It does come out of left field, no doubt. Can't say I read it as scummy, more way too in his own head.
At best it’s NAI, but by no means is it town.
I agree that it makes sense for the setup, but again, with a pool of named characters this small and the apparent split this obvious, pretty much every named character beyond the two animals is a given. Celine and Bobby being in this game, whether as actual characters or with one as a fake claim, is practically a given as were the three members of Huntr/x. All of them meet the threshold of providing a solidly town-looking character claim.
That’s fine, but the strongest claim is 1/3 girls for sure. Balance wise it makes sense to give that as a fake claim. And it’s far easier to give a fake role with that as well because they do so much in the show I presume.
That wouldn't be my MO, but I get your point. There's a WIFOM reason to softclaim that narrowly that early if you're scum, less obvious reason to do so if you're town. I'm considering it.
As scum he has nothing to lose and everything to gain from soft claiming that he’s one of the 3 girls.
I agree that he's gotten into TMI on a couple of issues, though it's not unusual for him in any of these games to hypothesize about things he's nervous could be in the game mechanics. It's weird that this was his worry, it's just hard for me to scumread it. The TP thing falls into a similar camp. I don't buy it and I don't get why he keeps bringing it up, but getting stuck on weird theories isn't a first for him as either town or scum.
But he’s coming off of a scum game where he just did that. But fine, at best it’s NAI.
We don't know what other roles the second scum has and, as I've already said, getting a fake claim that is one of the side characters is not a "shitty fake character claim," but I get your point on the balance feeling a bit off given the flip and what we currently know about the other scum's role.
Comparatively it’s definitely shittier. But we’re back to square one. At best Thoth’s behavior is NAI. At worst it’s scum. Holistically though, factoring in the eagerness to soft claiming is affiliation indicative. Combine that with everything else and you get a shift towards scum from NAI. By itself it may be NAI, but together it’s scummy. And even you admitted that his play here is just weird, but that doesn’t mean he’s town. It’s more likely he’s scum than he is town if we’re looking on a spectrum.