Nice of you to join us
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Nice of you to join us
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Honestly this game is just a massive cluster fuck with the million mechanics. It’s impossible to determine motive based on them. So just play it like a regular vanilla game imo. I’d say Kohai is behaviorally the most scummy right now. Going to reread DP1 just to be sure
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Also does scum me really verify whiteflame’s claim?
You were the first one to verify it but it’s not like Thoth wouldn’t tell us lol
ILikePie5 · a year ago
The 4 of us can secure the lynch in Kohai right now. His behavior isn’t scum hunting. It’s purely defensive
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Kohai’s behavior has been all over the place tbh. It’s like he’s in pure defensive mode
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Protective roles should be on Wryly tonight. She’s probably the most townie here
ILikePie5 · a year ago
I’m fine with the VTNL
VTNL
ILikePie5 · a year ago
We already have a lot of information. We can get more before making a decision. Especially if the NK is stopped, we will have more information at a minimum and time to obtain more claims
ILikePie5 · a year ago
The last post by Kohai scares me
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Disagree. If there is no traditional NK and it’s just recruitment I doubt this can be afforded plus we gain no new information.
What are you talking about?
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Good thing is that we can afford a no lynch here
ILikePie5 · a year ago
You’re the POE basically. From my POV it’s you or WF who were the original scum
ILikePie5 · a year ago
VTL REF for claim
ILikePie5 · a year ago
What’s your character?
ILikePie5 · a year ago
What is the name of your role. You might as well just full claim
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Kohai - Hitomi Shizuki - Emissary
Vader - Sayaka Miki - 2x Redirector
Mikal - ??? - ???
Pie - ??? - ???
REF - ??? - ???
Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic
Mag1cman - Madonna Kaname - ???
Wryly - ??? - ???
ILikePie5 · a year ago
I wouldn't keep Mag1c in my POE atm, at least not for OG scum. He was character confirmed last DP, so he can't be Kyuubey. He's either the recruit or he's town.
Hmm that’s a fair point. So that leaves you and REF basically
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Kohai - Hitomi Shizuki - Emissary
Vader - Sayaka Miki - 2x Redirector
Mikal - ??? - ???
Pie - ??? - ???
REF - ??? - ???
Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic
Mag1cman - ??? - ???
Wryly - ??? - ???
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Kohai - Hitomi - Emissary
Vader - Sayaka - 2x Redirector
Mikal - ??? - ???
Pie - ??? - ???
REF - ??? - ???
Whiteflame - Homura Akemi - Ascetic
Mag1cman - ??? - ???
Wryly - ??? - ???
unvote
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Thoughts on above
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Alright so let’s go with my patented technique of hunting the original scum in a game with conversions. Worked like a charm last time and we would’ve won if Kohai didn’t throw.
Eight players to start:
Pie
Mharman
Supa
Wryly
Whiteflame
REF
Mikal
Kohai
I am obviously out to begin.
First out of the list is Kohai. I think everyone here is in agreement that if Kohai is scum, he was likely recruited
Second one out of the list is Wryly. Behaviorally she’s been consistent with her town game in DP1 and DP2. I also don’t think it makes sense for her as OG scum to say she’s not recruitable when everyone else received an invite
Third out is Mikal. As the only claimed investigation role at this time regardless of the matter that it is weak af, he could only be the converted scum. Ofc this one is subject to change when other claims come on the table. This one is the weakest out of all of them though.
Fourth out is Supa. I think based on Thoth’s response, Mikal’s results checked out, which at least somewhat verifies Mikal? It’s possible Mikal as scum visited me and is using this role that I’ve never heard of as a cover.
That leaves Whiteflame, Mharman, and REF. I would prefer to go WF since it was his idea to NL, which scum want because it allows them to get the recruitment off.
VTL Whiteflame for claim
ILikePie5 · a year ago
bruh literally everyone feels scummy to me at this point
Literally a massive clusterfuck
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Are you claiming MD?
ILikePie5 · a year ago
I’m confused. You’re saying Mharman via redirection was visited by someone that is not you
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Kohai - Hitomi - Emissary
Vader - Sayaka - 2x Redirector
Mikal - ??? - ???
Pie - ??? - ???
REF - ??? - ???
Whiteflame - ??? - ???
Mag1cman - ??? - ???
Wryly - ??? - ???
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Kohai - Hitomi - Emissary
Vader - ??? - 2x Redirector
Mikal - ??? - ???
Pie - ??? - ???
REF - ??? - ???
Whiteflame - ??? - ???
Mag1cman - ??? - ???
Wryly - ??? - ???
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Character and justification?
ILikePie5 · a year ago
So it looks like Vader redirected Mikal to Mharman.
Anyone want to confess to visiting Mharman?
ILikePie5 · a year ago
Cue the Jeopardy music
ILikePie5 · a year ago
So you know that someone visited me but not who or what they did? Interesting.