ILikePie5

I agree with Vader’s analysis that Mharman is likely town. If scum were given fake claims, it doesn’t make sense for their claim to be revealed like that.


On a side note, I hate the whole hidden mechanics stuff. It’s impossible for either side to skillfully play around it. Basically makes the game luck base

ILikePie5
Madoka Magica is a mahou shoujo (magical girl) series about a group of middle school students who are approached by an effectively immortal Pokémon-looking creature called Kyuubey. He offers to grant their wishes and turn them into magical girls to fight creatures called witches that create their own little pocket dimensions where the animation gets crazy. I'll avoid spoilers unless necessary, but the long and short of it is that this isn't a sweetheart deal and, unlike most magical girl series, shit gets fucked up pretty fast and often. It's a story about obsession, sacrifice, and regularly rides the line between hope and despair. Yep, pretty upbeat.


Wtf, why yall watching this shit. Low key kinda creepy

ILikePie5

Alright, I’m just going to start by laying out what my thoughts are:


When I saw that Supa flipped Vanilla and Thoth flipped Vanilla (on a side note, I was right that Thoth was fake claiming), I was almost certain that Lunatic cannot be Vanilla because I’m a Vanilla as well. But then I thought about why I was townreading Luna in the first place: his claim of Vanilla. There is no shot that Mharman gives Vanilla as a fake claim. And there is no incentive to not claim the true fake role he would have had.


However, after reading WF’s lengthy post, I am pretty sure that he is scum for a few reasons. I’ll list them from most to least incriminating. All of this is arguably WIFOM and I recognize that, but all of the pieces imo fit to make up a puzzle.


  1. Silencing Supa. I think this is the most incriminating aspect. We were all wondering why Supa was chosen to be silenced out of all the people. But I think it was because of two reasons which now make sense if we consider Whiteflame as scum, which this post by Supa sums it up: 


“It's tough to say what balance could be in this game; we usually struggle in 7 games. I have some feelings about whoever claims Rumi.


I also don't think the theme is probably the obvious one but to be honest, not really sure. The ways you can divide the theme are really weird and I don't think make sense.”


The first is that Supa was the only one familiar with the theme besides Whiteflame himself. The second is that Supa at a minimum had an FOS on whoever claimed Rumi, which is what Whiteflame just claimed (and likely soft claimed—see next few arguments). It makes logical sense to silence him because WF would be dictating theme knowledge all of the DP and could avoid the suspicion that would come if he ever had to claim Rumi.


  1. The Cop claim from Whiteflame and the corresponding flip flop from not roleblocked to roleblocked.


First things first, Cop does not make sense at from a balance perspective at all. A Cop + Doctor + 3 Vanillas and then scum have a one night Roleblocker who also dies the next DP and the other scum is likely just a Silencer. That is extremely weak for scum because one cop investigation on the Silencer, and the game is over. Not to mention the fact that the Doctor can perma protect the Cop and scum have no recourse until they identify the Doctor. Scum would literally have to play perfectly by killing both the Doctor first, RBing the Cop, and then killing Cop to even have a shot of winning. The odds of that are astronomical. 


Also, it’s awfully convenient that WF chose to reveal that he was roleblocked in DP3. Small but also significant is that he didn’t say who he investigated NP1. It was a complete afterthought on his part which implies that he never thought about who he investigated NP1 (likely because he couldn’t because he isn’t the Cop). A town WF would 100% reveal that they were roleblocked during DP2, and a town WF would definitely reveal who they attempted to investigate NP1. It’s especially more suspicious considering he was wishy washy all day yesterday. 


  1. The Rumi claim and Cop is a fake claim given by Mharman


This one I stumbled upon when rereading DP1. Whiteflame was the one to suggest softclaiming gender, but he also in my opinion “soft-claimed” early on here in this post even though he hasn’t confirmed it yet:


“I've been thinking about how to progress this game. In terms of softclaims, demon/non-demon has a very obvious outlier in Rumi (she's half-demon) and I doubt anyone would claim to be a full demon anyway. We could do male/female, which is what I'm most tempted to do given that I think everyone falls into distinct camps on that one and it wouldn't winnow the field down too much while soft-locking people into certain sets of character claims. I'll volunteer to go first if we agree to this, since I'm suggesting it as an idea (though Thoth has already locked himself into female at this point).”


He’s basically saying Rumi is an outlier for certain themes, even though that’s his character and is saying he’s town, which doesn’t make much sense cause there’s no reason to bring that up in the first place. So I’m going to give him the benefit of the doubt and say that he was trying to soft claim here, which also doesn’t really make much sense unless he’s trying to plant the seed to gain town cred later. Now the second part. I’ve been adamant that it makes sense to give the non-weak scum as much survivability as possible because if they die, the game ends. That survivability comes in the form of a strong fake claim ie Rumi and Cop. I am Bobby (a relatively minor character). This was known the second I claimed my gender. And I’m also Vanilla (not a really strong fake claim with a bunch of other vanillas around). I sort of hinted at it last DP cause I didn’t really mind claiming (and tbh would’ve been fine with dying, but I have trust issues). It’s why I was reasonably confident that Luna was town because it doesn’t make sense to have Vanilla as a fake claim especially when I am Vanilla as well. Why would Mharman give Vanilla as a fake claim if it’s going to be sussed by the other vanillas in the game.


That’s basically all that I have to say. I’ve been typing this in the time that I’ve had today, but it’s budgeting season so I’m literally working like 12 hours a day and am exhausted. 


VTL Whiteflame


ILikePie5
I don't get this, is the idea that we need behavioral information from DP2 in order to be successful in a potential DP3? That's a pretty strange argument from where I'm sitting, especially since it's entirely possible that Vader did something during the night NP1 and might again NP2. That would be something to go off of, something Luna couldn't provide if he's telling the truth.


Anything he said he supposedly did at night is WIFOM on LYLO


We've discussed this several times already. I agree that Celine - Vanilla isn't a fake claim I'd expect Mharman to give. I believe Mharman would give Celine with some role and that he might just toss it out and claim Vanilla. Thanks for confirming that you're Bobby, but I don't have knowledge of your role so I can't say whether or not it makes sense as a fake claim beyond just being a very likely character to appear in this game. I'll admit, I'm taking a bit of a leap with suggesting that Luna fake claimed Vanilla, but I can't say that it's obvious at all yet that one of the three leads is the fake claim.


It’s more likely than not that it is imo. Also, yes I can confirm that I’m Bobby


This is the best of the three arguments because it also comports with the decision to use the Silencer on him at all. Unless someone had really good reason to believe he was a member of Huntr/x (I don't see one beyond him being female), the reason for Silencing him doesn't make a whole lot of sense since he'd be likely to be inactive as town compared to everyone else left in this DP and make more mistakes as scum, as you say.


Yep exactly

ILikePie5
Choosing Vader would effectively all be based on answering "yes" to the question of "did he Silence himself?" I get why you're down to these two since any vote among the three of us can only be successful if Vader's on that vote, but he would not be my choice. If both of you agree to go for Vader, I'll tow the line.


A) No Lynch - completely unacceptable

B) Lynch Vader - who we have zero behavioral information on

C) Lynch Luna - not preferred personally


Reason’s to lynch Vader from my POV


1) If we lynch Luna and it’s a mislynch and Vader doesn’t die tonight, we have very little to go off of in LYLO


2) He is presumably 1/3 main girls who I think is a strong fake claim for scum. I just don’t buy that scum would get Celine & Vanilla or Bobby & my role as a fake claim


3) He could’ve self silenced cause he messes up on talking and slips all the time.


Literally thought of all this in the last 5 minutes so please poke holes in my argument .

ILikePie5
just thought of something so to respond to this again; you really think the mod would give vanilla as a fake claim? That’s like the worst fake claim ever, anyone can come up with vanilla lol. Just saying 


I was going to say that lol

ILikePie5
To me, the Celine claim comes off as odd. She's a former member of the group previous to Huntr/x and her main focus in the plot is on keeping Rumi's identity as a half demon secret. She doesn't get up to much in the run of the movie, but her role is pretty crucial since Rumi's identity is a major focus of the film. I can see her being Vanilla, at least compared with the other claims we have on the table (would've pegged Bobby as the obvious Vanilla), but I have more trouble buying this than I do the Soldier claim from Thoth.


Why can’t there be more than one vanilla in the game?


That being said, we have to make a choice. I'd like Pie to chime in on both claims and give his thoughts. If Thoth is telling the truth, scum have incentive to kill him NP2, but they also are likely to bank on him being lynched next DP and leave him alive.


Thoth’s claim screams fake claim to me. He has been asking me the entire DP whether I thought he had soft claimed, and what was his first question to me? Insubordination. So that means he soft claimed his character and role basically. Cause there is no way in hell that Voodoo Lady story makes sense imo.


I want to read Thoth's lack of a clear role name (Luna had to volunteer that) as townie, but he could just have made the active decision to not state it in order to look townie. Both players have elements of what they've said that have rubbed me the wrong way. If I had to pick, I'd still say Luna would be my choice of lynch, but this isn't just my choice and that likely isn't happening unless Vader voted Luna already since I don't think Pie's changing his mind here.


I buy Luna’s claim, and I’ll talk about why tomorrow cause it partially has to do with me as well. Thoth as Soldier doesn’t make sense to me at all. Just look at balance. Game could’ve ended DP1, or DP2. Soldier just seems like overkill for town. Granted we don’t know exactly what scum has, but the anomalies are just too much.


I'll check in a little later and we can discuss this before the DP ends.


ILikePie5
I guess so. My role PM says my character, description of character, and ability, but does not give a role name or explicit justification. Before you accuse me of lying because I don't know what my role is called, you know that I would have researched it if I were fake-claiming.


Or Mharman gave it to you, and you’re feigning ignorance