ILikePie5
Pie and Vader, I want an answer from you specifically. If you were scum, who would you have killed last night and why?


It depends on what’s in my arsenal as scum tbh. I trust my abilities to manipulate so I can tell you I definitely wouldn’t have killed Shining, Wryly, and Ultra. Realistically I probably would’ve wanted to kill Kohai for personal reasons and to avoid the boneheadedness.

ILikePie5

Worst case scenario it’s 7-3 right now and my reads right now:



Town:


Pie - Everyone likes Pie


Max - Claimed Miller with a Cop flip. Only way he’s scum is if it’s a fake claim, but that’s unlikely imo



Lean Town:


Mikal - He’s said a couple of things that lead me to believe that he’s town behaviorally. If he’s scum, I’ll eventually find out unless he kills me.


Kohai - Same with Kohai. He feels identical to his townplay from previous games just based on how and where his mind is going + things he’s said.



Tilt Town:


Thoth - He has some information that that exonerates Mikal. Can’t tell if he’s buddying Mikal or if it’s true, but I’m fine with him for now. I’m curious what this type of role is though.



Null:


Vader - Gun to my head, vibes I feel like Supa is town just based on what he’s said, but it’s not enough to form a full read


WF (Ultra) - I always have a hard time reading WF behaviorally. Ultra didn’t do much DP1 either.


Wylted - I agree with Mikal in the sense that Poisoner + Healer doesn’t make sense based on what I’ve read for Milich. However I’m torn as to the motive for saying he visited Shining. Also if Tir exists, based on lore, I would assume he’s immune to being poisoned so it makes sense there.



Tilt Scum:


Wryly - I don’t get the same towny vibes I got from her in previous games. There are a lot more pointed questions that are different than I think what she has historically done. It’s sort of the shade that I think Thoth is accusing me of throwing.


Luna - I feel like Luna has been back benching a little, basicallly letting Mikal run the show. As scum, he tends to back bench, and I don’t see a genuine contribution besides the one reads post. I also don’t like that he wanted to keep an outted TP alive.







ILikePie5
Pie: As Lunatic noted (day 1, post #466), and I should note that Luna grouped me with Pie there, Pie has a pattern of chipping off the town bloc


Already explained this.


and throwing shade more aggressively than I think is needed, e.g., post #47 today.


It was a pointed question. One that seemed like no one was considering


He also directly asked wylted for character and justification today (post #29 and again in #57), which felt to me like he wanted information as anti-claim fuel and thought he could hide his ulterior motive behind Mikal's inquisition of wylted.


No. He claimed to visit someone who likely was Janitored. He needed to full claim. Also, as others have pointed out, REF isn’t a fan of anti-claim. Also, you probably don’t know this, but Wylted is HORRIBLE at fake claiming, and has been caught multiple times by it.


Correct me if I am forgetting that someone else beat him to it, but posting a claim tracker (post #205) strikes me as steering us towards revealing information.


It just keeps us organized. And people were doing it yesterday if I remember correctly.


I think Pie is our most promising target today. That said, wylted suggested (post #172) that whoever is weak enough to be led by Vader is his partner, and I don't think you are the type to be led by anyone.


I was going to point this out. Aren’t you claiming to know that the NK was Shining. I would never in a million years kill Shining lol

ILikePie5

1. Pie - ??? - ???

2. Mikal - ??? - ???

3. Lunatic - ??? - ???

4. Vader - ??? - ???

5. Victor/Wylted - Milich Oppenheimer - 1x Poisoner/1x Healer

6. Airmax - Sanchez - Miller

7. Thoth - ??? - ???

8. Kohai - ??? - ???

9. Wryly - ??? - ???

10. WF(Ultra) - ??? - ???


ILikePie5

Wait, what makes you think Milich can’t heal poison? I just read the wiki and it says he created an antidote


https://suikoden.fandom.com/wiki/Milich_Oppenheimer

ILikePie5

Couple of points


1) There’s already a TP Vig in the game

2) Shining’s flip is missing, presumably via a Janitor

3) Shining claimed a Scarlet Empire character

ILikePie5
I am waiting for a few other people to ask that since op in DP1 said character claiming could harm town and allow scum to know who is safe to recruit


What makes you say that?

ILikePie5
I just got word back. Red says a poison victim would still be alive the following DP so probably just a coincidence with the NK


So you’re admitting to visiting the person who you think got NKed?

ILikePie5
I guess you are catching up. I poisoned him but I was told he wouldn't die until the following NP so unless scum coincidentally killed him I think his death is temporary unless we decide I don't use my healing ability 


So if you choose to heal him, does he magically show up right now?

ILikePie5
Shining came across to me very scummy and I poisoned him. I am told the poison kills him this np unless I choose to heal him which I can decide to do. My plan going into this DP was to use the poison as a type of ace hanging over his head so I could unilaterally decide for town to apply extreme pressure. However I thought he would still be able to post in the DP and all that so it looks like my plan can't be carried out, so we need to discuss whether I should heal him or not.


Character and justification?


Also did you not ask what would happen if you used it in this manner?

ILikePie5

Question on Lynching WF Today as he is an outted Third Party:


Pie - Yea

Mikal - Yay

Wylted -

Thoth -

Whiteflame - Nay

Ultra - 

Lunatic - Yay

Earth -

Vader -

Kohai - 

Max -

Wryly -


ILikePie5
I think they work on everyone, even subconciously whether you admit it or not, he works it on you and even me. Hes good at enforcing his will. I've seen it a hundred times


Speak for yourself lol

ILikePie5

Question on Lynching WF Today as he is an outted Third Party:


Pie - Yea

Mikal - 

Wylted -

Thoth -

Whiteflame - Nay

Ultra - 

Lunatic - Nay

Earth -

Vader -

Kohai - 

Max -

Wryly -


ILikePie5
If we can’t commit to that then we just need to nip it in the butt now, but we set a bad precedent for third parties being willing to work with the town in future games


They don’t have a reason to work exclusively with town. If a TP gets outted, we are forced to lynch them period. I’m not taking a chance on someone’s goodwill. If they want to out themselves and help town, I will reconsider. But here:


1) He didn’t SOP claim

2) He shot just cause someone told him to

3) He shot to prove his “role”

4) He didn’t wait for a claim from Mharman

5) He’s blaming us for shooting a townie

6) You really think Mikal’s bullying tactics would work on WF

7) He doesn’t care at this point

8) We have no reason to believe he would support us down the line

ILikePie5
he literally did what Mikal bullied him into doing lol what you mean


That doesn’t mean anything. If he wanted to help town, he would ask for claims, etc.. Not just blindly shoot. It’s cause he doesn’t give two shits about it. He’s at best a loose cannon, who we can never trust again. It’s either lynching him today or lynching him sometime later. He’s not staying alive till MYLO/LYLO

ILikePie5
And why tf is everyone blaming whiteflame for targeting Magic. He has no reason to shoot responsibly, hes TP; Mikal, however, had a reason to choose the target responsibly. If he's town.


I agree with this, but Mikal said he thought WF was bluffing. Anyways, it’s partially Mharman’s fault too for being a retard.


Also, I’m confused why WF didn’t just claim Day Vig instead of TP Survivor. There’s something he’s clearly not telling us.

ILikePie5

Bottomline is no more character claims or hints or anything of that nature. We need to make a decision on whether to lynch WF today or not.


I am in favor. He provides nothing to town right now and we’ll be forced to lynch him down the line anyways.


Pie - Yea

Mikal -

Wylted -

Thoth -

Whiteflame - No

Ultra -

Lunatic -

Earth -

Vader -

Kohai -

Max -

Wryly -