in exchange for turning them into madical girls, but they also hide how they are either turned into a witch or die fighting one. The only mechanical thing was the Escape Wolf mention and his role he got


What does Escape Wolf do?

ILikePie5
Yeah. I'm beginning to think it's vader over whiteflame given vader admitted to accepting the contract plus a few other things. But again I'm also going a bit insane with the recruitment mechanisms.


I need to reread all the DPs before I make a determination. It’s a matter of whether I believe REF/Supa yoloed or not

ILikePie5

It makes sense for a REF/Vader team to lynch Wryly over me though. Cause I wouldn’t have pursued REF and would’ve settled for a Kohai lynch

ILikePie5
If Rex's role card does mention more than 1 contract form then he is basically confirmed scum. 


Probably. Need the details though.



ILikePie5

I think the answer to my question is that lynching Wryly > lynching Pie because Wryly knew exactly who scum was (REF). Scum probably didn’t factor in the fact that Weyly could’ve revealed the list after her death in twilight.


Until I CCed Wryly, scum probably were running under the assumption that Kohai was the TP. With the CC, they knew for a fact that Wryly was the TP and that’s why she was going after scum (REF).


The issue though is why REF + Vader/WF would vote Wryly in the first place. Because a Pie lynch there wins them the game. 4-2-1 becomes 2-2-1. At the same time, I think this is a red herring in the sense that it doesn’t matter WHY they voted Wryly over me. The point is all 3 did.

ILikePie5
This is what's bothering me as well. Also with rex being conf scum why not redirect the kill onto pie so there won't be a night kill? Pie is BP and we wouldn't have had a NK. 


REF doesn’t have to execute the NK. In fact, it was the recruit that did yesterday and today based on the OP

ILikePie5
Yes, and they knew it was a numbers game. I recognize they took a big risk claiming that Vader received it, but they already had good reason to believe you hadn't (you would have announced it in one of those first few posts), so they only had to bank on a 1 in 3 chance. Wouldn't be the first time I've seen someone play the odds to get townread with a ballsy claim.


But why take the risk is my point. He could’ve just as easily said that he directed Kohai to Pie without saying anything about the Rolecop. That still implicates you. REF was dying today no matter what. He was clearly the original scum, and based on OP, we know the recruit carried out the kill. And the recruit couldn’t have been Kohai. I’m basically confirmed town. So that leaves you. Doesn’t make sense to yolo

ILikePie5
It was obvious at the end of the last DP that Rex was scum based on the info that Wryly provided, so I guess the TP gave him up. That also makes Kohai locktown since Wryly also said that one of the characters on that list was real, which at this point can only be him. Rex has pretty clearly given up defending himself, so he's going to be the given as a lynch this DP.


I think everyone agrees that REF is scum here.


As for the second scum, it comes down to Vader for me at this point. Claiming he used the Role Cop on Rex is pushing the bus pretty hard, but makes a lot of sense when it was already obvious that Rex was scum. He clearly came into this DP knowing that much, as did his partner. Scum killed Mharman, so they could just have eliminated the Role Cop target and Vader just claimed it to push my lynch next DP.


So you’re arguing that scum got lucky by killing Mharman who had the role copied (which they wouldn’t have known btw) and they just yoloed the Rolecop first thing without anyone saying anything?


Regarding the read on me, I'll point out that I could have won this game for scum just by choosing to lynch Pie instead of Wryly last DP. You guys put that up to me entirely to make the decision, and scum apparently shared the fake character claim list with Wryly so they would have known Wryly was lying about her character claim at minimum. All I would have to have done is hammer Pie and then Wryly would have been the auto-lynch when Pie's flip was confirmed this DP. It would be a baffling choice to give up my chance at an easy win.


Yes, I was thinking about this. This is my only source of hesitation at the moment

ILikePie5
Though I should get some credit for having outted castin by asking her to clam. If I didn’t she would have flown under the radar this entire game. 


Bruh bffr, you just asked her if she had claimed or not. You didn’t ask her to claim

ILikePie5
I also don't have any redirects left. Realistically if we assume WF is the last scum he can't kill Pie, so he's either going to have to kill me or Kohai, which I think will likely be me. I was thinking about saving the redirect for next NP even when I got the ability, but we can at least get some form of an idea who scum is at this point


Unless Wryly was fucking with us, Kohai 100% dies tonight.

ILikePie5
Also I think the insta 1v1 between Kohai and Rex is pretty indicative of Kohai town, don't think scum would jump to that 1v1

If we lose we lose at this point, but I'm like 100% certain we won this game unless WF has some god ability


Unless the team is exactly REF/Kohai, Kohai has to be town here. Remember what Wryly said at the end of last DP.


The same list of 4 names was given to scum and TP with the knowledge that one of those names was a true town role. Kohai was the first one to claim one of those names, which makes no sense to do from an OG scum perspective. It only makes sense if he was the recruit and was recruited by REF.


A Kohai/REF scum team knows 100% that Wryly is the TP, so they obviously lynch Pie.


4-2-1 goes to 2-2-1. Here they lynch Wryly or ally with her.


Bottomline, Kohai has to be town here unless they’re just retarded.



Wonderful so that leaves Vader vs WF in a head to head.