ILikePie5
Requesting soft claims or some explanation for lack thereof


I think we should be consistent with what we soft claim

ILikePie5
DP1 problems lol. I feel like everyone is simply on board with policy lynching Cerulean and doesn't have much nore to add.


You never answered my question. Also who do you scunread

ILikePie5
48 hours in and I feel like we’ve gotten absolutely nowhere. I’ll start with a soft my character is male. 

VTL Cerulean

Not a fan of this but if we have to lynch I’d rather lynch a person who could negatively impact town.


Okay so what made him go from heavily town to scum cause you just completely 180ed

ILikePie5
My soft is that my character is on the list I provided. I recommend we all soft a different way, I think scum have in general caught on to the "type claiming" meta where people claim male/female, DOB, etc. Maybe we all do something different. 


I don’t think this strategy is effective though. You could just be vague like my guy is a criminal and it would encompass everyone. It’s hard to do POE if the baseline is different

ILikePie5
No offense dawg but at this point I think it’s one of those stances you have and believe but don’t ever really follow because you secretly realize the logic behind it is faulty but don’t wanna admit your wrong in lmao. You’ve had this anti miller policy for years but I don’t think I ever really remember you actually advocating a lynch on one past maybe saying they should be a default lynch in case of no others once or twice but then never following through on that. 


What do you mean? There have been a few games where we lynch a scummier player, and I think some were town and some were scum. Sometimes it’s worked in our favor down the line just purely based on the behavior of the Miller.


lmao it’s like the Christian parent who doesn’t believe in gay marriage but has a gay kid and they still love them and don’t lecture them on their life choices. It’s okay to admit you were wrong in that logic pie! Time to drop it lol not a hill worth dying on. Don’t be the Christian mom who refuses to change with the times!


Nah, I’d prefer not dealing with the potential headache. No lynching doesn’t make sense and right now idt there’s a legitimate target that tingles my spidey senses

ILikePie5
My question is what kind of monster would include a godfather in a setup where the player count almost guarantees two scum. What good is half a cop?


Thats a balance argument. Town could just be as weak

ILikePie5
So if the Cop checks you, you show up as the opposite of what a Miller would show???


What are you even saying?

ILikePie5
The problem I have with this is if there’s a cop and a godfather there’s almost certainly a miller. If the miller CC’s it’s good night for the mafia. 


That’s not necessarily true. Plus it could be a Lawyer or something as well

ILikePie5

Alright, we have 38 hours left and we’ve done nothing. We should start soft claiming. Yall are the most familiar with the theme. How do we go soft claiming without revealing who we exactly are?

ILikePie5
I’m willing to lend ceru a bit of a town cred for the miller claim sure


You know what my stance is lol

ILikePie5
You know, I'm having a hard time that Cerulean would gambit like that. It would be a waste of a question, and in addition force a mafioso into the spotlight. Cerulean could be town, but I wonder what Scum!Cerulean would feel about his scum buddy volunteering his head on the chopping block.


Why would it be a waste? It’s good play. Imagine if you’re a scum godfather. You know there’s a cop or something similar. It’s worth it to ask about a Miller and SOP claim that immediately

ILikePie5
There is no reason to townread Ceru unless he hard claims his role. However I'd like to know why he should be our de facto lynch target based on his soft claim.


It’s a couple of things. If he’s town, scum are never gonna kill him. If he’s scum, we can’t investigate him or anything. He also brings low value to the rest of the game in terms of his role. In MYLO/LYLO it’s always going to hang over you that he could be scum because they used one of their questions on this type of role. I’ve been wanting to do it for eons when I’m scum

ILikePie5
Eh. You have to look at free speech on a spectrum. I don't think it would fly on here if someone were wildly slinging slurs, especially not the N word and the bundle-of-sticks slur. That's what this site looks like to them.


Have you met Wylted lol

ILikePie5
2. I am town reading them for SOP claiming a negative utility role which is exactly what I would expect from a townie and not a mafia person


You realize scum could ask if roles exist right

ILikePie5
If you think MU is bad try MS. They’ll ban you if you even dare say lynch. At least MU is a tiny bit more lenient.


I prefer free speech. Anyways back to the game. Why are town reading Ceru

ILikePie5
Our style of games might be getting stale, but thats probably due to the size of our player base. We would start to complain if we did everything like MU. Kinda funny that Pie immediately told Cerulean his intention to policy lynch him if he couldn't find a better lynch after his long absence lol.


MU is liberal cesspool. I like Ceru…only if he isn’t scum


ILikePie5
I do think anti-claim is a good middle ground in that it means claiming is still allowed, but it becomes more of a last resort than an immediate "I have one vote, time to spill everything" option. Making claiming risky allows it to take a bit more of a backseat to behavioral analysis without completely disregarding it.


I think it should be 50/50. Early on, no one is lynching based on character anyways. It’s purely behavior. The person is forced to claim because of behavior. Town shouldn’t get punished because of that

ILikePie5
It's a difficult meta to change. Anticlaim is a decent way of forcing people to work around it, in my experience- I'm partial to the Unassigned Anti-Flavor Factional Roleblock. Pretty severe but not outright lethal.


Anticlaim is stupid. Just give scum strong fake claims if you’re concerned about that. Or just do a plain behavioral game

ILikePie5
This is honestly my biggest gripe with our meta. Character claims are almost always banned on sites like MU and MS. On this site we claim even when we don’t need to and most games the solving is done through analyzing character claims


Then just do straight vanilla games. Why even include a theme at all. Just for shits and giggles? If you want a pure behavioral game, the solution is to do a vanilla game.


Theme analysis is a legit analysis. And it’s not like lynches are purely based off of theme. There’s usually a combination of factors like role claim, behavior, character, and justification.

ILikePie5
I had hoped we would one day be scummates since I knew you have a reputation for taking wild risks. It happened very soon after, in Suikoden. We remember how that panned out.


Honestly yall probs would’ve won if the balance wasn’t wacko

ILikePie5
So he elaborates as kinda like a Miller but useful. Fair, but tbh would prefer a character claim for all SOP claims like that


He’s our defacto lynch anyways unless we have a better option.

ILikePie5
If you can elaborate further that would be great. Also almost an instant town read for you.

Welcome to debatecraft btw 

 

Why is that an instant townread?


ILikePie5
Hm hm hm, going to be interesting to navigate around a cast I mostly don't know.

In any case, I'm hard-claiming a negative utility role that affects investigations. I can elaborate further if necessary, but would rather hold back on specifics for now.


Alright so you’re basically claiming miller. I suggest you try extra hard to find scum otherwise you’re the de facto lynch today



ILikePie5

I disagree that lynching me wouldn’t have been an insta win. If you realized that Wryly was TP, after lynching me, you kill her and in a 3-2 LYLO you lynch Kohai pretty easily with Supa’s help.