ILikePie5
Toran is scum but what David is heavily implying is that the game is written as the game starts. There are people who start as empire and end up with toran. But I’m pretty sure based on everything he is hinting that there are some
jebaits. 


like tir is leader of the toran but if skep is writing this from the start of the game. Tir could be scarlet. 


same thing with Mharm flip. Leon was toran at end of the game 


So again, why do you need to know his character. If this is your theory, then just list the names of characters this would apply to and we will sus them down the line

ILikePie5
Because math 

if we leave him alive now we get an extra lynch and we are going into a lynch with more info 


and we can always use him as the kill. I don’t think scum can keep recruiting. Prob x shot 

so unless not killing him puts us as mylo. Let’s is take 2 shots with more info 


We have to waste a lynch on him anyways. You can’t get an extra lynch mathematically speaking. He’s proven to be unreliable.


In a 13p game, let’s say it’s 10-2-1. Right now it’s 9-2-1. With a lynch of the TP and NK, it will be 8-2. 6-2. 4-2 MYLO. Also consider that if there’s a Yakuza, a lynch on WF as TP would make it simply 9-2 tomorrow and we get 4 lynches.


Let’s say we don’t lynch the TP and No Lynch. It will be 8-2-1. Then 6-2-1. Then 4-2-1 (here we are forced to lynch WF or scum). Only 3 lynches possible (1 has to be on WF).


Let’s say there is a Yakuza. It’s 9-2-1. 7-2-1. 5-2-1 (here we are forced to lynch WF).


I guess it really depends on if we think there’s a Yakuza or not. But imo it better to get rid of WF here and avoid the unnecessary chaos we would get if he stays alive

ILikePie5
It’s less about him being in the town pile and more that 2 characters that are leaders of toran could claim and get mislynched 


I thought you said Toran were scum


ILikePie5
Would be 7 town and 4 scum including wf.


on 11 its 6 to lynch


i don’t think there is 3 scum 


prob 2 cus 3+1 as a recruit is nuts 


With the TP and recruiting mechanic, I would argue that it’s 2 scum (one has probably a Yakuza type role) and then the TP.

ILikePie5
Actually wylted has a huge point. 

we should no lynch

that shot was effectively the lynch and wf cannot be recruited. We can lynch him toward the end of the game and it gives us more info about scum tomorrow based on results so when we do shoot it matters.


Did he say he can’t be recruited? I must’ve missed that. Regardless, he needs to be lynched at some point in the game. What difference does it make if it’s now vs later. Right now we are lynching on our terms. Who tf knows what will happen tomorrow

ILikePie5
Scum read:

Pie/thoth- I am suspicious of these two for a similar reason, though they are doing it seperate from each other. I feel like they are trying to break up the town bloc. I have noticed pie questioning every town read on mikal from the get go, and thoth has been pretty hesitant to townread mikal either. Its especially weird from pie because I feel like hes the town bloc guy and wouldn't be this opposed to accepting people as town, and for thoth its weird when you look at some of the questions he's asking and I don't really see town motive behind some of his questions. These aren't major scum reads yet, just developing. I am looking at these individuals, but I do not want claims from them and think we should maybe look at them further next day phase. 


Oddly enough, I scumread Thoth right now too for all his back and forth. He’s flip flopped like 10 times now. As for me breaking town piles, I’d say that’s an incorrect assumption. Mikal is the one guy who if he’s scum, we’re all probably fucked. I’m trying to dot the i’s and cross the t’s before I feel fully comfortable with him. That’s why I’m asking why he townreads so and so. The devil’s in the details. It’s basically why I knew he was scum after REF flipped town in your game. Based on vibes right now, I’d say that he’s town though, same with David. Max is probably town but I always hate Millers.

ILikePie5
A majority of the people in the game use an ace but this will confirm something for me


Why do you care if he’s in your town pile? Getting more info only benefits scum


ILikePie5

We should just cut our losses, lynch WF and go into tomorrow imo. No reason for additional claims when we have a lynch in front of us

ILikePie5
Bro you guys are on nuts. 

he’s tp. He’s dying. Why would he care who he shoot’s. I called a bluff and was wrong. Simple as that 


we still got some decent info out of it.


He’s dying regardless, we’re just telling him that he ensured his death by taking that shot when he did

ILikePie5
Lol, as if I would have gotten out of this by waiting for everyone to chime in (which is what I called for) or seeking a claim from Magic. Don’t know why anyone’s calling out my choice here. You all knew I was the lynch regardless. I offered a choice despite knowing that. Mikal was the only one who took me up on it.


That doesn’t mean you just shoot. If you’re scum hunting, which is what town do and you said you want to be considered a townie for the time being, you wait for the claim and then shoot

ILikePie5
I was literally the only one calling for everyone to pick a target and Mikal told me to just shoot randomly before telling me to shoot Magic so… you’re welcome!


No, if WF wanted to help time, he takes the shot after the person has claimed. You’re being selfish cause you’re either scum or don’t want to help town.

ILikePie5
Agreed. Also I really detest that we didn’t seek a claim or have any discussion on who to shoot. 


I agree with that. I’m not getting off of WF today for taking that shot without a claim “just to sheep” Mikal


VTL Whiteflame


ILikePie5
Actually low-key useful. That locks Airmax.


Yes that’s true. If he had just claimed Hated, he would be basically lock too. Esp if he came in after and said he was the Cop if Max died. Very poor play imo

ILikePie5
A dark, malefic aura chokes the battlefield. Your hair stands on end. Something is not right.

Magic is dead. He was innocent.

Flip: Hated/Cop Leon Silverberg

Will post full flip tonight when I get home.


Well that sucks. Also sucks you didn’t SOP claim Hated bruh



ILikePie5
I feel like you are just fucking with us at this point lol 


Doesn’t matter if he is, he’s still the lynch. I’m interested to see if Mharman is living or if someone else dies or something. It gives us a lot of information, that’s for aurw

ILikePie5
I have a quick hypothetical question for everyone.

If Mikal somehow dies in this day/night cycle and we learn at the dawn of DP2 that he is scum, how badly are we going to be regretting sharing the information that we did, especially given that he can give advice to his scummate(s) after he dies if post-death scum chat works like in Ranger's Apprentice, which I bet it does? 

Just something to consider.


What information? You just said yourself that you were fine with saying you were Scarlet cause you didn’t see harm in doing that


ILikePie5
strengthens my town read on mikal for sussing that out


Agreed, though there is a chance that he does this as scum. Technically TPs go against him too

ILikePie5
Modpsychers unite: Can you imagine Rex giving scum a third-party as a fake-claim?


No, cause that defeats the purpose of a fake claim. I think what happened here is that scum saw townies claiming Scarlet and they went along with it either via any fake claims they were given or just to buy time

ILikePie5
I want other thoughts on a mass character claim. I would rather give value before I die


One word: No.


If you’re town, you’re are largest asset and townies will hopefully ensure you stay alive. If you’re scum, then mass claiming this early is a risk us townies cannot take

ILikePie5
Fine, then I'll come clean: I am the TP, I can win with scum or town, and I'm good with the latter. Pesmerga was given to me as a fake claim, and yes, it literally does say all that in the claim - the only things I read off of the Wiki were his affiliations. My real character is Yuber. The PM questions whether I'm human or demon, I loathe True Runes yet wield one and pop into huge historical moments to wreak havoc. I'm the TP Survivor.


Fair enough, though you do realize we cannot take you to MYLO/LYLO with us. It’s too risky

ILikePie5
I can see a scenario where WF comes home tired from work, is asked to claim Toran/Scarlet, sees nothing to that effect in his PM, and reads from the wiki. I don't want to jump the gun here. The major point for me is that scum would be crazy to claim Toran affiliation. You've just pointed out an Empire character he could've fake claimed instead. There must be more Empire characters scum could use.


Or he rolled TP and was like screw this. Everyone hates playing as TP

ILikePie5
he prob found a fake claim and was not given one and goofed. I don’t think skep gave this as a fake claim 


almost 10 people are scarlet and his character literally exists to hunt uber. Who I would bet is in this game


Sounds like he’s some form of a TP Lyncher if his set goal is to literally kill someone

ILikePie5
Whiteflame, I'd like more information about what you mean by member of the New State Army, as much as you can give me without toeing the line of copy-pasting your PM.

Maybe whiteflame and/or Rex poorly worded the fact that their character is loyal to the Empire now, i.e., at the cross-section in time our roles are based off of, and his membership in the New State Army is "current" as of the most recent canon. How far does the canon Suikoden timeline extend?


I thought you were firmly against revealing more information than necessary?

ILikePie5
Just to be clear, I'll paraphrase the details of what was sent with my character:

I'm the Black Knight. It's my mission to hunt down Yuber, I'm obsessed with it. I apparently don't seem to age, no one has ever seen my eyes, and I have the Crimson Sword.


This is like word for word from the wiki lol

ILikePie5
If you give me any theory on what TP could be , I would entertain it. 

I will bet damn near anything on the fact TP cannot recruit. Max's PM basically implies it heavily. Toran is the one recruiting and that thematically makes sense. There is only one TP in this game I could think of and it would make more sense as a TP SK or something. 

but largely town is scarlet 
toran is a primary cult or primary scum and can recruit. I am like near positive about this based on what Max posted and my own PM.


I think the whole TP thing is a distraction. It could literally be anything. I think you’re on the right page with the soft claims. Didn’t you say there could only be like 5-6 legit Scarlet Empire people? I think we’re up to like 7 or 8 now.

ILikePie5
In my limited experience DP1 reads are worth nothing 70% of the time anyway


Ya but they still build activity and analysis down the line for revirw

ILikePie5
Magic has been NAI so far, don't know where y'all are coming from


Imo the issue is the fact that he’s said a whole load of nothing, which fits his scum MO. The whole scum vs cult vs TP recruitment is a distraction. We don’t know this early. Also the fact that he’s town locked Mikal so early for basically no reason is very very odd. It’s almost like he’s just doing it cause everyone else was doing it. At least until I said it’s NAI and then he backtracked just now